25 Best Wrestling PPVs Ever

Fifteen years later, is 'Mania X-Seven still the wrestling PPV standard-bearer?

WrestleMania X Seven Poster
WWE.com

The perfect wrestling card, loosely, should follow a simple, proven formula:

A frenetically-paced, unpredictable opener designed to engage, intoxicate and keep the audience guessing, followed by a succession of similarly-paced matches to sustain the momentum - kept to a minimum content-wise in order to not overshadow the feature bouts.

A lengthier match should be slotted in at the midway point to make best use of the incited fever pitch and to reinforce or promote the real and emerging stars - before a designated cool-down match or two is wheeled out to preserve the heat of the main event, which ideally should be imbued with significant, unmissable stakes.

This isn't always the case. One need look no further than 2000-era WCW to see that even a talented roster, when subjected to rudderless direction, is unable to rescue an event from the depths of creative malaise.

Wrestling cards can even be too good - several semi-final matches and main events from recent NXT TakeOver specials have suffered from audience exhaustion resulting from pacing issues.

The shows discussed here, however, are uniformly outstanding, veering across an enviable spectrum of in-ring quality and storyline progression - the absolute best in wrestling's vaunted history...

25. WCW Spring Stampede 1999

Spring Stampede 99
WWE.com

Best Match: Juventud Guerrera Vs. Blitzkrieg

Worst Match: Scotty Riggs Vs. Mikey Whipwreck

WCW was already practically on its a*rse by spring 1999.

Having resolutely failed to cross the Monday Night Wars finish line at Starrcade '97, the overexposure of the nWo and the over-reliance on decrepit stars of yesteryear, combined with the resurgent and profane WWF youth movement, left the Ted Turner-financed corporation in a distant second place.

The infamous Fingerpoke of Doom in January, which relaunched the nWo precisely when WCW fans had grown most weary of it, sent a clear message: WCW had ran out of ideas.

Spring Stampede '99 was an aberration - but an entirely thrilling one. Showcasing the best of WCW - from a thrillingly inventive and dizzying Cruiserweight opener between Blitzkrieg and Juventud Guerrera to a procession of sterling efforts put forth by the company's loaded, stellar midcard - the show even equalised Goldberg's first loss to Kevin Nash in a match which was better than many anticipated.

The main event, pitting Diamond Dallas Page against Hulk Hogan, Ric Flair and Sting in a Four Corners match, was a lumbering and protracted affair - but that was an accepted drawback to the company which most fans had already made peace with.


24. WWF WrestleMania XIV

Stone Cold Shawn Michaels
WWE.com

Best Match: Shawn Michaels Vs. Steve Austin

Worst Match: Tag Team Battle Royale

The show started inauspiciously - the spectacle associated with the Show of Shows was jarringly disregarded with the in media res sight of an action-free and jobberfied tag team battle royal opener - but it soon generated momentum through several exciting and markedly different matches, none of which dragged on any longer than they needed to.

The match between the Undertaker and Kane was a botch-friendly disappointment, given the smash success of the formidable, illustrious wider storyline which preceded it, but the significant crowd heat just about carried it. Elsewhere, much excitement was provided by the WWF's stable of young bucks, demonstrating that they were primed to wrest the crown of ratings king away from the self-styled "Big Boys" of WCW.

The main event between Steve Austin and Shawn Michaels didn't reach the impeccable standards they'd set at King Of The Ring '97, but it was miraculous in that both men were in considerable pain before the opening bell. Michaels' spine was so mangled that he barely appeared on television to promote it and would disappear from in-ring competition for four years, while Austin was still in the process of working out an adjusted in-ring style which wouldn't place an excruciating strain on his decimated neck.

No one match would prop up a best-ever playlist, but it is the consummate studio album of wrestling events.


23. WCW Beach Blast 1992

Ricky Steamboat Rick Rude Beach Blast 1992
WWE.com

Best Match: Sting Vs. Cactus Jack

Worst Match: Greg Valentine Vs. Marcus Bagwell

Beach Blast '92 was such an excellent card that it transcended the dirge the company found itself in at the time.

WCW was flailing creatively following the beyond-abysmal stewardship of Jim Herd. The hopelessly anachronistic stylings of Bill Watts, who was so staunchly old school that he banned top rope offence during a time in which its Light Heavyweight division was restoring the league's critical reputation, were not enough to tarnish Beach Blast 1992's awesome aura.

The star-studded roster was used very effectively - even if its creative regime was stifling. The undoubted highlight was Sting's Falls Count Anywhere victory over Cactus Jack, which blended wince-inducing violence with cerebral storytelling. Jack, removed slightly from the deranged stuntman he styled himself to be, heelishly played possum throughout, enticing Sting into smashing himself into the concrete surrounding the ring. Watts felt that even protective matting was a contravention of wrestling tradition.

