5 Stupidest Questions Wrestling Fans Get Asked

It's still not real to me either, dammit!

What Do You Watch Wrestling For
WWE.com

The life of a wrestling fan is almost as painful as it must be for wrestlers themselves.

Even more so than fantasy fiction or sci-fi cinema, a special type of scorn is reserved for grapple fans. It doesn't take someone with the intellectual gifts of Damien Sandow to work out what will appear as the last entry on this list, but it's not just the fake predetermined nature of wrestling which non-fans take umbrage with.

As Paul Heyman once said, you either get it or you don't - but that isn't enough to satisfy incredulous non-fans, who seem to have as much difficulty comprehending our choice of hobby as they would solving the chalkboard equation from Good Will Hunting.

Wrestling, in essence, is very easy to grasp. A good guy and a bad guy resolve a storyline conflict through simulated combat. That's effectively it. Yet, the very same people who will happily accept that there are in fact monsters under your bed and superheroes soaring through the skies will for some reason reject the notion that something like the ankle lock wouldn't inflict excruciating pain.

This list probably won't stop their interrogations - but it might help you answer them.

5. How Many Undertakers Have There Been?

The Undertaker Mask 1995
WWE.com

This one is more likely to be posed from a lapsed fan - or at least somebody with a passing familiarity of the business. It's unlikely that they're referring to the diabolical SummerSlam 1994 headliner, in any event.

The Undertaker, despite playing a fictional character, has had the temerity to age and adjust his wardrobe over the years. He is, inarguably, one of wrestling's best ever workers - so much so that he appears to have convinced some that his physical transformations have been literal.

It's difficult to see the logic here. It's as if 'Taker's eschewal of the red rimmed eyes look and the pancake foundation brush is enough to convince some that he went a bit too far and scrubbed off his real face.

To this day, many are also convinced that the Ultimate Warrior was portrayed by another individual at WrestleMania VIII. He looked noticeably different (the impending steroid scandal saw him lose some of his artificial muscle mass) but it was clearly still Jim Hellwig under the facepaint and neon threads.

Wrestling fans are often considered to be fairly dense, yet those who ask this question are entirely ignorant to such concepts as ageing and character development.

"That can't be the real Undertaker - he's gradually lost his hair over a sustained period of time!"


4. Are You Gay?

Billy and Chuck, just a couple of buff dudes in bandannas and what?
WWE.com

Apparently, some find the idea of scantily-clad, oiled-up and supremely muscled men rolling around with one another on a mat to be slightly homoerotic. All wrestling enthusiasts must therefore be latent homosexuals who watch the product purely as a means of fulfilling their hidden desires.

This argument is ridiculous in itself but, moreover, wrestling is considered by many to be the lamest geek interest of all. If you were struggling with your sexuality - so much so that you felt shamed into hiding it - why would you then readily admit to enjoying something which is equally sneered at?

What non-fans don't know is that pro wrestling is, in reality, an uncomfortably regressive arm of the entertainment industry.

Gorgeous George pioneered the art of cheap heat with his effeminate posturing and predatory behaviour in the 1940s - wrestling prior to that was entirely straight-laced, no pun intended - but the industry never accepted homosexuality, even to the limited extent seen in wider society.

Goldust in the 1990s would also psychologically torture his heroic, straight opponents by molesting them with his unwelcome advances. Billy & Chuck infamously renounced their standing as open homosexuals to an eextent that was designed to be comedic. Both Kanyon and Orlando Jordan pitched sympathetic homosexual characters who weren't defined judgementally by their sexuality, but WWE refused to sanction the proposed gimmick shifts.

The irony is that we're meant to be the backwards idiots for enjoying wrestling - but it is non-fans who associate it, with an upsetting degree of ridicule, with an entirely natural sexual orientation.


3. What Do You Watch Wrestling For?

Balor Nakamura Kinshasa
WWE.com

Is there any other response than "Because I like it?".

It's easy enough to explain. Wrestling is probably the most unique form of entertainment on the planet; a beguiling fusion of sport and theatre, the sleight of hand aspect, when performed to the highest standard, is as impressive as that of even the most skilled magician.

