4 Ups & 5 Downs From WWE SmackDown (Oct 22)

Brock Lesnar goes too far; SmackDown debuts reap mixed rewards; WWE's ending sucks.

Brock Lesnar Roman Reigns

WWE were keen to hammer home that the "new era of SmackDown" arrived on Friday night.

Fresh blood debuted, some familiar faces from Raw made an impact and a part-time attraction bowed out (at least for now). There's a massive problem with this "new era" claim every year though: WWE position the Draft right before Survivor Series, which sucks when that pay-per-view relies on brand vs. brand warfare.

So, in other words, the writing team are left scrambling to try and match up ill-fitting pieces. Suddenly, fans are told, workers who previously crowed about one brand are now loyal to another. That never makes sense, but it's just something everyone must deal with 'cause...it's October/November and Survivors is on the horizon.

This week's SmackDown suffered from that. On the plus side, WWE produced one of the hottest opening angles in recent memory, and creative did do a good job when introducing the show's next hot faction. It was nice to see the E keep things simple for the most part, but they really struggled with the inter-brand stuff.

Like, really struggled...


Downs...

5. Missed Opportunity?

New Day Xavier Woods Kofi Kingston King Of The Ring
WWE.com

First, a lil' missed opportunity.

The coronation skit for Xavier Woods was functional at best, but maybe could've done with some heel interference - a villainous ambush would've gone some way to showing where WWE want to go with 'King' Woods in the short-term. Instead, Kofi Kingston just kinda showered him with praise.

That was, without doubt, the most boring direction SmackDown's creative team could've taken. Why not launch Xavier into a full-blown singles feud, or use this as an excuse to get someone like Ridge Holland over as an emerging threat? This whole segment achieved next-to-nothing.

One must question the boldness of presenting Xavier as SmackDown's third 'King' in 2021 too. He follows Baron Corbin and Shinsuke Nakamura in that role, and that could be a step too far for the gimmick. WWE need to come up with better things than this if he's going to thrive.


4. You’ve Got 30 Seconds Each. GO!

Ridge Holland WWE SmackDown
WWE

There were good debuts on this week's SmackDown (more on that later), but poor Ridge Holland, Aliyah, the team of Angel Garza and Humberto Carrillo, and Sheamus had to exist on the opposite end of the scale. Their brief intros, which were admittedly more important for the proper newcomers, lacked sparkle.

15-30 seconds just doesn't count as character development.

Holland said he belonged on SmackDown. Great? Aliyah promised to give it a makeover. What does that even mean? Garza and Carrillo said they were handsome. OK? Sheamus said he delivers great match after great match. Wow? Yeah, these promos were hardly thrilling.

That's not a dig at the performers themselves - they didn't have any time to explain their goals here. This is why it might've been better to have Ridge attack 'King' Woods, or to see Aliyah thrust her name into the Women's Title picture.


3. This Again?

Shinsuke Nakamura Happy Corbin
WWE.com

How many times is this match going to happen?!

Despite having obvious chemistry together, Shinsuke Nakamura and Happy Corbin have nothing new going on. They literally just finished feuding over the 'King' gimmick during the summer, and that's why it felt lazy to stick them back in the ring again for another go-around in October.

Someone on WWE's writing staff clearly thinks there's value in Naka and Rick Boogs vs. Corbin and Madcap Moss. Is there? Is there though? Unless one (or both) of those squads is about to become full-time tags and go after The Usos, then a series of matches like that will accomplish sod all.

Worse, Shin's up and down booking continues. He's a utility man, sure, but he's also been toiling big time since handing over the 'King' gimmick without protest. Losing to Corbin, who is also working with scraps to keep this Happy business afloat, won't help him.


2. A Nothing Rematch

Mansoor Mustafa Ali
WWE.com

Xavier Woods' coronation was pointless, and so was Nakamura vs. Corbin. This, however, earned the crown for 'Most Aimless Match' on this week's show. Honestly, why was Mansoor vs. Mustafa Ali II booked so soon after their clash at Crown Jewel in Saudi Arabia?

Why was it booked at all, actually?

The pair were handed less than three minutes to get their sh*t in, and the match didn't really do anything to further the story they've been telling. In essence, it existed to fill up a few minutes of air time and that's all. This is why some of these dudes find it hard to get over and connect to crowds.

It was bad enough that WWE lumped Mansoor and Ali together as a 'creative has nothing for you individually' tag on Raw. It was worse that they then failed to develop them before Ali turned. Now, they're being placed in an endless run of short matches.


1. The Title Swap Ending

Becky Lynch Charlotte Flair Sonya Deville
WWE.com

SmackDown's ending flat out sucked.

The fact that WWE chose to close the show with that title swap business at all must be questioned. There was no real drama beforehand, because everybody knew this was only going to end one way. Plus, creative just dumped on their own 'Champ vs. Champ' hook for Survivor Series.

