20 Reasons Why WWE Fastlane 2019 Was An Absolute Mess

In which Mustafa Ali becomes Rey Mysterio circa 2014.

Nia Jax Tamina Shite
WWE

WWE Fastlane 2019 was an entertaining little pro-wrestling pay-per-view.

When it was good, it was very good. The berserk United States, Raw/SmackDown Tag Team, and WWE Title matches knocked it out of the park. The right people won for the most part, and The Shield's post-main event embrace will go down as one of the feel-good moments of the year.

Simultaneously, WWE Fastlane 2019 was a car crash.

That's how WWE roll in 2019. Things happen just because, without a semblance of pre-planning or forethought, thus compounding their own erratic storytelling mechanisms. It's as exciting as it is troubling, because while WWE's modern methods do deliver the unexpected, it's hard to shake the feeling that they're doing everything on a whim, and that even the company aren't sure what they're doing.

Not disastrous enough to be a full-on trainwreck, Fastlane nonetheless produced all manner of head-scratching moments and unfortunate flubs, ranging from unsightly in-ring botches to the company hanging their own wrestlers out to dry. Fun to watch, but undeniably messy.

The Road to WrestleMania 35 should provide a respite, but god bless anyone who thinks they can make sense of this madness...

20. Is Shane Okay?

Shane McMahon Gassed
WWE

Shane McMahon is a hilarious professional wrestler.

Not just because his pitter-patter potato punches are legitimately the worst in wrestling (they look fake and hurt people), or because his 'Hardest Man Alive' shtick is wrestling's most mismatched character, but because the man is beyond gassed within a minute of the opening bell ringing.

Look at him: he's f*cked. It's incredible.

Last night's bout with The Usos wasn't as hilarious as the Royal Rumble, when Shane literally held his shirt down to prevent Cesaro's swing from exposing his gut. Still, he was bright red for the duration. This works when he's selling, as his real-life exhaustion plays into defensive periods, but it looks ridiculous when he's on offence.

Yes, there are reasons for the 49-year-old's declining state, but bore off and let us poke fun at an entitled billionaire's son, dweebs.


19. Some Swerves Are Good, Some Swerves Are...

The Miz Shane McMahon
WWE

... weird. Really, really weird.

WWE deserve some props for last night, because everything about the Miz & Mac storyline suggested that The Miz would be the one to turn. Instead, it was Shane. The former SmackDown Commissioner battered 'The A-Lister' in front of his father after their SmackDown Tag Team Title bout, peppering him with trademark piss-weak offence for entirely too long, before heading to the back. Later, he'd refuse to respond to Kayla Braxton's questioning.

McMahon will now talk into WrestleMania 35 opposite a babyface. That, in itself, is a mess. Miz is a great heel, one of the best in the world, but he's a lacklustre good guy, and Shane is Shane. This is going to reek. Relying on Miz to transcend weird writing isn't a thing we should have to do in 2019, yet that's what'll need to happen if this programme isn't going to tank.


18. All Elias Everything

Elias Fastlane
WWE

Fastlane was an unnecessarily long B-tier pay-per-view at almost four hours, and adding useless Raw Lite rubbish like the three Elias segments was a big reason for that.

The first saw the former 'Drifter' show up to shoot barbs at The Miz, his father, and the city of Cleveland for losing LeBron James last summer. So far, so weekly TV. In the second, Elias mocked The New Day and the Cavs again. Then, finally, he showed up just before the main event, facilitating another weird Lacey Evans walk-out, and a short angle in which he ate an RKO from Randy Orton, before AJ Styles battered his new SmackDown rival with a Phenomenal Forearm.

This colossal waste of airtime should've been held back for TV. Any heat drawn from Elias' diatribes as too cheap to last, and the AJ/Orton bit came, much like Randy himself, outta nowhere. Pay-per-views shouldn't house such fluff.


17. Flubbing The Finish

Sonya Deville Ring Skirt
WWE.com

Shout outs to the referee in the Asuka vs. Mandy Rose match, who saw Sonya Deville flick the ring skirt up for the planned finish, forgot that this was going down, then sorted it out, forcing Sonya to do the whole thing again. Was the conclusion even communicated to the poor sod?

