20 WWE Stars STRUGGLING Since WrestleMania 40
The Paul Levesque Era has been great for most wrestlers and fans, but not for these WWE stars!
You win some, you lose some, and WWE is no exception to the ups and downs of life. Every match needs to have someone standing tall with their hands held high and another person flat on their back, looking up at the lights.
But when the bad times pile up, and it starts to become more of a pattern, there's more to it than just coincidence or a bad day at the office, and lately, several wrestlers in WWE have been having a rough go about it.
Even after the switch to The Paul Levesque Era with WrestleMania 40 and the massive benefits the roster and fans have received since - along with the 2024 WWE Draft shaking things up with a refresh for Raw, SmackDown and NXT - not everyone is in a better spot than what they were before.
Some are losing matches left and and right, even dropping championships, and losing significant momentum. Others have been missing from action entirely, either due to injuries or WWE creative having nothing in mind for them to do. Friendships have broken down. Factions are fractured. One of these guys even seems to be leaving WWE altogether!
Let's take a look at over 20 WWE wrestlers who are currently struggling right now in this new era.
20. Tiffany Stratton
Tiffany Stratton had an amazing 2023, winning the NXT Women's Championship, Female Superstar of the Year for the NXT Year-End Awards and a Slammy Award for overall NXT Superstar of the Year during WrestleMania weekend. After being drafted to the main roster, it seemed the rocket would be strapped to her with even more fuel.
Sadly, Stratton quickly hit a bump in the road and was taken entirely off course.
Yes, she earned a shot at the WWE Women's Championship rather fast post-Mania, but WWE felt the need to put Naomi in there. It may have been just so Stratton didn't take the pin, but it could also be taken as a sign Stratton was deemed a big enough opponent for Bayley on her own.
Whatever the reasoning - has she in fact been punished for a stunningly ill-advised social media post? - Stratton lost and hasn't bounced back, losing everything since except for an non-televised first round Queen of the Ring match over Michin and a dark match against Tegan Nox.
These days, if Stratton is on screen, she's playing second-fiddle to Nia Jax. It seems she'll be put in a position as an underling, rather than a star of her own, which is a huge step down from where she was a few months ago.
19. Bayley
Wait a second, Bayley? The current top woman on SmackDown? How is she on this list while she holds the WWE Women's Championship and has won nearly all of her matches?!
Three words: Unfortunately, nobody cares.
It's harsh to say, especially for someone who has long been so great and deserved better, but her current run with the title has been one of the most drab, uninteresting reigns in recent history.
Her first feud after WrestleMania was with Naomi and Tiffany Stratton in a "quantity over quality" program. What's worse is that Bayley's part of that equation was the least interesting element, considering Naomi was fresh from a return to the company and Stratton was newly traded to the main roster. The feud was dull, uninspired, and quickly brushed aside.
Bayley was then overshadowed by Bianca Belair and Jade Cargill as the most prominent women on Friday nights, doing nothing of note until she was thrust into a half-assed, last-minute program with Piper Niven merely because Clash at the Castle took place in Scotland. That match wasn't even anything worth going back and watching if you missed it.
Bayley can't even get on most promotional posters and seems to just be killing time until Queen Nia Jax beats her for the title at SummerSlam.
18. Jimmy Uso
Roman Reigns suffered the biggest loss of The Bloodline during WrestleMania weekend this year, but in reality, the one who came out looking the worst was definitely Jimmy Uso.
His feud with his brother Jey had all the makings of a classic like Bret Hart vs. Owen Hart, as both were not only red hot at the time, but had been preparing for this their whole lives. Unfortunately, their match couldn't come remotely close to that level. In fact, it's widely regarded as a massive disappointment, getting only 3/4* from Dave Meltzer and resulting in apologies after the fact.
Only Jimmy was hurt by this, though. Jey not only won at WrestleMania, but he's kept his spot as a top babyface on Raw, fighting for the World title and now qualifying for the Money in the Bank ladder match.
In comparison, Jimmy was written off television with a humiliating beat-down, tossed unceremoniously out of The Bloodline by his younger brother Solo Sikoa, and hasn't been seen since.
