25 Greatest WWE WrestleMania Matches Ever
The most epic clashes from thirty years of grand spectacles.
So, what's the greatest WrestleMania match of all time?
It's a debate with no end. How does one pick one 'five star' saga over another? The matches that ostensibly are WrestleMania's consensus picks are great for different reasons. Is one really any better than the next?
What makes a great WrestleMania match? Something of length is preferred; it can't be an action-packed but short match, but it doesn't necessarily have to be War and Peace-length either. A match with high drama and an unpredictable outcome is also important. There needs to be suspense, that hair-tearing feeling of anxiousness with every twist of the screw - that 'big match feel', so to speak. Essentially, it is the duty of a great WrestleMania match to be memorable for the right reasons. What makes the list difficult is that there are more than 25 such matches.
If you go by the accepted tenets of what 'five star' matches are, and how it differs from a 'four star' match, know that in the eyes of the author, each match listed here was a heavy candidate for best match in its respective year. If something got left off, bear in mind that space was limited.
What's the greatest WrestleMania match of all time? Here's how one person stacks up the very best...
25. Kurt Angle Vs. Chris Benoit (WrestleMania X-Seven)
In an era where seemingly every main event included one lengthy brawl around ringside and into the crowd, would Attitude Era fans appreciate a straightforward scientific battle? The likes of Benoit and Angle had spent the previous year or so playing the WWE game, fusing their mat mastery with the company's simplified main event style. As a taste of something different, the two were given time in Houston to show that they could do more.
Aside from Angle's underhandedness later in the match, he and Benoit delivered a slice of something foreign to the audience of the time, and it was very well received. From the opening stalemates to the jockeying for big moves late, the gallery that came to expect lawless mayhem was popping fiercely for suplexes and submission attempts.
24. The Rock Vs. Hollywood Hogan (WrestleMania X8)
No, it's not a technical classic, but it needn't be. Any fan aged 16 or over who saw this match live was transported to a simpler time. Long before wrestling was about the chaos, the drama, and the glut, there was 'The Hulkster', fighting for the rights of every man. The infusion of youthful innocence was coaxed out by a Toronto crowd that felt like turning the clock back.
Even Hogan seemed surprised by the hero's ovation for his every move, and before you knew it, the roof over SkyDome nearly fragmented by the shockwaves of 68,000 fans egging on the Superman comeback. It's an audience match, which is what every big match is realistically supposed to be. Compared to the average indy-fantastic suplex-and-headdrop-fest, give me Hogan channeling 1984 any day.
23. Kurt Angle Vs. Brock Lesnar (WrestleMania XIX)
The closer of WrestleMania XIX was less an excellent match and more of a triumph over circumstance. It was once unfathomable that Angle, with his spine in shreds and tatters, could even work any match with Lesnar come March 30, let alone a highly-physical one. Against better judgement, Angle performed in the bout, and just about came out of it in better shape than his brutish opponent.
Those that don't hang in the dirtsheet chow line wouldn't have known about Angle's medical crisis from watching the match, as he ably kept up with Lesnar. But those watching all realized how close Lesnar was to a broken neck when his shooting star press went awry. Even with the horrifyingly-botched finish, it's a match worthy of each man's talents.
22. Shawn Michaels Vs. Chris Jericho (WrestleMania XIX)
Michaels was only performing on a semi-regular basis at the time, still wading into the waters of a full-on return to the ring. After a mediocre match with Triple H at Armageddon, and a very brief Royal Rumble appearance, it stood to reason that expectations shouldn't be so elevated for the WrestleMania match. However, a highly-motivated Jericho had captivated Michaels with his ideas for a storyline, and it only escalated from there.
Thus was the rebirth of Mr. WrestleMania, the exhumation of a performer that routinely put his peers to shame at one time out of insecurity, but now out of second-nature friendly competition. Michaels and Jericho wove a wonderful story of envy and ego, indicating that Michaels may well be a Dorian Gray that painted over the smeared portrait of his troubled youth.
21. Ric Flair Vs. Macho Man Randy Savage (WrestleMania VIII)
In the vast desert of increasingly-cartooned WWE programming, Savage stretched as an oasis across two racy storylines: one with Jake Roberts involving cobra venom and the battery of Elizabeth, and one with Flair for the WWE Championship, intertwining with a curious claim that Flair 'knew' Savage's wife first. Lecherous Flair and blind-rage Savage are a potent witches' brew.
There has never been a Randy Savage match in which you didn't feel that his actions weren't genuine. When he slugs a bloodied Flair in the face, there is no doubt to even jaded eyes that he's willing to beat Flair to death if need be. The championship is secondary to the 'music', and Flair was just the right foil for Savage's command of sound.
20. Brock Lesnar Vs. Roman Reigns Vs. Seth Rollins (WrestleMania 31)
After weeks and months of the standoff between the Reigns-backing office and the most vociferous fans (the ones that wouldn't cancel their Network subscriptions out of protest because of NXT), WWE held their position and went on with the planned Lesnar-Reigns match, only modifying the ending to the delight of most. The extended build was limp, but the match itself was tremendous.
Reigns took an extended beating and then returned to dish it out on a bloody Lesnar, something akin to a 1992 Vader-Sting match, but with an action-movie bent to it. The Rollins cash-in was just the slightly-tacked-on finish that WrestleMania 31 needed to put it over the top as a transcendent event, but it must be said that the match prior to Rollins' music hitting was doing quite well.
19. Money In The Bank (WrestleMania 21)
It's a fair point to make that Money in the Bank matches over time have diluted the idea of World title changes meaning something, but in the beginning, Edge's cash-in on John Cena was pretty dang special. That magical briefcase was claimed in what stands up today as the greatest Money in the Bank match to date, a notch or two above the 'All Stars' match from 2013.
When you've got spots like Chris Benoit German suplexing Chris Jericho as Y2J holds a ladder, and Shelton Benjamin running hands free up ladder rungs to throw a clothesline, you know you're watching a watershed match. While most Money matches hardly ever disappoint, few have approached the flow and craziness of the original.
18. Macho Man Randy Savage Vs. Hulk Hogan (WrestleMania V)
When inducting Savage as part of last year's Hall of Fame class, Hogan noted how Savage would bring the people he worked with to his skyward level, even if he had to hit them a bit harder as a beckoning. That level of intensity was evident when Hogan and Savage locked horns in Atlantic City, and it was a far cry from Hogan's paint-by-numbers fare.
There's something about seeing Hogan away from the bounds of a 'safe' match, slugging it out with more oomph in his punches, and throwing Savage to the floor with a bodyslam. Savage slipped so seamlessly into the role of underhanded fiend, giving Hogan his most intriguing opponent since Andre, and most likely even before then.
17. Daniel Bryan Vs. Triple H (WrestleMania XXX)
It was like a 'Choose Your Own Adventure' book at gunpoint. Weeks and months of hijacking shows led to WWE caving in and giving the world its desired "Daniel Bryan Conquers the Machine" story, taking place in two parts and ending with him claiming the WWE Championship. Both matches were excellent, but the latter misses this cut. The former places a wee bit higher.
Triple H held his own in a highly-physical battle that lacked middling frills, and showed everyone that even in his mid-forties, he could still perform at the level of an uninhibited technician like Bryan. It's the second-greatest opening match in WrestleMania history, and a pleasant surprise for fans that pre-10 March 2014 weren't expecting much out of WrestleMania.