3 Ups & 7 Downs From WWE Raw (31 Oct)
Triple H dresses up as Vince McMahon for Halloween on a flat Crown Jewel go-home show...
The 'Papa H' era of WWE has hit something of a snag-uh.
The Bloodline storyline remains great, gaping plot hole aside. Each warring member could simply watch the television show back to clarify the various misunderstandings that have led them to this point. It's different to something like the Elite saga of early 2020 which, on Dynamite at least, was elegantly constructed so that a replay wouldn't have solved anything. This Bloodline programme requires a lot of suspension of disbelief, but happily, is so good that most are willing.
It's a joy to watch Sami Zayn slowly rediscover his inner genius babyface, it's even more of a joy to watch WWE talent in love with performing, and Roman Reigns remains so good at conveying menace that - for now - the corpsing isn't affecting the quite brilliant dynamic.
Beyond that, the gains made over the past few months are fading. Kevin Owens has cooled off. Matt Riddle is an obnoxious and frivolous goof again. Johnny Gargano is such an irritating brat that it feels as though this is exactly how he'd be booked if Vince McMahon were still in charge. Also, there's a sobering note of irony to the old "What will Tony Khan do when he runs out of pops?" take, since Triple H has gone return mad, and is more mad on these returns than his audience.
Did this week's Raw represent a return to something promising...?
Downs...
7. It's Just A Numbers Game
Triple H is now presenting new character upon new character upon new character upon rebooted NXT character with minimal exposition.
Ironic, no?
Gauging by the contrasting crowd reaction between Bianca Belair Vs. Nikki Cross and most Forbidden Door developments, AEW fans are more cognisant of NJPW than WWE fans are of WWE NXT. The return of the unhinged Nikki Cross character barely registered with the Texas crowd, who did not react to her fire-ups. She's very talented, so all should go well enough, but this was a strange start in what is becoming a pattern. Triple H clearly has no idea what to do with Candice LeRae nor Emma. What to do with Cross?
The answer is what he does with seemingly everybody else: a distraction finish. The match was solid if unremarkable fare built around the premise that Bianca Belair is strong and Nikki Cross will fly into her with no compunction regardless. Because she is unhinged.
Little more than a means of establishing the character as an indiscriminate tweener - and of course, a loser - her being shafted by Damage CTRL suggests we're in for a "Whose side is she on?" direction ahead of WarGames. This might be halfway interesting, and something has to be - statistically, if nothing else. So far, it feels like Triple H has fancied doing WarGames, created a stable and recruited more names to facilitate it, and failed to tell a compelling story beyond some rumblings of "control".
Pop quiz: recite literally anything Bayley has said over the last few months verbatim.
This is an issue, and this segment did little to clarify any real purpose surrounding the women's division.
6. Nothing We Didn't Already Know
The Roman Reigns Vs. Logan Paul programme has been highlighted by precisely one good segment, and that it didn't take place on WWE television - rather a staged press conference - says rather a lot about WWE's approach to telling stories.
This angle was hardly the sort of thing that fires up the fanbase into begging for the weekend to come 'round quickly. The Miz offered his help to Roman; having introduced Logan Paul to WWE, he knows what the man is capable of more intimately than anyone. In a great individual performance, Roman grew progressively more agitated at the nonsense that is Paul's bionic hand. He wondered aloud why nobody was talking about his stopping power, which he demonstrated by unloading a Superman punch in Miz's face.
A neat enough way of working around Paul not being available, it was fine enough, but Reigns got over as the megastar he is by pumping himself up with an aggressive, confident to-camera spiel as he walked up the ramp. In that moment, he felt like the biggest wrestling act on earth - even if he was hardly appearing on the best wrestling show on earth.
But then, everybody knows how great Roman is already. This, to reiterate, was the go-home angle for the main event of a big stadium show. There's a level of expectation for this sort of thing, and WWE came nowhere near it.
5. The Geekening Of Mustafa Ali
WWE stop booking smaller babyfaces to have sh*te patter and generally behave in a cocky and unlikeable fashion challenge (impossible).
Mustafa Ali and Johnny Gargano are at this point playing the same, dreadful character: Zack Morris wearing kick pads. As far as stupidly broad WWE "comedy" goes, The Miz did a decent, massively over-the-top job of selling Roman Reigns' Superman punch by icing his face and acting as if his jaw had been dislocated. In another continuation of the low-key weirdest story WWE tells, Miz, who always takes the chicken sh*t heel thing to an absurd extreme, used the assault in an attempt to get out of his match with Mustafa Ali.