Becky Lynch, a known bad ass, willingly gave up her SmackDown Women's Title in exchange for the Raw prize. Meanwhile, Charlotte Flair (a known belt hoarder), ditched the red version for blue. That's enough to drive anybody who tries to give a toss about these championships absolutely mad.

Yes, Sasha Banks challenging Flair will lead to fun matches. No, that does no excuse the crappy formatting from WWE in the lead up to the Draft. If they knew that Becks and Flair would be switching shows, then why put titles on them at all?

Maddening.


Ups...

4. Reinforcing Drew McIntyre

Sami Zayn Drew McIntyre
WWE.com

Drew McIntyre calling out the entire SmackDown locker room is exactly the kind of thing an alpha male looking to make his mark would do. This wasn't out-of-character for the Scotsman either; he's been a fighter since those WWE Title days on Raw, and he does a neat job of staying babyface even when arrogantly stomping around.

Sami Zayn was the right opponent for Drew too. Beating someone so delusional and so easy-to-dislike represented a strong start for McIntyre on Fridays. A few more of these and he'll be ready to challenge Roman Reigns for the Universal Title once WWE powers past Survivor Series.

Drew even got to reinforce his workhorse mindset by making light of SmackDown's promo-heavy open. He pointed out that the show was almost 40 minutes deep before fans got to see any actual wrestling, and that made him look like a man of the people.

Big well done to everyone involved for this re-debut.


3. The Perfect Debut

Hit Row WWE SmackDown
WWE

It still wasn't SmackDown's best.

Hit Row take that trophy home. Sure, their material is cheesier than cheddar and everyone could do without Michael Cole checking thesaurus.com for adjectives, but their SmackDown intro was well-produced. Every member got some mic time, then they squashed some local jobbers.

The best thing about this short entry point was that Hit Row never outstayed their welcome. They also all came across as stars right out of the gate - compare this to the meagre amount of screen time others (like Ridge Holland and Aliyah) got and it's night and day.

Fans didn't pop like they were seeing the second coming here or anything, but Hit Row's first showing didn't play before silence. That'll be encouraging to those who matter behind the scenes, and it should give the group a fighting chance to become SmackDown stalwarts.


2. Scared Paul Heyman Is Scared

Roman Reigns Paul Heyman
WWE.com

The way Roman Reigns toyed with Paul Heyman during SmackDown's early minutes was majestic. Credit must also go to Paul E for playing the coward who's deathly afraid of losing his meal ticket so well. He shamelessly ass-kisses where appropriate, and beams with pride when Reigns hypes himself up.

Yeah, this was awesome. That's nothing new for these guys though.

Roman referenced events at Crown Jewel by asking if Heyman wanted to rehearse and try handing him the Universal Title again. That tiny insert expertly discussed Paul chucking the belt into the ring over in Saudi without over-egging things, and it let Heyman play the sycophant yet again.

Some may not like that SmackDown's opening promo run lasted anywhere between 30-40 minutes, but damn...it was good stuff. This wasn't some time-wasting failed experiment. It was more stunning build for Roman and Heyman as characters.

Then, all hell broke loose...


1. Brock Lesnar Destroys Everyone

Brock Lesnar Adam Pearce
WWE.com

Brock Lesnar destroyed everything in his path.

This is the unhinged 'Beast' that he does so well. Seeing Brock rampage out to take down Roman as promised, then fend off The Usos as Heyman looked horrified just worked. Not even WWE's usual procession of unimportant lower-card wrestlers could turn this into a stock beatdown bit.

Lesnar was ferocious, then turned things up a notch when Adam Pearce kayfabe suspended him for "endangering" everyone (including the fans). Does it make much sense that Pearce suspended Brock for doing something so many stars get away with weekly? No, not really, but his call did make the scene more dramatic and newsworthy.

Every wrestling TV show needs at least one major event. It could be an excellent match, it could be a killer promo, or it could be Brock freakin' Lesnar tearing strips off everyone who crosses him. This was a textbook example of how to write a major star off TV for the next couple of months.

What did you think of this week's WWE SmackDown? For more like this, check out 5 Ups & 3 Downs From WWE SmackDown (Oct 15) and WWE Crown Jewel 2021: 35 Things You Probably Missed!


Contributor

Lifelong wrestling, video game, music and sports obsessive who has been writing about his passions since childhood. Jamie started writing for WhatCulture in 2013, and has contributed thousands of articles and YouTube videos since then. He cut his teeth penning published pieces for top UK and European wrestling read Fighting Spirit Magazine (FSM), and also has extensive experience working within the wrestling biz as a manager and commentator for promotions like ICW on WWE Network and WCPW/Defiant since 2010. Further, Jamie also hosted the old Ministry Of Slam podcast, and has interviewed everyone from Steve Austin and Shawn Michaels to Bret Hart and Trish Stratus.