The promos, boasts and insults are more entertaining than those seen in cricket* or boxing. The backstage machinations of the industry are almost objectively fascinating. The reasoning for Vince McMahon's sabotage of the ECWCW Invasion angle - one which conceivably could have made him several hundreds of millions of dollars better off, year after year - is the consummate example of how ego and pride can often obscure the very reason the industry exists.

And, with all due respect to Kenny Loggins, one of life's simple joys isn't playing with the boys - it's watching Shinsuke Nakamura kick somebody full force in the face.

In future, when asked the asinine question, just go with "IT DOESN'T MATTER WHAT I WATCH WRESTLING FOR!" - or question why superhero films are somehow exempt from such scrutiny despite being patently more ridiculous.

Two human men simulating combat is ludicrous... but possessing a star in one's head is credible.

*Perhaps not cricket. When asked why he was so fat by a sledging Glen McGrath, Zimbabwean batsman Eddo Brandes replied "because every time I f*ck your wife, she gives me a biscuit". Ric Flair would have been proud of that one.


2. Isn't Wrestling For Kids?

bray wyatt kid
WWE.com

Wrestling is meant to be for children, according to many, who by extension must think that it is acceptable to teach that the best form of conflict resolution is through cracking somebody in the spine with a steel chair.

Wrestling is an incredibly diverse form of entertainment, and this question merely exposes the ignorance of those posing it - and we're the ones who are meant to be stupid.

Even when directly targeted towards the family audience, wrestling can be enjoyed by everybody. Saturday Morning Slam contained within it incredible ingenuity given the restrictions imposed on the talent. CHIKARA, meanwhile, is unashamedly PG, but is so creative and fun that there is no need for the weapons and blood that have made countless shows and matches decidedly unsuitable for innocent eyes.

The demarkation between demographics isn't just marked by barbed wire. At its best, the storytelling craft within pro wrestling is as layered and rewarding as other forms of entertainment which are deemed as "acceptable".

A young fan might enjoy something like the recent Sami Zayn vs. Kevin Owens series for its flashy moves and the former's brilliant portrayal of an underdog, but an older and more informed fan can better appreciate its epic backstory and the way in which the matches are structured and subverted to recall it.

The Pixar films and The Simpsons are routinely and heavily praised for their ability to transcend age barriers, yet wrestling is rarely if ever given credit for its longevity and diversity.


1. You Do You Know It's Fake, Don't You?

Kane Great Khali WrestleMania 23
WWE.com

Yes, we do. Nobody over the age of seven years old has believed wrestling to be real since the late 1980s.

It's difficult to determine from where this line of enquiry originates. Wrestling is patently predetermined, but so by definition is every other form of fiction. It may have something to do with the way in which it is filmed.

WWE in particular has long since given up on the idea of presenting wrestling as a form of legitimate competition - so much so that they notoriously failed in their attempts to rename it sports entertainment - but they still tape it live on front of an arena audience.

Perhaps people find it difficult to reconcile the live environment with the scripted content. It's not as if the theatre has been in existence for several centuries, after all. Watching a movie being filmed on the set must be a similarly jarring experience, yet it is easy enough to suspend disbelief once the reel has been spliced up in the editing suite. We shouldn't be decried as idiots for having superior imaginations.

Wrestling fans are often told that they should "graduate" to UFC, which is insulting. MMA is an entity unto itself, but the vague similarities - they're surrounded by a cage, but actually hit one another! - are enough for the non-fan to act condescending despite being hugely ill-informed.

It's fake - not fixed - but the clever sh*tes, ironically, are the ones unable to tell the difference.


Contributor
Contributor

Michael Sidgwick (Creative Writing BA Hons) is an editor, writer and podcaster for WhatCulture Wrestling. With over a decade of experience in wrestling analysis, Michael was published in the influential UK institution that was Power Slam magazine, and specialises in providing insights into All Elite Wrestling - so much so that he wrote a book about the subject. You can order Becoming All Elite: The Rise Of AEW on Amazon. Possessing a deep knowledge also of WWE, WCW, ECW and New Japan Pro Wrestling, Michael’s work has been publicly praised by AEW World Champions Kenny Omega and MJF, and Undisputed WWE Champion Cody Rhodes. When he isn’t putting your finger on why things are the way they are in the endlessly fascinating world of professional wrestling, Michael wraps his own around a hand grinder to explore the world of specialty coffee. Follow Michael on X (formerly known as Twitter) @MSidgwick for more!