3 Ups & 2 Downs From WWE 205 Live (Dec 20, 2016)

Thank you, Neville.

Neville Swann Elbow
WWE.com

Sunday’s Roadblock: End Of The Line PPV lived down to its nonsensical name.

The main event was a glorified television match with a tainted finish, designed purely to set up a rematch between Kevin Owens and Roman Reigns. The predictability was eye-rolling. WWE can never just promote a one-shot deal; every top-tier title bout must end with some sort of contrivance to necessitate a rematch. And, when a title does change hands, the mandated rematch clause just adds to the overexposure.

The very good Women’s Championship match was mired by a stupid ending; Sasha Banks tapped with just seconds to spare, seemingly to save herself from serious harm - and yet, they ran with an injury angle anyway.

At the end of a nothing Cruiserweight Title match, however - which Jim Ross rightly slated on Twitter for its alienating approach - The Man WWE Forgot, Neville, made his return. While it was an indictment of the Cruiserweight division that fans thanked him for his heelish beatdown of its top two babyfaces, Neville’s cameo was excellent. The feigned clapping, the sudden bait and switch, the intensity of his attack - Neville really did establish himself as the King of the Cruiserweights.

For once, WWE’s hyperbole was fully justified…


Downs...

2. Austin Aries: You Still Suck

Dorado Ariya
WWE.com

We’ve been spoiled as it pertains to the heel commentator role.

Bobby Heenan’s best performance, famously, was at the 1992 Royal Rumble, in which he shouted himself hoarse screaming “It’s not fair to Flair!”, when his charge was ransacked by the 29 other men. The structure of the Rumble match alone guarantees drama - and, largely thanks to Heenan, what is fondly recalled as the Flair Rumble is often regarded as the best ever. If Heenan had casually dismissed the likes of Sid Justice and Roddy Piper, with sarcastic putdowns, that drama would have been nullified.

Jerry Lawler, when not triggering feminists the world over, was equally histrionic in his anxiety when the heels he was biased toward received their comeuppance.

Austin Aries, meanwhile, has not grasped that balancing act; he’s there to poke fun at the faces, not to unravel them at the seams. Lince Dorado, in the opening seconds of his match against Ariya Daivari, performed his trademark, lightning quick kip-ups as a psychological taunt. Aries offhandedly remarked that he was wasting his time. He was - Dorado lost - but you don’t say that.

The heel commentator’s jibes need to be conditional (see: Corey Graves). Aries is too quick to grab the shovel.


1. Numbing Predictability

Gallagher Daivari
WWE.com

As brilliant as Jack Gallagher is, his feud with Ariya Daivari is pure filler.

WWE’s attempt to position Daivari as a legitimate threat was transparent in the extreme. He defeated Lince Dorado in a match which was tonally identical to anything seen on RAW and SmackDown!, but it rang hollow. His positioning and performance was embodied by his match-winning frog splash; it arrived from out of nowhere, and was unspectacular in execution.

That WWE replayed the Jack Gallagher video package, for the umpteenth time, was more or less a spoiler. Predictability in wrestling is by no means a bad thing - those who lived through the worst of the Attitude Era would testify to that - but the wool can be pulled over the eyes of the audience. Just stopping short of announcing Gallagher as the winner is not the way to go about it.

A Cruiserweight Title feud between Gallagher and Neville is quite the prospect - a powerful geordie ruffian versus a refined and cerebral gent - but Gallagher’s inevitably journey to the top of the card doesn’t promise much drama.


Ups...

3. Dorado > Cena

Dorado Stunner
WWE.com

As mentioned, the Lince Dorado Vs. Ariya Daivari match evidenced the widely-held belief that Vince McMahon has intercepted the division, and decreed that the Crusierweights must tone down their style.

A deathly dull procession of rest holds, it operated within the standard WWE mode of psychology. The only drama was unintentional; Dorado almost broke his neck attempting to land a nearly aptly-named suicide dive.

