3 Ups & 3 Downs From AEW Rampage (Dec 25)
Cody Rhodes wins gold; AEW presses reset on Miro; Rampage continues sending Hook.

There's always a different energy when Rampage is pre-taped.
Being fair, that's only natural, but the early zip provided by appearances from CM Punk and Bryan Danielson has been very much lost. Is it WWE Heat/Metal/Jakked/Main Event levels of low-key? No, not quite, and yet AEW must be very careful the show doesn't go from red-hot 60 mins to total afterthought.
This week's edition was more Dark than Dynamite, and that's not really meant as a compliment. Only one major happening saved the broadcast from being 100% skippable, but even that's sure to p*ss a few folks off or make them wonder about the importance of the TNT Title and its young lineage.
AEW moved Rampage from its usual Friday slot to Christmas night itself. Perhaps that'll be an annual play by Tony Khan - the NWA traditions run strongly through All Elite at times, so providing Christmas Day fun could become habit for the company. If so, then Khan will need to do more to show his product off to a potentially-new audience tuning in for the first time.
Here's all the good and the bad from the latest Rampage.
Downs...
3. An Exhibition For The Sake Of It

Nothing was especially wrong with the Kris Statlander vs. Leyla Hirsch match, but these women had no story going in and it showed. Their scuffle also won't have any bearing on the AEW Women's Title scene; granted, not every match needs to be about the title, but neither wrestler seems close to the level of others in the division right now.
Sadly, this was throwaway fare that belonged on Dark.
Rampage should not be this relaxed. It's an extension of Dynamite, and AEW must treat it as such - sticking Statlander vs. Hirsch out there in a babyface vs. babyface bout that begins with a friendly handshake won't cut it. This isn't the way to drive ratings towards the show, put it that way.
Fans responded politely to what they were seeing. Is that fine? Yes and no. On one hand, it's cool because fans aren't sh*tting on matches to look edgy. On the other, a small ripple of applause makes AEW look more indy than big time. They need to be careful here.
2. Pressing Reset?

Same old sh*t.
That's all this fan could think when that video package for Miro aired on Rampage. The former TNT Champion made his usual grand promises about 'bringing joy to his cruelty' and harped on about being 'The Redeemer'. This is a step backwards for the former Rusev - he's back to square one.
Miro didn't get off to a fabulous start in All Elite. His interactions with Kip Sabian as the 'Best Man' were rather lame and unwanted, but AEW got it right by turning him into a wrecking machine as TNT Champ. Since dropping that belt to Sammy Guevara, the guy has been sinking again.
Be honest, Twitter would have a field day if WWE did this. There would be endless moans about the creative team, Vince McMahon being out of touch with what his audience wants etc etc. Pressing reset on Miro after booking him so strongly absolutely deserves criticism.
1. Merry Xmas (Here’s A Title Change)

Fans in attendance for the dual Dynamite/Rampage 'Holiday Bash' tapings didn't like that Cody Rhodes TNT Title win one bit. They booed the crap out of him (that's been a recurring theme), so AEW are gonna have to pull the trigger on his full-blown heel turn at some point.
Interestingly, reports from the post-show revealed that Rhodes cut a heel-style promo once the cameras stopped rolling. He then did some business with Hook (more on that later) and posed with the title. The problem here is that his TNT Title victory reeked of someone backstage saying, 'Aw sh*te - we'd best stick something meaningful on Rampage'.
It was a title change for the sake of it, in other words.
Now, don't get this writer wrong. The match Guevara and Cody had was lively and fun, but the end result felt forced because it's Christmas rather than organic. AEW are head butting a brick wall by pretending that they can salvage Rhodes' character in its current state too.
Heel turn, please.
Ups...
3. Hook Continues Taking Baby Steps

Onto the positives.
Everybody and their gran could see that Hook was beating Bear Bronson, and probably within five minutes. Contrast this to the throwaway bout between Statlander and Hirsch; Hook is on an upwards trajectory. It feels like he's building towards something, whereas they're just spinning wheels.
That's why this gets an 'Up'. The match was a glorified squash, which is fine. Also, Bronson is a decent opponent for Hook right now, because he shouldn't be pushed right into a major program quite yet. Of course, the post-show shenanigans with Cody Rhodes (slap, potential title match and all) suggests AEW want to hurry things up.
Suggestion: Hook should rule Rampage first. Make this his show, and continue taking baby steps rather than jumping head first into something massive. It's important to remember that Taz's kid is still at the start of his career. He's 22 years old - there's no rush.
2. Jungle Boy Snares A Solid Win

There's some history between Jurassic Express, their pal Christian Cage and Matt Hardy's gang. That story going in is partly why this sits proudly in the 'Ups' section too, but it's not the only reason. Jungle Boy and Private Party's Isiah Kassidy had a solid little match that opened Rampage with a bang.
Both should be proud of that.
Kassidy showed AEW management something different here. He's not just a tag-team guy and that's that. The Private Party man bumped around nicely for Jungle, and some of his aerial stuff (whilst lacking from a psychology standpoint) is flashy and rivals other top flyers like Rey Fenix or Dante Martin.
Seeing JB win with his trusty Snare Trap was another big plus for the match. That finish needs to become something Boy can use to cut down much larger opponents. For now, it's great to see him ground a high-flyer by tapping him out.
Good, high-energy match.
1. Sammy Guevara’s Resilience

Everything was dynamite (ahem) about the main event TNT Title bout until the finish. In hindsight, it might've been better to see Sammy Guevara prove his mettle as the reigning champion and hold onto his prize heading into the new year. That's a personal opinion though, so some will disagree.
At least AEW let Sammy look resilient on the way out.
The Inner Circle man came across as a champion willing to do everything in his power to survive. During the closing stretch, he took two Cross Rhodes from Cody and then fell to a Tiger Driver. Basically, it took three finishers to stamp out his flames, which is helpful for Guevara post-title run.
His never-say-die spirit has been firmly established. Even if you hated the title change, which this fan did, it's hard to deny that Sammy looked tough-as-balls by hanging in there as Rhodes emptied both barrels into his chest.
Tough Sammy = the best Sammy.
What did you think of this week's AEW Rampage? For more wrestling, check out 10 Shocking WWE House Show Moments You Haven't Seen and 4 Ups & 2 Downs From AEW Rampage (Dec 17)!