20 WWE WrestleMania Matches We Almost Got (And Why We Didn't)

WWE's biggest card of the year! (Subject to change)

AJ Styles Triple H
WWE.com

Now more than ever, WWE's plans seem to constantly be in flux. The mass releases of talent, injuries and suspensions play on the mind of wrestlers and talent alike. But one thing that will remain constant is that WrestleMania will always be the biggest, most important show on the calendar (no matter how much Saudi Arabia claims otherwise).

It's the one show that wrestlers around the world aspire to be apart of, be it a pre-show battle royal to winning the big prize in the main event. But there's always the possibility that you're given a spot on the grand stage, only for the powers-that-be to take it away. After all, Vince McMahon is a vengeful God. There have probably been countless matches proposed, pitched and sometimes advertised only for them to disappear into the aether, never to be heard from again for better or for worse.

Certain matches have been announced and altered, so have taken place in some different form - any match with the last minute insertion of Daniel Bryan comes to mind. But the following 20 matches have entered the planning stage but for whatever reason, never saw the light of day.

20. Hulk Hogan Vs. Zeus - WrestleMania VI

Hulk Hogan Zeus No Holds Barred
WWE.com

Following Hulk Hogan's victory over Macho Man Randy Savage at WrestleMania V, the film No Holds Barred was released much to the derision of fans and critics alike. But it did allow Savage to bring in some fictional muscle in the form of real actor Tom "Tiny" Lister, portraying the fictional wrestler Zeus from the movie. Confused? That is the correct response.

The two would battle throughout the latter half of 1989, mostly in tag team matches where Savage could do all the athletic stuff. Zeus' contributions to a match would usually amount to bearhugs, no-selling and making huge facial expressions. So really, he fit right in with the 80s style.

After a tag team steel cage match between Hogan, Brutus Beefcake, Savage and Zeus, plans were for the Hulkster and Tiny Lister to go one-on-one at WrestleMania VI for the WWF Championship.

Why didn't it happen?

At some point in early 1990, Hulk Hogan was scheduled to drop the world title to Zeus, which Hogan flat out refused to do. And judging by both Zeus' wrestling ability and the reaction to celebrities winning world titles (David Arquette) that was the right call. So the green light was given to The Ultimate Warrior to ascend to the main event, whereas Zeus left the company after the Royal Rumble.


19. Hulk Hogan vs. The Big Show - WrestleMania 23

Hulk Hogan Big Show
WWE.com

At WrestleMania 23, the big selling point was the Battle of the Billionaires, where Vince McMahon and Donald Trump would put their hair on the line if their chosen superstar lost the match. McMahon chose Umaga, while Trump had ECW Champion Bobby Lashley.

The original plan however was to see a repeat of the iconic Irresistible Force vs Immoveable Object of 20 years prior. But as Andre the Giant had long-since passed away by that point, the role went to his once-kayfabe-son The Big Show. At the show, Hogan would obviously have won following a recreation of the famous bodyslam & leg drop combination, and the WWE Chairman would have been shaved bald.

Why didn't it happen?

Both competitors withdrew from the show for different reasons. Big Show was the first to leave, wanting to take time off to heal lingering injuries and lose some weight. The plan then changed to the Great Khali entering the fray but Hogan had a falling out with McMahon wanting a huge payday for the show that McMahon refused to grant, so Hulk didn't appear at all.

The match eventually became Lashley vs. Umaga, with the dominator going over. The Great Khali meanwhile, fought Kane at the event and recreated the bodyslam in a pretty dreadful match.


18. Hulk Hogan vs. "Mr. Wonderful" Paul Orndorff - WrestleMania III

hulk hogan paul orndorff
WWE.com

Speaking of the bodyslam, THE feud of the 1980s was Andre the Giant vs. Hulk Hogan. After Andre turned heel against Hogan and sided with the Ted DiBiase, the stage was set for a mega-match between the two at WrestleMania III for the WWF Championship.

By this stage of his career though, Andre's body was in a bad way and needed major surgery in order for him to compete. Which recovering, Hogan fought Kamala on house shows and even on the day of the biggest wrestling event of the year, it was touch and go whether or not he would/could compete.

