21 WWE Matches That Almost Got 5 Stars
A lot of WWE fans will insist these deserve 5 stars, but there's no changing the past.
Dave Meltzer can be a controversial figure in certain parts of wrestling fandom. Even though his star rating system is strictly opinion-based and never to be held as sacrosanct, people will take his ratings a definitive statement of quality, and thus, an attack on their character if they hold a match in higher regard than he does.
It's especially ugly when he rates a match the dreaded 4.75 stars. To most people. that's an extremely high rating, and it applies to matches we should most certainly check out. However, to insane people, it means that Dave hated the match, and is trying to destroy its reputation. It's a lot like those idiots who take Metacritic or Rotten Tomatoes scores very seriously, and will do anything to uphold their integrity (mainly by yelling at the people who criticize their game or film of their choice).
There have been 21 matches in WWE history that have been rated 4.75 stars. We hope to prove that just because they didn't rate 5 stars according to Uncle Dave, they shouldn't most definitely be considered must-watch affairs.
21. Shawn Michaels Vs. Marty Jannetty (Monday Night RAW 1993)
I hope you're ready for endless gushing about how amazing Shawn Michaels is, because spoiler: this guy is gonna show up on this list several times. Of course, when he can almost get 5 stars for a match on RAW in 1993, can you really be surprised?
In the early days of Monday Night RAW, there wasn't that much of a focus on in-ring action. A typical episode mainly consisted of promos with jobber squashes sprinkled throughout. However, in July of '93, Shawn Michaels and Marty Jannetty defied convention, opening RAW with what was, at the time, considered one of the best title matches in history, when HBK defended his IC belt against his former tag partner.
Though not up to the standards of modern WWE matches, this high-flying, fast-pasted encounter was still a far cry from the usual plodding squashes audiences were used to at the time. And hey, when Randy Savage says only a few minutes in that it's one of the best matches he's seen in his life, clearly, you're doing something right. Dave Meltzer agreed, giving this match 4.75 stars.
20. Owen Hart Vs. Bret Hart (WrestleMania X)
Few stories of the post-Hogan era were as engrossing or elegant as the sibling rivalry between Owen and Bret Hart. Starting at Survivor Series 1993, the seeds of resentment were planted as Owen desired to move out of brother Bret's shadow. When tensions boiled over at the Royal Rumble, Owen snapped, turning on his brother, and challenging him to a match at WrestleMania X.
Opening the show, Owen wouldn't let the spotlight mess up his composure, as he and Bret put on a classic, forever raising the bar for curtain-jerking matches. The chemistry between the brothers was obvious, as both men used their training in the Hart Dungeon to put on an excellent display of technical prowess, but more important was the story they told: Bret tried to contain his wily younger brother and keep the encounter a simple wrestling match without losing his composure.
Ultimately, Owen would get the upset victory, but Bret would have the last laugh, as later in the night, he would reclaim the WWF Championship, thus allowing this iconic feud to continue and bring forth another classic at SummerSlam '94 (that one got 5 stars).
19. Shawn Michaels Vs. Razor Ramon (SummerSlam 1995)
Who doesn't love a good sequel? Blues Brothers 2000, Electric Boogaloo, The Legend of Curly's Gold- all revered follow-ups to beloved classics that hold up just as well.
WWE had a hard task to put on a good show for their annual SummerSlam event during the utter doldrums of 1995. The plan originally was for Intercontinental Champion Shawn Michaels to defend his title against Sycho Sid. However, realizing that the Mabel-headlined show was in danger of being the utter pits from a match standpoint, Vince decided to add some sizzle to the steak. Thus, a rematch of the WrestleMania X's ladder match between Shawn and Razor Ramon was commissioned. That match was, of course, the first ever in company history to earn 5 stars from Uncle Dave.
Despite having to live up to the expectations of the previous match, the new rule that barred them from using the ladders as weapons, and the fact that they were now both babyfaces, Razor and Shawn still put on an amazing athletic contest. While not as revolutionary as the first ladder match, it's still an exhilarating watch, and holds up today if you look at it as a match with ladders rather than a modern WWE ladder match.
18. Shawn Michaels Vs. Mankind (In Your House: Mind Games)
A big problem that plagued Shawn's run as WWF Champion in 1996 was the fact that the fans' attitude toward good guys was changing. While in WCW, the nWo were changing the game and enticing audiences with their cool bad guy personas, over in WWE, Shawn Michaels continued to be the clean-cut babyface who could do no wrong. It wasn't a recipe for success, and Vince knew he needed to inject more edge, albeit gradually (and begrudgingly).
One of his first steps was to have a one-off match at September's In Your House PPV, where Shawn defended his title against Mankind. Before becoming the lovable goof, Mick Foley's original portrayal of the character was like that of a psychotic wounded animal à la Jason Voorhees or Leatherface. The character combined with Foley's brawling style forced Michaels to become a nastier, more brutal wrestler than before. As a result, this match is often lauded as one of the best of the era, featuring extreme (for the time) spots combined with a compelling story.
Perhaps the one thing that kept it from getting a full 5 stars was a DQ finish, but that should come as a small price for an otherwise classic match.
17. Chris Jericho Vs. Chris Benoit (Royal Rumble 2001)
Alrighty then, so in addition to Shawn Michaels, Chris Benoit was quite the factory of almost-5-star classics. With that being said, I don't begrudge you if you gloss over the next few pages, as, well, you know.