It sounds cruel, but it needs to be said: if Jimmy doesn't turn things around soon when he returns, he's going to be viewed as the Marty Jannetty of The Usos.
17. Legado Del Fantasma
WWE might only now just be getting back to pushing Legado Del Fantasma, but a single win over Apollo Crews doesn't guarantee that's the case.
Santos Escobar lost at WrestleMania, followed it up with losing a Triple Threat against LA Knight and Bobby Lashley, traded wins with Carlito, and came up short with everything else since then.
Elektra Lopez continues to bring nothing to the table, but that isn't new, as she's only been a valet and hasn't wrestled once—not even on a house show—to follow up her win over Zelina Vega the Friday before WrestleMania.
Angel and Berto can't even just lose all their matches on one show. They have to keep going back down to NXT to fail there, too, like when they both were quickly eliminated in the 25-man battle royal that Je'Von Evans won.
If you see them come out for a match, you already know they're minutes away from getting pinned, and sometimes, not even three full minutes. Berto's so low on the totem pole that he couldn't get past 2:55 to lose to Tyler Bate on WWE Speed in early May.
Legado Del Fantasma went from being a top heel act at WrestleMania to the most underperforming group on SmackDown.
16. New Catch Republic
Heading into WrestleMania, Pete Dunne ditched the Butch name, reformed his partnership with Tyler Bate, and New Catch Republic was positioned as a truly viable option to win the SmackDown Tag Team Championship at WrestleMania.
They failed, but not without putting on a great performance and still looking like they could capture those belts in due time.
Unfortunately, since then, all hopes of that happening appear to be dwindling with each passing week, as they have lost every match except one on Main Event against The Creed Brothers, who beat them a few weeks later to even the score.
Bate and Dunne aren't even big fish in a small pond for NXT anymore, as they made a special trip down to developmental on June 11th, volunteering to back up Wes Lee against Gallus, only to be beaten then, too.
It's now clear that the buzz they had before WrestleMania was mostly meant to set them up as the first team A-Town Down Under could topple after Grayson Waller and Austin Theory won those belts, and now, New Catch Republic seems stuck in the role of the team others beat to add a win to their records.
15. The Latino World Order
WrestleMania XL was good for The Latino World Order. Rey Mysterio and Andrade took down Santos Escobar and Dominik Mysterio. Since then, though, things haven't been quite so hot.
A kayfabe downer for the group was the reveal that Carlito was Dragon Lee's previously unknown assailant in an attack that kept him out of that WrestleMania match, meaning two members of the group were down. From a reality perspective, it was disappointing to see Lee sidelined, instead of getting that big moment at The Showcase of the Immortals, and losing Carlito meant The LWO no longer had its best talker.
Then, Cruz Del Toro suffered an injury right after, getting surgery on April 18, which will undoubtedly put him on the shelf for the next several months.
WWE also mostly decided to sweep Joaquin Wilde under the rug in the meantime to coincide with his tag team partner's absence, as he hasn't wrestled since losing to Ridge Holland on the April 16 edition of NXT.
Somehow, LWO's numbers have dwindled from a robust seven, to just three, while making more enemies along the way and achieving nothing of note in the past two months.
14. Dijak
In his initial run in NXT from 2018 through most of 2022, Dijak seemed like a major star in the making with the capacity to be a future World champion. All that got turned upside down when he became a member of the horrendous Retribution faction and rebranded T-Bar.
For years, under an awful mask with his terrible name and a go-nowhere gimmick, Dijak served no purpose other than to mostly lose on Main Event—a program even WWE refuses to acknowledge the existence of on their shows page to this day.
When he was sent back to NXT at the tail end of 2022, things started to pick back up for him. He refurbished his character and reestablished himself as a talent that shouldn't be overlooked and had way more untapped potential.
All that seemed to pay off when he was traded back to the main roster in the 2024 WWE Draft, only to wrestle just two matches since. Those were both losses, by the way, and on Main Event and WWE Speed. He's essentially back to square one.
Supposedly, his contract is up at the end of June, and while he's in negotiations to re-sign, there is a chance he ends up released either on his own free will, or by WWE's decision.