As a backup plan, Paul Orndorff was in the wings, waiting to step into the main event if the Eighth Wonder of the World wasn't able to perform for whatever reason. Both he and Hogan were long-time rivals and would have put on a more than serviceable main event to end the night.

Why didn't it happen?

By some miracle, Andre felt able to go out and battle the Champion in front of the 93,000 (alleged) fans in attendance following his surgery, a new back brace and drinking over a dozen bottles of wine. Physical fitness is paramount in today's WWE, but back then, it was Dutch courage all the way!


17. The Undertaker vs. Braun Strowman - WrestleMania 32

The Undertaker Braun Strowman
WWE.com

The term "Vince McMahon's Pet Project" is something that wrestling fans dread, because a lot of these projects end up with the sort of rabid fan rejection on the levels of Lex Luger, Diesel and pre-chief Roman Reigns. Braun Strowman initially looked like more of the same.

Regardless, while still connected to the Wyatt Family, Braun Strowman was initially pencilled in as the 24th WrestleMania opponent of the Undertaker at WrestleMania 32 in a match more akin to his battles with Giant Gonzales and King Kong Bundy rather than Shawn Michaels. Needless to say, fans were concerned as this was scraggy hair, chubby cheek and wet patch Strowman, and not the Monster Among Men that won everyone over.

Why didn't it happen?

Simply put, Undertaker flat out refused to work the match as Strowman at that point was far too green to work a high profile match that the Deadman's WrestleMania resume demands. Undertaker was then moved to a poorly thought-out feud with Shane McMahon inside Hell in a Cell so it's difficult to tell what would have ended up worse.

However, if they'd have waited one more year for the Strowman bout, it could have lived up to those lofty heights.


16. Hulk Hogan vs. "Superfly" Jimmy Snuka - WrestleMania 2

Hulk Hogan Jimmy Snuka
WWE.com

Both Hogan and Snuka were obviously huge parts of the inaugural WrestleMania in 1985, and the reasons why it was a huge success. So when it came to the follow-up event a year later, McMahon wanted to triple down on the show by hosting it at three different venues simultaneously, something that was never done again because it was a stupid idea.

One idea that was suggested but never came to fruition was a match between the Hulkster and the Superfly in the main event. The first ECW Champion was pitched by McMahon to turn heel and feud with Hogan until the event. Considering the main event of the show ended up being a steel cage match, we likely could have seen a recreation of the famous dive.

Why didn't it happen?

The story of this match only comes from the mouth of Jimmy Snuka himself, and according to him, it was once again Hulk Hogan who refused to work the match, not wanting to work with who he described as "that crazy maniac". However, considering what we know now about Snuka, it was probably for the best he turned it down.


15. Brothers of Destruction vs. Snitsky & Heidenreich - WrestleMania 21

The Undertaker Kane Sit Up
WWE.com

Two poorly received feuds coming together for a big blow off. Sounds ideal right?

At the Royal Rumble in 2005, the Undertaker fought Heidenreich in a Casket Match after feuding for the last couple of months. Snitsky, who had been feuding with Kane in the abhorrent Lita-pregnancy-miscarriage storyline, interfered on behalf of the future Legion of Doom member when Kane popped out of the casket to make the save, giving Undertaker the win.

Because the heels liked poetry and punting babies I guess, the two would come together and eventually battle the Brothers of Destruction in a tag team match at WrestleMania 21.

Why didn't it happen?

This was once again a case of the Undertaker putting his foot down and proposing a better alternative in the form of a Legend vs Legend Killer match against Randy Orton. Kane meanwhile was inserted into the Money in the Bank ladder match.

As for the feud with Heidenreich & Snitsky; their scheduled tag team blow off was saved for a February house show. A much more fitting end to such a terrible idea.


14. Hulk Hogan vs. Tugboat - WrestleMania VII

Tugboat Hulk Hogan
WWE

This is easily one of the more bizarre ideas that is very hard to believe, but considering Fred Ottman was up for the role, it's amazing it even got to the ideas phase.

