20 WWE Champions Who Never Got Their Rematch

Brock Lesnar is finally getting his, but these superstars never got their title rematch.

Professional wrestling is an industry steeped in tradition. While many things have changed over the years, many longstanding traditions remain intact. One of those that even the least observant fan has to notice comes after a champion loses his or her title. Inevitably, you will hear them demand their contractually obligated rematch for said championship. Automatic rematches are as commonplace in WWE today as pyro, authority figures or distraction finishes. In today€™s wrestling world of monthly PPVs and multiple weekly television programs, these rematches help stretch out feuds, fill a programming slot and answer a big question: Will the new champ solidify his or her reign, or can the former champ turn him or her into a one-hit wonder? Currently, Brock Lesnar has returned from suspension and immediately reinserted himself in the WWE World Heavyweight Championship picture, having lost the title to Seth Rollins at WrestleMania XXXI three months ago. Lesnar€™s automatic rematch has been delayed, but has not been forgotten. However, there have been numerous high-profile examples throughout the years where a champion has not gotten their rematch for one reason or another. In some cases, the loser left the WWE. In others, the new champ quickly lost his title before a rematch could take place. Since the PPV era began, there have been several notable title changes that haven€™t been followed up with a rematch. For some of these, the real losers were the fans who were robbed of a great second contest. Let€™s look at some of the most notable former champions who never got their rematch.

20. John Cena

Title Lost: WWE Championship Lost Title To: CM Punk This is a tricky one, as Punk launched himself into superstardom at Money in the Bank 2011 when he beat John Cena for the WWE Championship and then left the company €“ for eight days. In that eight-day span, WWE held a tournament for the €œvacant€ title, Rey Mysterio won the tournament, then lost the title to John Cena the same night, and Punk returned with his title in hand. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=c9PIdDXmLgY At Summerslam, Punk and Cena held what could be termed a rematch, or it could be called a title-for-title match. Both men laid claim to the WWE Championship €“ Punk had never lost it, but his leaving left it vacant and Cena had won the title created through the vacancy. Either way, Punk won the match, but he would succumb to Alberto Del Rio cashing in his Money in the Bank briefcase. The title flipped around the next three months to Cena, back to Del Rio before Punk would recapture his gold and kick off the longest title reign in modern history.

19. Edge

Title Lost: World Heavyweight Championship Lost Title To: CM Punk In 2008, Edge was drafted to Smackdown while still holding the World Heavyweight Championship. He went on Raw to crow about it, but Batista took out his frustration at being screwed over at Night of Champions and left Edge laying in the middle of the ring. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sXJrDa2qoT4 Cue CM Punk running to ringside with referee and Money in the Bank briefcase in tow. One GTS later, and Edge was on his way to Smackdown without his title. He also never got a rematch since he had been drafted away from his title. Punk moved on to a feud with Batista, while Edge challenged Triple H for the WWE Championship €“ which he would win in November of that year.

18. Bret Hart

Title Lost: WWF Championship Lost Title To: Yokozuna Get used to seeing Bret Hart on this list. By the end, you€™ll probably be agreeing with any conspiracy theorists who think that Vince was always trying to screw Bret, not just in Montreal. Of course, this is the (in)famous double title change at the end of the abysmal WrestleMania IX, where Hart lost to Yokozuna after being blinded by salt. Hulk Hogan ran down to ringside to help his friend (cough, cough), and then somehow found himself accepting an immediate title match against Yoko. Less than a minute later, Hogan pinned Yokozuna for his fifth WWE title. Hart€™s automatic rematch went out the door, but he€™d regain the championship a year later against Yokozuna at WrestleMania X, so it worked out in the long run. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gMXBasNpiEI As for Hogan, the party was short-lived, as he lost a rematch to Yoko two months later and wouldn€™t hold WWE gold again for nearly nine years.

17. Brock Lesnar

Title Lost: WWE Championship Lost Title To: Big Show €˜The Next Big Thing€™ was virtually unstoppable from the time he debuted in 2002. Brock Lesnar was the real deal, which he proved when he won the WWE title from The Rock as a rookie. It looked like with Paul Heyman in his corner, there was nothing that could derail Lesnar€ except Heyman himself. At Survivor Series, Heyman costs Lesnar the title in a match against Big Show. But in typical Heyman fashion, the double-cross was only half of the treachery. Heyman had it written into Brock€™s contract that he wouldn€™t get a title rematch, leaving Lesnar with no way to compete for the title€ until there was a new champ. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NbbGE5dMvCM A month later, Lesnar cost Show a title match against Kurt Angle. This in turn helped set up the Lesnar-Angle title match at WrestleMania XIX, so Heyman€™s treachery served a purpose.