It didn't work; Ali goaded Miz into it by saying "Everything is bigger in Texas - well, maybe not everything..."
He was insinuating that Miz has tiny balls, and then said the quiet part loud with a tragic three camera sitcom delivery. His match with the Miz later in the evening wasn't shabby at all. The fans were getting into it towards the finish. The issue however is that Dexter Lumis interfered at the finish, Ali capitalised on the distraction, and then celebrated as if he'd just won the big one at WrestleMania.
WWE - despite some earnestly great stuff on SmackDown involving the Brawling Brutes, Imperium and the Bloodline - is bad enough in and of itself. It gets worse when you use your imagination and wonder what could be. Ali could be a valuable earnest babyface, but instead, his character is another smug unfunny geek celebrating tiny, insignificant victories.
4. Segment Simply Exists Because Raw Is Three Hours Long
In a meaningless segment of television - almost literally so - Karl Anderson defeated Damian Priest in another solid, unremarkable match. There was nothing overtly wrong with it - they worked mechanically fine sequences in the correct order - but it was drab. There was no emotion, spectacle, excitement or creativity to it. It was a solid, uninspiring match.
It was also a match booked as if it didn't matter. Anderson scored the win with a backslide pin, and the segment descended into a stable brawl the very second the referee's hand struck three. It wasn't even sold as a fluke because it wasn't sold at all; it was just pretext to shoot the go-home angle for Crown Jewel, which was decent enough. The very notion that Dominik Mysterio even approaches Eddie Guerrero's legend is a good meta heel bit. When he eats sh*t, it gets the biggest pop on most shows, and he had the final say here.
It was clever enough to save that pop for the PLE, but this was just a narrative obligation masquerading as a heat angle.
3. Baron Corbin's Push Continues To Be Not Good
There's a very good performer lurking within Baron Corbin. Fans have briefly glimpsed it over the years, through the shock value heel work at Stomping Grounds and, more consistently, his excellent grasp of detestable facial expressions. This push is not the vehicle that will drive his career forward.
JBL cut a baby's first heel promo on the shindies by droning on about "woke" "snowflakes" and yes, it was bad when Dan Lambert did it in AEW too!
Baron Corbin followed up with yet more punishingly generic material about how he sold the tickets to the house, and everybody came from the factories and the farms to see him. When they jeered - very mildly, which says it all - he reasoned that they were only doing so to impress their friends. This out-of-date drivel summoned R-Truth, whose retort wasn't even R-Truth funny (i.e. not remotely). His response was too wordy, didn't generate a reaction, and after initially getting one over on Corbin, JBL's distraction allowed him to hit the End of Days.
Another waste of time and resources on what was the defining theme of the evening.
2. The Same Sh*t Every Year
There's nothing wrong with light, holiday-specific material. Wrestling is inherently silly and can get away with being even dafter on certain shows.
It would help if the material was actually amusing, and this wasn't.
At first glance, it appeared that Riddle was dressed as somebody problematic - unusual! - but it turned out he was cosplaying as Ezekiel for Halloween. Holiday or no, his Trick or Street Fight with Otis was another regression from the halfway serious character he had played effectively under Triple H. Not the first time on this show, or in recent weeks for that matter, the booking fuelled a conspiracy theory that Vince McMahon is back in some capacity or other. That, or D-Generation X's Triple H isn't all too different from the relative and close friend he studied under for decades.
Aspects of the match were amusing. Otis dressed as an exotic dancer doing the worm was too dumb not to crack at, and Gable took a superb slapstick bump through a table. That was brilliantly timed.
Every year, a heel gets a pumpkin put over his head and takes a bump. Every year, without fail. Couldn't they have had a bit more fun with it? Couldn't they have failed to get it on this year, in a sight gag putting over Otis' preposterous neck?
No, because they think it's an absolute stitch.
1. The Continued Geekening Of Johnny Gargano
Suddenly, an appearance on Dynamite followed by six weeks of Dark squashes doesn't seem so bad, because WWE has handled Johnny Gargano dismally. He probably fantasises, idly, of being interrupted by Smart Mark Sterling or getting recruited by Ari Daivari. Anything is better than this.