13. Damage CTRL
Lately, Iyo Sky keeps screaming in frustration that Damage CTRL needs to change. She couldn't be more right about that!
They've suffered some significant downgrades in the past two months, starting with Sky dropping the WWE Women's Championship to her former stablemate, Bayley, at WrestleMania XL. Soon after, The Kabuki Warriors lost the WWE Women's Tag Team Championship titles to Bianca Belair and Jade Cargill.
Immediately after that, Asuka's been on the shelf with an injury, and the three remaining active members are all grappling with trying to mount a comeback. However, that's easier said than done, as both Dakota Kai and Sky failed to make it even into the finals, as both were knocked off by Lyra Valkyria. Kairi Sane wasn't even invited to participate at all.
Sky fluctuates with some wins, such as qualifying for the Money in the Bank ladder match, but is still several notches below where she was two months ago.
Clearly, the success Damage CTRL had over 2023 compared to the current fumbling means the pendulum has swung in the opposite direction. How Sky plans to change Damage CTRL for the better remains to be seen, but she has every right to look down on her teammates.
12. The O.C. (Michin, Luke Gallows and Karl Anderson)
At a quick glance, it seems each member of The O.C. has been on the cusp of success recently, but when you look closer, all they've actually done is fail.
For instance, Michin was able to secure a spot in the ladder match to crown the inaugural NXT women's North American champion at NXT Battleground, but lost. She had another shot at Kelani Jordan, but Jaida Parker interfered to cost her. All of this indicates Michin is there to put over Parker and others, rather than gain any momentum of her own.
The Good Brothers have had multiple opportunities at the NXT Tag Team Championship and can't pull it off. These veterans are being punked out by developmental talent!
Luke Gallows and Karl Anderson have been coming across more like the losers who hang around high school long after graduating, rather than established top guys who are there to help out the younger crew.
At least AJ Styles is back to being a top heel on SmackDown, even if he did lose 8 out of his 11 recent matches and had to say "I quit" at Clash at the Castle.
11. The Creed Brothers
Brutus and Julius Creed proved during their time in NXT that they have all the tools to succeed as a top-tier tag team in WWE, so why is it so difficult for them to gain any traction on the main roster?
Right before WrestleMania, they failed to defeat #DIY to qualify for a spot in the tag team title match on The Grandest Stage of Them All. This forced them to merely be fodder in the Andre the Giant Memorial Battle Royal match on SmackDown—a spot nearly everyone can get by default.
Post-WrestleMania offers new opportunities, though. In particular, the WWE Draft allows some restructuring of a wrestler's spot on the roster, where they may be better positioned to succeed.
Unfortunately, The Creed Brothers stayed on Raw with little to no direction. They've mostly been used on Main Event, trading wins with random tag teams. If they do appear on Raw, it tends to be in the background, not doing anything substantial.
An easy fix could be in the works with them joining Chad Gable, turning heel and getting a fire lit up underneath them. But until that happens, they're just another duo filling out Raw's tag team division. Maybe let's at least start with some better entrance music.
10. Blair Davenport
Did you know Blair Davenport was traded to SmackDown in the 2024 WWE Draft? It's okay if you didn't, as she's been largely lost in the shuffle the past few months.
She's yet to wrestle a single time on television, only losing to Tegan Nox in a dark match on June 7. In fact, she hasn't even been seen on screen most of the time, save for a few quick shots here and there.
One of those times, she was immediately discredited by Naomi, who made it a point to illustrate she had no idea who Davenport even was. Ouch!
Normally, other wrestlers say they're aware of how talented a newcomer is as a customary nod to let unfamiliar audiences know this person isn't a total slouch, and the newbie gets a chance to fire back an insult. Instead, Davenport said Naomi would find out who she is, only to spend the next few weeks off television.
Now, Davenport not only has to reintroduce herself to a whole new audience that didn't watch her in NXT, but also prove Naomi's dismissal wrong. She has a chance to do that when she attempts to qualify for the Money in the Bank ladder match, but there's a good chance she even loses that.
9. Ashante "Thee" Adonis and Cedric Alexander
All the way back in January, Ashante "Thee" Adonis met with SmackDown General Manager Nick Aldis about how he's hungry for an opportunity. Aldis said he believed in him and had some ideas for the future. Several weeks later, a new tag team was forged when Adonis was paired up with Cedric Alexander for a vignette.
