3 Ups & 6 Downs From WWE Clash In Italy (Results & Review)
Questionable decisions plague first Italian PLE: Brock over Oba? Gunther loses via pin?

Here we are, six weeks removed from WrestleMania 42, and WWE is mired in an unmistakable creative slump. Clash in Italy was the latest case study in unimaginative, formulaic booking that has resulted in the product treading water rather than taking bold risks to rejuvenate a stale product.
There are probably three solid examples of this morass that were on display Sunday night: Oba Femi losing to Brock Lesnar, Gunther losing in questionable fashion to set up a rematch, and Roman Reigns wrestling a half-speed Bloodline-style main event that evoked the worst memories of 2022.
Femi has been one of the rare can’t-miss success stories in 2026 WWE, a magnetic superstar who should be main-eventing WrestleMania as early as next year. Rather than continuing to ride his invincible run longer, the company decided that now would be an ideal time to torpedo his undefeated streak to (presumably) set up their formulaic trilogy booking.
Gunther has lost just four singles matches in his four-year run on the main roster. Sunday, he inexplicably lost his fifth to Cody Rhodes in controversial fashion, presumably to set up a rematch.
And Reigns wrestled Jacob Fatu in a slow, dull Tribal Combat match that reminded fans of what many of them despised about the overdone, boring booking at the Bloodline’s height.
All told, Clash in Italy looked great on paper, but it all fell apart in execution.
Let’s get to it…
DOWNS…
6. Oh Goodie! More Bloodline Stuff On The Horizon

If you turned off Clash in Italy shortly after Roman Reigns vanquished Jacob Fatu and effectively folded him into Bloodline 2.0, you missed the next chapter of the burgeoning saga.
As Reigns, the Usos and Fatu left the ring, they caught sight of Solo Sikoa and the remains of the MFTs in the crowd. Roman pledged that he had something for them and that they would be dealing with them very soon. Jacob made eye contact and lingered for a bit while Solo shook his head at him disapprovingly.
What does all of this mean? Look, it could be a positive development – the MFTs have had their moments as a mid-card act, and bringing the different personalities into the mix could make for more interesting television than a focus on Roman arguing with Raw GM Adam Pearce.
However, it’s hard to have any level of confidence in the ability of the creative team at present, meaning that we will most likely get a lot of soliloquies, staredowns and melodrama that leads nowhere. The original Bloodline drama worked because of the humanity of characters like Sami Zayn and Jey Uso. Unless Fatu and Solo are going to replicate that humanity, we could be in store for a less-than-ideal Bloodline reboot.
We’ll be cautiously optimistic, but until WWE rebuilds trust in its booking, this will get a tenuous “down.”
5. Cole Stumbles And Bumbles On The Mic

Jim Ross has gotten a fair amount of criticism in his later years for forgetting angles and bungling things on commentary, but the man has decades of prime match-calling to his credit, so he gets a decent amount of grace.
Michael Cole, on the other hand, has been serviceable at best while being dubbed “The Voice of WWE” simply due to his longevity. And now, as he enters his third decade of work for WWE, his match-calling has reached levels where he can’t even be counted on to call basic moves correctly.
During Clash in Italy, Cole botched several calls, including saying Cody Rhodes’ cartwheel was a “somersault;” missing a Pedigree and simply yelling, “face first!”; referring to Rhea Ripley’s basement dropkick as a “missile dropkick;” calling Rhea’s avalanche back suplex a “superplex;” dubbing Jade Cargill’s Blue Thunder Bomb a “sit-out powerbomb;” declaring that Sol Ruca had only won the North American Championship, with Corey Graves correcting that she also held the Speed Championship; and missing that Naomi (wife of Jimmy Uso) is technically a member of the Anoa’i family who has captured a world championship.
No one is perfect, but Cole has been slipping more often lately, and it’s getting a bit ridiculous. Calling a cartwheel a somersault is pretty bad.
4. Becky Wrestles Herself

As WWE likes to remind everyone, Sol Ruca has only been wrestling for four years. She has made tremendous strides in that short span and deserves credit for reaching the level she has achieved to date.
That said, Ruca has had a rough go of it lately on the main roster, and it raises valid questions about her readiness to perform in major spots like a title match on PLE.
During Sunday’s Women’s Intercontinental Championship match, Sol found herself being carried by Becky Lynch, who guided the rookie through a serviceable match, positioning herself and her opponent to cover for mistakes. Ruca’s punches looked incredibly weak, her European uppercuts had enough space to fit a basketball, and her attempt at a Sasuke Special nearly ended in disaster as she clipped the ropes and almost wiped out on the apron.
The finish saw Becky having to position herself multiple times to be in the correct spot, then had to signal for Sol to charge at her to get caught in the Manhandle Slam attempt, which fed into the Sol Snatcher for the win.
When you can so clearly see the wires like that, it raises questions, and it makes you wonder if WWE is doing the right thing charging ahead with Sol Ruca when she’s hit her finisher cleanly for a win once on the main roster, and there is a growing mountain of examples of her either needing more reps or suffering from a case of the yips.
There will be some praise later, but the overriding view here is that there are some concerns as Sol continues to grow into her role on the main roster.
3. A Finish Out Of Nowhere

