25 WWE Champions Who Never Got Their Rematch
15. Steve Austin
Title Lost: Intercontinental Championship
Lost Title To: The Rock
It’s hard to call this a title loss. In late 1997, “Stone Cold” Steve Austin was on a meteoric rise to the top of the WWF roster. Although he held the Intercontinental Championship, Austin had his sights set on the company’s top prize, and feuding with the Rock over the IC title wasn’t in his plans. So Austin decided to forfeit the title to Rocky in pursuit of the WWF Championship.
However, the Rattlesnake wasn’t handing the belt over that easily.
Austin confiscated the title and dragged a cameraman to the General Sullivan Bridge in New Hampshire, where he threw the title into the Piscataqua River. Rock was the IC champion, but Austin had no desire to get his rematch. A month later, Stone Cold won the 1998 Royal Rumble en route to winning the WWF Championship at WrestleMania XIV, kicking off the Austin era.
14. Lita
Title Lost: WWE Women’s Championship
Lost Title To: Trish Stratus
Title Lost: WWE Women’s Championship
Lost Title To: Mickie James
Poor Lita. Has anyone lost their title twice in a two-month span and been denied a rematch both times? Both situations, however, involved retirements, so it’s not like there was a vast conspiracy against the Hall of Famer.
Lita lost her Women’s Championship to a retiring Trish Stratus at Unforgiven in 2006 in Trish’s hometown of Toronto (tapping out to the Sharpshooter, no less). Lita would go on to win the vacant title six weeks later and announce that she also was retiring at Survivor Series and planned to go out as champ.
Enter Mickie James, who had lost to Lita in the tournament finals. Mickie redeemed herself and saved WWE from having to hold two tournaments for a vacant women’s title that fall. While it kind of stunk for Lita to go out like that, WWE gave two of their most talented female wrestlers great platforms to go out on – in high-quality, PPV championship matches. Win or lose, that’s not a bad way to end your career.
13. Rob Van Dam
Title Lost: WWE Championship
Lost Title To: Edge
Rob Van Dam was flying high during the summer of 2006. Mr. Monday Night was also Mr. Money in the Bank, and he used that briefcase to defeat John Cena at One Night Stand and become the only man to hold the WWE and ECW Championships at the same time.
For a month, RVD was on top of the WWE landscape, ruling both Raw and ECW. It looked like after years of trying to break through the glass ceiling in WWE, Van Dam had arrived.
And then he and Sabu were busted with drugs in their car. Just three weeks into his reign, RVD would drop both titles on successive nights to Edge (WWE) and Big Show (ECW) because he was facing a 30-day suspension. While Van Dam would receive a rematch against Show, he never got a chance to get revenge on Edge and reclaim the title.
In hindsight, that was RVD’s peak in WWE. He left and would return a few times for short runs with the company, but he hasn’t sniffed gold like that since then.
12. Randy Orton
933147Title Lost: WWE World Heavyweight Championship
Lost Title To: Daniel Bryan
During the summer and fall of 2013, Randy Orton and Daniel Bryan traded WWE World Heavyweight Championship title victories as both men competed to be the “Face of the WWE.” Orton would emerge the victor of the feud with some help from the Authority, but his luck would run out at WrestleMania XXX.
Fans know the story all too well: Batista returned and won the 2014 Royal Rumble, only to be met with instant and overwhelming rejection from the fans, who wanted Bryan to finally conquer the Authority. In a fairytale twist, WWE gave fans exactly what they wanted, and Bryan won the title at Mania.
Orton, however, never got his return match. He teamed with Triple H and Batista as the newly reformed Evolution and tried to take down the Shield. By the time that feud ended, Bryan had gotten injured and would relinquish the WWE World Heavyweight Championship. Orton competed for the vacant title at Money in the Bank 2014, but as he would claim multiple times, he never got his one-on-one rematch.
11. John Cena
Title Lost: WWE Championship
Lost Title To: Daniel Bryan
It’s doubtful anyone is crying a river for 16-time world champ John Cena not getting a rematch after losing the WWE Championship to Daniel Bryan in 2013 at SummerSlam in a hard-fought classic of a match.
Bryan attained a lifelong dream, main-eventing a major PPV and winning the gold, only for Randy Orton to cash in his MITB briefcase and turn Bryan’s celebration into a five-minute title reign.
In reality, Cena was not getting a title rematch anytime soon, as he was heading for an operating table to have surgery on his elbow. He’d return two months later to beat Alberto Del Rio for the World Heavyweight Championship, so don’t pity the poor guy.
