21 WWE Matches That Almost Got 5 Stars
11. Kurt Angle Vs. Chris Benoit (Royal Rumble 2003)
It's arguable that Kurt Angle and Chris Benoit had the best in-ring rivalry in WWE history. From around 2001 to 2003, these two feuded on and off, and each time they met, it was like magic. They were rough, ground-based technicians who knew how to make every match feel like a fight. Perhaps there is no better example of that than their WWE title match at the 2003 Royal Rumble.
The two had scrapped before, but now, on a stage like the Royal Rumble, with the WWE Championship up for grabs, these two were ready to put everything on the line, especially Benoit, who had never won the gold at that stage in his WWE run. What followed was a blistering series of suplexes, chops, and submission holds that never dragged in pace. It was the kind of speed, athleticism, drama, and storytelling that people had come to expect of the SmackDown Six around this time, and Benoit and Angle were perhaps the two greatest ambassadors. This match certainly ranks among the best Royal Rumble title matches.
10. Chris Benoit Vs. Triple H Vs. Shawn Michaels (WrestleMania XX)
If you're tired of us talking about Chris Benoit, worry not: we're done after this.
After a ripper of a performance from the #1 position in the Royal Rumble match, Chris Benoit earned his shot at the WrestleMania main event. Rather than stay on SmackDown, however, Benoit chose to butt in on Triple H and Shawn Michaels' lovers quarrel. It ended up working well in the story, as Hunter and Shawn were so focused on destroying each other, they forgot to properly factor Benoit into the equation.
Interesting psychology aside, however, this match was a nonstop flurry of offense. It's likely one of the most action-packed WrestleMania main events of all time, as the pace would not cease. To add to that, Triple H and Shawn Michaels spilled enough blood to fill the elevator from The Shining, and the emotional ending of Benoit finally winning the gold and celebrating with Eddie Guerrero is the sugar-coated fairytale ending we all wanted.
Of course, if you think Shawn Michaels would be satisfied with just a couple amazing WrestleMania matches, think again...
9. Kurt Angle Vs. Shawn Michaels (WrestleMania 21)
So you know how Shawn Michaels is Mr. WrestleMania? Well, along with classics such as the triple threat at WrestleMania XX and some other matches we'll get to, this was one of the reasons why. At WrestleMania 21, at the height of the Ruthless Aggression era, HBK and Kurt Angle, the two best workers in the company finally clashed for a dream match and delivered on every expectation and then some.
Michaels, working in his natural role as the face (hey stop laughing, smarks, it's true!) faced against a naturally heel Angle. It was the ultimate battle of smug good vs. goofy evil, and moreover, it was an amazing clash of styles. Michaels, the ultimate smooth mover and high flyer, had to stoop down to Kurt Angle's ground-based grappling. Ultimately, Angle would win out with his tactics, but he would have to dig deep to make the Heartbreak kid submit.
Angle and Michaels would have several encounters throughout 2005, but this one is rightfully remembered as the best, showing that WrestleMania is the best place to have these dream encounters.
8. The Undertaker Vs. Shawn Michaels (WrestleMania 25)
The Undertaker and Shawn Michaels had a long, storied history going into WrestleMania 25. The two had a series of matches in the late '90s that included the inaugural Hell in a Cell match, one of the few WWE matches to earn the illustrious 5 stars.
But it was at their first WrestleMania match, nearly 12 years after their Hell in a Cell encounter, where both men sought to rewrite their history and build a legendary rivalry for a new generation. What resulted was what many consider to be the greatest WrestleMania match of all time.
Despite both men being in their 40s, Michaels and 'Taker had the in-ring smoothness and chemistry of a Pete Dunne and Tyler Bate (but more on those two later). With every high flying maneuver and near-fall, it was clear why these men had the longevity and popularity they did, as they were simply the best. Aside from a rather nasty botch which made viewers briefly believe 'Taker had broken his neck and died, this is simply a flawless match, one that probably should have earned that extra quarter star.
7. The Undertaker Vs. Shawn Michaels (WrestleMania XXVI)
Shawn Michaels was unable to end 'Taker's streak at WrestleMania 25, and such a failure drove him mad. After costing the Deadman the World Heavyweight Championship, HBK decided to put it all on the line: it was either gonna be the streak, or his career.
In one of the greatest retirement matches of all time, HBK and 'Taker replaced the crispness and majesty of their previous encounter with pure aggression and hatred. Neither man could afford to lose this match, least of all Shawn, who fought like his life was on the line. Every move was done with such purposeful intent to harm the enemy, to inflict pain, to remind them of what they did. It's a brilliant example of how character and story can inform the psychology of a match, and who better to show that to an audience than these two?
Ultimately, Shawn's desperate brawling was for naught, as 'Taker put him away with a fateful tombstone, ending the Heartbreak Kid's legendary career. He may have lost, but ultimately he, as did all the fans, won, having one more amazing match to add to his legacy.
