3 Ups & 2 Downs From WWE 205 Live (January 24, 2017)

Without Gallagher, there’s Jack sh*t to write home about.

The Brian Kendrick
WWE.com

205 Live, at its worst, is the punchline of the most cynical message board jokes; divorced almost entirely from the Cruiserweight Classic, the original, real sports framework has been abandoned altogether. So too has its eclectic range of styles. The cruiserweights wrestle in much the same mode, if not manner, in adhering to the archetypal, slower-paced, story-driven WWE style.

Classic wrestling tales, like the fraught war contested by partners that was Johnny Gargano Vs. Tomassa Ciampa, have been jettisoned, supplanted by sports entertainment love triangles and hackneyed sub-plots of betrayal and dated geopolitical tensions.

It’s hard to focus on the positives, though there are a few. There are more roster members than segments; consequently, the show, at just an hour of length, is nowhere near as interminable or indulgent as RAW. That show, a bloated mess of filler, has so much time to fill with nowhere near enough creativity to fill it that matches are often repeated ad nauseam - even given away for free in the week before we’re meant to pay for it.

The structure of 205 Live means that WWE need not preview pay-per-view offerings with a feature-length trailer - but, to indict this week’s episode, the company did just that...


Downs...

2. Another Chapter In A Predictable Story...

The Brian Kendrick II
WWE.com

...one which might not even happen.

Prior to the second match, The Brian Kendrick sounded off on his opponent - Tripp Bradshaw - whose conspicuous lack of internet presence marks his moniker as quite the coincidence. It’s a little suspicious that the infamously petty company managed to source a hometown jobber with a name that just happened to double as a rib at JBL’s expense.

Squash matches work because the talent doing the squashing is a newly-introduced and intriguing face. Booking the most overfamiliar member of the roster to lay waste to some nonentity was a waste of five minutes, really. “Here’s the cold, harsh reality, kid: you’re neither cold enough or harsh enough to make it here,” Kendrick said. His promo was another waste of time. The outcome was nailed on - but the match, at least, was heated enough by 205 Live’s cold, harsh standards.

The map is easy to read - Kendrick is underscoring his seniority to set-up a veteran rivalry with Tajiri - but there is no timescale for the Japanese Buzzsaw’s return. What if he’s out for months?!


1. Homogenised Action

Nese Perkins
WWE.com

In the opening match, Tony Nese, with his impossibly chiselled physique and greasy streak of jet black hair, wrestled the excavated TJ Perkins in what was a match of not inconsiderable quality. The two shared an interesting dynamic; Nese was the more powerful of the two, cutting off Perkins’ more flamboyant, aerial-based offence with his deadly power game.

In the main event, Neville, with his impossibly chiselled physique and greasy streak of jet black hair, wrestled Cedric Alexander in what was a match of not inconsiderable quality. The two shared an interesting dynamic; Neville was the more powerful of the two, cutting off Alexander’s more flamboyant, aerial-based offence with his his deadly power game.

Facetiousness aside, Tony Nese deserves his push. He’s a fantastic talent. But the timing is all wrong.

While the content of the opener was too similar to the main event, the booking of the aftermath was still very astute. Perkins recaptured some relevance in victory, and Nese was positioned as a monster during his retaliatory post-match attack. That victory was realistic. It ruins suspension of disbelief, when WWE cools on a performer and jobs them out. Weren’t they meant to be really quite good just a month ago?


Ups...

3. The Aries Has Landed

Nese Perkins II
WWE.com

Austin Aries’ absence from NXT had somehow contrived to weaken two shows - the yellow developmental brand itself, and the purple brand of 205 Live he was dispatched to commentate on - but his rapid rate of development has seen him undergo a purple patch in form.

Much criticised on these pages, the man is redeeming himself to such an extent that it will almost be a shame when he heals up - or at least, it would’ve been, if the rapidly-fading NXT wasn’t building towards a grudge match between No Way Jose and Kona Reeves. Lord, give me strength. I’m reviewing it tomorrow.

As TJ Perkins was helped to the back, Maura Ranallo wished him well, describing Nese’s brutal post-match attack as unnecessary. “It was necessary,” Aries deadpanned, in response. The line reading was so bluntly and hilariously wrong that Graves couldn’t help but corpse when he questioned his colleague’s choice of words. “Tony Nese is making a statement,” Aries reasoned, as Graves recovered just in time to react with a crucial roll of the eyes. The three-man team is almost wasted on 205 Live - they are the best WWE has at their disposal.

