Advertisement

20 Reasons Why WWE The Horror Show At Extreme Rules Was An Absolute Mess

Outstanding wrestling undone by hilarious eyeballs and swamps.

WWE

Has there ever been a pay-per-view that so perfectly captures the exasperation of the modern WWE fan?

The Horror Show at Extreme Rules was a night of excellent wrestling, mostly notably in Sasha Banks vs. Asuka, where two of the best in the world reached for a characteristically high ceiling and smashed right through it. Seth Rollins and Rey Mysterio transcended the wacky Eye for an Eye stipulation with a brutish encounter that conveyed its high stakes though ugly, weighty violence. Murphy and Kevin Owens killed it on the Kickoff and Dolph Ziggler looked great against Drew McIntyre, entering his best performance since 2018's feud with Rollins.

Again, excellent wrestling. The independent contractors killed it. It's a shame, then, that the booking team drowned their efforts in a tidal wave of urine.

While bad writing screwing good wrestling is nothing new, this Horror Show took it to new levels. Only the first three matches (Kickoff included) emerged unblemished. What's most irritating of all is that Extreme Rules' dumber moments weren't even funny enough to compensate, with even the wacky Swamp Fight devoid of the so-bad-it's-good fluff that often turns WWE's cinematic disasterpieces into perverse joys.

Let's unpack the mess...

Advertisement
Contributor
Contributor

WhatCulture's Senior Wrestling Reporter. A fan since 1992, still geeking out for everything from WeeLC to mid '80s Jim Crockett Promotions. Give him a follow @andyhmurray. You'll have a great time. Maybe.