3 Ups & 6 Downs From WWE Raw (Nov 21)

Ali buried, Gargano squashed, women's feud sputters. At least Tozawa isn't a ninja anymore.

Rhea Ripley Asuka
WWE.com

That’s it, time to get off the train.

After four months of giving WWE the benefit of the doubt and letting the rose-colored glasses of “a new era” brighten up the outlook of Raw, it’s time to stop treating this show with kid gloves or grading it with a feeling of optimism.

Put bluntly, Raw is a bad show. Again. Even without Vince McMahon at the helm. Maybe Triple H can’t cure the terminal. Maybe he’s afflicted as well. But Raw has been trending badly for a little while now, and Monday’s show finally tipped the scales to where good wrestling could not overcome the negative vibes of the overall program.

Sure, we should give credit to some good in-ring action, but you can’t ignore the burial of two fan favorites, one of whom returned to the company just a couple of months ago, and another who returned to television after a public spat. We saw the continuation of bad habits and WWE tropes that made Raw almost unwatchable at times, a sign that new leadership does not fix problems.

The regime change might have masked the issues for a while, as a series of shock returns and debuts, combined with explosive angles and more in-ring action, gave a feeling that we’d entered a new era.

But it’s pretty clear now that Raw still has the same fundamental flaws, and they will continue to expose themselves, leading to stinkers like this episode.

Let’s get to it…


Downs…

6. Tozawa Ditches Ninja Gimmick, But…

JBL Akira Tozawa
WWE.com

In a move that should have earned an “up” on its own, Akira Tozawa finally ditched the offensive ninja gimmick he’d been saddled with for more than two full years.

Tozawa, an accomplished wrestler in his own right, has spent the past two years chasing the 24/7 Championship while dressed as a ninja. That really shouldn’t surprise anyone – Vince McMahon and his cohorts thought dressing a Japanese wrestler up as a ninja was a great idea, and then kept it up for more than 24 months.

To be fair, Akira played his role well, eliciting some genuine laughs with his ninja horde, but this gimmick should’ve never happened and at worst should have been killed off when the empty arena shows ended.

Monday, Tozawa appeared on top of the Raw commentary desk to torment JBL as a continuation from last week. However, he jumped into Bradshaw’s arms, then stole his cowboy hat before fleeing through the crowd with it.

Yes, Tozawa’s return to a “normal” appearance was punctuated by a bad comedy angle involving the theft of a hat. Credit for ditching the get-up, but we can’t give this positive marks yet.


5. What Was The Opener Supposed To Be?

The Brawling Brutes
WWE.com

If you love promo trains that say very little and impromptu matches, then the opening segment was just for you.

Kevin Owens, who often can do no wrong, came out to explain why he returned last week on SmackDown to join the Brawling Brutes and Drew McIntyre to take on the Bloodline. Of course, if you’ve watched WWE programming for the past two years, you already know the answer, but WWE needs to spoon-feed the storylines to its audience.

This brought out his teammates, which somehow triggered The Judgment Day. And then this gave way to a six-man tag match because Finn Balor said some fightin’ words, and Sheamus decided that that should lead to a fight.

While the match itself was perfectly fine (more on that later), it takes five seconds to ask the question: What was supposed to follow KO’s promo and fill those 15 minutes that the match occupied?

Brawling Brutes versus Judgment Day could actually be a rivalry with some stakes or a storyline, but here, it was set up with a five-minute back-and-forth and burned out on free TV because Raw is three hours and we’ve got to fill it somehow.


4. RIP Johnny Wrestling

Johnny Gargano Omos
WWE.com

It’s probably safe to officially call Johnny Gargano’s return to WWE a complete dud.

Barring some tremendous reversal of fortune, Gargano’s return has consisted of a couple decent matches and then playing second banana to Dexter Lumis in his rivalry with the Miz. As a result, he’s been stuck playing goofy and plucky underdog who delivers the exposition since Lumis is a mute.

In the past two months, Gargano has lost to Otis, Baron Corbin, Miz, and now Omos on Monday. Johnny Wrestling was slated to get a rematch with Miz, but because we have to try to find a way to make people boo Miz more (as if him being on our TVs wasn’t enough), he ducked out claiming an injury while making a TikTok.

This gave us an awful match between Gargano and Omos that saw Johnny look like one of those WCW cruiserweights who had no shot against an nWo member but got a brief hope spot before being squashed. He certainly didn’t look like an NXT triple crown winner.

But hey, Miz versus Dexter Lumis should certainly… be a match that happens.


3. The Burial Continues

Austin Theory Mustafa Ali
WWE.com

As if being squashed by Bobby Lashley last week wasn’t bad enough, Mustafa Ali was sent out there to die on Monday night in epically bad fashion.

Ali went out to have a semi-competitive match against Austin Theory (you know, the guy who had literally the worst Money in the Bank cash-in in history) before losing clean to the guy getting a renewed push.

But it got worse. Way worse.

Theory called out Bobby Lashley, who (after a commercial break) brawled with Austin, and they both ran back through gorilla, where Ali inexplicably was sitting. Theory threw Mustafa at Lashley, and because both men are idiots, Ali shoved Bobby, and Lashley immediately forgot he was chasing Austin and instead tossed Ali out the entrance and beat him up for good on the stage.

At that point, they might as well have tossed Ali in a crate labeled “NXT” or “AEW” or even just “future endeavored.” What a horrible use of such a talented wrestler.


