25 Greatest WWE WrestleMania Matches Ever

16. Eddie Guerrero Vs. Kurt Angle (WrestleMania XX)

Eddie Guerrero Kurt Angle WrestleMania XX Frog Splash.jpg
WWE.com

Over three hours into a super-extended five hour card, and two supreme-level wrestling machines were able to hold the attention of the fans for around 20 minutes. Not that you'd expect anything less from Guerrero and Angle around the apex of each man's career. Little more was required than telling both men to go out there and just do what they do best.

The dynamic was as form-fitting as lycra, with Guerrero's cat-and-mouse cleverness weaving impeccably with Angle's bull-headed destructiveness. Angle's resolute focus on getting Guerrero to submit to his ankle lock led to a swank moment of invention on Guerrero's part, and the ending satisfied each man's persona, while leaving the door open for rematches down the line.


15. Hulk Hogan Vs. The Ultimate Warrior (WrestleMania VI)

wwe.com

From 1984 to 1990, every extended Hogan rivalry that toured the live event bend came in two forms: the gastropodic behemoth begging to by slain by a Superman, and the treacherous 'best friend' that dared double-cross Hulk. Warrior was a new wrinkle: a fellow Superman that laid claim to Hogan's throne. Without face paint, this was the original Mortal Kombat mirror match, new terrain for Hulk's character to explore.

Through meticulous planning and rehearsal, two heavyweights whose best work usually came with the aid of a smaller worker were able to string together a masterpiece. The idea of determining the mightier slayer of giants translated into a dramatic battle that affirmed each man's elite status. Even if Warrior's ensuing reign didn't match up to Hulk's glory years, the match remains a treasure.


14. John Cena Vs. Shawn Michaels (WrestleMania 23)

WWE.com

Despite plunging deeper and deeper into the throes of verbal fan revolt, WWE stuck with Cena as its ace, as he was justifying the position with his energy and work. A WrestleMania clash with the always-motivated Michaels would be another impressive notch in Cena's spinner-belt, even if the fans were vehemently unwilling to bite the bait.

Michaels' piledriving Cena onto the ringsteps split the back of the champion's head open, a gruesome visual that underscored the, "How bad do you want to be the man?" story that was playing out in the minds of naysayers. Cena, as is his custom, proved capable of rising to the level of his opponent, and a great match was guaranteed from the moment it was signed.


13. Bret Hart Vs. Shawn Michaels (WrestleMania XII)

WWE.com

The length of a 60-minute Iron Man match makes a viewer apprehensive. To those that do open the lid and take in the match, some have found it boring, time-killing, and hollow. Others appreciate the physical efforts of Hart and Michaels, who didn't sit on their hands and ride out the clock. Given the daunting task of filling an hour with wrestling, they did their best.

Would a fall or two during the hour-long body have satiated fans that required an attention-keeper? Most likely, and it's the match's biggest flaw that the contest was scoreless for the planned duration. Seeing past the poorly-planned forest for the trees, the individual performances of Hart and Michaels are something to behold, and Michaels' win remains an unscratchable gem of a forgone time.


12. The Ultimate Warrior Vs. Macho King Randy Savage (WrestleMania VII)

WWE.com

Ordinarily the stories of the technicolor kayfabe era didn't come loaded with so many layers, but the Warrior/Savage 'career ending' match told two tales concurrently: one of vanquishing, and the other of redemption. Pretty deep for a toy company, but you figure they'd want to send Savage out as something of a conquering hero.

The late match tension gives way to a Warrior win, but alas, Savage is redeemed by the lovely Elizabeth, who saves him from Sensational Sherri's blinded wrath. The tearjerking moment just about undermines Warrior's victory, making it one of the prime examples of a loss elevating someone's stock instead of extinguishing it. By the fall of 1991, fans were demanding once-nefarious Savage's return, and were thrilled to get it.