With that said, the ladder match at the 2001 Royal Rumble between Chrises Benoit and Jericho is simply outstanding. Since arriving in WWE the year prior, Benoit had been feuding on and off with Jericho, delivering hard-hitting, technically outstanding matches. To blow off their feud, the two had an encounter at the Rumble that set a new standard for one-on-one ladder matches. In an era where the Hardyz, Dudleyz, and Edge & Christian were setting the bar for multi-man spotfests full of acrobatics, Benoit and Jericho brought things back to basics, focusing on one ladder at a time and using it as a weapon with which to kill each other.
Granted, parts of this match haven't aged well, including a particularly nasty chairshot Benoit takes to the head while diving outside. Nevertheless, this match is still a must-watch for any ladder aficianados.
16. Triple H Vs. Steve Austin (No Way Out 2001)
We've all had dispute with a coworker. They don't like that you're ranked above them, so they run you over with a car, take you out of action for a year, you swear revenge, and everything is settled in a bloody grudge match. Mondays, amirite?
To cap off the infamous "Austin hit by a car" storyline, Stone Cold and Triple H settled the score once and for all in a 3 Stages of Hell match. This stipulation, popular in many SmackDown: Here Comes the Pain sessions, consisted of a straight wrestling fall, a street fight, and a steel cage match. Hunter and Steve proceeded to beat the tar out of each other, bloodying each other until neither man was able to stand. Most remember this one fondly, as it showcased the strengths of both men: Austin's intensity and Hunter's in-ring psychology.
However, this match's high rating is a point of controversy, as some are turned off by the 39 minute length (in the middle of the PPV, no less). Still, if you can stomach that length, you'll see there's some fantastic violence and storytelling to be found in this Attitude Era gem.
15. TLC II (WrestleMania X-Seven)
It truly speaks to the depth and the talent of WWE's roster during their golden era when at their most acclaimed PPV of all time, a midcard tag team match managed to steal the show above classics such as Shane vs. Vince or Austin vs. Rock. Of course, this was no ordinary tag match. Just months after innovating the tables, ladders, and chairs match, the Hardyz, Dudleys, and Edge & Christian managed to out-do themselves with TLC II. Much like Shawn and Razor's ladder-iffic sequel, these teams added to the legacy of the ladder match and then some as they raised the bar of car wreck spotfests to heights that likely will never be reached.
In front of a rabid Astrodome crowd
14. Chris Jericho & Chris Benoit Vs. Steve Austin & Triple H (Monday Night RAW 2001)
Everyone agrees that from a booking perspective, teaming up a heel Steve Austin and Triple H was a bad idea. However, it cannot be denied that they had tremendous in-ring chemistry, especially when paired up against the likes of Chris Benoit and Chris Jericho. In what is considered one of the best RAW matches of all time even to this day, Team Chris took on the Two Man Power Trip for their tag team titles in a blistering affair.
This match is of course most well known for the famous incident where Triple H's quadriceps tore. However, despite such a devastating injury justifiably ending a match nowadays, Hunter chose to go through the finish anyway, including taking a Walls of Jericho on the announce table like the absolute man of steel he is.
Triple H being a masochist aside, this match is still a fantastic affair that shows off how good a heel Stone Cold could be in-ring, and allowed Benoit and Jericho a real rub as babyfaces against the company's two biggest heels. A victory all-around (except for Triple H's quads).
13. TLC III (SmackDown 2001)
What's better than another TLC featuring the three classic teams? Why the addition of Chris Benoit and Chris Jericho. What's better than a TLC featuring the three classic teams and Team Chris? Putting it on SmackDown for a national audience to watch for free.
Yes, in the utter bedlam that was 2001, WWE capped off their hot run of amazing matches by putting on the third TLC match, one that featured eight of their most talented superstars, on a May episode of SmackDown of all things. Why did this happen? Whose idea was this?
Who knows, and frankly, who cares? The point is: fans across America got to witness the same wicked car wreck shenanigans PPV buyers had seen twice before, with the added bonus of Benoit and Jericho's Hart Dungeon grit to add a little variety. That's like getting a free beer and then a shot of fancy liqueur on the house.
Although this match won't be talked about as much when looking back on TLC (because you-know-who is in it), it's still one that should definitely be checked out.
12. Kurt Angle & Chris Benoit Vs. Edge & Rey Mysterio (No Mercy 2002)
Hope you also like a lavishing of "Kurt Angle is amazing," because he too has put on a smattering of near 5-star classics.
Many fans today look back fondly on the era of SmackDown when Paul Heyman was the head writer, and for good reason. That was the time of the vaunted "SmackDown Six." Consisting of Angle, Benoit, Edge, Rey Mysterio, and Eddie and Chavo Guerrero, the Six would regularly put on great matches week in and week out on SmackDown in both singles and tag team action. The group reached perhaps their in-ring zenith at No Mercy 2002, when Rey and Edge tagged against Benoit and Angle to determine the inaugural WWE Tag Team Championships in a match that won the Wrestling Observer's Match of the Year award. That's right, kids, you could win Match of the Year without going 5 stars or higher back in the day! Crazy stuff.
Naturally, the match is fantastic. All four men had amazing chemistry and showed off what they cold do. A young Edge showed that he was more than just a gimmick wrestler and was a true main-eventer. Add that with a hot crowd that grows hotter with every nearfall, and you have the makings of an instant classic.