It was a dumb finish regardless. Mandy Rose, trained professional wrestler, couldn't see the skirt on the apron. She slipped and had her head booted off by Asuka for the 1-2-3. That's dumb, but not even the worst part...


16. Mandy Needs Protection?

Asuka Mandy Rose
WWE

Mandy Rose vs. Asuka was mediocre, because of course it was, and the "logic" behind its finish might be the worst thing about it.

WWE decided that Mandy Rose needed to be protected in defeat to Asuka. Think about how ridiculous that is for a second. Rose, an undercarder, couldn't take a clean pinfall or submission to someone who once went 914 days undefeated. Instead, they had to concoct the convoluted ring curtain gimmick, because lord forbid this hot-shotted SmackDown Women's Title contender 'The Empress' a decisive finish, and lord forbid WWE actually put some effort into making Asuka look dominant in victory.

This bout played out to polite golf claps and mumbles, with only ripples of minor excitement to break the arena's library-like atmosphere. Booking like this will only exacerbate such problems.


15. Shoot Season

mandy rose sonya
WWE.com

Who on Earth does Mandy Rose think she is, picking a fight with Sonya Deville, AKA the Real Shooter, AKA Sonya Shibata, AKA the hardest women's mixed martial artist to ever cross into professional wrestling, AKA Nobuhiko Takada's rightful heir, AKA the Best Spear in This Business?

RIP Sex & Violence. You were great, and now you're gone.


14. ... But Those Guys Were Banned?

Rusev Xavier Woods
WWE.com

WWE were this close to telling a good in-show story with The New Day last night, but discrepancies like Big E and Xavier Woods interfering in Kofi Kingston's handicap bout with The Bar prevented it from landing.

This was silly. It was explicitly stated that E and Woods were banned from ringside for the bout, yet they came out anyway, attempting to save their buddy from Sheamus and Cesaro. This prompted Rusev and Shinsuke Nakamura to run down and better them before they could hit the ring. Dumb, dumb, dumb

Why set a "no interference" stipulation if you aren't going to adhere to it? And if the counter-argument is "well maybe The New Day weren't going to interfere," what the hell were they going to do? Call Sheamus and Cesaro names? Stomp their feet and make a noise? Have a cry?


13. "This Is Boring!"

the bar kofi kingston
WWE.com

The idea of swerving Kofi Kingston out of his WWE Championship Triple Threat and booking him against The Bar was done to draw heat and generate sympathy. It didn't land, and that isn't a subjective take.

This guff handicap bout was plagued by chants of "this is boring!" from a crowd that was electric for The Miz and Shane McMahon vs. The Usos. Mandy Rose vs. Asuka cooled them off, and this killed them off, with the chant capping a big booking misfire from Vince McMahon and co.

Kofi is great, and absolutely deserves his moment in the sun. Here's hoping that WWE do a better job of preparing hoops for him to leap through before we hit WrestleMania 35. Him vs. Daniel Bryan is the right match, but moments like the Bar bout suggest the writers might not make the most of it before 7 April.


12. What's The Point Of The Revival?

Ricochet Dash Wilder
WWE.com

... seriously.

Dash and Dawson might be Raw Tag Team Champions, but they're still close to hopeless. Yes, they looked good wrestling Chad Gable & Bobby Roode and Aleister Black & Ricochet last night, and yes, they picked up the victory, but what does any of that matter when the booking team undo it within seconds of the referee's hand hitting the mat thrice?

A Shatter Machine secured The Revival's victory. Afterwards, Roode decided to be a sh*t and attack Dawson for no reason. Black jumped in next, killing Wilder with the Black Mass, before Ricochet flipped off the top with this 630 splash, and that was that. The babyfaces were irredeemable pr*cks, and the heels looked like goobers.

Throw The Revival in the Shinsuke Nakamura pile. They're cooked.


11. Nia & Tamina Are Not The Usos

Nia Jax Tamina Shite
WWE

What happens when you throw two of the absolute worst wrestlers in the company into a two-on-two title match that they clearly aren't ready for? Sh*t like the above.

Nia Jax and Tamina mistook themselves for tag wrestling virtuosos, with the latter attempting to pop pint-sized Sasha Banks into the air after she'd sent her to the ropes. Tamina screwed up, missing Nia's shoulders completely, and Jax tumbled to her knees before eventually rising up, then planting 'The Boss' with the intended Samoan Drop.