Aries added to the presentation of the Nese character with a similarly sociopathic zeal - and his aloof demeanour only served to heighten the drama when he cranked up the gears towards the finish of the main event, remarking with some conviction and volume how impressive it was that Neville shifted the guardrail a good foot by crashing Alexander to it. His main roster colleagues should take note, and reserve the bluster for when it acually means something.


2. A Vignette That Actually The Flattered Its Subject

sami zayn bo dallas
WWE.com

The last two Akira Tozawa vignettes were almost comically thrown together, installing as they did the jobber tandem of Kalisto and Apollo Crews as cheerleaders for the imminent debutant. They were so obviously taped and edited hours beforehand that it does not auger well for Tozawa’s prospects on a show which only seems capable of pushing two guys at once.

As soon as Corey Graves segued into the vignette, the air became pregnant with morbid curiosity. Which evidently bored lower-rung SmackDown performer would be hastily removed from the locker room, given five minutes to give Google a cursory search before espousing Tozawa’s in-ring game? The Vaudevillians and Curt Hawkins had something to do for once, even it if was being eliminated early, with numbing predictability, from a battle royal - so they were out of the question. So too were the remaining thin field of jobbers.

Jack Swagger wasn’t even marched out to perform lumberjack duties in the main event. Was he even in the building? Perhaps he volunteered to step in front of the camera, just for something to do, but nobody heard him because he’s been literally forgotten. That “you don’t know Jack!” stuff feels like a rib now.

Oddly enough, it was Sami Zayn’s turn to trot out some platitudes. His hyperbole was at times transparent. “I think he’s a guy that actually kinda transcends what we’ve known about Japanese wrestlers in the past,” he said, patently lying through his teeth. Zayn would not be the wrestler he was today, if it weren’t for those talents.

But it was an effective way of promoting Tozawa, regardless. He debuts next week. Simon Gotch will be breathing a sigh of relief.


1. The Good With The Bad

Neville Alexandar II
WWE.com

It was yet another stellar performance from Neville, who might just be the very best performer WWE has in its midst right now. Imploring Alexander, with coiled menace, to get out of his ring, he unleashed that fury throughout the course of a match which, as good as it was, occurred on the wrong show. A fifteen minute-plus Neville showcase, I’d be surprised if it was much different from his Cruiserweight Title challenge at Sunday’s Royal Rumble. We were constantly reminded that it wouldn’t be by the otherwise excellent commentary team.

It deviated sightly from RAW’s counterproductive formula, in that it wasn’t the actual match - but not enough to create sufficient intrigue for the weekend. It’s bizarre; HBO bosses must have been infuriated when the first four episodes of Game Of Thrones season six leaked online. And yet, this is WWE’s foremost marketing strategy.

Alexander deserves much of the credit, one glaring botch aside. The horror with which he reacted to Neville’s stunning defiance of physics towards the finish was acted wonderfully; so too was his selling of Neville’s double underhook crossface, itself a fantastic development. Neville, like a 90s AJPW headliner, now has three proven match-winning moves in his arsenal, creating scope for kick out and reversal drama months in advance.

There was nothing abysmal about the show; as the title of the article suggests, there was more bad than good contained with in it. But it’s just sort of…there, as homogenised in itself as it is with the ring style of its main roster bigger brothers.


Contributor
Contributor

Michael Sidgwick (Creative Writing BA Hons) is an editor, writer and podcaster for WhatCulture Wrestling. With over a decade of experience in wrestling analysis, Michael was published in the influential UK institution that was Power Slam magazine, and specialises in providing insights into All Elite Wrestling - so much so that he wrote a book about the subject. You can order Becoming All Elite: The Rise Of AEW on Amazon. Possessing a deep knowledge also of WWE, WCW, ECW and New Japan Pro Wrestling, Michael’s work has been publicly praised by AEW World Champions Kenny Omega and MJF, and Undisputed WWE Champion Cody Rhodes. When he isn’t putting your finger on why things are the way they are in the endlessly fascinating world of professional wrestling, Michael wraps his own around a hand grinder to explore the world of specialty coffee. Follow Michael on X (formerly known as Twitter) @MSidgwick for more!