5 Things WWE Cinematic Matches Should NOT Do (And 5 Things They SHOULD Do)

It's a thing now. Better run with it.

OTIS HEYMAN Thumb
WWE

Cinematic matches continue to polarise. Some are entertaining, and some are a mess. In the space of just four months, they have become entrenched in WWE programming, irrespective of ongoing popular reaction. A gut response to this might be 'ditch them and never look back', but it may also be worth breaking this situation down and looking a little bit deeper.

Let's at least appreciate that this is an offshoot of the current global situation, so it's fair to give the creators credit for trying to entertain in bleak times. Yet at the same time, cinematic matches run the risk of fully deterring audiences amidst already dwindling viewing figures. It's a tough balance.

So can WWE afford to take the risk with this stuff, and if they insist on keeping it around, what improvements should they make going forward? While many are forced to remain on the fence on whether this convention should get a fair run or die a death, here's a list of ‘Dos’ and ‘Don'ts’, in equal measure to clarify their best route ahead... for however long that may be.

10. DON’T: Meander Between One Convention And Another

Edge Randy Orton Backlash
WWE.com

While it's become the norm, there needs to be at least a few rules.

Presently there are standard wrestling matches, and there are cinematic matches, and blurring the two together is the first thing WWE need to put some reconsideration into. Giving matches the cinematic touch, and grounding cinematic spectacles so far into normality that they might as well have just taken place in the empty arena, makes the convention extremely confusing and leaves audiences wondering what the heck they were even looking at.

The Randy Orton vs. Edge ‘Greatest Wrestling Match Ever’ of Backlash 2020 had no end of weird cutaways, which ruptured the illusion at a very early point. Editing segments together to create a whole impression is one thing, (probably necessary given the circumstances) but shooting the two competitors from underneath during their first lock-in, only to have said cameraman disappear in the next shot is just plain weird… borderline patronising in fact.

So was it even cinematic or not? WWE are urged to clarify beforehand and keep with the programme.


9. DON’T: Give Wrestlers Superpowers

Baron Corbin Rey Mysterio Money In The Bank
WWE.com

The biggest advantage to the cinematic style is that creativity can be taken to higher levels (more on that further down the list), but this doesn’t mean that writers can abandon reason and expect viewers to run with it. Cinema already exists, and with it comes certain expectations.

Wrestling is indeed strange when you think about it. Able-bodied men and women get dropped on their heads every week, only to get back up and fight. They endlessly change their personalities and their morals. They decide for seasonal segments to adopt an exclusive hatred or admiration for another competitor. It’s not like real life.

That said, having Aleister Black and Rey Mysterio survive being thrown off the top of a bloody tower and submerging Braun Strowman in a swamp for a duration long enough to warrant drowning (he's back and cutting angry promos only a handful of weeks later) is pushing the realms of realism just a little more than is tolerable.

If it's too unrealistic for Hollywood, then the same should probably go for WWE.


8. DON’T: Segue Them Into Bigger Feuds

Braun Strowman Bray Wyatt
WWE.com

In a perfect world, it may have been feasible for WWE to seamlessly blend the tropes of cinematic matches into arena-based, (albeit empty arena), storytelling. The awful truth, however, is that the creative powers-that-be do not seem to have the foresight and continuity to pull this off.

The prime example lies, unfortunately once again, in the Swamp match. The Bray vs. Braun 'trilogy' began with a neat hierarchy of intensity, opening with the tactically nonchalant match with Funhouse Bray, only to escalate into a supposedly definite resolve with The Fiend at next Summerslam.

Given the history of the two competitors, a brief resurgence of 'Eater of Worlds' Bray Wyatt was a cool interlude... on paper. If nothing else, this character’s in-ring presence had no shortage of charisma, which made the eventual cinematic intersperse all the more unnecessary. Literally drowning the opponent weaved a fictitious mess which in turn required fixing with some semblance of dignity.

Keep in mind that this appears to have been rescued, SOLELY by the Firefly Funhouse format and Bray Wyatt’s mad magician-like talent for narrative. Time will tell how much collateral the risk caused, long term.


7. DON’T: Make Them A Monthly Routine

Vince McMahon Money
WWE.com

Cinematic is the new standard. We get one per pay-per-view now, and it has been that way since WrestleMania. For an idea that was originally refined as a remedy for global-situation-sadness, dropping one per month by default seems a little counter-intuitive.

Putting all other criticisms aside, one must respect the uncertainty and anxiety a global bastard can exert over a company, and the resulting pressure placed on each employee. It’s been well documented as of late. Bluntly put, does WWE even have the creative juices to engineer no less than one cinematic spectacle every four (approx.) weeks, on top of their already busy and notably chaotic weekly taping schedule?

If they can’t, it’s not their fault, and they’d be better off putting more stock in the bigger tribulations of their weekly programming. If they get stuck for good ideas, are they going to churn out a disasterpiece regardless? Likewise, if they have moments of creative clarity, are they just going to stir them in with the consistent murk of everything else happening?

Better that they go sparingly with these matches. Fans would appreciate it more.


6. DON’T: Emulate Bad TV Movies

Backlash Tag Match
WWE

It might be that they’ve only stopped being quite so weird because we’ve gotten used to them, but let’s reiterate that making the jump from an in-ring wrestling match to a cinematic production is one hell of a shift. Yes, WWE already have an impressive archive of in-house movie productions. This is different.

Whilst pioneering the commercial stadium appeal of wrestling more than 30 years back, WWE seems to be snail-trailing in harnessing the already established conventions of, well… making a film… or more accurately, a one-off TV episode.

