20 Reasons Why WWE Superstar Shake-Up 2019 Was An Absolute Mess

EC3 gets buried, tag teams split, and the Raw women's division is destroyed.

EC3 Buried
WWE

This year's WWE Superstar Shake-Up was simultaneously the best and worst of the company, resulting in episodes of Raw and SmackDown that, at times, resembled complete trainwrecks.

Learning how to laugh at this nonsense is critical to enjoying the modern WWE product. Take it seriously and you'll drown yourself in a sea of negativity, consumed by the idea that Vince McMahon' is the most incompetent television writer in the world. It's perverse, and it'd be nice if the company served up more content we can enjoy earnestly, but the dumpster fire is often just as entertaining.

It'd be wrong not to cut Raw some slack after travel issues seemingly forced widescale last-minute rewrites across the show, though its three hours were still riddled with nonsense. SmackDown was less shambolic, as you'd expect from WWE's most consistent weekly show, but far from immune.

The company's vast talent pool feels suitably refreshed after a series of trades that sent the likes of AJ Styles, Roman Reigns, and Finn Balor to pastures new, where they'll enjoy all kinds of exciting storytelling possibilities. We can't fault the destination, even if the journey frequently veered towards so-bad-it's-good territory...

20. The Feud MUST Continue!

The Miz Shane McMahon
WWE.com

Shane McMahon and The Miz's WrestleMania brawl was a shambles. It was exactly the kind of thing that this column was devised to cover, with its perfect cacophony of bullsh*t combining to create one of the best so-bad-it's-good matches this company has produced in years. For the love God, Shane spent a minute adjusting George Mizanin's boxing stance... and he won by getting suplexed off of a very high thing. It was mental.

The good/bad (delete as appropriate) news is that the Banter Era's foremost banter feud continued in Raw's first segment. Miz was unveiled as Raw's first Shake-Up acquisition and ambushed 'The Best In The World' from behind, getting himself bloodied in the inevitable Shane fightback, but ultimately standing tall to close.

Remember when WrestleMania was the point at which all ongoing WWE storylines concluded? Shane and Miz apparently don't. Here's to another trainwreck pay-per-view match or two, culminating in Big George nutting Shane with his "potato face."


19. Pew Pew Pew

What the hell is this nonsense?!

Ricochet's entrance music now starts with two gunshots followed by the sound of the bullets, ahem, ricocheting around the place, because he's Ricochet. That's his name, idiots. Don't you get it?! Here, let the WWE Subtlety Hammer smack you right in the face.

There's something wrong with you if you didn't burst out laughing upon hearing this.


18. Old Creaky

As if Ricochet's pewpewpew wasn't enough, the power of Aleister Black's awesome ring entrance was shattered when WWE edited a bunch of creaky sound effects into the bit where he rises from the dark, turning one of wrestling's best walk-outs into slapstick silliness.

It wouldn't be so bad if these new effects didn't sound like they were downloaded from some free online soundbank, but alas...


17. Confused Announcing

Michael Cole Corey Graves Renee Young
WWE

The slapdash nature of this week's Raw came out several times throughout the show's three hours, including a couple of moments where it seemed like the announcers genuinely weren't clued in on what was supposed to be happening.

Ricochet's emerged for the eight-man tag team match, prompting Michael Cole to question whether or not he had officially joined the Raw roster. He did the same thing when Aleister Black came out, too. Later, Corey Graves gave Lars Sullivan's destruction of Rey Mysterio a similar response, quipping that the Raw roster must be wishing 'The Freak' would be sent to SmackDown.

Ricochet, Black, and Sullivan's switches were confirmed later in the night, but why sow seeds of confusion in the first place? It built no intrigue and only gave the impression that the show was still being written on the fly.


16. The Viking Experience

The Viking Experience
WWE.com

Vince McMahon's patented Subtlety Hammer was swung for a third time within Raw's first hour, as the tag team formerly known as War Raiders marched out for their role in the eight-person war, their main roster rebranding complete.

No longer Rowe and Hanson, these two now go by Erik and Ivar individually. Or, as a collective, The Viking Experience.

Read that again. The Viking Experience. It's awful.

It might be the worst name-change WWE have ever pulled off. Sounding more like a run-down theme park attraction or an exhibit at a National Trust museum, it makes the fearsome NXT Tag Team Champions sound like a couple of goobers.

Even more harmful was the announcing, with Michael Cole and co. suggesting that for Ivar and Erik, the viking lifestyle was so much more than a gimmick. This highlights one big difference between developmental and Raw. In NXT, these guys used Norse iconography to intimidate their foes; on the main roster, they are literal vikings who drink mead and craft their own war fatigues.

The only way this could possibly get goofier is they are rechristened Ronnie Ragnarok and Smashy McAxe next week.


15. A Way Of Life?

Cedric Alexander
WWE

Cedric Alexander coming to Monday Night Raw is cool. The former Cruiserweight Champion had done all there was to do on 205 Live, and while he hadn't quite outgrown the brand like Buddy Murphy, WWE had ran out of options on their most neglected brand. The timing was right, and it'll be fun to see if he flourishes like Ali has done on SmackDown.