It worked out pretty well for Bryan too, at least for a little while.
10. Wendy Richter
Title Lost: WWF Women’s Championship
Lost Title To: Fabulous Moolah
The Original Screwjob. If you want to see a wrestling interpretation of “Hell hath no fury like a woman scorned,” just watch the aftermath of this match.
The backstory leading up to this match has changed somewhat over the years (and softened a bit too with Richter being inducted into the WWE Hall of Fame in 2010), but the bottom line was that Women’s Champion Richter wasn’t happy with the company, and Vince McMahon wasn’t happy with her.
This led to a masked opponent, the Spider (Lady) challenging her at Madison Square Garden. Several minutes into the bout, the Spider hooked an inside cradle and the ref fast-counted to three, despite Richter kicking out at or even before two. Even with Howard Finkel announcing Moolah (whom Richter unmasked during a post-match brawl) as the new champ, Richter kept coming, whipping her with the belt until she fled the ring.
Richter would not be seen in WWE again until her HOF induction nearly 15 years later. Moolah would hold the belt for another seven-plus months before dropping the title to Velvet McIntyre – for all of six days.
9. Bret Hart
Title Lost: WWF Championship
Lost Title To: Bob Backlund
The Bret Hart Conspiracy Theory really starts picking up steam here. The Hitman lost multiple titles to what could be termed ‘inferior’ opponents, and never got a chance to face them in a title rematch because both men went on to lose their newly won gold in less than four days.
Hart lost a long, hard-fought “I Quit” match to Bob Backlund for the WWF Championship, only to watch Backlund drop the strap three days later to Diesel in eight seconds. Hitman would get his revenge on Backlund at WrestleMania XI and would be the one to end Diesel’s year-long run on top in late 1995. Unfortunately, this wouldn’t be the last time Hart lost a title and never got to challenge again for it…
8. Bret Hart
Title Lost: Intercontinental Championship
Lost Title To: The Mountie
This is proof that sometimes it’s better to be lucky than good.
In 1992, Hart (who in storyline was suffering from the flu) dropped the Intercontinental Championship to The Mountie, who in turn lost the championship to “Rowdy” Roddy Piper at the Royal Rumble two days later. No one ever would have thought that the Mountie was championship material, but his number got called and he got himself a two-day IC title reign.
Hart would go on to beat Piper three months later at WrestleMania VIII and then have a classic IC title match at SummerSlam that year against Davey Boy Smith, so Hart did OK for himself as IC champ that year. Plus we got the classic moment of Piper winning his only WWE singles title, so that’s an added bonus.
7. “Rowdy” Roddy Piper
Title Lost: Intercontinental Championship
Lost Title To: Bret Hart
The Rowdy One’s lone singles title in WWF/E was more of a victory lap in 1992 for the unretired superstar. (Who could have predicted a 2006 Tag Team Championship run for Piper and Ric Flair?) But for Piper, the Intercontinental Championship had to represent a huge ‘thank you’ from WWE for his contributions throughout the years.
When he lost the title to Bret Hart at WrestleMania VIII, Piper never challenged his real-life cousin to a rematch, quietly leaving WWE for nearly two years (with only a couple guest appearances). One can only wonder if he actually was trying to step away from wrestling and into retirement.
6. Daniel Bryan
Title Lost: WWE World Heavyweight Championship
Lost Title To: Surrendered
Title Lost: Intercontinental Championship
Lost Title To: Surrendered
Daniel Bryan was the undersized, talented indy star who organically connected with WWE fans in a way that the company only wishes it could duplicate with in-house creations like Roman Reigns.
Bryan improbably won the WWE Championship at SummerSlam 2013, then spent the rest of summer and fall fighting Randy Orton and the Authority over the title. He faded out of the title picture until after the Royal Rumble, when the fans forcefully reinserted him into the program, culminating in a WWE World Heavyweight Championship victory at WrestleMania XXX. Bryan’s storybook title reign would end after less than three months when he was forced to surrender the title due to legit injuries.
Those injuries would keep him out of action until January 2015. Bryan would never get a world title rematch, as it transitioned from John Cena to Brock Lesnar. Instead, Daniel was moved to the Intercontinental Championship, which he won at WrestleMania XXXI. It seemed like a fitting consolation prize, but that reign would be even shorter, as injuries once again forced him to forfeit the title.
Sadly, Bryan would not compete for WWE again and currently serves as SmackDown Live’s general manager, which is about the closest to a consolation prize we can get.