16. Jeff Jarrett

Title Lost: Intercontinental Championship Lost Title To: Chyna This is another infamous title change, as Jeff Jarrett dropped the Intercontinental Championship in a €œGood Housekeeping€ match to the first female to hold a major title, Chyna. The Ninth Wonder of the World had been competing with the men for several months, and Jarrett began their feud by attacking her over a period of several weeks with various household items: a frying pan, a coffee can and a toaster. There have long been stories that Jarrett help the IC title hostage since his contract technically ended before No Mercy and demanded a king€™s ransom to appear and lose the strap. Regardless of how much truth there is to those stories, Jarrett left for WCW the next day and has never appeared in a WWE ring since. Chyna, meanwhile, enjoyed a two-month reign as IC champ. She and Jarrett would meet up again 12 years later in TNA, but the less that€™s said about that, the better.

15. Steve Austin

Title Lost: Intercontinental Championship Lost Title To: The Rock It€™s hard to call this a title loss. In late 1997, €œStone Cold€ Steve Austin was on a meteoric rise to the top of the WWF roster. Although he held the Intercontinental Championship, Austin had his sights set on the company€™s top prize, and feuding with the Rock over the IC title wasn€™t in his plans. So Austin decided to forfeit the title to Rocky in pursuit of the WWF Championship. However, the Rattlesnake wasn€™t handing the belt over that easily. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=boXxvFrLFic Austin confiscated the title and dragged a cameraman to the General Sullivan Bridge in New Hampshire, where he threw the title into the Piscataqua River. Rock was the IC champion, but Austin had no desire to get his rematch. A month later, Stone Cold won the 1998 Royal Rumble en route to winning the WWF Championship at WrestleMania XIV, kicking off the Austin era.

14. Lita

Title Lost: WWE Women€™s Championship Lost Title To: Trish Stratus Title Lost: WWE Women€™s Championship Lost Title To: Mickie James Poor Lita. Has anyone lost their title twice in a two-month span and been denied a rematch both times? Both situations, however, involved retirements, so it€™s not like there was a vast conspiracy against the Hall of Famer. Lita lost her Women€™s Championship to a retiring Trish Stratus at Unforgiven in 2006 in Trish€™s hometown of Toronto (tapping out to the Sharpshooter, no less). Lita would go on to win the vacant title six weeks later and announce that she also was retiring at Survivor Series and planned to go out as champ. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_WbwGuVJZT0 Enter Mickie James, who had lost to Lita in the tournament finals. Mickie redeemed herself and saved WWE from having to hold two tournaments for a vacant women€™s title that fall. While it kind of stunk for Lita to go out like that, WWE gave two of their most talented female wrestlers great platforms to go out on €“ in high-quality, PPV championship matches. Win or lose, that€™s not a bad way to end your career.

13. Rob Van Dam

Title Lost: WWE Championship Lost Title To: Edge Rob Van Dam was flying high during the summer of 2006. Mr. Monday Night was also Mr. Money in the Bank, and he used that briefcase to defeat John Cena at One Night Stand and become the only man to hold the WWE and ECW Championships at the same time. For a month, RVD was on top of the WWE landscape, ruling both Raw and ECW. It looked like after years of trying to break through the glass ceiling in WWE, Van Dam had arrived. And then he and Sabu were busted with drugs in their car. Just three weeks into his reign, RVD would drop both titles on successive nights to Edge (WWE) and Big Show (ECW) because he was facing a 30-day suspension. While Van Dam would receive a rematch against Show, he never got a chance to get revenge on Edge and reclaim the title. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WhmEbm912mY In hindsight, that was RVD€™s peak in WWE. Since then, he€™s been a valuable commodity in the mid-card and an occasional threat for major titles, but he hasn€™t had another chance to be €œthe guy,€ which is a shame that one night, one mistake cost him.

12. Randy Orton

Title Lost: WWE World Heavyweight Championship Lost Title To: Daniel Bryan During the summer and fall of 2013, Randy Orton and Daniel Bryan traded WWE World Heavyweight Championship title victories as both men competed to be the €œFace of the WWE.€ Orton would emerge the victor of the feud with some help from the Authority, but his luck would run out at WrestleMania XXX. Fans know the story all too well: Batista returned and won the 2014 Royal Rumble, only to be met with instant and overwhelming rejection from the fans, who wanted Bryan to finally conquer the Authority. In a fairytale twist, WWE gave fans exactly what they wanted, and Bryan won the title at Mania. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1cAXfUjw3M4 Orton, however, never got his return match. He teamed with Triple H and Batista as the newly reformed Evolution and tried to take down the Shield. By the time that feud ended, Bryan had gotten injured and would relinquish the WWE World Heavyweight Championship. Orton competed for the vacant title at Money in the Bank 2014, but as he would claim multiple times, he never got his one-on-one rematch.

Contributor
Contributor

Scott is a former journalist and longtime wrestling fan who was smart enough to abandon WCW during the Monday Night Wars the same time as the Radicalz. He fondly remembers watching WrestleMania III, IV, V and VI and Saturday Night's Main Event, came back to wrestling during the Attitude Era, and has been a consumer of sports entertainment since then. He's written for WhatCulture since 2014, establishing the Ups and Downs articles for WWE Raw and WWE PPVs/PLEs and composing pieces on a variety of topics.