3 Ups & 2 Downs From WWE NXT (Dec 21)

Was that the best TV match of the year?

Roderick Strong
WWE.com

The problem with modern wrestling is that there’s too damn much of it. You need two hands to count the hours, even on the ever-decreasing weeks on which there isn’t a Pay Per View event, but you need just one to count the reasons to tune in. Three of those - loyalty, routine, fear of missing out - have nothing to do with WWE’s turgid creative process.

This over-saturation does at least provide a platform for great wrestling. With no US Open Challenge, 2016 failed to reach 2015’s lofty heights, but there were some corkers to be found, regardless. Charlotte and Sasha Banks’ Falls Count Anywhere bout on November 28 was a pleasant and thrilling surprise. Finn Bálor Vs. Shinsuke Nakamura, on the July 13 episode of NXT, compensated for predictability with fine, suspenseful storytelling. But the Fatal Four-Way No. 1 Contender’s match on this week’s NXT might have stolen TV Match Of The Year honours, right at the death.

This week’s edition of NXT was far from perfect. Percy Watson had to be reminded by Corey Graves that he was there to talk. Billie Kay and Peyton Royce generated only minor X-Pac circa 2001 heat with their nails-on-chalkboard post-match promo. A certain tag team reminded us that bigger certainly does not equal better.

The last half hour, however, was glorious…


Downs...

2. Diminished Returns

Daria Berenato
WWE.com

As mentioned in last week’s write-up, the Billie Kay/Peyton Royce partnership is a plagiarised bastardisation of the winning Emma/Dana Brooke pairing, lacking as much in quality as it is in originality.

Kay’s opening match, opposite Daria Berenato, was inauspicious in the extreme. What’s ironic about Berenato is that, prior to appearing on Tough Enough, she experienced minor success within the fringes of the MMA scene - and yet her shadow boxing looks atrocious. She punched the air for so long - nine bizarre seconds - that I momentarily thought it was computer game glitch.

The match itself was a short, nothing affair, memorable only for the weak finish. Berenato was driven back-first into the apron, which as we’re constantly reminded, is the hardest part of the ring. But, since it’s now used so frequently, the power of such spots has faded considerably.

This led to her inevitable defeat, which only advanced a storyline we’ve already seen done better. Kay, Royce and Berenato are new to the game, and they’re not terrible. They just have an impossible standard to live up to.


1. The Authors Of Botch

Authors Of Botch
WWE.com

NXT, by definition, is WWE’s developmental brand.

As much as it exists as a singular brand in its own right, propped up as it is by excellent, internationally-honed name talents, it’s there to develop greenhorns to prepare them for the big time. As such, the odd botch, the odd experimental gimmick (read: Elias Samson) could be excused. But NXT isn’t Tough Enough; if a performer is too dangerous to step foot in the ring, they have no business being in there.

Akam and Razar only laced up their first pair of non-skid baby shoes little over a year ago - and their inexperience endangered the career of enhancement talent Anthony Bowens, whose partner Jonny Vandal was powerbombed onto his head. The intended area of impact was missed by a good foot. Bowens, in the aftermath, was forced to pull out of his scheduled dates in December. His health, and his livelihood, was put at risk.

The GIF has already done the rounds online, but in full HD, on a decent-size television, the extent of the danger was sickeningly apparent. The entire Authors of Pain act is predicated on danger. Their opponents are thrown onto their necks in the corner, with dubious frequency. Such a miscalculation was probably inevitable.

“The Authors of Pain don’t seem to be anywhere near done,” remarked Corey Graves on commentary. He was right on two counts.


Ups...

3. A Tantalising Tease

Asuka wwe
WWE.com

The Billie Kay Vs. Daria Berenato match was dismal filler, barely worth promoting in advance - and the angle is set to continue into the new year. There was a faint glimmer of hope in the post-match, though, when Asuka’s post-match comments were interrupted by Nikki Cross.