According to "Brother Love" Bruce Prichard, the original choice to battle Hulk Hogan at WrestleMania VII was indeed Tugboat, who would have filled the role that Sgt. Slaughter took on as the America bashing Iraqi sympathiser under the ludicrous name of Sheikh Tugboat.

He also mentioned that a rematch between Hogan & The Ultimate Warrior was never a consideration for Vince McMahon. It was apparently always the plan to have Hulk Hogan vanquish an anti-patriot in "support" of US troops fighting in the Gulf War (And by support we mean "exploiting" and/or "profiteering")

Why didn't it happen?

Sgt. Slaughter had recently resigned with the company and McMahon, thinking Tugboat wouldn't be a strong enough foil for Hogan, had Slaughter turn against American, beat Ultimate Warrior for the WWF title and lose it at Mania to Hulk Hogan. Because America will always win/profit!


13. The Big Show Vs. Shaq - WrestleMania XXVIII & 33

The Big Show Shaq
WWE.com

A match that Shaquille O'Neal was so keen on, it was under the radar of two different WrestleManias.

In 2009, Shaq was the guest host of Monday Night Raw and came to blows with the Big Show. Naturally, the rumour mill started swirling regarding a potential feud between the two men, but a WrestleMania match didn't come to light until 2012, when Shaq was gearing up for a bout against the World's Largest Athlete at WrestleMania XXVIII.

Then at WrestleMania 32, Shaq and Show came to blows briefly in the Andre The Giant Memorial Battle Royale and began a Twitter feud later in the year with plans for a one-on-one confrontation at WrestleMania 33. The two would throw shade, show off their abs, all the normal macho stuff that big fellas do. It wouldn't have been a classic match, but two big chunks of beef engaging in some Shaq Fu is what classic WrestleMania is all about.

Why didn't it happen?

A different reason for each year. For XXVIII, WWE just weren't interested in the match despite Shaq's insistence that it was on. But Show fought Cody Rhodes for the Intercontinental Championship instead, with the basketball legend not being mentioned at all.

For 33, a match was all-but confirmed for the show but this time it was scheduling issues on O'Neal's part that prevented the match from happening.


12. Triple H vs. Mike Tyson - WrestleMania X-Seven

Shawn Michaels Triple H Mike Tyson
WWE.com

Boxing matches have never gone down well at WrestleMania. Roddy Piper and Mr. T's match was closer to a cuddling contest with a bodyslam DQ to spice things up, then the Bart Gunn punishment knockout against Butterbean. So it's strange that WWE would think that third time would be a charm.

For WrestleMania X-Seven, a.k.a. the greatest wrestling event that is, was or ever will be, the idea was pitched for Triple H to face Mike Tyson in a straight boxing match going over six rounds. The storyline going in was likely going to revolve around the initial breakdown of D-Generation X, and "Iron" Mike's part in it.

Why didn't it happen?

According to an interview with Hunter himself, he claimed that Tyson was demanding "ludicrous" amounts of money to take the match. As such, that planned match was scrapped and Tyson didn't appear at all. Triple H meanwhile ended up feuding with The Undertaker, becoming Streak victim number nine.


11. Hulk Hogan vs. Ted DiBiase - WrestleMania IV

Hulk Hogan Ted DiBiase Survivor Series
WWE.com

The WrestleMania IV tournament was designed to crown a new WWF Champion after Ted DiBiase purchased the belt from Andre the Giant following Saturday Night's Main Event which saw Hulk Hogan screwed out of the title.

The plan for the tournament was for The Million Dollar Man to buy his way through half of the tournament and for Hogan to make it to the final but being thoroughly exhausted. This would have seen Hulk Hogan vs Ted DiBiase in the finals.

It was also noted that Ted was booked to win the bout and the championship following another screwy finish. There would have been no grand celebration with Randy Savage & Miss Elizabeth, just DiBiase running away with the belt with Hogan chasing him.

Why didn't it happen?

The brackets of the tournament were changed and Savage ended up beating DiBiase for the gold. The reason was to do with WWF's secondary belt, the Intercontinental Championship.