The cinematic matches of 2020 that have actually been effective is not something this writer has overlooked and they will be celebrated shortly, but the ones which haven’t, when nudged only slightly out of context of the larger programming of WWE, resemble nothing more than a failed pilot episode to a TV show that no sound-minded network would commission, even in a drunken stupor.

Basically, if it's worse than a '90s Channel 5 film, either in the comedy or horror genres, then it's not to the benefit of any party involved. They need to be more than this. A lot more.


5. DO: Nominate The Cinematic Match With Care

Velveteen Dream
WWE

Case in point: The Backlot Brawl of NXT Takeover: In Your House.

Adam Cole versus Velveteen Dream: That concept alone is a winner. Then, in the run up, William Regal announces the match type: A Backlot Brawl. That’s basically a ring outdoors, with street fight rules, right? Good handle...

Except, when it came to the event, it got just a pinch of the cinematic. As with the Randy/Edge match, it was almost regular wrestling but not quite. None of that was necessary, and the match would have been a superb spectacle without it. If it's a concept that can be done equally or more effectively in the ring, then it should be kept as such.

This proves that, as a rule of thumb, it’s unwise to re-jig existing matches into the cinematic format. Surely it would be better to create a blank cinematic slate beforehand and then weave in the finer details accordingly. Having this level of foresight would give greater rise of the question: Does this need to be cinematic? If the answer is anywhere close to a 'no', then a neat pass will earn a lot of gratitude from audiences.


4. DO: Clarify That It Isn't Really Wrestling

Otis Paul Heyman
WWE.com

In theory, cinematic matches have real potential, and this has been proven more than once. They present the opportunity to do something different, to showcase some originality and creative thinking, and to inspire weary spirits in uncertain times. Whilst arenas are sparse, fans are looking for something to push the boat out, and WWE is in no shortage of charismatic individuals. That’s the whole point of having gimmicks.

Creating the right cinematic experience is a fine balance but nothing says it has to revolve around wrestling… does it? If it did, then why even bother jumping ship to another medium? More importantly, witnessing competitors brawl in wrestling fashion can start to look silly rather quickly in the cinematic format. It might be ill-founded to dub wrestlers 'stunt people' rather than actors, but without a ring and the appropriate other props, there's only so far they can take their craft.

Creators are therefore encouraged to make that jump with more conviction, and to make the distinction that 'different' does indeed mean 'different'. A hot take? Maybe... but worth the risk.


3. DO: Keep In Mind The Power Of Good Dialogue

Drew McIntyre WWE Raw
WWE.com

With scripted promos being a thing anyway, and being delivered in multitude on no less than a twice-weekly basis, surely cinematic dialogue should be through the roof.

Good storytelling needs good lines and professional wrestling, since the dawn of its popularity and before, has a library’s worth. The key to the success of cinematic matches may also lie in the same place, but for some reason, this opportunity has been largely overlooked, with good verbal interaction between athletes being pushed back even more so than they would in the ring.

To really sell the idea, wrestlers should be given the chance to flex their well-honed vocal talents with some decent dialogue, seeing as they’re being goaded into acting parts as it is. Looking at it the other way, why not let well-spoken superstars ad lib in front of the camera. Several talented directors use this technique to bring out the best in their actors (Shane Meadows immediately springs to mind). There’s no reason why WWE shouldn’t offer the same creative freedom to their wrestlers.

Cinematic pipebombs? Let’s do this!


2. DO: Stylise It Around The Wrestler

Undertaker Boneyard
WWE.com

To reference one of the best and most successful cinematic matches to date, the Boneyard match of WrestleMania could have been nothing besides The Undertaker through and through. The lighting, sound, and mise en scène was Deadman to a fault, and that’s why it worked.

Atmosphere, music, and storytelling to suit the wrestler is a must. Perhaps a good way to look at it would be as less of a short film and more of an extended entrance video... with a story. The only condition is choosing a wrestler dynamic enough to suit the format.

In this regard, the world is WWE's oyster. Imagine an exuberant and stylised window into the heads of the likes of Shotzi Blackheart, Dexter Lumis, Asuka…

We're just scratching the surface here. Karrion Kross practically writes itself. They’d probably miss a trick with veterans like Finn Bálor. On the list goes.

Another existing example of when this has worked is the enigmatic and wholly brilliant Firefly Funhouse match, which was the perfect twisted conduit into the mind of one Bray Wyatt.

Which leads us to...


1. DO: Let The Imagination Run Wild… With Emphasis On 'Imagination'

John Cena Bray Wyatt
WWE.com

Yup, that entire segment sure was special. The references, the humour, the horror, the victimisation of a haplessly conventional John Cena. Damn, what a ride.

The Firefly Funhouse match was unlike anything, and that was its power. It sure as hell wasn’t wrestling, It wasn’t an A-B story either. It was like The Fiend himself had crawled his way into a video package and infected it with his madness. For this one-time deal, WWE had raised the bar on their own imaginative boundaries, and it paid off tenfold.

Letting loose with some avant-garde creativity might be a gamble, but how the hell is it any worse than some of the latter delves into cinematic territory? Surely it’s better to steer clear of tired horror tropes and Benny Hill-style comedy skits and risk a nugget of mainstream disdain by turning this project into a multimedia, fourth wall-smashing, headscrewing endeavour, unlike anything else anywhere. If WWE wanted to give these packages the David Lynch treatment, nobody could stop them, and they’d get some commendation for at least trying.

In short, they’ve got nothing to lose… literally nothing. It doesn’t have to be brazen or edgy, just original.


In this post: 
Otis Dozovic
 
Posted On: 
Contributor

Writer, proud father and also chimp. Plus I talk music at Everythingisnoise.net