4 Ups & 2 Downs From WWE 205 Live (Dec 27)

In which the king demands his crown.

Neville Swann 27 II
WWE.com

December, the odd excellent TLC bout aside, is often an inconsequential and dull month in WWE lore - but last night’s edition of SmackDown! is generating considerable praise. Some are calling it the best television show WWE has presented all year.

John Cena’s opening promo was cut with typically flawless execution, and the reality-leaning content was dripping with intrigue. His sense of entitlement probably didn’t foreshadow a heel turn - but it did add much needed shades of grey to a character which had worn out its welcome. American Alpha surprised everybody by wresting the tag straps from the waists of the Wyatt Family. It was a curious decision which irked some, but the contrast between the interminable and predictable RAW division was refreshing.

The show as a whole was so bulletproof that even the much-maligned Baron Corbin emerged from it as a star. It’s more likely that AJ Styles dragged him up to his peerless orbit - but it was a standout performance, nonetheless.

All of which is to say that 205 Live had much to live up to, and subdued past form might lead one to give it a miss. The show couldn’t compete with SmackDown! - but it was the best episode of the nascent show yet…


Downs...

2. A Hot Opener Cooled

Nese Alexander
WWE.com

The opening bout, between Cedric Alexander and Tony Nese, was on its way to becoming something quietly special.

The two men shared winning chemistry, exchanging pacy sequences as fluid as they were convoluted in a suspenseful and exciting match - but it was sacrificed at the altar of rote, contrived trademark WWE storytelling. Towards the finish, Alexander’s beau, Alicia Fox, argued with Drew Gulak on the outside. Cowering at the sight of her, he fell on his backside. In a very obvious movement, she then kicked the boot from her foot, which Gulak claimed was used as a weapon. She was then ejected from ringside, allowing Nese to drop Alexander with the match-winning palm strike.

The finish was almost comically contrived, and Alexander - whose star arguably shone brightest during the Cruiserweight Classic, owing to his Match Of The Year-calibre outing opposite Kota Ibushi on 14 July - was left looking like a dope. Outsmarted by the second heel in as many weeks, he has been reduced to ancillary player in a dreary soap opera angle.

At least Noam Dar provided some comedy in the post-match, adding a masochistic layer to his inexplicably funny sex pest act by enjoying the hard slaps Fox subjected him to. It’s a far cry from the rewardingly novel approach taken by the CWC - but Dar is somehow contriving to enliven a DOA gimmick.


1. An Atypically Poor Video Package

Daivari Lead Pipe
WWE.com

WWE is usually unrivalled in the production department.

The pre-match hype videos on pay-per-view, in particular, are almost unfathomably great; editing the long-winded and repetitive RAW promos which exist only to pad out airtime, Kevin Dunn and his team are masters at re-contextualising them into something unmissable. Less is more, is the lesson - but the production truck was unable to work similar magic with the Ariya Daivari vignette which aired before his “duel” with Jack Gallagher.

Footage was screened of Daivari’s defeat, alongside Drew Gulak and Tony Nese, at the hands of Cedric Alexander, Lince Dorado, and Rich Swann at October’s Hell In A Cell event. “I bring experience to the game,” remarked Daivari in the voiceover. We were somehow expected to take a man who lost a filler warm-up match before the event itself as a crafty, honed veteran. By that distorted metric, Pete Rose would be the bookmaker’s favourite if he were to wrestle a debuting Hiroshi Tanahashi at Royal Rumble 2017.

It was a total miscalculation - but creative had done such a poor job of establishing Daivari as an equal threat that it was probably an impossible task.


Ups...

4. Commentary Is Gathering Pace

Yurnet Ali
WWE.com

The commentary on 205 Live, specifically Austin Aries’ contributions, has been criticised within these write-ups in weeks gone by - but the three-man team was a welcome improvement last night.

While Aries is still a little too preoccupied with putting himself over - as the self-styled Greatest Man Who Ever Lived, that in fairness is probably his right - his sense of humour is slowly becoming more palatable as he develops hilarious chemistry with Corey Graves. When John Yurnet’s groin gave out in his match with Mustafa Ali, Aries suggested that it was made out of wood. “Maybe he’s a pirate?” he posited. Graves’ straight-laced response (“Potentially…”) was brilliant. It was as if he was giving serious consideration to a patently absurd notion.

Mauro Ranallo continued to bury puroresu-shaped Easter eggs in his commentary, by referencing the 1612 sword duel which inspired the longest and oddest match New Japan Pro Wrestling ever produced - the weird-but-not-wonderful rest hold exhibition that was Antonio Inoki and Masa Saito’s two hour-plus Ganryujima Island Death Match.

And, while Aries did bury one of the performers on commentary, it was funny enough to excuse it. “Don’t forget,” remarked Graves in the opener, “Alicia Fox is a celebrated in-ring competitor herself. She’s got some veteran knowledge to lend her boyfriend.” “Hahaha - that was a good one, Corey,” Aries deadpanned in response.