Corey Graves' response to all this? Claiming that Alexander is out to "show that Cruiserweight is more than just a weight class - it's a way of life."

But if Cruiserweight was a way of life, surely that'd mean sticking around on 205 Live, the designated Cruiserweight show, for... life?

Whoever fed Graves this line isn't very smart.


14. Spoiling The Surprise

The above tweet says it all.

This amateurish production botch came before Bobby Roode and Chad Gable had even issued their open challenge, spoiling the surprise completely. Isn't this supposed to be one of WWE's strong suits?


13. Shoot Season

The IIconics Bayley
WWE

Worked shoots are lame. There are exceptions, but most come off like sub-Russo level bullsh*t, and own the writers way harder than any intended targets. Enzo Amore and Big Cass' recent invasion of Madison Square Garden was a good example of how to do it right: The IIconics backstage interaction with Bayley on this week's Raw was the opposite.

Sasha Banks' name has dominated wrestling media since WrestleMania 35, with rumours that she'd tried to resign from WWE after the event morphing into 'The Boss' reportedly refusing to turn up for work this week. WWE addressed this on Raw. Bayley was backstage, trying to get her tag partner to call her back, opening her to mockery from Peyton Royce and Billie Kay, who challenged 'The Hugger' to find a new sidekick to face them.

This facilitated Naomi's Raw debut, but the clear shot at Banks felt childish and petty. You can argue that Sasha's recent actions come off the same way. This shouldn't matter, though: the company should rise above such things if they're trying to take the high ground in this apparent labour dispute.


12. Three Champions Losing

Naomi Raw
WWE.com

The Revival and The Viking Experience d. Aleister Black, Ricochet, and Raw Tag Team Champions Zack Ryder and Curt Hawkins in 13:15.

Andrade d. Intercontinental Champion Finn Balor in 10:30.

Bayley and Naomi d. Women's Tag Team Champions The IIconics in 1:55.

That's three separate WWE champions knocked down in non-title bouts within Raw's first two hours, highlighting the p*ss-poor job this company continue to do when it comes to protecting their belt-holders, who should, in theory, be among the strongest wrestlers in the territory.

Billie Kay and Peyton Royce's Raw defeat is the most galling, given that it took less than two minutes for a thrown-together unit to brush them aside. That they were an established duo with considerable chemistry and experience working together was one of the main arguments made in favour of their WrestleMania 35 victory. So much for that...


11. Oh, Bray...

Bray Wyatt Bird
WWE

This b*llocks again?!

Might as well just release the poor bastard...


10. "How D'ya Like A Taste Of The Good Life You Sack Of Sh*t?!"

Raw EC3 Braun Strowman
WWE.com

EC3 probably thought that this week's Raw was going to be his big night.

Having struggled to make a mark throughout his three months on the main roster, and barely even making television most weeks, the former Impact Wrestling standout, we were told, was demanding competition. In his character's head, this probably meant a springboard victory over whatever poor, unfortunate sap was deluded enough to answer his call. In Vince McMahon's head, it meant Braun Strowman beating the absolute sh*t out of EC3.

This was hilarious. Instead of wrestling EC3, Strowman battered him like a Mars Bar in a dirty Scottish takeaway. A brutish pummeling took both men up the ramp and to the main entrance way, where the ripped jobber's life was ended by a Chokeslam through a panel set up by the stage.

So much for "competition," Pec Boy. Get wrecked.


9. Eric Young Gets Buried

Eric Young lol
WWE

Consider the wrestlers featured on the above banner.

The Miz made his Raw debuted by walloping Shane McMahon in the opening segment, continuing their blood-feud. Andrade and Zelina Vega made their arrival via 'El Idolo' beating Intercontinental Champion Finn Balor in singles competition. Cedric Alexander got his own video package. The Usos smashed Chad Gable and Bobby Roode. Naomi replaced Sasha Banks as Bayley's tag partner, walloping The IIconics in less than two minutes. Rey Mysterio, admittedly, got smashed, but WWE at least put him in a feud with Lars Sullivan.

Eric Young got Photoshopped into the end of said banner. That's it.

This is a hard, hard own of the former Impact Wrestling Heavyweight Champion. This was WWE saying "oh yeah this guy's here as well lol". They buried EY and split Sanity with a quick handwave, and it was almost as funny as the way they presented EC3 earlier in the evening.


8. Whatever THIS Is Supposed To Be

Laughing Doll Thing I Don T Know Man
WWE

Reminder: Raw is supposed to be a TV show about professional wrestling.

Airing just before the main event, this bag of balls featured cheesy horror movie music, flickering lights, a "spooky" dollhouse, and the above mannequin doing a mad laugh. It probably has something to do with Bray Wyatt. Who could possibly care, though?


7. Splitting Charlotte And Andrade

1384647

Hey guys, how do you like spending time together during this important, formative stage of your relationship?

Enjoy travelling together, do you?

Does your bond help make those brutal late-night car journeys feel less soul-destroying?

Helps keep you sane, does it?

Brings you closer together?

Makes the sacrifices worthwhile?

Cool! Well, we're going to put you on separate brands anyway. Enjoy seeing each other once a week!