And that's the last fans saw of them as a duo on television, somehow, as their grand total of five fights since have all been dark matches.
WWE must not see enough in them worth trotting out to the watchers at home. Is it too much to ask for some hype videos or vignettes to set them up as potential tag title contenders, even if they end up jobbing out to Austin Theory and Grayson Waller? The division could sure use more teams, so why waste them?
On their own, their singles careers haven't been any better. Alexander was squashed by Bron Breakker and Bronson Reed, while Adonis hasn't wrestled a singles bout since losing a dark match to Butch in September 2023.
Is this team ever going to go anywhere, or were they dead on arrival?
8. The Final Testament
Things started going down south for The Final Testament with their loss at WrestleMania against The Pride.
How does a group that features three of NXT's most dominant former champions, a legendary manager, and one of the most eye-catching valets out there continue to make such little impact each and every week? It's crazy!
Karrion Kross suffered four losses against Lashley and The Pride on the house show circuit. He's also been failing miserably to convert Xavier Woods over to the group in an effort to split up The New Day. If anything, this has only made Woods and Kofi Kingston even more connected with a stronger bond.
The Authors of Pain have fared much better in comparison, picking up some wins, but all three times something was on the line, they couldn't get the job done.
This is a group that is supposed to be menacing, but they keep looking like fools, and the lack of a crowd response isn't helping.
7. The Pride
The Pride was victorious over The Final Testament in their Philadelphia Street Fight at WrestleMania XL, but it's been a bumpy ride ever since, starting with Bobby Lashley's injury that has had him inactive since early May.
B-Fab continues to be a rather valueless member of the team, not wrestling or contributing much as a valet or manager, either.
The Street Profits have been trying to hold down the fort, but they're wandering aimlessly on SmackDown. As they bounce between various opponents, failing to capture the tag team titles, they're being shoehorned into supporting roles as [insert wrestler]'s friend.
Sometimes, they're on the receiving end of a beat down by The Bloodline. Other times, they're teaming up with LA Knight to defeat A-Town Down Under and Carmelo Hayes. But it's all random and gives off the vibe WWE doesn't know what to do with them.
At least they're still being used, which means they haven't lost their value. Being on television and not just solely in a losing capacity is better than nothing. But considering how great The Pride can be, it's sad to see the sheer lack of capitalization on them since WrestleMania.
6. Katana Chance and Kayden Carter
The longest-reigning NXT women's tag team champions, Katana Chance and Kayden Carter, have firmly found themselves in limbo on Monday Night Raw.
They're a solid tag team that gets sporadic pushes here and there, but can't seem to sustain their wins for more than a few weeks at a time, and lately, have been positioned as go-to filler options bordering on enhancement talent. They scored a win over Damage CTRL on the June 17th edition of Raw, but this will surely only lead to them losing a future title match against The Unholy Union. That is, if they don't just lose to Shayna Baszler and Zoey Stark before that.
Their reign with the WWE Women's Tag Team Championship earlier this year was less of a run and more of a sprint, holding the titles for just over a month as transitional champions so The Kabuki Warriors could beat a heel team instead of Chelsea Green and Piper Niven. Since then, they've made almost no progress in reaching that top of the mountain again, even as proper contenders.
At some point, they'll find themselves back in the mix for a title shot, but fans won't believe for a moment that they'll actually capture the belts unless WWE does some serious rehab with their win-loss records.
5. Apollo Crews
Go ahead and browse the Cagematch profile for Apollo Crews. See how often you see the phrase "defeats Apollo Crews" rather than "Apollo Crews defeats" on the list.
You'll notice Crews hasn't won a single match since being drafted to SmackDown, despite his enthusiasm for a fresh start.
The best he's accomplished was making it to the finals of a No. 1 contender's tournament for the WWE Speed Championship at the tail end of May, but that's only because Ivar, who had beaten him in the semifinals (and the week prior on Main Event), was injured, giving him a bye. Since then, he's lost to Andrade on SmackDown in a match that was entirely just about giving El Idolo a win after forgetting about him, too.