2. A Very Fake-Feeling Feud

WWE Women's WarGames teams
WWE.com

After three months of feuding, you’d think that Bianca Belair and Bayley’s motivations and purpose would be second nature by now, but Monday’s promo before the main event was anything but natural.

Whether it was a case of having to recite certain dialogue or get specific points across, the promo between Damage CTRL and Belair, Asuka and Alexa Bliss was incredibly forced and artificial. It was impossible to feel like these were real people with real animosity toward each other.

Considering that this is the main feud for the Raw women’s division, that is a terrible feeling to have, but this is the go-home promo for what is supposedly the culmination of a three-month feud between these groups – inside WarGames no less - and you might as well have had cue cards out there with them rather than letting them cut loose on each other.

At this point, just put an end to the rivalry once and for all at Survivor Series and let’s move on to something hopefully better.


1. Who Runs This Place?

OMos The Miz
WWE.com

If WWE taught us anything Monday night, it’s that Raw is apparently a lawless place where anyone can make matches and substitute other wrestlers to take their place.

Raw opened with a promo train that saw Judgment Day and the Brawling Brutes book themselves into a six-man tag match, which was a good for WWE since apparently they didn’t have anything scheduled for that segment.

Immediately afterward, Johnny Gargano was scheduled to face the Miz, but the Awesome One claimed an injury. Never fear, Miz found a suitable replacement: Omos.

In no way should we be clamoring for the return of a Raw GM, but it’s just impossible to even pretend that WWE is the emulation of a competitive sport – or even a scripted TV show – when you have chaotic, on-the-fly booking taking place right in front of you every week.

Ask yourself a simple question: If Judgment Day hadn’t accepted the Brutes’ challenge, what would have eaten up 15 minutes of Raw? Or, if Miz can name his own replacement out of the blue with no repercussions, why would any heel ever wrestle when they don’t have a huge advantage?

This kind of thing is going to happen in wrestling, but with WWE, it’s any every week occurrence. You might have thought this would have ended in the Triple H era, but all of WWE’s worst tropes are returning at an alarming rate, and these are the latest examples of a show descending back into the gutter.


Ups…

3. Perfectly Acceptable Tag Wrestling

Chad Gable Matt Riddle
WWE.com

Let’s put this out into the universe quickly: Alpha Academy are a vastly underrated tag team that has managed to have good matches with several teams during the past year.

So, it’s no shock that they had a good match on Raw Monday night against Matt Riddle & Elias. The four gelled well overall, with Chad Gable and Riddle doing the bulk of the work and Elias and Otis playing their roles nicely. Even though it was their first time teaming, Elias & Riddle had some nice double-team moves, including an elevated Broton with Elias hoisting Riddle up for the move.

Only two things detracted from the enjoyment overall: the fact a first-time pairing beat former Raw tag champs who are still in their prime, and a feeling of whether this will matter next week.

That’s probably a holdover sentiment from the former regime, because for all the faults emerging under this new leadership, things do proceed linearly.


2. Dom Knows His Role

Dominik Mysterio The Judgment Day
WWE.com

Once again, hats off to Dominik Mysterio for playing his role perfectly.

The man with the most punchable face once again did his shtick during the Judgment Day/Brawling Brutes six-man tag match, tagging in when his team was in control to get a couple cheap shots and celebrating like he was Kurt Angle winning a gold medal. When the fans booed and chanted, “Who’s your daddy?”, he did his Eddie Guerrero impersonation while Rhea Ripley simply gestured at herself.

But when it came time for both teams to get hot tags, it was Dominik suddenly facing off with Sheamus and look like he soiled himself. Mysterio took a sh*t-kicking, eating a Brogue and taking the pin, which works just fine as the group’s true weak link.

At some point, you have to wonder if they’ll reveal the reason the Judgment Day lets Dom hang with them – or at least be their third in six-man matches – because with Rey Mysterio on SmackDown, there isn’t a ton of value added in reality.

But there’s a ton of entertainment value added with Dominik.


1. Ripley Hasn’t Lost A Step

Rhea Ripley Asuka
WWE.com

News flash: Rhea Ripley is really good at wrestling.

Honestly, no one should have expected Ripley to forget how to wrestle, but fans might have forgotten how good she is in the ring, considering she competed in her first main roster match in more than five months Monday night.

Ripley defeated Asuka in the main event to give her team the person advantage for their WarGames match at Survivor Series this weekend, a result that largely should have been a foregone conclusion. What wasn’t guaranteed was whether this match would be a singles battle solely between the two or if their respective camps would get involved.

Instead of a debacle involving everyone, the match ended about as cleanly as possible, with a massive brawl taking place immediately afterward. And spoiler alert: Ripley and Asuka had an excellent match.

Rhea winning like this gives more credence to the notion that she could be Belair’s challenger for WrestleMania 39 should things progress that far.


Contributor
Contributor

Scott is a former journalist and longtime wrestling fan who was smart enough to abandon WCW during the Monday Night Wars the same time as the Radicalz. He fondly remembers watching WrestleMania III, IV, V and VI and Saturday Night's Main Event, came back to wrestling during the Attitude Era, and has been a consumer of sports entertainment since then. He's written for WhatCulture since 2014, establishing the Ups and Downs articles for WWE Raw and WWE PPVs/PLEs and composing pieces on a variety of topics.