3 Ups & 7 Downs From AEW Dark (Nov 5)
Lowlights aplenty in AEW's worst weekly show so far.
So here it is: the first net negative show of AEW's weekly existence, and what a stinker it was.
These 62 minutes were a slog to get through, and that's something one should never be able to say about a show designed to be a light, breezy, and easily-digestible platform to highlight performers yet to break through on Dynamite. Parts of it felt like a genuine trainwreck. It's a shame, because Dark has been consistently solid so far, but while the B-tier classification means that these issues don't matter all that much in the grander scheme, they can't go unmentioned either.
Dasha Gonzalez (formerly Dasha Fuentes in WWE) joined Tony Schiavone in the studio. She brought a different energy to proceedings, but neither contributed to nor detracted from the presentation to warrant an individual Up or Down. In the ring, we got a women's tag featuring two unsigned stars, Michael Nakazawa vs. Shawn Spears, and a Joey Janela/Jimmy Havoc vs. Jurassic Express main event, broken up by a strong Britt Baker promo and the latest instalment of From Undesirable to Undeniable.
Let's break down everything that happened on this sloppy show...
Downs...
7. Women's Match Ravaged By Telling Cuts
Big Swole and Mercedes Martinez vs. Allie and Sadie Gibbs was a shoddy match far below the quartet's collective talent level.
It started off with Swole and Gibbs, whom the commentators put over as hosses even though they weren't wrestling that way. It was an awkward, plodding sequence typical of the bout as a whole, with only a few flashes of excitement down the stretch saving it from outright failure. Slow, overlong, and peppered with obvious editing cuts to cover miscommunications and errors, it was at its best when Martinez was in the ring to hold things together, but never anything close to blow-away.
A shorter runtime, more action-focused layout, and increased volume of spots from the hyper-athletic Gibbs and world-class Martinez would've surely helped shake the crowd from their slumber.
6. This Isn't Working
Shawn Spears has a cool entrance, a banger theme, and a decent look, but this heel run isn't working.
His is a malfunctioning act. It isn't terrible, but it isn't connecting either, with his wrestling pedestrian and boring and his character work unconvincing now that he's no longer working with Cody. He didn't come across well while wrestling Michael Nakazawa. In fairness, he should've been booked to crush the oily boy in just a few minutes and victory over a comedy jobber was never going to offer much upward momentum, but it looks very much like the former Tye Dillinger might just be the "good hand" Cody branded him in the build to their All Out match.
He's gotta change his nickname, too. There's only one 'Chairman' in this business, chief, and it ain't you.
5. Unlikely Alliance
Booking Jimmy Havoc and Joey Janela to team against Jurassic Express was an oddball move that didn't make a whole lot of sense on paper.
The duo have been cast as enemies so far in AEW, with their Fight For The Fallen trio's implosion providing the impetus for All Out's Cracker Barrel Clash. Nothing has changed since then. Heading into Dark, there was no reason to believe that Janela and Havoc were anything close to on the same page, and while this eventually played into the tag match's finish as Joey stapled Jimmy in his goddamn face, why they were booked as a team wasn't put over well at all.
This wasn't framed as an odd couple pairing, but just a random pair of dudes thrown together on the B-show. The problem is that Janela and Havoc aren't that. This should've been addressed as they were making their way to the ring, not deep into the bout.
4. Fragile Defiance
Last night played host to From Undesirable to Undeniable's weakest episode yet, with Jimmy Havoc joining Cody in the bleachers (and later, backstage).
When asked about a time he'd felt undesirable, Jimmy said that pretty much everything that brought him to this point fed into this, adding that his divisiveness fuelled him. He said he wanted to carry on as a "f*ck you" to his doubters, coming off overly defensive as he constantly reiterated this. More than one middle finger was flashed to the camera as he trolled haters about getting signed. That's fine on paper, but not when said defiance feels so fragile, and his off-the-cuff spiels were all over the place as well, making this a sloppy, messy offering from the weekly highlight segment.
This is Jimmy to a tee, to be fair, and he probably wouldn't have it any other way, but ramshackle nonetheless.
3. Water & Oil
Comedy has a place in All Elite Wrestling, but not like this. Shawn Spears vs. Michael Nakazawa stunk.
Imagine the least engaging house show action possible, meshed with an oily comedy spot. That's what this was. Coming in at almost nine minutes in length, it was basic, plodding action interspersed with Nakazawa's antics. The Japanese lube enthusiast slid out of a waistlock with his baby oil, forced Tully Blanchard to skitter off the apron, and had Spears falling on his arse as he dashed to the corner. At one point, he pulled off his jockstrap and tried to attack Shawn with it - and none of it conjured even the politest of laughs.