Crews has all the talent to get back to at least midcard title contender status, if not a champion, but WWE seems comfortable with him just being a go-to enhancement guy on Friday nights. Even if he comes out of this feud with Legado Del Fantasma with a win or two, it's doubtful it will lead to anything sustainable.
4. Pretty Deadly
Like many others on this list, you'd be hard-pressed to remember when Pretty Deadly was last in action at all, let alone when they last scored a victory.
I'll tell you. They lost two matches to New Catch Republic on the Road to WrestleMania house show loop in March and defeated Kevin Owens and Randy Orton on the SmackDown before that. That's it. Most recently, they were seen just throwing darts on the Countdown to WWE Clash at the Castle and losing to Adonis and Alexander in a dark match.
Their momentum on the main roster was stagnated when Elton Prince suffered a separated shoulder injury last July, but once he was healed up and returned in October, they've been used even less often, somehow.
It's strange, as they would make perfect opponents for a team like The Street Profits to goof around with. They could be stepping stones for Johnny Gargano and Tommaso Ciampa while they're being set up to face A-Town Down Under. Hell, Prince and Wilson could even just have more comedic backstage segments to remind audiences they're still around.
Has the shine already rubbed off Kit Wilson and Elton Prince? hopefully, the answer to that isn't "Yes boy."
3. Tegan Nox
Tegan Nox just cannot catch a break in WWE, no matter what roster she's on or who she's paired up with. It seems WWE would rather not use her at all than to keep her in rotation, despite how the women's division could always use more viable contenders.
Nox spent the better part of the year still clinging onto her tag team with Natalya, despite how the two rarely ever won and would even argue with each other.
The WWE Draft was a chance for a new beginning, only to see Nox fall into the same predictable patterns of only being used on house shows and dark matches.
She did score a win over Blair Davenport in one of those, but considering Davenport is also on this list and it wasn't aired, that means next to nothing.
WWE should consider sending Nox back to NXT. There, she could be a big fish in a small pond. Otherwise, she's prime to be someone they could lend to TNA Wrestling with this new crossover, if there's just no interest in using her on WWE television. Eventually, it's going to lead to her leaving the company entirely if something doesn't change soon.
2. Baron Corbin
Had Baron Corbin not tweeted out that he's been on vacation for a few weeks, things would have seemed even more dire, as he's been on a downward spiral the past two months.
He had clearly been having fun alongside Bron Breakker and doing some of his best work ever in NXT. Together, The Wolf Dogs had great segments week in and week out and were successful tag team champions.
They lost those titles to Axiom and Nathan Frazer days after NXT Stand & Deliver. Then, Corbin lost to Lexis King at Spring Breakin' as his exit from NXT.
The Wolf Dogs were split up in the draft, wherein Breakker's been tearing up the Raw roster. In contrast, Corbin's only had one match, losing to Carmelo Hayes in the first round of the King of the Ring tournament.
He's once again falling into a rut of being one of the "jobbers to the stars" types that plagued his career for so many years until that NXT run revitalized it. All that's been thrown out the window, and he's now back to his familiar role as an overlooked supporting player with untapped potential.
1. Shinsuke Nakamura
At the beginning of 2024, Shinsuke Nakamura was one of the most interesting heels in WWE as he feuded with Cody Rhodes, the top babyface who would soon get one of the biggest wins in WrestleMania history.
That storyline had more than enough meat on its bones to revisit, but WWE kept the follow-up to the live event circuit.
Instead of walking into WrestleMania red hot, Nakamura cooled down so much that he couldn't even get a spot in the Andre the Giant Memorial Battle Royal and has since lost every single match he's been in.
He was served on a platter to Ilja Dragunov and Sheamus on Raw, and everything else has been a house show loss to Braun Strowman or LA Knight.
These losses sting so much because the longer he spends off-air, the harder it will be to regain that clout from earlier this year. Being used as live event filler is beneath him, and it's confusing, considering how well he was booked under Triple H during his run in NXT.
There are nine wrestlers on SmackDown competing to earn three spots in the Money in the Bank ladder match, but Nakamura isn't even in the running to try, which is sad.