6. The Undertaker Vs. Triple H (WrestleMania XXVIII)
After Shawn Michaels had his Undertaker-induced retirement, DX bosom buddy Triple H took on the task of trying to defeat the Deadman and end the streak. His first effort came at WrestleMania XXVII (AKA the bad one), where he succumbed to the Hell's Gate submission, but not before severely injuring The Undertaker and taking him out of action for nearly a year. Humiliated by such an ignoble victory, 'Taker asked Hunter for one more match so he could get revenge. Daddy Helmsley acquiesced, but on the condition that the match be under his terms: a Hell in a Cell match with Shawn Michaels as the special guest referee.
Obviously, unlike his matches with Shawn, 'Taker's encounter with Triple H was going to rely more heavily on spectacle and storyline, but damn if the crowd didn't eat it up. 'Taker and Tri pummeled the bits out of each other, and even HBK got in on the action, delivering a superkick to 'Taker which Hunter complimented with a pedigree, a combination which 'Taker managed to kick out of, much to the utter shock of the Miami crowd.
This match was full of emotion, grit, and was well deserving of the "End of an Era" moniker.
5. Sami Zayn Vs. Adrian Neville (NXT Takeover: R Evolution)
Around late 2014, it became clear that the main WWE product was badly losing an arms race to NXT. Whereas RAW and SmackDown were becoming a same-y, tacky advertisement for the WWE Network featuring the same guys on top, NXT was offering fresh, exciting storylines with new talent putting on excellent matches. The center of this revolution was Sami Zayn, the top babyface of the promotion, as a lengthy story followed his journey to the NXT Championship. After several failed opportunities, Zayn had one last chance against longtime rival Adrian Neville to achieve his dream.
In a dramatic, high-flying encounter in front of a fired-up Full Sail crowd, the amiable Zayn stuck to his principles and managed a clean, decisive victory over Neville, being congratulated by the NXT roster.
This match is probably most well-known for the segment that followed, in which the newly-debuted Kevin Owens turned on his friend Sami. It also suffers from Rich Brennan's terrible commentary. However, none of that should take away from this match's place as the pinnacle of NXT's first peak era.
4. Brock Lesnar Vs. John Cena Vs. Seth Rollins (Royal Rumble 2015)
The Royal Rumble 2015. What a joke, right fellas? That's the show where the dismal Roman Reigns push began, and has yet to cease ever since. Oh, and it was also the site of one of the best WWE title matches of all time, but whatever! A guy we don't like won a different match, and thus everything else is invalidated!
Seriously though, no one can deny what a belter John Cena, Seth Rollins, and then-champion Brock Lesnar put on right before the fateful Rumble match. Each man played their part perfectly: Brock the unstoppable monster who suplexed everyone and everything, John Cena the mainstay powerhouse reviled by the crowd, and Seth Rollins the young opportunist who pulled out amazing athletic displays. What resulted was a high-octane flurry of offense that never let up.
It was here that Seth Rollins, with his high-flying maneuvers and excellent character work, began his streak of amazing matches in 2015 that would cement his status as superstar of the year, and it's also what makes it harder to forget that it was... that other one from the Shield who WWE decided to make "the guy."
3. John Cena Vs. AJ Styles (Royal Rumble 2017)
Here's where we really start to get into the area of controversy when it comes to Dave Meltzer's star ratings. This match came weeks after Kazuchika Okada and Kenny Omega broke the system and earned 6 stars for the main event of Wrestle Kingdom 11. John Cena and AJ Styles, who already had two great singles bouts under their belts, sought to take the world by storm with a clinic of their own. And to most WWE fans, they did just that, not only surpassing their previous encounters, but topping many peoples' match of the year lists for 2017. Meltzer himself loved the match, awarding it 4.75 stars.
Of course, ranking a whole star and a half below Okada and Omega meant WWE fans got angry, and where there's anger, there's controversy. But if you were to distance yourself from the noise and fury and look at the match itself, you'd see Cena/Styles III doesn't need to compare itself to other matches. It is, simply, a showcase of what two veterans who have perfect chemistry can do in the right circumstance in front of the right crowd. It is, in this author's opinion, both men's finest hour, and you should definitely watch it again.
2. Pete Dunne Vs. Tyler Bate (NXT Takeover: Chicago)
You're probably at least older than Tyler Bate, who at the age of 20 almost had a 5 star match, and by many WWE fans' standards, did. Now, before you close the computer and wallow in existential dread, let us take a moment to appreciate what Tyler Bate and Pete Dunne were able to accomplish before either of them were legally old enough to rent a car in the United States.
Bate (20) and Dunne (24) were first seen on WWE screens in January 2017's UK Tournament, in which Bate defeated Dunne in the final to become the inaugural UK Champion. The division went mostly quiet until NXT Takeover: Chicago, where Dunne and Bate reemerged, now in front of a molten Chicago crowd who ate up every hard chop, high flying maneuver, and expert near-fall. These young adults were wrestling like grizzled veterans, and were giving WWE audiences a first-rate lesson in British strong style. Ultimately, Tyler Bate looked stronger here than he did in the tournament, despite taking a loss in this match, and his and Pete Dunne's stock have only risen higher.
If this was your match of the year in 2017, I can't say I blame you.