3 Ups & 4 Downs From Last Night's WWE SmackDown (Mar 28)

Words speak louder than actions as Cena, Miz, and Styles shine.

Randy Orton Cross
WWE.com

SmackDown's build towards WrestleMania 33 has been lukewarm at best. The Miz and John Cena's promo exchanges are always gold, and the AJ Styles/Shane McMahon story is suitably heated, but the rest of the brand has lagged behind. Last night's go-home show gave SD the chance to forget all that and head into the Ultimate Thrill Ride (cringe...) on a high, but it was another middling episode.

The Miz and Maryse revived their Total Bellas parody routine, and got more heated than ever with John Cena and Nikki Bella. AJ Styles reminded the world just why he's considered the best in the business during the opening segment, meanwhile, and SmackDown closed with a big match between Luke Harper and Bray Wyatt, then Randy Orton's last strike at the Eater Of Worlds' cold, black heart.

Mauro Ranallo was once again absent on commentary, and there was no sign of Dean Ambrose or Baron Corbin either. The Women's Title scene once again descended to chaos, and in the absence of a WrestleMania Tag Team Championship match, the likes of The Usos and American Alpha were officially relegated to the Andre the Giant Memorial Battle Royal.

It was another night of peaks and valleys from the blue brand, but how did it all stack up? Let's take a look...


Downs...

4. Spinning Their Wheels

SmackDown Women's Division
WWE.com

SmackDown's lazy booking of their women's division continued last night. While the performers were granted a lot more airtime than the previous week, their contributions built little hype for WrestleMania, and only emphasised the idea that the show's multi-woman title match is just an excuse to get as many people on the pay-per-view as possible.

Carmella and Becky Lynch started with a sloppy singles match, before guest commentators Alexa Bliss and Mickie James inevitably got involved. This turned the match into a tag bout, and while given plenty of time, it absolutely stunk. A disjointed, overbooked mess, it featured an interference from Natalya and another from James Ellsworth, before Carmella eventually picked-up the victory, mercifully putting an end to this waste of 10 minutes.

The women's division has been one of SmackDown's biggest assets since the brand split resumed, but they're spinning their wheels at the moment. The current approach seems to be "let's just put them all on the screen at the same time and hope something cool happens," but it's not working, and the lack of care and attention shows. These performers are far too talented for such a haphazard angle, and they'll likely be glad when WrestleMania is over.


3. Another Throwaway Match

SmackDown 10 Man Tag
WWE.com

Last night's show was full of throwaway matches, and the Andre the Giant Battle Royal preview was the worst offender. Tag team champions American Alpha teamed with Heath Slater, Rhyno, and Mojo Rawley to face The Usos, Dolph Ziggler, and Breezango, and while the contest built to a decent finish, it was another nothing affair.

The ATG Battle Royal has little stakes, and has already been relegated to the WrestleMania Kickoff Show. The victor never receives a significant push, and the only reward for winning is the right to carry a comically oversized trophy around for a couple of weeks. Thus, there's little incentive for the viewer to care about the match, which makes WWE's decision to dedicate such a big chunk of SmackDown to it this week confusing.

The babyfaces eventually won, but none of it mattered. As a bout, it was entirely inconsequential, and dragged SmackDown back to mediocrity following the excellent John Cena/The Miz segment. It was just a bunch of guys with nothing else to do throwing meaningless exchanges together, and a couple of fun moments towards the end didn't make up for 10 boring minutes, sadly.


2. Mr. Irrelevant

Luke Harper Bray Wyatt
WWE.com

What on Earth happened to Luke Harper? A month ago, it looked like he was being set-up as SmackDown's next big babyface. As the "third man" in the Bray Wyatt/Randy Orton saga, Harper was over with the crowd and seemed as though he was finally building momentum as a singles act. Then he lost an excellent match to Orton at Elimination Chamber, and his appearances started dwindling.

Harper hasn't been seen for weeks, but he resurfaced last night. He cut a brief promo on Wyatt before facing him in the main event, but was ultimately served-up as nothing more than cannon fodder. Instead of capitalising on Harper's upswing after his removal from the Wyatt Family, WWE have once again relegated him to also-ran status, and his main event experiment is likely over.

It's hard to gauge Harper's upside as a singles wrestler, particularly given his lack of microphone time. Still, he's one of the best big men around, and he rarely disappoints between the ropes, whether he wins or loses. Nobody's star has fallen more than Luke's recently, however, and if WWE are serious about ever building him up, he can't be missing weeks of television at a time, only to return as a jobber to the stars.


1. A Dumb Conclusion

Bray Wyatt Randy Orton
WWE.com

In a bubble, last night's main event was perfectly acceptable. Bray Wyatt and Luke Harper wrestled a competent nine-minute match that never got out of second gear, but was relatively well-paced, and at least had a story behind it (unlike most of the action on the card). The problem is the conclusion, however, and what came after it.