'The Samoan Slaughterhouse' was sloppy throughout, and yet WWE seemingly trust them to not kill Beth Phoenix (who hasn't wrestled a proper match since October 2012) at WrestleMania 35? Amazing.


10. Take A Seat

Nia Jax Tamina
WWE

Here's how in tune Nia Jax and Tamina were last night: 'The Irresistible Force' almost knocked her tag partner off the apron while running for a leg drop during their post-match beatdown of Natalya and Beth Phoenix.

You can't make this sh*t up.


9. Lamest Run-In Ever?

Tamina Natalya
WWE.com

Hot run-ins are supposed to be... well, hot. They should get the crowd popping and the adrenaline buzzing, bringing a spark of excitement to even the most rudimentary of heel beatdowns, regardless of whether they succeed or fail. The audience need to care about the person taking the beatdown, and therefore care about them being saved, but more importantly, the saviour can't be any old doofus from the rank-and-file.

Which is why Natalya's attempted save of Beth Phoenix went down like a damp fart in an elevator.

Her and Phoenix are close friends, but it's bloody Natalya. You can hear a rat p*ss on cotton when her entrance theme hits at the best of times, so how did whoever put this together expect anything but indifference with Nia Jax and Tamina involved?

Bland, boring dreck.


8. Belts? What Belts?

beth phoenix natalya
WWE.com

The biggest crime with Sasha Banks and Bayley vs. Nia Jax and Tamina wasn't a botch or an ineffective run-in, but that this WWE Women's Tag Team Title match wasn't about the WWE Women's Tag Team Titles at all.

This was a vehicle to get to Nia and Tamina vs. Natalya and Beth. That's it. The bout itself barely lasted a couple of minutes, and the triumphant babyface champions were dispatched within seconds of the final bell. They were the appetiser for the post-match, and now, frustratingly, it looks likes like WWE are about to prioritise a nostalgia programme over these "historic" new belts.

It's a maddening situation made worse by the beloved Bayley/Sasha tandem coming out as the biggest losers, despite their victory. Why spend time building them and their titles up if you're going to bury them with a stupid Raw angle immediately after? Compare their situation with The Revival's earlier in the night, and it looks like WWE's longstanding tag wrestling problems are already creeping into the women's division.


7. 2014 Rey Mysterio

Daniel Bryan Mustafa Ali
WWE

Way to hang Mustafa Ali out to dry.

The former 205 Live man played the role of 2014 Rey Mysterio last night. Ali was inserted into the Daniel Bryan vs. Kevin Owens WWE Championship bout, and, much like Rey was obliterated for not being Bryan in the 2014 Royal Rumble, Mustafa was slaughtered because he wasn't Kofi Kingston.

It's almost understandable. Ali was jeered for not being Kingston, and that sucks. At the same time, though, Ali isn't Kingston... and that sucks too.

Mustafa's story is a mess at the moment. Yes, he was probably owed a WWE Title shot when injury cost him the opportunity to compete at Elimination Chamber, but giving him one at the expense of the hottest male act in the company didn't make a jot of sense. Only in WWE will you find a babyface being used to take heat for another babyface's undermining.


6. Face-Face-Heel

Daniel Bryan Mustafa Ali Kevin Owens
WWE

WWE got the dynamic in Mustafa Ali vs. Daniel Bryan vs. Kevin Owens all wrong.

Face-face-heel Triple Threats don't work. At all. The crowd don't have a clue what to do or who to root for, because they're used to the good guy being the underdog. Here, Ali and KO technically had the advantage, and while they didn't exactly wrestle like tag team partners, the fudged setup left them with a mountain to climb.

That Ali was able to turn the crowd's reactions around towards the end of the bout speaks to his power as a fiery babyface performer. Regardless, this bout's opening stages were all over the place, asking the question of why Ali was even added at all. You can't exactly turn a guy like that heel for the occasion, so why not save his title shot for a random episode of SmackDown instead? It's not like the rising star needs a big pay-per-view platform this early in his main roster run.