Thank the wrestling gods that this thing was on Dark, because it should never make it to Dynamite. This is the kind of nonsense that will turn casual fans away, not Orange Cassidy's effective work, and while Spears picked up a much-needed win over Nakazawa, that it took him so long undermined any credibility gained.
2. Torture Porn
Dark's closing segment was a poorly-executed, rushed match-builder that felt like it came out of nowhere - and not in a good way.
The action cut backstage soon after Joey Janela and Jimmy Havoc had defeated Jurassic Express. Joey was hanging out, smoking a cigarette, when Tully Blanchard approached, scorning 'The Bad Boy' for their last interaction. This led to Shawn Spears jumping Janella, jamming a pair of pliers into his mouth, and seemingly targeting a tooth, then shoving the cigarette down his throat. End scene.
This is supposed to be a wrestling show, not a Saw movie, so why are Spears and Blanchard going around yanking teeth and making men swallow lit cigarettes? It's one thing using a staplegun or barbed wire skateboard in a hardcore match, but this? This is off. It doesn't work for a wrestling company that champions a real-sport feel and we can only hope that the eventual match between these two is better than the setup.
1. Scheduling Nightmare
AEW Dark is supposed to broadcast live on YouTube at 7pm EST every Tuesday night. Unfortunately, last night's show was delayed to 8pm. This wouldn't have been a major problem had the promotion advertised this in advance and adjusted accordingly, but they didn't, leaving thousands of fans hanging before AEW eventually acknowledged the delay at 7:15pm.
Worse still was the company's Twitter account, which was tweeting out gifs and highlights from a show that wasn't even on the air yet. These have since been deleted, but it looks like whoever runs AEW's social media scheduled these tweets before Dark hit the air, then forget to change the times to coincide with the delay, prompting streams of angry responses for a show that wasn't even online yet.
What a mess. Mistakes happen, but this is basic, basic stuff, and should be going down on any promotion's watch.
Ups...
3. Baker Bites Back
Britt Baker was great in a mid-show promo that probably should have gone down on Dynamite, not Dark, given how effective it was in putting her rivalry with Bea Priestley over.
The good doctor stressed that part of being a wrestler is being professional in her pre-recorded sitdown promo, adding that she was all about becoming the best pro-wrestler she can possibly be, not hurting other people. Her peers, unfortunately, aren't so professional, and when Priestley hurt her at Fight for the Fallen, she received calls, texts, and other well-wishes from everyone else on the roster. Not Bea, though. The New Zealander violated an unwritten rule by not checking in with her. "Some people are professionals," Britt said, "and some people are pieces of sh*t."
Though she put Priesley over as a wrestler, Baker threatened to rip her jaw off when they face at Full Gear. Does she have that in her, though? Britt, herself, wasn't sure, but said Bea would experience what she felt like at Fight for the Fallen.
Comfortably Baker's best piece of content since AEW began. It was tremendous, and here's hoping Bea claps back on Dynamite.
2. MJF Tags In For JR
MJF took Jim Ross' place in the Dark commentary booth last night and did an absolutely tremendous job in coming off like a young Jerry 'The King' Lawler, delivering some of the night's most memorable lines in the process.
"Michael Nakazawa is a freak, always covered in baby oil," he said as the Japanese wrestler made his entrance. "And what's baby oil made of? I'll let you do the math: if olive oil is made from olives, and coconut oil is made from coconuts... do the math, folks." Then, when Sadie Gibbs was arriving: "She's trying to cover up her weaknesses, knowing she's from the UK, wearing a mouthpiece... very intelligent, we don't wanna see those teeth!"
Was MJF a little too distracting and a tad too focused on putting himself over before the action? Under other circumstances, definitely, but the bulk of said "action" was of such a low standard that MJF's presence was most welcome. Maybe we'll see more wrestlers step into the booth in future episodes, though they'd do well to follow young Max.
1. A Fun Main Event
While nothing to write home about, Dark's main event pitting Jimmy Havoc and Joey Janela against Jurassic Express' Marko Stunt and Jungle Boy was a fun little tag match and comfortably the best contest on the show, though the lineup looks like it was custom-built to anger fans of certain persuasions who claim they aren't watching, but still find nitpicks.
"Solid" is the operative term here. It was fifteen minutes of back-and-forth action highlighted by Jurassic Express' bursts of life, with the pint-sized Stunt taking a disgusting-looking avalanche package piledriver for the finish. The man's bumping is something else. He looks like he's being folded like an accordion every single time.
Janela's pinfall came after he'd stapled his partner right in the face, taking him out of the equation. That Joey technically defeated Jurassic on his own enhances his victory ahead of the teased Shawn Spears match, though it's curious that rather than striking back, Havoc just slinked into the background after the match. Nonetheless, a decent effort from the participants.