3 Ups & 3 Downs From AEW Rampage (April 12 - Results & Review)
AEW's surprising grudge match; Rampage has no atmosphere; Tony Khan resists more CM Punk.
Many in the wrestling world are still scratching their heads over Tony Khan airing security footage of CM Punk scuffling with Jack Perry backstage at All In last summer. The AEW boss teased that as the main hook for Wednesday's Dynamite, but it was a ridiculous decision that backfired and only made the company look petty.
Could Rampage get back to basics and start, y'know, promoting wrestlers who actually work for All Elite Wrestling? Yes, but it's also clear Khan has completely given up on the 'C' show as anything more than a homage to Sunday Night Heat circa 2000. Sadly, even Collision in the 'B' slot is struggling these days.
Back to Rampage.
Tony booked a blowoff (it better be) grudge match, Jay White's bid to bounce back from a Billy Gunn bout few liked, Julia Hart defending the TBS Title and more for Friday night. The opener involving Orange Cassidy and his ongoing Best Friends implosion provided arguably the best match on the show - Orange was right up for this one.
Here's all the good and bad from an episode that apparently saw AEW hand out sleeping pills before the cameras started rolling.
Downs...
3. So, What Was The Point?
Reports coming out of Wednesday's twin Dynamite and Rampage tapings say Julia Hart suffered a shoulder injury during her TBS Title defence vs. Leyla Hirsch. That sucks, and fingers crossed Hart is alright, but...it doesn't excuse AEW's booking. Is anyone else getting real tired of these one week mini-stories that lack the actual story bit?
The promotion scripts this sort of thing constantly, and it's dull.
Hirsch fired out her challenge on last week's Rampage, then lost in four minutes on Friday's show. Granted, Julia's injury likely cut their time short, but nothing about the segment felt inspiring to begin with. Honestly, this sort of fare is not a substitute for actual storytelling or character development.
After losing, Leyla will be shoved into the background yet again. In short, the whole exercise of having her tape a promo/challenge Julia then wrestle for the belt was pointless. AEW gained nothing from this, and neither did Hart. It was a total waste of time, and a blatant time killer.
2. Leave The Comb At Home
Someone have a word with pro wrestlers.
Angelo Parker was scheduled for a vicious grudge match vs. Zak Knight on Rampage, but you wouldn't have known that during his entrance. The babyface came to the ring slicking back his hair like he normally does, and even flashed a smile at the camera before pulling out a comb. Hmm.
This is nitpicking to the extreme, but it's important that wrestlers pay attention to even the tiniest details and react accordingly. Parker knew he was probs going to be in for one hell of a fight against a brutal Brit, but he performed his usual 'handsome man' entrance routine anyway. It didn't suit the presentation here at all.
Bianca Belair has been guilty of this over on the WWE side too. Beaten up by Damage CTRL earlier in the night and eager for revenge, the 'EST' shows that by twirling her braid and dancing with a smile to the ring. Wrestlers need to stop it, and start paying attention.
1. There’s Still Zero Atmosphere
This was plain awkward.
There was a moment right before Jay White made his entrance for the main event: Justin Roberts was standing mid-ring, the camera panned down from the Rampage logo on the tron to the ring, and there was literally no noise in the building. Seriously, fans were really quiet and acting like a movie was about to start.
Tony Khan has to start booking smaller buildings at some point, man. It'd be great if AEW could still pack in bigger crowds to justify the venues they run, but they can't. The lack of atmosphere on company telly is affecting the product too, and that's even more worrying. It's not a good look for people watching from home, and (again) makes AEW look less than.
Practically none of the entrances caused a stir in the audience either. If Tony's outfit shifts anywhere between 3,000-4,000 tickets, then start booking 5,000 seat venues and aim for that number. It's embarrassing to hear episodes of TV sound like they're being filmed in your local swimming pool.
Ups...
3. Jay White Bounces Back
People did not like Jay White's match vs. Billy Gunn on Dynamite recently, so it was always gonna be important for 'Switchblade' to bounce back. Whilst there was nothing earth-shattering about his Rampage match with Matt Sydal, it was more along the lines of what fans want to see from White.
The final few minutes were excellent.
Sydal looked like he might actually spring a surprise, and frantically climbed the turnbuckles to go high risk. Sensing danger, Jay came to his senses and shut the headliner down like he knew winning was essential. Meanwhile, The Gunns stalked ringside and added to the match by encouraging their stablemate from first bell to last.
White isn't as big a deal as he was when he first arrived in AEW full-time. That's clear. However, he is still a stunning pro wrestler when the occasion calls for it, and this one definitely did. Here's hoping this is the beginning of a road to recovery for the ex-New Japan man.
2. Surprisingly Well Done
The story framing Angelo Parker vs. Zak Knight has been the drizzling sh*ts, but that's not necessarily their fault. All Ang and Zak could do was deliver a solid outing in-ring, and they tried their best to do that. Social media doesn't seem keen on the match, but this writer thinks it was better than expected.
Parker got cracked open early, which meant he was portrayed as a baby constantly up against it after that. Almost literally smelling blood, Knight came across as a dangerous loose cannon who loves inflicting pain. Honestly? The match was way better than it perhaps had any right to be.
AEW should move on from this tale, 'cause it's been crap, but these lads can be proud of themselves for gamely doing everything they could to make something of the sorry situation. It's a mystery whether or not Zak has any long-term future on the roster, to be fair. He might've only been drafted in as backup for Saraya during this rivalry before fizzling out.
Only time will tell.
1. Orange Cassidy’s Fire
Orange Cassidy is at his best when he dispenses with the laid back stuff and gets fiery. The ex-International Champ did that at several points during this opener vs. Alex Reynolds, and the match was better for it. Orange grew increasingly frustrated with John Silver for interfering, then kinda/almost/sort of snapped to get his revenge.
Post-match, Trent Beretta came out onto the stage and had a staredown with his old pal. Then, Chuck Taylor appeared behind Cassidy and it looked for all the world like he was about to turn too. Nope. Chuck stopped Trent from entering the ring, then breezed straight past Orange on his way out through the crowd.
The moment wasn't OTT by any means, but it did get the point across. Chuck is caught in the middle, and he doesn't know which horse to back yet. Some sort of explanation from Beretta would be nice soon - that'd let the story develop. Hey, at least these guys have a story to tell instead of just working random matches.
Progress!
What did you think of this week's AEW Rampage? For more wrestling, check out 10 WWE Superstars Who Need To Get Their S*** Together Before WrestleMania 41 and Predicting WWE’s WrestleMania 41 Cards - 1 Year Out!