4 Ups And 4 Downs From NXT UK TakeOver: Cardiff
A surprisingly superb show from Wales - but did anyone even watch it?
When WWE announced that NXT UK would be coming to Cardiff on 31 August - coincidentally the same date as both New Japan's Royal Quest show in the country, and hours ahead of AEW's huge All Out event - it garnered widespread titters around the wrestling commentariat.
Did the company seriously think that a Welsh-themed edition of their least followed brand was adequate competition for NJPW bringing their absolute best to London's Copper Box Arena on the same date? According to a company spy at the arena, the answer was 'yes'. Indications suggested their cross-Pacific rivals were struggling to shift tickets, hence the ballsy decision to go head-to-head.
Turned out, their spy was wrong. By their own making, WWE had stupidly set their second NXT UK TakeOver up to fail.
On the night, it did anything but. Not only was the Cardiff International Arena full to the brim in spite of the competition down south - helped no doubt by the late announcement of Cesaro's involvement - but the content presented more than delivered. We saw a stunning title switch, a wonderful cameo, and a main event which, whilst maybe not quite as brilliant as early reactions suggest, was one of the finest WWE matches of the year.
If only it'd been on a different day, eh?
Downs...
4. An Underwhelming Setting
It might seem like an excessively superficial criticism, but Cardiff's International Arena (for commercial reasons, known elsewhere as the Motorpoint Arena) evinced none of the opulence of NXT UK's first TakeOver special emanating from Blackpool's prestigious Empress Ballroom.
Admittedly, few wrestling venues can compete with the historic Winter Gardens location, but as a follow-up, Cardiff's attempt was so relatively spartan as to seem penurious. The darkened arena might be in keeping with NXT's general aesthetic, but here came across like a glorified house-show rather than a TakeOver special. WWE can only work with what they have, but they seemed to put in the least effort possible to make the Wales show an occasion. Where were all the dragons?!
3. Cold Coffey
How could Dave Mastiff and Joe Coffey follow the sheer euphoria that was Flash Morgan Webster and Mark Andrews crowning themselves WWE's first-ever Welsh champions before an adoring crowd? The answer was not particularly brilliantly - though not particularly terribly, either.
Last-man standing contests are laborious affairs at the best of times, but with the Motorpoint Arena notably drained, it took a while for two of NXT UK's slowest men to build any sort of momentum. There was an injection of excitement early on when Mastiff, dressed like a Butlins' Vader, launched Coffey into the turnbuckle, causing it to dramatically dislodge (obviously gimmicked during the lengthy interval; this is WWE afterall) but things soon devolved into disconnected destruction.
"This is getting hard to watch," opined McGuinness, as the match continued as an unfocused series of weapon shots. Eventually, things migrated to the pre-show area, where the two men very obviously telegraphed that they'd take a tumble. A Premier League style headbutt - ie, weak as p*ss - pushed them over the edge, and it came to an underwhelming conclusion when Coffey kicked a travelling case out from under Mastiff to keep him down for the count. Most people in attendance were caught entirely cold by it.
2. The Calm During The Storm
When Kay Lee Ray hit a second Gory Bomb on NXT UK Women's Champion Toni Storm to capture the Aussie's belt, it practically played out before crickets.
The match had only been going for the better part of ten minutes when the Scot ended Storm's 231 day grip on the title - an underwhelming apotheosis if ever there was one. The action leading up to that point had done nothing to draw in the audience, perhaps burned out thanks to the show front-loading all its biggest pops.
The incumbent champ unloaded on Ray with intensity to begin with, but the story of the challenger psychologically unnerving her opponent wasn't adequately conveyed. Storm's enthusiasm merely came across as naivety - not exactly befitting a long-term champ. If this defeat presages a call-up to NXT proper or even the main roster, it's a very peculiar way to write her exit.
1. Will Anyone Care?
Ultimately, NXT UK: TakeOver Cardiff was always going to struggle as, if you'll excuse the casual misogyny of this analogy, the ugliest of three suitors vying to dance at this weekend's ludicrously stacked wrestling ball.
