5 Biggest Winners & Losers From AEW In 2024
Who in AEW is walking out of 2024 having had a great year, and which ones were more of a bust?
Everyone has ups and downs throughout any given year, and that applies not just to the WWE roster, but to those in All Elite Wrestling as well. For every massive victory someone has, another person as to be the one to take the pin or move further down the totem pole.
AEW itself had its fair share of wins and losses as a company, and that trickled down toward some of its performers, as a result. It was far from a year of pure positives or negatives.
In some cases, wrestlers soared to new heights and became major fixtures of the company for what feels like years to come, really cementing their status as talent to watch by winning championships in the main event of major shows or taking a huge amount of the spotlight for themselves. Others fell by the wayside, downgraded, spent most of the year failing, and have almost nothing to show for the past 12 months but injuries, gimmick problems, or staring up at the lights more days than not.
Whether for better or worse, let's take a look at some of the biggest winners and losers AEW had to offer in 2024.
10. Winners: Jon Moxley and The Death Riders
In case of emergency, break glass and put the title on Jon Moxley. That's been the go-to action for AEW over the years, and he never fails.
When The Elite takeover storyline flopped and the biggest angle in the company just wasn't working out, AEW pivoted, turned Blackpool Combat Club heel, excommunicated Bryan Danielson, tossed PAC and Marina Shafir in the mix, and the Death Riders rebranding has worked significantly better.
Moxley in particular seems more dangerous than ever and has given the roster a centralized top villain to go after, which should also be a huge factor in 2025 when someone (likely Darby Allin) is able to overthrow his tyrannical reign and restore some stability to the company.
In the meantime, Moxley continues to ride the wave of being the only four time champion in AEW history—double the next-highest with CM Punk's two quick reigns—and has more than cemented himself as the franchise player of AEW.
Thankfully, he's also using that clout and aura to give a boost to someone like Wheeler Yuta, who is also coming into his own even more this year. PAC is more dangerous than ever, Shafir isn't a joke anymore, and Castagnoli holds down the fort.
9. Losers: Best Friends
It's been a terrible year for the extended group of Best Friends, as 2024 featured the piece-by-piece dismantling of this unit across the board.
Chuck Taylor suffered a foot injury in October 2023 that kept him out of action for a few months. By April, Trent Beretta and Orange Cassidy came up short in a tournament to crown the new tag team champions, and Trent decided to attack Cassidy, causing a huge rift.
Trent eventually beat Taylor in a Parking Lot Brawl, which would serve as Taylor's retirement match due to osteonecrosis from his prior injury.
Trent lost several times to Cassidy before joining The Don Callis Family, but before he could get the ball rolling on that push, had to be written off television to undergo neck surgery.
Cassidy was also turned on from Kris Statlander, who would also turn on another Best Friends ally and her closest partner, Willow Nightingale.
Only Cassidy and Nightingale have received sustained pushes and achieved accomplishments this year, while the rest have suffered many losses amid the dissolution of AEW's most positive, care-free group, who had spent this year duking it out instead of hugging it out.
8. Winner: Will Ospreay
Will Ospreay was turning heads in AEW before he was even officially signed to the company, but once he became a legitimate member of the roster in 2024, it was all systems go.
He was welcomed as one of the biggest signings in AEW history and immediately thrust into a prominent spot, defeating Konosuke Takeshita, Kyle Fletcher, and Powerhouse Hobbs to establish himself as the golden child of The Don Callis Family—something that, upon him leaving the group, has hurt Callis so badly that they have a major vendetta against him.
Within just over two months, after scoring other massive victories over people like Bryan Danielson and a Casino Gauntlet, Ospreay beat Roderick Strong to capture the International Championship, which he would win a second time later in the year in a big moment at AEW All In: London.
Ospreay has been hailed as not only arguably the best in-ring performer in the company, but one of the top stars to build around for the future, as well as one of the few faces of this new era leading the charge to "restore the feeling" of what AEW once was and can be going forward.
7. Loser: Chris Jericho
How can Chris Jericho—one of the best of all time and a bona fide Hall of Famer who even won two titles this year and is the reigning top champion of Ring of Honor—earn a spot on this list? By having a full year of nothing but less successful repeats of things he's already done in AEW.
Given his musical career with Fozzy, Jericho won't appreciate this comparison, but his 2024 was less of a greatest hits compilation and more of an equivalent to when you go to a concert and hear the classics, but the singer can't hit the high notes anymore and you'd have been better off with a cover band doing their own spin on those songs you love.
I say this as someone who actually finds some aspects of The Learning Tree fun, but it's impossible to deny it's just a rehash of The Jericho Appreciation Society.
He feuded with Orange Cassidy over a coat that was destroyed four years ago. That spot with The Conglomeration dumping change on Jericho's Bentley was a dud facsimile of better car spots done nearly 30 years ago.
The angle with mentoring Hook, being The Nueve instead of The Ocho, and everything else was just a rerun, and if Jericho's best he has to offer these days is already copying his shtick in just five years, maybe he's been sipping a little bit too much of the bubbly.
6. Winner: Swerve Strickland
Alongside Will Ospreay, another star of this current era in AEW who had a fantastic 2024 is Swerve Strickland, who boasts not only a 29-4 win-loss record this year, but achieved the biggest highlight of his career when he defeated Samoa Joe at AEW Dynasty in April to win the AEW World Championship.
Having been viewed in NXT and on WWE SmackDown as a talent with a lot of potential, but stuck in the midcard title hunt at best, Swerve leaving for AEW in 2022 wasn't particularly shocking. But for those first two years, it seemed he might not be able to escape that misfortune, as he was lingering in the same spot.