Promos in modern wrestling are often interminable, given the extent to which TV time needs to be filled. Asuka’s limited grasp of English - and her credibility - is a welcome departure from the stale norm. The scarcity of her words - “they need to be careful” - was as powerful as her chilling, stoic delivery was believable. The camera then panned to Cross, dangling from the staging with a demented sway. The subtlety of her body language, again, was astute; she reinforced her insane character within a matter of seconds. So, too was Asuka’s; she literally smacked her lips in anticipation of the unspoken challenge.

The prospect of an Asuka Vs. Nikki Cross match at TakeOver: San Antonio is one to cherish. Two hugely believable lunatics who seem to relish incurring pain as they do inflicting it? There is massive intrigue in that match. Perhaps the Women’s division is in a healthier state the opening ten minutes indicated.


2. A Big Fight Feel

Strong Dillinger
WWE.com

The pre-match hype video was almost as fantastic as the match itself.

To the strains of Bring Me The Horizon’s Throne, a theme synonymous with NXT, highlights of last week’s qualifying matches were spliced with sit-down interviews, in order to convey the importance of the occasion. Tye Dillinger’s comments reinforced his babyface credentials. “The match with Eric Young ended in disqualification. I’m not a big fan of “winning” that way.”

“I simply care about myself,” Andrade ‘Cien’ Almas followed up. As the match confirmed, his dismissal of the field perfectly foreshadowed his downfall. Bobby Roode’s arrogant entitlement was a prophecy - and his eventual victory strengthened his character, arguably 2016’s best. Wrestling is all in the marketing - and that vignette was so good that fans were worked into receiving the match as a minor classic before the opening bell even rang.

A match on a weekly episode of WWE’s developmental programme was promoted with as much conviction as anything on main roster PPV events. That’s why NXT remains the most cherished wrestling show there is.


1...Big On Quality

Roode Dillinger II
WWE.com

Paul Heyman once stated that, in the greatest wrestling match, one performer goes over and the other gets over. Bobby Roode, as most would have predicted, emerged victorious - but Tye Dillinger glowed in defeat.

This gorgeously-paced, content-laden high quality main event, loaded with subplots and scope for future storylines, highlighted the quality inherent to the stipulation.

The balance was perfect. Andrade ‘Cien’ Almas was eliminated first, but only via opportunism on the part of Roderick Strong. He was the star of the opening third, and as such, his elimination was more dramatic shock than necessary contrivance. Strong was the next removed from the fray, but only after making an, ahem, strong impression. Besides which, as Roode pointed out in that awesome pre-match video package, he’s only been in NXT for “ten minutes”. His exit didn’t harm him one jot. His star rose, quietly, just by appearing in the match.

Neither did Dillinger’s; coming agonisingly close to winning the big one, NXT officials have learned the lesson imparted by Tyler Breeze’s booking throughout 2015. Whereas his heat, in the heel role, was doused by his nearly man status, Dillinger’s rotten luck only serves to fortify his standing as sentimental underdog.

The expert booking of Dillinger - a man mired in developmental for so long that hr even lived through Ohio Valley Wrestling - may yet culminate in an NXT Title win outright. From Nakamura to Roode to the Perfect 10, the title scene writes itself. That’s what happens when such glorious foundations are put in place.


Contributor
Contributor

Michael Sidgwick (Creative Writing BA Hons) is an editor, writer and podcaster for WhatCulture Wrestling. With over a decade of experience in wrestling analysis, Michael was published in the influential UK institution that was Power Slam magazine, and specialises in providing insights into All Elite Wrestling - so much so that he wrote a book about the subject. You can order Becoming All Elite: The Rise Of AEW on Amazon. Possessing a deep knowledge also of WWE, WCW, ECW and New Japan Pro Wrestling, Michael’s work has been publicly praised by AEW World Champions Kenny Omega and MJF, and Undisputed WWE Champion Cody Rhodes. When he isn’t putting your finger on why things are the way they are in the endlessly fascinating world of professional wrestling, Michael wraps his own around a hand grinder to explore the world of specialty coffee. Follow Michael on X (formerly known as Twitter) @MSidgwick for more!