Cody Rhodes versus Gunther had just hit third gear Sunday when the Undisputed WWE Champion nailed a Cross-Rhodes… for the pin?
Rhodes and the Ring General have really good chemistry, and their match at Clash in Italy was good while it lasted (more on that later), but the abrupt finish – combined with the entire “foot under the ropes” routine – was more suited to a television match than a big title fight on PLE.
Why book that finish? It seems clear that they did this to stretch out the feud, as Cody already said he’d give Gunther a rematch, which is madness. During his main roster tenure, Gunther has only lost four matches (Sami Zayn, Rhodes, Jey Uso, and CM Punk), so having him lose another here – even with the referee missing the rope break – to set up a rematch is mind-boggling.
The match was the second-shortest bout on the card, behind only Brock Lesnar/Oba Femi, and it cut off at what felt like the midpoint rather than the climax, and they booked Gunther’s fifth singles loss in a throwaway manner. What are we doing here?
2. Plodding PG Plunder Match

Welp, Tribal Combat is 0-3 as a gimmick match. Might be time to retire it for good (and not a Brock Lesnar-style retirement).
Roman Reigns versus Jacob Fatu was a dull snoozer of a main event, a plodding PG plunder match that dragged on for an eternity with no urgency or real energy behind it. When they went into the crowd for a slow, half-hearted brawl around the arena, you got the feeling that the entire match was going to reflect that meandering fight.
Oh sure, there were weapons shots galore, and Roman attempting to cripple Fatu’s hand to nullify the Tongan Death Grip was a smart story beat. We also got the traditional Reigns mid-match monologue and the low blow kickout spot. A barricade got destroyed via spear as well.
All told, this was as paint-by-numbers of a CM Punk-less Roman Reigns main event you could imagine. The only thing missing was the Usos running interference throughout to protect their Tribal Chief. Had it been wrestled with intensity and at anything faster than half-speed, this might have rated positively, but it was just far too dull of a match to award an “up.”
1. Colossally Bad Booking

Oba Femi is a once-in-a-generation talent, a rare combination of athleticism, charisma, and an unmistakable crowd connection that can’t be faked. WWE has a gold mine on their hands here – all they needed to do was stay the course and book him to dominate until the wheels fell off.
At Clash in Italy Sunday, WWE knocked the wheels off themselves and derailed their own homegrown megastar by feeding him to an over-the-hill, part-time wrestler who has been appearing to diminishing returns for years and is name-dropped 40-plus times in a sex trafficking lawsuit.
Brilliant move, geniuses.
WWE fed Oba to Brock Lesnar in what could pass for an extended squash, with Lesnar nailing seven F-5s and locking in a kimura for about one-quarter of the match. Femi would fight back, but he never really was in control for more than a few fleeting seconds.
Just like that, WWE fell back into their old trope of booking a trilogy, with Brock avenging his WrestleMania loss. In doing so, WWE sacrificed Oba’s unblemished aura and an opportunity to do something truly unique. Instead, we’re likely getting a third Femi/Lesnar match that – no matter how great it is on the night – will do nothing to make Oba a bigger star or elevate him any more than his perfect WrestleMania 42 feud and squash already has done for him.
Even WCW managed to not screw up Goldberg’s undefeated streak for 15 months. WWE pissed Femi’s away in less than four.
UPS…
3. A Sliver Of Goodness From The Opener

Taking into account all of the negatives raised earlier about Cody Rhodes versus Gunther, their brief match was pretty good while it lasted.
Cody and Gunther have really good chemistry, which was on full display throughout their match. They countered each other nicely and had fans invested from the opening bell. A rematch between the two – given more time and a proper finish – could be incredible.
If nothing else, their Clash in Italy match gave hope for their eventual rematch.
2. Kudos For Going All In

After expressing concerns about Sol Ruca’s performance and the potential for issues on the main roster, there should be a bit of praise for WWE committing to a push for the rookie call-up.
For better or worse, this could be a sink-or-swim moment for Ruca. She defeated Becky Lynch for her first real main roster victory, capturing the Women’s Intercontinental Championship. Her run thus far has been botchy and uneven, but even in her match Sunday night, Sol showed flashes of the talent that got her called up in the first place.
If Ruca is able to focus on the positives – her flip out of a DDT attempt, her moonsault to the floor, and landing a clean Sol Snatcher – then whatever has led to the mistakes will hopefully fade and she will be off to the races.
There was a good argument for WWE pumping the brakes on this Sol Ruca push given some of the mishaps, but let’s give credit here for the positives and for WWE sticking with the direction change. Hopefully, Sol gets to have matches with other superstars and gain more experience rather than just existing in the Becky-verse for the time being.
1. Jade’s Best WWE Match To Date

Jade Cargill has had a checkered record with her matches in WWE. Many have been lacking, but several have played to her strengths and resulted in solid showcases for the powerhouse wrestler.
Sunday’s Clash in Italy battle with Rhea Ripley was a notable upgrade from their WrestleMania 42 match, with the WWE Women’s World Championship match getting 17 minutes (as opposed to 10 at 'Mania). Jade and Rhea were able to stitch together longer sequences, with Cargill methodically using her strength to overpower Ripley (and then do push-ups to show off), and Ripley responding with her own mix of speed and power.
Both women battled for their signature moves and finishers, countering each other repeatedly until Jade turned a Riptide into a DDT and followed up with a Blue Thunder Bomb. Rhea could continuously avoid Jaded and managed to overcome Michin and B-Fab with a little help from Charlotte Flair. The Queen repaid the Baddies’ interference by putting Rhea’s foot on the rope.
Rhea getting the pin with a Riptide after the outside interference from all the seconds worked well, giving Mami a big win in a high-profile rematch. While this wasn’t a great match, it was the best one on the card Sunday night and probably was the best version of a Jade/Rhea match.