4 Ups & 3 Downs From WWE SmackDown (Feb 17)
Montreal blows Sami Zayn away; Bray Wyatt's WrestleMania challenge; WWE hypes Elimination Chamber.
It'd be impossible to give less of a toss about either cage bout heading into Elimination Chamber 2023.
WWE's focus has been elsewhere, and rightly so. Who cares about Austin Theory defending his United States Title or who Bianca Belair's WrestleMania challenger will be when Sami Zayn vs. Roman Reigns is on the card?! This pay-per-view is the prime example of a one match show, and everybody knows it.
Company creative knows it too, which is probs why they panic-booked some last-minute hype for one of Saturday's titular scraps on SmackDown. Did it work? Nah, not really, but WWE has bigger fish to fry anyway. Besides, Bray Wyatt just revealed his plans for 'Mania 39. Huh? Yep, that also happened on FOX.
This Roman Reigns-less episode lured fans in with the promise of a "banger" tag-team clash, another Intercontinental Title defence for GUNTHER, and a show-ending Sami love-in that almost reduced the man of the moment to tears.
It was a functional two hours of telly, but hardly a poor use of your time. Don't sleep on Smackers before watching Chamber, and here's why...
Downs...
3. Get Your Sh*t In. GO!
First though, some bad.
WWE relies too heavily on this kind of segment. You know the ones - everybody involved in an upcoming multi-person pay-per-view view match has to get their sh*t in as commentary stakes a claim for them winning. It's too formulaic, and it badly hurt Asuka vs. Liv Morgan this week.
Both women proper struggled to get going before everyone else interrupted the flow and gave them no chance. Carmella being out there on guest comms, and all the other Chamber match moving parts rushing out to steal spotlight, meant fans were constantly distracted throughout.
Special mention must go to how hard Liv has tanked since her SmackDown Women's Title reign last year too. It's almost like that run never happened, 'cause she's actually feeling like less of an ongoing concern than she was before WWE started that experiment.
2. A Failed Experiment
Speaking of failed experiments.
Right, so GUNTHER vs. Madcap Moss wasn't a bad match by any means. Sadly, despite both guys trying their best, the live crowd just didn't care about it. WWE can't blame anyone for that, because they elevated a cold character (Moss) into the title scene against a dominating champ (GUNTHER) without warning.
People watching knew Madcap didn't have a hope in hell of taking the Intercontinental prize here, so folks kinda yawned their way through the early exchanges waiting for GUNTHER to put him down. That, dear reader, is precisely the kind of situation WWE hopes to avoid with Sami Zayn challenging Roman Reigns at Elimination Chamber.
Again, not bad, but definitely the kind of title bout nobody will remember one week from now. This wasn't on par with GUNTHER's prior defences vs. the likes of Sheamus, Rey Mysterio or even Shinsuke Nakamura. Back to the drawing board for ol' Madcap.
1. Empty Threats
Karrion Kross insulting Rey Mysterio then telling him to do something about it would 100% mean more had Rey not thumped him in seven minutes on the 27 January episode. This backstage promo played out like WWE's writers had forgotten all about that, but the loss was such a misstep for Kross that it's hard to overlook.
Where is he going?
Karrion's previous rivalry with Drew McIntyre (and threats he made towards Roman) seemed to suggest that Triple H viewed him as a major player on Fridays. Everything about his booking since, including the stupid loss to Rey that has killed this feud stone dead, has suggested otherwise.
It's rather embarrassing that WWE has whiffed on this story whilst showing what's possible elsewhere. Being honest, it wasn't even a difficult one to tell - Kross should've been physically overwhelming for Rey, thus causing Mysterio to call on all of his experience to fight back.
Simple. Or not.
Ups...
4. Way Better Than Expected
Some might be shocked to see this get an 'Up'.
Everyone worked hard to make the opening women's tag better than it perhaps had any right to be though, and there's genuine chemistry between Ronda Rousey and Shayna Baszler that WWE better not spoil. Sure, it might've been better had they ripped through a random team like Natalya and Shotzi, but...yeah, about that.
It'd be silly to complain that women don't get enough time on these shows, then blast WWE higher-ups for giving a match like this some minutes to kick off SmackDown. Also, for what it's worth, the heels beating Shotzi rather than Nattie was the right call considering the veteran's involvement at Chamber.
Yours truly is willing to overlook some of the sloppier moments (they all came during the first half) and shower this match with some praise. It was a fairly solid start on the road towards surefire Women's Tag Title success for Ronda and Shayna.
3. Well, Nobody Saw That Coming!
Hats off to WWE, because nobody tuning in for SmackDown could've predicted that Bray Wyatt would challenge the winner of Brock Lesnar vs. Bobby Lashley. Honestly, did anybody see that coming before Friday night's delight? It's doubtful.
Bray vs. Brock at 'Mania does have a curious vibe to it, but it could be a disaster to mix supernatural silliness with Lesnar right now. Hey, at least this will get people talking if nothing else, and it does give Wyatt some purpose heading into the biggest show(s) of the entire year.
That's gotta count for something.
Bray, who was accompanied by 'Uncle Howdy', kicked lumps out of the failing Hit Row before revealing his WrestleMania 39 plans. The segment achieved what it set out to, and did add a fresh layer of intrigue to Wyatt's new alliance with 'Unc'.
2. Hot Tag-Team Action
Now for a prediction everyone had pre-SmackDown: Drew McIntyre vs. The Viking Raiders would be one of those "bangers" the hip and happening Michael Cole can't stop talking about. It was - the match smoothly sailed into 'must see' territory, and all four beat the crap out of one another.
Predictably excellent tag-team fare is always appreciated.
This fan wouldn't have been against WWE sticking the match on the card at Elimination Chamber, but it was a free TV gift to everybody watching. Drew and Sheamus work so well together, and The Raiders got their licks in too. Erick and Ivar, despite this defeat, will be fine after a few squash match wins soon.
As always, ad breaks did disrupt a lengthy match like this one, but that's obviously unavoidable and way less-annoying than AEW's dreaded picture-in-picture rubbish. At least the cuts were outright cuts, and you didn't get some tampon commercial hogging the screen as Sheamus thumped some chests.
1. Sami Zayn’s Fire
The love pro wrestling fans currently feel for one Sami Zayn is really heartwarming. Everyone's on board with his push, and there's real scope to continue his rise post-Elimination Chamber even after he loses to Roman Reigns. Oh, the 'Tribal Chief' wasn't on SmackDown this week, and his Bloodline was totally absent too.
This was all about Sami.
He was greeted like a cherished legend returning to WWE after years away. That'll only make it even more heartbreaking when he inevitably stares at the lights for Reigns, but Zayn showed tremendous fire during his promo, and it succeeded in painting him as the ultimate underdog against the peerless champion.
Giving Sami the mic, and letting him bask in adulation from the Canadian masses, was a fine way to close out the show and make the Chamber pay-per-view look like a bigger deal than PPV stops right before WrestleMania normally do.
What did you think of this week's WWE SmackDown? For more wrestling, check out WWE Elimination Chamber 2023: 10 Nightmares That Could Come True and WWE 2K23: 21 Wrestlers Making Their Series Debut!