11. Hulk Hogan Vs. Andre The Giant (WrestleMania III)

WWE.com

Certainly it's not technical merit that put Hogan and Andre on this list, but could you really assemble a run-down of WrestleMania's greatest matches without it? Sometimes a wrestling match exudes so much mythological aura that its legend supersedes tempo or precision. Much like the Rock/Hogan match earlier in this list, Hulk vs. Andre will forever be sustained by its mythos. Rarely ever is something so otherworldly firmly held as real by jaded eyes.

When Hogan finally hoists Andre up and slams him down before (allegedly) 93,000 fans, it's lived up to every ounce of hype. There have been great matches that don't reach their imagined potential, with fan expectations rising higher than ever. Hulk vs. Andre did what it was expected to do, what it was hoped it would do, and that was scratch the stratosphere. Basic astounds perhaps once in a generation, explaining its perma-etched place in wrestling lore.


10. The Undertaker Vs. Shawn Michaels (WrestleMania XXVI)

shawn michaels undertaker wrestlemania 26
WWE.com

If you don't count Michaels taking bumps during high-profile Triple H matches so that Helmsley can suck wind, then WrestleMania XXVI was indeed his swan song. Even with compressed time due to earlier matches running long, Michaels and Undertaker just about matched the quality of their battle from a year earlier.

While some worked melodrama falls flat under the weight of its own BS (depending on the example), Undertaker acting conflicted about ultimately finishing Michaels off, with HBK defiantly goading him into doing so, was a magnificent ending. In his last act as a wrestler, Michaels did what he always does (end a great match on a high note) and what he used to have problems doing (the right thing).


9. The Dudley Boyz Vs. The Hardy Boyz Vs. Edge/Christian (WrestleMania X-Seven)

WWE.com

When all three duos plunged from ladders and splattered through tables at the previous WrestleMania, the entire ordeal was heralded rightfully as a show-stealer. The new formula of car-crash combat was better implemented at SummerSlam that year, faster paced and with a slicker sheen. The WrestleMania X-Seven rendition of 'Tables, Ladders, and Chairs' rivals the SummerSlam battle in the sparse class of insanity done perfect.

Two enduring images, one of Edge spearing Jeff Hardy off of a skyhook, and the other of Matt Hardy and Bubba Ray Dudley reducing four tables into instant splinters, resonated most in a match where the chaos was perpetual. A TLC match must be both elaborate and hold the viewer's attention at all times. More than most others of the genre, this one did both.


8. Shawn Michaels Vs. Kurt Angle (WrestleMania 21)

WWE.com

By now the time was reached where it was decided that WrestleMania needed at least one match that would hurtle past the four-star mark with barely a doubt. Story wasn't important, as Angle and Michaels undertook some faint argument over who the better man was, which was enough to justify close to a half hour of balls-out wrestling. Any arguments? Didn't think so.

Whether it was Michaels' crazy quebrada onto a table-bound Angle, or Angle's dogged determination to score a submission victory, you see the clear difference in two wrestlers that bring it to a high level on free TV and lesser PPVs, and then throw it into a gear most can't comprehend when it comes to WrestleMania. 'Five stars' was less a prediction, and more a certainty.


7. The Rock Vs. Stone Cold Steve Austin (WrestleMania X-Seven)

wwe.com

For my money, The Rock has never had a better match. While the first battle with Cena was pretty good, that was largely just the spamming of finishers and finisher reversals (the sequel made it more blatant). With Austin, he and Rock built layer after layer on the foundation of competitive fire, and steely-focused alpha male-ism that would drive two protagonists toward busting each other open without a blink.

The ending may be infamous, with Austin's ill-devised heel turn cooling off an unstoppable WWE product, but the shocking juxtaposition in the moment doesn't harm the well-crafted match - in fact, it strangely enhances it. The only other long-term shame is that most people remember the astonishing finish more than the tireless work that went into getting to that point.


Contributor
Contributor

Justin has been a wrestling fan since 1989, and has been writing about it since 2009. Since 2014, Justin has been a features writer and interviewer for Fighting Spirit Magazine. Justin also writes for History of Wrestling, and is a contributing author to James Dixon's Titan series.