The mystery surrounding the Miz/Dexter Lumis connection was finally revealed: in a "tell-all" interview, complete with unfunny crime doc reenactments as part of a '60 Minutes' parody, Gargano theorised (with incriminating audio evidence) that Miz paid off Dexter, struggling for money, in a bid for attention and publicity. Internationally famous wrestler and star of his own reality show, the Miz.
A preposterous plot development, and worse, it has taken months to arrive at it.
And for what?
Any Miz Vs. Lumis match is guaranteed to be almost physically painfully dull, and Gargano playing the comedic lead in WWE's version of Psych or whatever is such a waste. Gargano possesses a dorky charm and good comedic timing, but he's not so good that it justifies this atrocious material. Gargano as NXT funnyman worked because his epic match formula had descended into parody. He needed a character refresh. He needs a character reboot at this point.
This prankster prop comic with the scoop bit is horrendous.
Ups...
3. Simple, Effective Booking Enhanced By The Performance
The build to Brock Lesnar Vs. Bobby Lashley was kept simple without being too generic.
Brock failed to turn up as scheduled for a sit-down face-to-face booked to promote their fight. He does what he wants, and what he wanted to do was make an unplanned trip to the ring complete, weirdly, with his entrance pyro. Bobby Lashley looked a bit of a mug just sat there none the wiser as Brock rampaged to the ring, but it was a weird production choice more than it was something that damaged his character.
Snark aside, the resulting pull-apart was well done; Lesnar orchestrated a booming response by taking Lashley off his feet, the brawl looked worthy of separating, and Lesnar breaking free and flying at Lashley, while a tried-and-true device in such an angle, is never not rousing in that it makes you feel like a bloodthirsty jock every time.
Such segments are meant to turn you into the Just Bleed UFC guy, and if it wasn't quite that red-hot, everybody involved, Triple H included, did a grand job of convincing fans that the fight had totally consumed both men.
2. Seth Rollins As Top Babyface: Third Time Lucky?
If his match against Austin Theory was a backdoor pilot for a babyface turn, on this evidence, Seth Rollins could emerge as a credible Royal Rumble winner. Any plans for a fourth Cody Rhodes match may have to be scrapped.
The post-Hell In A Cell beat-down write-off makes that hard, since standards are higher for continuity without Vince McMahon, but Rollins has drawn tremendous responses for a while now, and here, fans were loving the encouragement to go all in as he played situational babyface. He played it terrifically well too. In one of a handful of blistering sequences in a really good match, Rollins narrowly evaded an Austin Theory strike, and after a springboard from the top rope kneed him in the face and rolled through in one seamless motion.
He performed as the wily veteran still in his athletic prime so well that, when Theory finally wrested the advantage, it scanned as all the more impressive. This was elegantly crafted, so much so that it was Theory's best week in a long while.
Atypical of a Raw match, this was hot throughout - more grounds to execute the turn, since fans are often happy to sit on their hands until the finish.
They want to get up for Rollins.
1. A Hot Main Event
In something of a shocker, in a match made earlier in the night - what did "WWE officials" have planned for the main event of an important televised show? - Alexa Bliss and Asuka dethroned Women's Tag Team champions Dakota Kai and IYO SKY.
This was really worked and very dramatic by the finish. IYO in particular did a great, unique job with the the "down, not out" story beat by taking a cut-off facebuster, tapping to the Asuka lock unsighted by the ref, and, moments later, missing a PK to Alexa Bliss only to catch her with a back heel to the jaw. Amid all that, Asuka and Kai exchanged a quality exchange of kicks. The timing of the near-misses was blood-pumping
Amid that, Bayley and Bianca Belair built their Last Man Standing match at Crown Jewel with a Bayley to Belly through a table that made you want to see a Last Man Standing match.
The pop was immense for the title switch, but then, it always is. It's a cheat code. Until this story gets good for longer than a week, this was probably an aberration - but a fairly electrifying one, actually.
The booking was puzzling. Shouldn't the heels have all the power and "momentum" ahead of WarGames, to make the babyface reckoning all the sweeter? That's of course assuming that the babyface team is going to win, which you'd expect (or hope) to be the case, since Damage CTRL is cold, the story is cold, and it's been dragging on since the summer.
Bad comedy, mostly generic in-ring action, the same eye-rolling heel verbiage you've heard for years and years: meet the new boss, same as the old boss.