Competing against NJPW's Royal Quest and AEW's All Out later in the night, it's eminently understandable if overwhelmed wrestling fans opted to skip what was inarguably the least relevant of the fare on offer. Given how superb the show was, minus a slight lull prior to the main event, it's a bit of a shame. Unless Royal Quest's streaming issues forced disgruntled viewers to switch over, it's likely the majority missed Cesaro's superb flying visit, and a magnificent main event. What a waste.
Ups...
4. A Buzzing Curtain-Raiser
Although nothing exceptional, the WWE's first PPV visit to Wales proper opened in very promising fashion, as Noam Dar dispatched Kiwi Buzzsaw Travis Banks to mark his first big show match since Extreme Rules 2017 (a defeat alongside Alicia Fox to Rich Swann and Sasha Banks, would you believe).
Broadly typical of its bigger NXT cousin's usual opening fare sans stakes, Banks and Dar put on fast and furious affair that was mindful not to steal the show early given what was to come both immediately, and later. Bang tidy.
3. Welsh Wizards Cast Magic
The Cardiff crowd was naturally 100% behind local heroes Mark Andrews and Flash Morgan Webster in the tag team triple threat for NXT UK's doubles straps, and the Cymric couple absolutely fed off arguably the most fervent crowd they've ever performed in front of.
As utterly abysmal as FMW's tights were - he looked like a stick of Brighton rock - it wasn't reflected in his performance, or that of his partner. The occasion got the better of the two at times, as their multiple spots frequently suffered from sloppiness, but for the most part this simply translated as excitement rather than incompetence. The crowd certainly didn't care; a double moonsault had them on their feet, and they stayed there for every subsequent bit of aerial magic from the Welsh wizards.
Only the mistiming and general untidiness of Wolfgang and Mark Coffey threatened to derail the match's momentum, but it found its way again once Gallus were effectively written out of proceedings. A closing sequence with two dramatic near-falls and a wonderful ref pull ratcheted up the tension, before the lengthy contest finally concluded with the correct result. The ovation which followed was one of pure elation, a sense of raucous pride which could have been heard right around the capital.
2. A Swiss Superhero
As could reasonably have been predicted ahead of time, the Swiss Superman's cameo in Cardiff stole the show. Despite nominally playing heel, the migrating Cesaro was always going to inspire an absolutely electric response from the Welsh crowd, and so it transpired when he emerged as Ilja Dragunov's opponent for the night's second match.
The fan fervour wasn't predicated simply on the Raw star slumming it for a night, however. The Swiss and the Czar shared an absolutely superb singles contest, which saw a superman swing for the ages of over 40 rotations (prompting Nigel McGuinness to quip that he didn't know the Welsh could count so high), and a vicious GTS from Cesaro, instigating the now customary "Are you watching Vince McMahon?" chants.
Obviously, the main roster man got the victory, catching Dragunov with his patented European Uppercut/Neutraliser combo. The young German lost nothing in defeat, and was given the natural leg-up from his opponent with a respectful post-match handshake. Cesaro came off like an absolutely superstar here - though he would within such a setting.
1. Bate Is Unabated
If anyone could reinvigorate the flagging crowd for the main event, it was Walter and Tyler Bate.
Whilst not exactly the match of the decade, the NXT UK Championship war re-confirmed the Austrian and the Brummie as the true stars of the brand (in as much as that means anything).
Walter began in typically methodical fashion, as he looked to wear Bate down before the challenger could even get going. Obviously, it was never going to end as simply as that. The impetuousness of the former champion soon shone through, as the match became a story of Walter's brutish resistance in the face of Bate's indefatigable fire.
The beast was repeatedly prodded: a little kick into Walter's back from the mat gave rise to a furious series of chops. Again, Bate ducked out, and it was only through fortune that the dumbfounded Imperium man landed on his nibbling foe's back.
Bate was unabated, as it were. A finger snap on the top rope opened the door for an enormous superplex. Not enough. Nor was the Tiger Driver '97.
But still he wouldn't give in. When the Austrian caught Tyler with a murderous snap suplex on the apron, that seemed that - especially when it was followed up by a similarly enormous splash. Nope.
Bate. Would. Not. Quit.
A powerbomb couldn't do it either. In echoes of Shawn Michaels' original last match, Bate crawled up Walter's midsection, practically begging him: give me what you got. So he did. A huge lariat finally ended things, and Walter remained champion.
Gosh.