Elsewhere, Randy Savage and Ricky Steamboat assembled a gripping 30-minute Iron Man contest, which never outstayed its welcome and made great use of its inherent sympathy-generating match structure. The main event pitting the Steiner Brothers against Steve Williams and Terry Gordy was a little long-winded, but Scott and Rick were in the form of the careers. A little self-indulgence could be excused.


22. WWF Royal Rumble 2000

Tazz Royal Rumble 2000
WWE.com

Best Match: Triple H Vs. Cactus Jack

Worst Match: New Age Outlaws Vs. Acolytes

This show so typified the oversexed ultra-violence of the Attitude Era that UK television station Channel 4 opted not to renew what would have been in incredibly lucrative agreement with the WWF. They even took the step of digitising blood on subsequent PPV broadcasts.

They were revolted at the oceans of blood and the intentionally disgusting sight of Mae Young's prosthetic breasts - but the Madison Square Garden crowd lapped it up, furnishing a diverse and thrilling card with massive heat throughout.

This was the night on which Triple H established permanent residency in the main event bracket as a result of a career-best, wholly selfless performance from Cactus Jack, who achieved this, ironically, by going on the (uncharacteristic) offensive in what began as a one-sided war. This was astutely designed to underline Triple H's eventual triumph.

The show was so bulletproof in execution that it even presented Tazz as a deadly proposition, who following which looked certain for a considerable degree of midcard success.

Taka Michinoku wasn't so lucky; his infamously painful-looking flat-face bump was the subject of much amusement to commentator Jerry Lawler.


21. WWE WrestleMania XXIV

Edge WrestleMania XXIV
WWE.com

Best Match: The Undertaker Vs. Edge

Worst Match: Playboy Bunnymania Lumberjill

Headlined by The Undertaker's brilliant Streak defence and World Heavyweight Title victory over Edge, WrestleMania XXIV was able to sustain audience enthusiasm over its epic four hour duration through diverse and momentous in-ring action.

Shawn Michaels and Ric Flair's Career Threatening Match was imbued with a tangible sense of emotion, which equalised the sloppiness resulting from Flair's lack of mobility. Even though he later reneged on his retirement, as many predicted, it's difficult not to empathise with the man, even on repeated viewing, as he burst into tears before the referee's hand struck the mat for a third time. He had made a career out of making wrestling his life.

The classic main event was supplemented by one of the weaker and less believable - but still exciting - Money In The Bank ladder efforts, before Big Show and Floyd Mayweather tore the house down in a match far better than it had any right to be.

The opening Belfast Brawl was also stunning, made all the better by style of the burly bruisers who contested it. Suspension of disbelief was incredibly easy as JBL and Finlay tore lumps off one another.


20. NJPW King Of Pro Wrestling 2013

King Of Pro Wrestling 2013
NJPW

Best Match: Kazuchika Okada Vs. Hiroshi Tanahashi

Worst Match: Minoru Suzuki Vs. Toru Yano

Kazuchika Okada and Hiroshi Tanahashi equalled the rivalries of Ric Flair and Ricky Steamboat on this celebrated night - before somehow surpassing them in their subsequent matches. This was the match in which Tanahashi famously resorted to heel tactics in an ill-fated attempt to halt the changing of the guard. By feigning a knee injury and taking advantage of Okada's hesitation, he foreshadowed his supplanting as New Japan ace in a match which your writer reckons is the most intelligent of their series.

Okada's selling of his arm is so masterful throughout that his subsequent inability to apply his Red Ink submission and smash Tanahashi with his Rainmaker clothesline receive more of a reaction than they would have had he been successful.

Katsuyori Shibata's rematch with Tomohiri Ishii lacks the novelty of their original G1 Climax d*ck-measuring contest, but retains its gruesome physicality, while Shinsuke Nakamura and Naomichi Marifuji is a feast of stiff, delirious inventiveness.

Massively gifted and even more deranged sh*tkicker Minoru Suzuki was wasted against comedy midcard jobber in the show's only blotch.


19. WCW Bash At The Beach 1996

Hogan Heel Turn
WWE.com

Best Match: Rey Mistero, Jr. Vs. Psicosis

Worst Match: Steve McMichael Vs. Joe Gomez

Pay Per View events usually act as the stage on which major angles are settled. In revolutionising the industry in the mid nineties, it's almost appropriate that WCW subverted the script and initiated their biggest ever storyline on Pay Per View.

The angle was so incendiary, so momentous, so unpredictable, that it, almost by itself, excused what was a night of fairly middling in-ring action. The prospect of Hulk Hogan as Scott Hall and Kevin Nash's third man in their battle with Lex Luger, Randy Savage and Sting was so inconceivable that even Bobby Heenan's suggestion that Hogan might not be on the expected side came across more as heel bluster than a botch.

When Hogan, whose early career heel run was a forgotten memory in the wake of his business-expanding face persona, dropped that infamous leg, infuriated fans pelted the ring with garbage. This image soon become the nWo's calling card. Hogan told those same fans to "stick it" in a career-best, industry-shaking promo.