3. The Reorientation Of Mustafa Ali

Ali Yurnet
WWE.com

A more contentious ‘Up’, this, but the progressive chord WWE struck deafened the bizarre execution of it.

On the 13 December edition of 205 Live, Mustafa Ali was introduced as Muhammad Hassan 2.0, in that he chastised American fans for automatically receiving him as a heel before reinforcing that perception by performing like one. Billed from Pakistan, the implication was clear: Ali, of Middle Eastern descent, was fated to be a villain. Apparently, the expansive transcontinental region somehow falls under one sole bad moon.

On this week’s episode, however, Ali was billed from Chicago, Illinois, and was received with some fanfare by his notoriously loyal hometown crowd. His ensuing match, opposite John Yurnet, was compromised immediately. Yurnet suffered what must have been a legit groin pull. The segment was designed to put Ali over, and having a babyface beat a one-legged man in an a*se-kicking contest isn’t the way to do that.

To Yurnet’s credit, he fought through the pain barrier in a match most in the arena were willing to give the benefit of the doubt. His post-match interview was similarly shaky - but irrespective of politics, WWE’s decision to retcon Ali’s gimmick is a sound one. The Middle Eastern market is an untapped resource. Alienating it makes little business sense.


2. ...And Now For Something Completely Different

Jack Gallagher Umbrella
WWE.com

On Monday’s otherwise dire edition of RAW, Jack Gallagher challenged Ariya Daivari to a duel, slapping him across his beleaguered face with a leather glove.

Said duel took place on this week’s edition of 205 Live, and Gallagher carried the segment like the superstar-in-waiting he is. The most over 205 regular, the Chicago fans chanted “scoundrel!” at Daivari in much the same manner they used to call Vince McMahon an “a**hole”. The volume was very much lower in comparison, but Gallagher’s rise was as audible as it was entertaining.

Gallagher has been rewarded for his ingenuity in the character department; his is so unique, and so suited to the sports entertainment environment, that such a segment could not have been scripted for everybody else.

In it, Gallagher explained the rules he knew Daivari - being of Middle Eastern descent - was DNA-encoded to break. Anticipating the ruse with the wit required by a babyface to get over (take note, Cedric Alexander), Gallagher set upon Daivari with an umbrella (!), maximising his minutes by doing so in a gentlemanly manner, almost delicately trouncing him on the head with one hand stuck to his waist.

This was something entirely removed from the CWC - and, for once, all the better for it.


1. The Presentation Of Neville

Neville Swann 27
WWE.com

Neville is approaching the heights he literally ascended to in his awesome United States Title Open Challenge match against John Cena on the 11 May 2015 RAW, in which he only denied what looked like certain victory by an interfering Rusev.

Neville in spring 2015 was as relevant as he was exciting - and in just a matter of weeks, he has pushed himself at the forefront of the water cooler conversation. The presentation of the character is not without a few teething issues - his new anti-American slant is as derivative as it is pointless, in a division populated by babyfaces from Puerto Rico, England, Mexico, and Japan - but elsewhere, it has been pitched perfectly.

His mid-show sit down interview with Renee Young was something WWE should do more often. The contrived backstage skits do much to unravel suspension of disbelief - and Neville’s performance was totally credible, veering across a spectrum of bubbling menace and outright fury. It ended, with Young misunderstanding Neville’s “doddle” colloquialism, on a comedic note - and Neville used his newfound nationalist rage to inform the content of what was a gripping main event opposite Rich Swann.

His heel performance in that main event was similarly worthy of praise; decimating Swann’s back in the early going, the injury pervaded the narrative of a match in which every move struck mattered, and ebbed and flowed into the next. Swann’s selling was exquisite, Neville’s timing even better. It wasn’t perfect - Swann is yet another jobber champion, a trope which by design compromises the very narrative it generates - but it was awesome, regardless.

205 Live isn’t quite the most exciting hour of television, as per its marketing hype - but, much like Neville, it is gaining relevance by the week.


Contributor
Contributor

Michael Sidgwick (Creative Writing BA Hons) is an editor, writer and podcaster for WhatCulture Wrestling. With over a decade of experience in wrestling analysis, Michael was published in the influential UK institution that was Power Slam magazine, and specialises in providing insights into All Elite Wrestling - so much so that he wrote a book about the subject. You can order Becoming All Elite: The Rise Of AEW on Amazon. Possessing a deep knowledge also of WWE, WCW, ECW and New Japan Pro Wrestling, Michael’s work has been publicly praised by AEW World Champions Kenny Omega and MJF, and Undisputed WWE Champion Cody Rhodes. When he isn’t putting your finger on why things are the way they are in the endlessly fascinating world of professional wrestling, Michael wraps his own around a hand grinder to explore the world of specialty coffee. Follow Michael on X (formerly known as Twitter) @MSidgwick for more!