Current title holder, the Honky Tonk Man refused to drop his belt to Savage prior to Mania, so first round tournament matches were shuffled to give Savage the company's top prize as compensation. The Million Dollar Man was given the Million Dollar Championship a short while later which honestly seems pretty unfair.


10. The Rock Vs. Brock Lesnar - WrestleMania XXX

The Rock Brock Lesnar
WWE.com

The Rock & Brock Connection are no strangers to each other inside the ring. At Summerslam 2002, Brock Lesnar defeated the Great One to win his first WWE Championship. 12 years later, the plan was for the pair to meet again, this time at WrestleMania XXX.

Following his loss to John Cena at WrestleMania 29, the Rock was set to call out Lesnar on the next night's Raw and set up a year long storyline, leading to the clash of titans at the next year's show.

There was also a rumour that the match was going to happen at Mania 29 but WWE had the Twice in a Lifetime match already in the works.

Why didn't it happen?

During the match with Cena, Dwayne suffered a serious pelvis injury and required immediate treatment, therefore the setup on Raw was off. WWE were still hopeful that the match would take place but Rock's movie career was so massive at that point, there was just no time to set up anything meaningful.

The Brahma Bull did appear at the show alongside Steve Austin & Hulk Hogan, while Brock fought the Undertaker, handing him his first loss at the event.


9. Triple H vs. AJ Styles - WrestleMania 37

Triple H Styles
WWE.com

At WrestleMania 31, one of the biggest names in WWE history fought one of the biggest names in WCW history. 6 years later, one of the biggest names in TNA history fought for a similar match.

Triple H fought Sting in a nostalgic throwback match, which turned out a lot better than many expected considering the age of the two. And since AJ Styles was still very capable of delivering 4-5 Star matches against anyone, he wanted to try his skills against the Game.

When WrestleMania season rolled around, Styles began to pitch a match against Hunter (mainly because a match against Edge was off the table). He would apparently pester the man himself constantly, the same as he did with the Undertaker the year before.

Why didn't it happen?

While Triple H was still in good condition to wrestle that year, he was also bogged down with running NXT and simply had no time to indulge in a match against the Phenomenal One.

Sadly, Hunter suffered a cardiac event later in the year and, although he recovered, his in-ring career is uncertain. A shame, as Styles ended up in a tag team title match with Omos at Mania instead.


8. Roman Reigns Vs. "The Fiend" Bray Wyatt - WrestleMania 36

Roman Reigns The Fiend
WWE.com

The Fiend was the hottest heel in WWE, Roman Reigns was the biggest face, so the two were set for a collision course at WrestleMania.

After winning the Universal Championship from Seth Rollins in Saudi Arabia, Bray Wyatt's newest gimmick was set to hold the title until the Showcase of the Immortals, while Roman Reigns would challenge him in the main event after winning his second Royal Rumble. The story and the match was set and it would have been likely that the Big Dog would have beaten the Fiend to much rejoicing... or so WWE would have hoped.

Why didn't it happen?

Two rather major events took place that totally derailed these plans. First was the return of Goldberg at a Saudi Arabia event. Goldberg engineered the match so as to have him win the championship from Wyatt, completely burying the character and forcing him out of the main event.

Second was a certain worldwide pandemic that shut society down and made all the toilet paper disappear. Due to concerns about the health of Reigns, having recently recovered from leukaemia, he pulled out of the event entirely, and the Universal title match was totally rejigged to Goldberg vs Braun Strowman.


7. Stone Cold Steve Austin vs. Triple H - WrestleMania X8

Steve Austin Triple H Royal Rumble 2002
WWE

During WrestleMania X-Seven's main event, Stone Cold Steve Austin turned heel against the Rock and allied with Vince McMahon in order to regain the WWF Championship. Meanwhile, Triple H was coming off of a feud with the Undertaker and soon allied himself with Austin to form the Two-Man Power Trip after winning the Intercontinental Championship.