6. No Home For Nikki

Nikki Cross
WWE.com

Nobody wants to play with Nikki Cross, it seems.

While it looked like WWE would find permanent spots for all of their early-2019 call-ups in this year's Shake-Up, Cross remains homeless. Neither Raw nor SmackDown took her on-board. Even Heavy Machinery were sent to the blue brand via website update after the show had gone off the air, but the former Sanity member is still lost in the free agency sea.

This only makes sense if she's to go full-time with NXT UK and never appear on the main roster over the coming year of programming, but it's still worth burying. Did they just forget about her?


5. Sayonara, Squad...

Riott Squad
WWE

The flippancy with which WWE ended several onscreen partnerships in this year's Superstar Shake-Up is something else.

Sanity's was the most hilarious. It began with Eric Young's under-the-radar Raw switch, continued when Killian Dain tweeted that the group with effectively over, then concluded with the news that Alexander Wolfe is probably on his way back to NXT. Former associate Nikki Cross is nowhere to be found.

Chad Gable and Bobby Roode's tag team is no longer a thing either. You might have missed this, given the lack of focus it was given on SmackDown, but Gable has been sent to the blue brand.

Most surprising of all, however, is The Riott Squad, who had Liv Morgan flung off to Tuesday nights. It's a shame, really, because they're a likeable group of performers who consider themselves sisters behind the scenes. Still, these things don't take friendships into account.

At least they didn't separate any married couples this time around...


4. The Sullivan Switcheroo

Lars Sullivan R-Truth
WWE.com

Now this was sloppy.

Lars Sullivan was unveiled as a Raw Superstar on Monday night. Speculated by the announcers as he savaged Rey Mysterio, it was made official when WWE included 'The Freak' as part of their online list of every wrestler who'd jumped to the flagship show.

They undid this 24 hours later, with Sullivan's SmackDown appearance making him the only wrestle to jump twice during the same Shake-Up. His unexpected beatdown of R-Truth was greeted by widespread surprise not because it was a particularly effective angle, but because we'd just been told Sully was a Raw guy, but here he was, showing up on Tuesday nights. WWE.com confirmed the big man's latest move later in the evening.

SmackDown is a smarter destination anyway, as Raw already has a major league monster in Braun Strowman. Regardless, moves like this make creative look scatterbrained and clumsy.


3. Pillaging Raw's Women's Division

Bayley Becky Lynch Ember Moon
WWE.com

SmackDown's women's division looks awesome coming out of the Superstar Shake-Up. Becky Lynch, Charlotte Flair, and Asuka were already there. Joining them are Bayley, who is one of the main reasons this Revolution took off in the first place, the underutilised Ember Moon, and Kairi Sane, who's among the most likeable babyfaces in the entire company. Mickie James is a solid veteran hand who'll play a key role as a midcard gatekeeper, and the likes of Mandy Rose, Liv Morgan, and Sonya Deville are all laced with potential.

Contrast the situation with Raw's sh*tty new division. Lynch, the champion, is a SmackDown wrestler. Ronda Rousey will be absent for something between nine and twelve months, and the same goes for Nia Jax. Sasha Banks has taken her ball and gone home. This leaves a character-first performer in Alexa Bliss, Lacey Evans, Natalya, and a bunch of flotsam.

It's hard to see what WWE were trying to accomplish here, given how important women's wrestling has become to their modern product. Raw's group is thinner than your writer's hairline. They're really, really going to struggle to hold interest, particularly if WWE take the belt off Becky.


2. The KO Wiggle

Kevin Owens Wiggle
WWE

For f*cks sake, man.


1. The Lack Of Hype

WWE Superstar Shake Up 2019 2
WWE

The Superstar Shake-Up is a big deal.

While the brand split has softened over the past 12 months or so, this is supposed to be the only time of year fans get to see wrestlers switching brands. It's an overhaul, a refresh, and a new day. The sins of the previous year should be washed away, and the audience should be buoyed by the prospect of seeing performers who'd struggled in their old homes move to pastures new, ready to seize whatever opportunities await wherever they land.

Unfortunately, the company did a p*ss-poor job of building it up this year. Barely any hype went into what should be one of the calendar's most exciting weeks. The little work WWE did put forth felt underwhelming, and we were treated to the least anticipated Shake-Up ever as a result, resulting in a 9% viewership slump from the Raw after WrestleMania 35.

WWE's complacency is showing, and they need to do more to make shows like this feel special. Hype it, sell it, advertise it. Marketing is supposed to be one of their biggest strengths, too.


Channel Manager
Channel Manager

Andy has been with WhatCulture for 10 years and is currently WhatCulture's Wrestling Channel Manager. A writer, presenter, and editor with 10+ years of experience in online media, he has been a sponge for all wrestling knowledge since playing an old Royal Rumble 1992 VHS to ruin in his childhood. Having previously worked for Bleacher Report, Andy specialises in short and long-form writing, video presenting, voiceover acting, and editing, all characterised by expert wrestling knowledge and commentary. Andy is as much a fan of 1985 Jim Crockett Promotions as he is present-day AEW and WWE - just don't make him choose between the two.