5. Overwrought & Overcooked

Becky Lynch Charlotte Flair Fastlane
WWE.com

No Fastlane match was more disappointing than Becky Lynch vs. Charlotte Flair, which could (and should) have been a home run. Instead, the duo were struck out by an overwrought, overcooked, and overbooked scrap that was impossible to get into from the moment it was made clear that Becky wouldn't be doing much wrestling.

90% of the bout was an injured Lynch selling for Flair. The other 10% was hope spots. That fits with the story WWE were trying to tell: the problem is that said story f*cking stinks.

'The Man's' fire is her biggest strength, and WWE had Flair pour gallons of cold water on it last night. She just sold, and sold, and sold. This harmed the crowd reactions, and by the end there was more than enough evidence to make the case that WWE should never have leaned into the "injured knee" angle so heavily.

Throw the ridiculousness of Becky being forced to win back the title shot she rightfully won in the Royal Rumble into the mix, and you're left with a big puddle of narrative slop. How have WWE messed this, of all things, up?


4. An Opportunity Earned?

Becky Lynch Fastlane
WWE.com

Much of Becky Lynch's patter since becoming 'The Man' has revolved around earned opportunities versus gifts. She earns her shots, while Charlotte Flair and Ronda Rousey were handed theirs. It's a simple, effective piece of antihero presentation, and feeds into her opponents' characters, particularly Flair, who has always worked best as an entitled silver-spoon heel.

So obviously, when Becky faced Charlotte for the opportunity to be added to WrestleMania 35's main event... she'd earn that victory, right? Somehow, she'd find a way to beat 'The Queen.' She'd prove that 'The Man' isn't an act by defeating the company-sponsored golden child. and then, hopefully, score victory on the night itself, taking her character arc full circle?

Nope! She won via disqualification.

In a move that undermined everything the Becky Lynch character is supposed to be about, 'The Lass Kicker' punched her WrestleMania ticket not through heroism or determination, but because Rousey whacked her while she was down. She'll be in the main event, but she hasn't earned a thing.

The Triple Threat is going to rule. Sadly, the build's recent detour through Sh*tsville means the next few weeks could be rough.


3. Sassy Southern What-The-Hell?

Lacey Evans
WWE

Lacey Evans' contractually obliged Abe Simpson walkdown came just before the main event, as the 'Sassy Southern Belle' strutted down in a red two-piece, turned around, and f*cked off whence she came, further cementing her status as WWE's most pointless act.

Even EC3 has more direction than Evans, yet this is who Vince McMahon supposedly wants to face Asuka at WrestleMania 35?

Burn it down. Burn it all down.


2. Communication Breakdown

Baron Corbin Roman Reigns
WWE

Roman Reigns looked fantastic on his return to competition, and deserves some kind of award for helping Baron Corbin to the most heated and exciting exchange of his career thus far, particularly when the former 'Constable' almost put 'The Big Dog' away with an awesome Deep Six.

Corbin probably should have let Roman know what he was trying to do here, though. They were on different pages as 'Big Banter' went for his slidey-around-the-post thing, with Roman booting him straight in the moosh, prompting Baron to continue regardless, eating a Superman Punch upon re-entry.


1. "ONE LAST MOTHERF*CKIN' TIME!"

The Shield
WWE

Were you excited to see The Shield back together last night? Seth Rollins certainly was, and couldn't hide it as him and his brothers prepared themselves for the bout-ending Triple Powerbomb.

Baron Corbin was at The Shield's mercy. They walked around the ring whipping the crowd up, and Rollins let the moment get to him. "ONE MORE MOTHERF*CKING TIME!" he screamed, prompting the company's censors to step in before the big finish, guaranteeing himself a backstage slap on the wrist in the process.


Channel Manager
Channel Manager

Andy has been with WhatCulture for 10 years and is currently WhatCulture's Wrestling Channel Manager. A writer, presenter, and editor with 10+ years of experience in online media, he has been a sponge for all wrestling knowledge since playing an old Royal Rumble 1992 VHS to ruin in his childhood. Having previously worked for Bleacher Report, Andy specialises in short and long-form writing, video presenting, voiceover acting, and editing, all characterised by expert wrestling knowledge and commentary. Andy is as much a fan of 1985 Jim Crockett Promotions as he is present-day AEW and WWE - just don't make him choose between the two.