After both winning the World Tag Team titles from the Brothers of Destruction, Austin and Helmsley were in possession of every major title in the company. A career threatening quadricep injury to The Game in May however took him out of action for the rest of the year. Shortly after this, Austin cut a promo blaming his former partner for their loss of the tag team gold with the plan of setting the stage for a match between the two at WrestleMania X8.

Why didn't it happen?

Triple H did indeed recover in time for a Royal Rumble victory but it was Chris Jericho, not Steve Austin who he met in the main event of the Show of Shows. The reason being that Austin wasn't happy with his character's direction during the Invasion and his heel turn in general. He eventually turned face, battling the nWo's Scott Hall at WrestleMania, while Triple H fought Undisputed Champion Chris Jericho.


6. Bret "The Hitman" Hart vs. Ricky "The Dragon" Steamboat - WrestleMania II

Bret Hart Ricky Steamboat
WWE.com

In 1986, Bret Hart and Ricky Steamboat were two of the most talented smaller wrestlers lost in a sea of giants that was the WWF in the 80s. Steamboat was a multi-time champion in Jim Crockett Promotions who had left a year prior due to creative headbutts with Dusty Rhodes. Bret Hart was part of the acclaimed Hart Foundation tag team who were still finding their feet.

The feud began early in the year and the plan was for the two men to go against each other at the second WrestleMania at one of the three venues booked for that day. With two technical masters going one-on-one, it would easily have been match of the night, especially considering the competition it had.

Why didn't it happen?

Shortly before the two had a match at the Boston Garden, they were told that their WrestleMania bout was off. According to Hart in his DVD, they believed Hercules would be the bigger star so wanted Steamboat to put him over instead, rather than giving the Hitman a platform to expose his skills in the ring which the Dragon wanted.

Nevertheless, Hercules fought Steamboat at the event, while Hart was stuffed into the WWF/NFL battle royale, though he did last until the final two before being eliminated by Andre the Giant.


5. Stone Cold Steve Austin vs. Hollywood Hulk Hogan - WrestleMania X8

Steve Austin Hulk Hogan
WWE.com

Triple H wasn't the only man Austin had on the books for WrestleMania X8. After the kybosh was put on the Two-Man Power Trip imploding, the new plan was for the Rattlesnake to take on the leader of the nWo, Hollywood Hulk Hogan in a clash of two undisputed icons of the wrestling business.

Following the underwhelming Invasion angle, Hogan, Scott Hall & Kevin Nash returned to the Fed in an attempt of hostile takeover. A feud between Hogan and Austin seemed to write itself as during 2002's No Way Out, Hogan cost Austin an Undisputed title match against Chris Jericho and, after a beatdown, sprayed the nWo logo on Austin's back.

Both Austin and the Rock feuded with the trio and both men fought a member of the faction at WrestleMania.

Why didn't it happen?

There was apparently heat between the two men and the word at the time was neither wanted to do the job for the other, though as previously mentioned, Austin wasn't happy in the company at this point in time. Because of the lack of animosity between Hogan & the Rock, that was the match booked and Stone Cold was stuck with Hall, which caused him to take a break from the company shortly after WrestleMania.


4. Triple H vs. CM Punk - WrestleMania XXX

CM Punk Triple H
WWE.com

Speaking of people unhappy with the company, CM Punk was the most high profile exit from WWE since Brock Lesnar. He was also the company's biggest star since Stone Cold, no matter how much the higher-ups tried to bring him down.

Leading up to WrestleMania XXX, Punk was offered the opportunity for a high profile match against Triple H, a man who he'd had history with during the all-too-brief Summer of Punk. Now the figurehead of the Authority, Triple H orchestrated Kane eliminate Punk from the Royal Rumble in 2014 and would eventually lead to a one-on-one match between Punk and the Game.

Why didn't it happen?

Punk suffered a serious case of burnout and frustration with the WWE creative team, not to mention them neglecting his health following a misdiagnosed staph infection. The night after the Royal Rumble, seeing the WrestleMania plans was the last straw for him and he walked out, never to step foot in a WWE ring again.

The Second City Saint also released a list of the WrestleMania card, which included Daniel Bryan vs Sheamus, Roman Reigns vs Dean Ambrose and Big Show vs Kane. All altered or scrapped because Punk valued his health over his pay check.