In 2023, he was building steam for a breakout year, to the point that he was undeniable as the obvious pick for AEW's first black world champion.
Swerve held the title for a respectable 126 days—the sixth-longest reign so far—and only lost it to Bryan Danielson of all people, which is far from a burial by any means.
Strickland's feuds with "Hangman" Adam Page and now The Hurt Syndicate have also been highlights of this year, with his Lights Out Steel Cage match being one of the year's most interesting fights, and he was captain of Team AEW in Blood & Guts to show that this is truly Swerve's house.
5. Loser: Kamille
Kamille left NWA as the undisputed top woman in the company, ready to take the next big step of her career by moving on to more of the major leagues, only for 2024 to turn into an absolute bust for her.
For months after her signing, she just wasn't around in any capacity, only for the wait to lead to the most generic placement as Mercedes Moné's bodyguard. That is among the easiest layups in wrestling storytelling, as it is an incredibly simple formula that is hard to mess up, but they did.
All she had to do was be physically imposing, beat people up, win matches, and eventually turn on Moné. Instead, she quickly lost her mystique by losing her sixth match just to put over Kris Statlander, who didn't even beat Moné to make it worthwhile.
This felt like Tony Khan wanted to skip through the building up process and go straight to the end of the story, but since Kamille and Moné never had any real chemistry and it was all rushed, there's no clamoring for this to become a feud.
Instead of fans chomping at the bit to see Kamille return from her "injury" to beat up The CEO, the growing consensus among pundits is that she may not even return at all, and that it would be for the better.
4. Winner: Mercedes Moné
Yours truly is not a fan, at all, of what Mercedes Moné has been doing in AEW. From my point of view, she's had overrated matches, her character is a worse version of what Sasha Banks was in WWE, her promos have been flat and her "CEO" theme is the worst in the company.
But if I separate myself from the situation and take my personal opinions out of the mix, then even I have to admit that she's been successful in many of the ways that she likely would tout as her goals.
Mercedes came into All Elite Wrestling with a ton of fanfare as the biggest signing they could possibly get. She's been treated like a mega star ever since.
Somehow, she has been positioned as so big, in fact, that holding the midcard TBS Championship has taken priority over the AEW Women's World Championship. If you didn't see which belt she or Mariah May were holding, you'd assume Moné was the top woman on the roster.
By all accounts, Moné is making a ton of money, holding multiple titles, is enjoying herself, and is being praised to the heavens as the most viable asset. You can't look at that and see that as a failure.
3. Losers: The Butcher, Matt Sydal, Aaron Solo, Iron Savages and the Zero Wins Club
If you're running a pure numbers game, there are 201 people who have a 100 percent failure rate in 2024, having lost every single one of their matches in AEW this year.
Granted, a good amount of them are enhancement talent no one could remember the names of, but some people like Iron Savages (Boulder and Bronson), Aaron Solo, AR Fox, and Jon Cruz are employed at this point just to strictly be losers.
The worst record goes to The Butcher with 19 losses, while Matt Sydal (14), and Robyn Renegade (11) aren't too far away from him.
Not too far off from this list is Harley Cameron at a 95 percent loss, only winning 1 out of 20 matches, but she's super entertaining and isn't meant to be taken seriously. Someone like Kip Sabian, at one point, wasn't a total jobber, but has firmly become one this year.
Even someone like Saraya has had a terrible year with 8 losses and 3 wins, after winning the AEW Women's World Championship in 2023, for a massive decline, but that's still a much better overall record than someone like Solo, whose highlight in 2024 was being quickly taken out by "Big Boom" AJ at AEW Full Gear, of all things.
2. Winner: Bryan Danielson and Honorable Mentions
Rounding out the list of top winners this year is Bryan Danielson, who finally ascended the throne and defeated Swerve Strickland at the biggest show of the year, AEW All In: London, to win the AEW World Championship.
He didn't have the longest reign with the belt, but he etched his name in the history books, got to wrestle his close friend Nigel McGuinness (who himself is worth mentioning for finally stepping back in the ring and getting a retirement-worthy match against Danielson), and was able to put over the new Death Riders angle in a way to really kick off that faction's heat.
If his downer of an exit is too depressing for you, some other honorable mentions worth suggesting for this list could be:
Christian Cage for his overall promo skills and winning what could be a future AEW World Championship once he cashes in his contract.
Kazuchika Okada and Jack Perry for winning the AEW Continental and TNT Championships respectively.
Konosuke Takeshita for winning the AEW International Championship.
Mariah May for being the champion and top focal point in the women's division save for Mercedes Moné.
Darby Allin for his involvement in Sting's retirement and being an overall MVP of the roster.
And lastly, Kyle Fletcher for leveling up considerably and currently leading the Continental Classic leader board.
1. Losers: Ricky Starks and Honorable Mentions
Finishing out the biggest losers list could be any number of wrestlers who were let go from AEW or were missing in action for the bulk of the year.
In particular, Ricky Starks is one of the most annoying examples of this, as he started off 2024 holding the tag team titles alongside Big Bill, who went on to become the right-hand man of Chris Jericho in The Learning Tree, while Starks has sat at home doing absolutely nothing. By all context clues, it appears Starks wants to leave All Elite Wrestling, but Tony Khan is forcing him to sit out his contract purely out of spite.
That is something that Khan previously acted above, as if he wouldn't do what WWE has done in the past, but is also doing to The Lucha Bros, as Rey Fenix lashes out on social media about his "inhumane treatment" in AEW, watching the clock and waiting to join Penta El Zero Miedo under Paul Levesque's regime.
Out of sight, out of mind, and while some wrestlers may enjoy the time off being paid to do nothing, others are clearly itching to move on, but are stuck in limbo, achieving nothing this whole year but grief and aggravation.