30 Most Inconsequential WWE Titleholders Of All Time

10. The Godfather - Intercontinental Champion - 43 Days (1999)

When the Intercontinental Title was in a game of hot potato during the first few months of 1999, in April, the belt made its way to the Godfather, who defeated Goldust on Raw. He held the belt longer than a month, before losing the belt to Jeff Jarrett on Raw. Godfather's reign is notorious for the match that never happened. Godfather was supposed to defend the title against The Blue Blazer (played by Owen Hart) at Over the Edge 1999. That was the match where Owen fell from the ceiling and died in a tragic accident. Owen was supposed to win the belt from the Godfather at the event, and Owen's tag team partner and friend Jarrett was booked to win the belt instead, as a tribute to Owen.

9. Diamond Dallas Page - European Champion - 49 Days (2002)

After Christian's reign as European Champion where he declared himself the Champion of Europe, he dropped the title to Diamond Dallas Page, who would then act as Christian's life coach, keeping Christian from throwing tantrums after losses. The highlight of DDP's reign as champion was successfully defending the championship against Christian at Wrestlemania X8. Just before the brand extension, DDP dropped the championship to William Regal on Smackdown. He would retire from full-time competition soon after.

8. Bobby Lashley - United States Champion - 49 Days (2006)

Lashley is a case study in what might have been for the WWE. They certainly had high hopes for him, as he defeated JBL on an episode of Smackdown (the night JBL retired for the first time). Unlike his ECW title reign the next year, Lashley didn't have a very memorable reign for his first singles championship. He held the belt for seven weeks, but never got the chance to defend the belt on Pay Per View, as he was pinned for the first time in his career by...

7. Finlay - United States Champion - 49 Days (2006)

Finlay used the shillelagh to hand Lashley his first loss, and it was an odd choice because at the time, Finlay wasn't really pushed that highly. Nevertheless, he was slated to defend the belt against Lashley in a rematch at the Great American Bash, but because Lashley had "elevated enzymes in his liver," or whatever that means, Finlay had to face William Regal in a rare heel vs. heel match. Finlay would go on to hold the title for seven weeks after winning it, but rarely defended it. He was in the main event of the No Mercy pay per view as champion, but he was part of a fatal four way match for the World Heavyweight Championship against King Booker, Batista, and Lashley. Two days later on Smackdown, Finlay dropped the belt to a returning Chris Benoit.

6. Ezekial Jackson - Intercontinental Champion - 51 Days (2011)

Jackson was known for defeating Wade Barrett, his former teammate in the Corre, at the Capitol Punishment Pay Per View in 2011. He held the title for seven weeks and two days, before dropping the belt on Smackdown to Cody Rhodes with pretty much no build. In that entire time as champion, Jackson didn't really have any major feuds other than a rematch against Barrett. Jackson wrestled sparingly after losing the title, and eventually left the WWE in 2014. The championship run did nothing for him.

5. Val Venis - European Champion - 58 Days (1999/2000)

Val Venis was more known for his Intercontinental Championship runs in WWE, but for more than eight weeks in late 1999/early 2000, he was the European Champion. Val won the belt in a triple threat match with champion The British Bulldog and D'Lo Brown, and was basically a placeholder champion until he was beaten by Kurt Angle on an episode of Smackdown in February 2000.

4. Test - European Champion - 69 Days (2001)

The European Championship in late 2000/early 2001 was pretty much in the background, and there were rarely any storylines for the belt. Test defeated William Regal for the championship the night after the 2001 Royal Rumble on Raw, and held the belt until Wrestlemania, where he dropped the belt to Eddie Guerrero in the worst match on a stacked card. You might recall in that match that Test got his foot stuck in the ropes and both Eddie and the ref took forever to get Test out of them.

3. Ryback - Intercontinental Champion - 112 Days (2015)

Daniel Bryan had big plans for the Intercontinental Championship after he won the belt at Wrestlemania 31. He had mentioned on Table for 3 that he had planned to make the title Smackdown-exclusive because John Cena was doing his U.S. Open challenge on Raw. Unfortunately, Bryan suffered a concussion and was stripped of the belt. The vacant title was put on the line in the Elimination Chamber, which Ryback won. Even through Ryback held the belt for more than 100 days, a small portion of that time Ryback was on the shelf with a staph infection and there was talk that he might be stripped of the title. The only real feuds Ryback had was against the Miz and the Big Show, and against Kevin Owens, who made fun of Ryback for following The Secret book. Owens took the belt from Ryback at Night of Champions, ending a long but ultimately unimpressive reign.

2. Curtis Axel - Intercontinental Champion - 155 Days (2013)

Saved from the depths of hell that was Michael McGillicutty, Joe Hennig was rebranded as Curtis Axel and dubbed the new Paul Heyman Guy after Extreme Rules 2013. Axel was immediately thrust into a program with Triple H (where he helped knock Hunter out of action) and immediately became Intercontinental Champion at Payback. Axel's reign as champion was not as eventful as the month or so before he became champion. He successfully defended the title against The Miz at Money in the Bank and Kofi Kingston at Night of Champions, but for the most part, he acted as Paul Heyman's lackey during Heyman's feud with CM Punk. Heyman dropped Axel as his client, and three days later on Raw, Axel lost the championship to...

1. Big E - Intercontinental Champion - 167 Days (2013/2014)

If you looked at the amount of days that Big E was Intercontinental Champion and went "wow," then you'll know that he belongs at the top of this list. E dethroned Axel on Raw and held the belt from October 2013 all the way until May 2014, where he lost the title to Bad News Barrett at Extreme Rules. What went against Big E was that all of the multi-man events (The Royal Rumble, The Andre The Giant Battle Royal) were happening during his reign, so he didn't have to have a signature feud to define his title reign. He did have two successful title defenses on Pay Per View: against Damien Sandow at TLC 2013 and against Jack Swagger to kick off the Elimination Chamber 2014 Pay Per View (was a pretty decent match), but those were truly the high points of his reign, and they weren't really that high. Big E's title reign is what people can point to when they talk about how the Intercontinental Title has been devalued, and he tops the list of most inconsequential championship reigns. Thoughts on the list? Comment below or follow me on Twitter @PocketSeagull.

In this post: 
Kalisto
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Justin has been writing about professional wrestling for more than 15 years. A lifelong WWE fan, he also is a big fan of Ring of Honor.