Match quality wasn't entirely nonexistent, though - the blinding opener pitting Rey Mistero, Jr. against Psicosis, despite the near-silence of the ungrateful crowd, is a typically awesome WCW Cruiserweight effort, one which, almost fittingly, made its audience wait for the most spectacular aerial assaults.


18. WCW/AAA When Worlds Collide

AAA When Worlds Collide
WWE.com

Best Match: El Hijo Del Santo & Octagon Vs. Eddy Guerrero & Art Barr

Worst Match: N/A

The Wrestling Observer ***** effort pitting El Hijo Del Santo & Octagon against Eddy Guerrero & Art Barr is completely warranted in its undying praise.

Set against a backdrop of genuine, emotional, cacophonous heat, it is a masterpiece of American wrestling fused seamlessly with awe-inspiring lucha libre, in which the best of both styles is showcased. The stunning aerials and dives are not employed arbitrarily, but rather woven into the fabric of the match just when the colossal heat generated by the heel Gringos Locos heel team of Guerrero and Barr is cut off at its apex.

That the best sequence of the match - a Doomsday Frankensteiner followed by Barr's best ever Frog Splash - arrives so early into it is a testament of its immaculate pacing.

Their heat-seeking tactics (Art Barr in particular is loathed by the raucous and partisan crowd) are stupendous. They, adorned in US-flag patterned tights, pretend to swim, insulting the Mexican fans by insinuating that they'd have to illegally cross the border to reach their apparent promised land.

Far from a one match card, When Worlds Collide features four other matches ranging from worthy to excellent - the young Rey Misterio, Jr. is frighteningly quick, demonstrating winning chemistry in his exchanges with Psicosis, with whom he'd put Cruiserweight wrestling on the mainstream map in WCW.


17. WCW Spring Stampede 1994

Spring Stampede 1994
WWE.com

Best Match: The Nasty Boys Vs. Cactus Jack & Maxx Payne

Worst Match: Sting Vs. Rick Rude

That Sting and Rick Rude at or near enough their peak had the worst match on the card isn't necessarily an indictment of their performances - even though they were capable of much better - but more an affirmation that several uncelebrated stars had their best ever matches, curiously, on this single night.

The Nasty Boys were a basic tandem, effective heels though they were, but their Falls Count Anywhere match with Cactus Jack and Maxx Payne was a full-on riot, so fractious in execution that Jerry Sags doesn't even bother to fold a steel chair before practically stabbing it in Payne's back. The match ends, after the two teams destroy a merchandise stand in a proto-Attitude Era spot, when Sags cracks Foley full-force in the face with a shovel.

Bunkhouse Bunk's Bunkhouse Brawl win over Dustin Rhodes was similarly unruly. Elsewhere, the action was diverse enough to incorporate a fusion of British chain wrestling and high-flying in Lord Steven Regal Vs. Brian Pillman, and a retread of the seminal Rick Steamboat Vs. Ric Flair series which, while not the ***** classic they wrestled ad nauseam in the late eighties, was still a fantastic effort .


16. WWF King Of The Ring 1993

Bret Hart Bam Bam Bigelow King of the Ring 1993
WWE.com

Best Match: Bret Hart Vs. Mr. Perfect

Worst Match: Shawn Michaels Vs. Crush

WWE, until fairly recently, was derided for having a one-dimensional style, based on a compartmentalised and predictable narrative pattern with an emphasis on logic over bombast.

The argument has its merits - and legion examples - but Bret Hart went some way towards expanding the in-ring palette at King Of The Ring 1993, during which he entered his umpteenth career-making performance, one so awesome that it compelled Vince McMahon to belatedly designate him as The Man in the World Wrestling Federation.

In wrestling three very different - but very, very good matches against Razor Ramon, Mr. Perfect and Bam Bam Bigelow - Hart, who accounted for over a third of the show's run time, had proven himself capable of sustaining audience interest over an extended period of time.

Elsewhere, the action was middling - his would-be successor Hulk Hogan's match with Yokozuna bombed, precipitating the emergence of the New Generation - but the post-coronation ceremony, in which Jerry Lawler destroyed Hart, was a winning return to the long-term narrative policy jettisoned at the mercy of Hulk Hogan's fading star at WrestleMania IX.


Contributor
Contributor

Michael Sidgwick (Creative Writing BA Hons) is an editor, writer and podcaster for WhatCulture Wrestling. With over a decade of experience in wrestling analysis, Michael was published in the influential UK institution that was Power Slam magazine, and specialises in providing insights into All Elite Wrestling - so much so that he wrote a book about the subject. You can order Becoming All Elite: The Rise Of AEW on Amazon. Possessing a deep knowledge also of WWE, WCW, ECW and New Japan Pro Wrestling, Michael’s work has been publicly praised by AEW World Champions Kenny Omega and MJF, and Undisputed WWE Champion Cody Rhodes. When he isn’t putting your finger on why things are the way they are in the endlessly fascinating world of professional wrestling, Michael wraps his own around a hand grinder to explore the world of specialty coffee. Follow Michael on X (formerly known as Twitter) @MSidgwick for more!