In a listless match, with an incongruous winner, a faint ember of hope glowed dimly through the shadows, indirect though it was. Dorado’s springboard stunner was a thing of beauty - but even more beautiful is the implication that John Cena has retired it from his repertoire. Cena’s version of it was horrendous - an ugly and defensive attempt at proving that he was capable of performing more than five moves.

Tyler Reks was disallowed from using his tame variation of Kenta Kobashi’s Burning Hammer because it too closely resembled Cena’s Attitude Adjustment. WWE wrestlers, in the main, aren’t allowed to share moves. Hopefully, this means the days of Cena gracelessly falling on his a*se are long gone.


2. A Correction From Last Week

Noam Dar Sex Pest
WWE.com

In last week’s 205 Live rundown, I bemoaned Noam Dar’s positioning as a sex pest. WWE rarely learns from history, and Dar’s update on Dean Malenko’s Double Ho Seven schtick was destined to fail…

Only, it isn’t. Dar has been handed sh*t - but he is making lemonade out there. The script he reads from is as limited as it is ridden with cliché (“all I want for Christmas is you”?). But Dar, whose sterling reputation, it must be said, wasn’t forged by his promo game, has made the best of it. His line readings are hilarious; referring to the object of his affection as Alicia Fuurrxxxx, the twenty-three year old Dar sounds like a leering, dirty old man, lingering over that sole syllable to blackly comic effect.

The post-match angle saw him carry the stricken Alicia Fuurrxxxx, whose ankle was twisted in the melee of the finishing sequence, to the backstage medical area. The smug grin he flashed towards Cedric Alexander was equally brilliant. It was a face you’d never tire of punching, and in a show short on storyline hooks, the thought of seeing him get punched is a reason to tune back in.

And, as seen by Fuurrxxxx’s post-match tweet, she didn’t specify who her lover boy was…


1. A Quality Main Event

Neville Swann Elbow
WWE.com

The tag team main event was the best match WWE has promoted all week; handily eclipsing anything on RAW and SmackDown!, it advanced storylines, reinforced characters and developed others.

The narrative was focussed around Neville, and his new role as a powerhouse was perfect casting. The massively-muscled Neville, in order to differentiate himself from TJ Perkins and Rich Swann, emphasised his scary dead-lift power game to underscore his big dog status. He still used the Red Arrow, but that, too, was logical. The man looks invincible. Kendrick, meanwhile, looked on at Swann’s plight with a pithy smirk, underlining his conniving opportunist character. Perkins was also decimated by Neville, and while neither face generated much in the way of sympathetic heat, the foundations, slowly, are being erected. Then again, the embarrassing empty seats likely didn't help.

A triumph of body language and character progression, WWE even managed to avoid one of their more annoying quirks by booking Perkins to take the pinfall. Swann was protected. After last week’s episode and the events of Roadblock, he needed it.

Though the upcoming Neville Vs. Swann feud promises much, here’s hoping that Perkins and Kendrick aren’t left to resume hostilities. That feud is as stale as Daviri’s gimmick.

Promisingly, WWE did run a vignette hyping the return of a man who might question Kendrick’s claim that he was the origin of the Cruiserweight style…


Contributor
Contributor

Michael Sidgwick (Creative Writing BA Hons) is an editor, writer and podcaster for WhatCulture Wrestling. With over a decade of experience in wrestling analysis, Michael was published in the influential UK institution that was Power Slam magazine, and specialises in providing insights into All Elite Wrestling - so much so that he wrote a book about the subject. You can order Becoming All Elite: The Rise Of AEW on Amazon. Possessing a deep knowledge also of WWE, WCW, ECW and New Japan Pro Wrestling, Michael’s work has been publicly praised by AEW World Champions Kenny Omega and MJF, and Undisputed WWE Champion Cody Rhodes. When he isn’t putting your finger on why things are the way they are in the endlessly fascinating world of professional wrestling, Michael wraps his own around a hand grinder to explore the world of specialty coffee. Follow Michael on X (formerly known as Twitter) @MSidgwick for more!