3. Shawn Michaels vs. Eddie Guerrero - WrestleMania 22

Shawn Michael, Eddie Guerrero
WWE

The phrase "dream match" is something purely in the opinions of wrestling fans. There are some who consider Stone Cold Steve Austin vs. CM Punk a dream match. But there maybe some odd folk out there who consider a dream match to be the Great Khali vs. Giant Gonzales.

In the mind of Bruce Pritchard, a dream match looked like a pure wrestling match between Shawn Michaels & Eddie Guerrero. The two men have had very similar journeys throughout their pro-wrestling life, two very talented technical wrestlers but fought battles against the demons of drink and drugs, both found salvation in Christianity when hitting rock-bottom and going on to have a career renaissance.

Pritchard put forward the match to Vince McMahon himself who pencilled it in for WrestleMania 22.

Why didn't it happen?

In a tragic twist of fate, a matter of days after the match was proposed, Eddie Guerrero suddenly passed away at the young age of 38, thus the dream match would never take place. The death had further reaching consequences as he was due to win the World Heavyweight Championship from Batista before the end of the year.

Rey Mysterio won the title at WrestleMania in tribute to Guerrero, whereas Shawn Michaels fought Mr. McMahon in an unsanctioned match.


2. Hulk Hogan Vs. Ric Flair - WrestleMania VIII

Hulk Hogan Ric Flair 1992
WWE.com

If ever there were two people synonymous with their respective companies, it was WCW's Ric Flair and WWF's Hulk Hogan. Following short-sighted business decisions new WCW's new owner Jim Herd, Ric Flair had not only jumped to WWF, but taken the Big Gold Belt with him.

During his stint, Flair won the Royal Rumble match after famously lasting an hour, also winning the WWF Championship in the process. The stage was then set for the dream match between Flair and Hulk Hogan in the main event of WrestleMania VIII. On-screen President Jack Tunney had made the match official and the two toured house shows leading up to the event, while also holding a press conference hyping the match.

Why didn't it happen?

In storyline, the match was changed after Sid Justice wanted retribution against Hogan for him getting unfairly eliminated at the Rumble. In reality, during the house show tours where Flair/Hogan was the main event, they didn't sell out tickets, though during that time the wrestling golden era was fading due to steroid investigations, prompting Hogan to take a hiatus.

There was also the story that Hogan refused to lose on his way out (because of course), but Vince McMahon didn't want Hulk to take the WWF Championship off of TV for an unknown period of time. So Hogan was booked to win by DQ to Sid, and Flair lost the title to Randy Savage instead.


1. The Undertaker vs. Sting - WrestleMania XXVII

Undertaker Sting
WWE.com

This was the dream match to end all dream matches, the Icon vs the Phenom, two undisputed legends of their respective companies and who had never crossed paths under their most famous guises.

Going into 2011, Sting's contract with TNA was due to expire and WWE was fighting hard to sign the last WCW loyalist. In the early months, the company began airing promos of a crooked shack, sinister background and the traditional spook'ems that you might expect, alongside the date 2/21/11 which was indeed going to signal Sting's arrival into the company.

The plan was for him to arrive on that date, end up confronting the Undertaker and set up a match between the two at WrestleMania XXVII.

Why didn't it happen?

Sting was offered the world by WWE to get him to sign a contract, not only a money-match with the Deadman, but also a Hall of Fame induction at that year's ceremony in Atlanta. Sting was apparently very close to signing on the dotted line but ultimately refused, citing his previous concerns about not trusting the company to treat his career with respect, in the same way they didn't with Booker T in 2001.

Sting eventually signed in 2014, fought in a losing effort to Triple H, and ended his WWE career following a catastrophic back injury at 2015's Night of Champions, putting rumblings of a WrestleMania 32 match between him and Undertaker firmly 6-feet under.


Contributor
Contributor

A connoisseur of Star Wars, WWE, Sonic the Hedgehog, musical theatre and mature cave-aged cheddar cheese. Can't say that I have limited taste!