The finish saw Harper hesitate on a discus clothesline, giving the impression that he was still under Wyatt's control. This allowed Bray to gaze into his eyes and nail him with Sister Abigail for the victory, and it came-off entirely flat. It was a limp finish ahead of Bray's big match at WrestleMania 33, and a moment that suggests Harper hasn't quite shaken-off the Wyatt Family's shackles, and faces an uphill battle to do so.

The cameras cut away to Abigail's burial site immediately after, and there was Randy Orton. Brandishing the paddle that Wyatt had placed on him last week, Orton spiked it into Abigail's grave, then stated he was going to win on Sunday. Though brief, it was every bit as lame as it sounds, and in revisiting the Abigail material, SmackDown's writers have proven their creative bankruptcy when it comes to this feud.

Orton vs. Wyatt should still be a hot match, but this was an ineffective go-home segment.


Ups...

3. AJ Styles Really Hates His Boss

AJ Styles Shane McMahon
WWE.com

Just as AJ Styles will likely carry Shane McMahon to a fun, chaotic brawl at WrestleMania 33, he continues to outshine him through the build. Shane was egregiously invasive after having his head thrown through a car window the other week, but he was absolutely fine last night, and his "land of opportunity" spiel threw an effective pitch for Styles' home-run. McMahon wasn't bad at all - but AJ was on a completely different level.

Styles ripped into Shane's vision, insisting that he made his own opportunities in WWE before reminding the Commissioner of his undeniable pedigree. Calling himself "the best performer to ever step into a WWE ring," AJ finally signed the match contract, but rejected Daniel Bryan's call for a handshake and bailed instead. A strong exclamation point ahead of a match many didn't want to see, but one that has benefited from a surprisingly strong build.

WWE made a wise choice in avoiding physicality here, as another week of Shane's pitter-patter punches would have only dragged the segment down. Whether or not they can hide his weaknesses at WrestleMania is a completely different matter, but if he and AJ focus on spots and moments above all else, they have a legitimate chance of stealing the show in Orlando.


2. Welcome Back

Naomi Smackdown
WWE.com

The women's division was a shambles last night, but the chaos came with a bright spot. While Carmella, Alexa Bliss, Becky Lynch, Mickie James, and Natalya brawled following the tag bout, former champion Naomi returned to the fray, cleared the ring, and announced her participation in the Women's Title match at WrestleMania.

The return got a strong response from the crowd, and so did her promo. She might not be the most polished or refined wrestler in the division, but Naomi has clearly built a decent following on Tuesday nights, and she has every right to be in the title match. She'd still be champion if it wasn't for her injury, after all, and while WWE love beating wrestlers in their hometown, she'll be a huge fan favourite in Orlando.

Naomi's inclusion turns the contest into a six-way, and seemingly removes the open-ended "all available women" stipulation. This suggests that the former female talent reported to appear at Mania won't be part of the contest as was previously speculated, but that's fine - none of them were going to win anyway. The match has been streamlined, and regardless of who wins, the outcome should allow the division to move forward from the mess it has become.


1. The Final Salvo

The Miz John Cena
WWE.com

The Miz and John Cena can't go a week without spitting hot fire, and last night might have been their most spirited exchange yet. It started with another Total Bellas parody skit (highlighted by Miz's incredible Daniel Bryan impersonation), and continued with Miz & Maryse removing their disguises and once again ripping into Cena & Nikki Bella's relationship.

"I hope you enjoyed the Kid's Choice Awards," Maryse said, "because that's as close to having kids with John as you're going to get." Ouch.

Cena and Nikki interrupted, and John held nothing back in his response. After burying Maryse ("you weren't brought back before because you did nothing the first time"), he accused Miz of being somebody who talked a good game, but couldn't back it up. The insults kept flowing, and after calling Miz a p***y, Cena dared his rival to throw the first punch, adding that if Maryse tried anything, Nikki would "knock the Botox out of her cheeks."

Deep, personal, and grounded in reality, the Miz/Maryse vs. Cena/Nikki build has been excellent. The match itself might not be particularly exciting, but the group have done an outstanding job of making their bad blood feel very, very real. It feels like Miz and Cena are legitimately shooting on each other at times, and last night was definitely one of those moments.

They're two of the best talkers in the business, and if WrestleMania's match order was based on heat alone, this would be the main event.


Channel Manager
Channel Manager

Andy has been with WhatCulture for 10 years and is currently WhatCulture's Wrestling Channel Manager. A writer, presenter, and editor with 10+ years of experience in online media, he has been a sponge for all wrestling knowledge since playing an old Royal Rumble 1992 VHS to ruin in his childhood. Having previously worked for Bleacher Report, Andy specialises in short and long-form writing, video presenting, voiceover acting, and editing, all characterised by expert wrestling knowledge and commentary. Andy is as much a fan of 1985 Jim Crockett Promotions as he is present-day AEW and WWE - just don't make him choose between the two.