5 Ups & 2 Downs From WWE SmackDown (27 Dec - Results & Review)
WWE announced a Royal Rumble ladder match and waved goodbye to SmackDown being 2 hours.
Don't laugh, because it might happen.
WWE will be taking SmackDown three hours from next week onwards, so Triple H could be on the lookout for some out there matches that'll fill time. No, Michael Cole fetching his orange singlet to wrestle Chelsea Green probably won't be one of them, but...who knows? All the 'Cole Miners' worldwide demand it. Ahem.
In all seriousness, there's a bit of concern that the extra hour will hurt SmackDown's flow. Generally, the blue brand has been one of the easiest shows on wrestling telly to watch every week for years, but an added 60 minutes could well change that. Or, maybe it'll give some overlooked undercard workers some time to shine. Let's just wait and see, eh? No point in moaning before finding out.
This week's final two hour sendoff had one mission and one mission only: Announce a ladder match for February's (still weird) Royal Rumble between Cody Rhodes and Kevin Owens. Both the standard WWE Title and 'Winged Eagle' belts will hang high above the ring in Indianapolis on the road to WrestleMania 41. The warring pair closed Friday's show with a spirited segment that showcased the best of Rhodes - he's the man when deadly serious and out for blood.
The Bloodline got to look vicious yet again too. Solo Sikoa sent a message to Roman Reigns via Sami Zayn's limp body, and there was even time for a cool standoff between Braun Strowman and Jacob Fatu. Fingers crossed Trips books that match sometime. Hey, maybe it'll even contest a title in the future.
Here's all the good and bad from the end of an era! Goodbye, traditional SmackDown. Thanks for the memories!
Downs...
2. What Changed?
Previously, this writer gave WWE a lot of praise for maintaining Bianca Belair's warranted frost towards Bayley. The 'EST' wasn't willing to go along with Naomi/others and play pals with the ex-Damage CTRL leader because she'd been punted from the group. That rocked, because it portrayed Bianca as a real human being who needed more than just, 'Bayley is a babyface now' to get onboard.
What changed, and why?
Belair suddenly trusts Bayley. That's one of Triple H's near misses, creatively speaking. Bianca started accepting Bayley shortly before WarGames without any real context as to why, and now says "we're good" like beef has been squashed. No, un-squash that beef! There's plenty to unpack. It's a minor grumble for sure, but WWE definitely could've handled this plot point with way more finesse than they have; Bianca went from hating Bayley’s guts to being totally cool with having her around, and there wasn’t enough of an explanation as to why.
Worse, they’re not even frosty in the slightest. The pair are like great pals all of a sudden. Did Belair have a change of heart because Naomi helped her hold onto the Women's Tag-Team Titles? Or, did the company simply view the aggro between old rivals as boring and want to move on from it ASAP? People need answers, Hunter. Right now, quietly shelving this plot point is making Belair look a little foolish.
If she must team with Bayley, fine, but it isn't much to ask that she's chippy about it. After all, Bayley hasn't actually done anything to change that other than stepping into the breach for a one-off match at Survivor Series.
1. Swing And A Miss
Literally, as far as the kendo stick swing goes.
This segment was veering towards 'Up' territory before Michin was revealed as Chelsea Green's first challenger. Look, that's not meant as some cruel dismissal of Mia Yim as a worker. It's just, well...we've been there, done that with Chelsea vs. Michin, surely. Their rivalry should've been a closed book once Green won the Women's United States Title back at Saturday Night's Main Event, at least for now.
Instead, WWE has decided to keep it going after the fact and book Michin as Chelsea's first challenger. There was no need. Going with Bayley (or someone of that higher stature) would've been a better call, and the complete lack of live crowd interest in everything once Michin came out with a weapon proves it. She just isn't quite clicking. Something's missing.
Green deserved something bigger than retreading old ground now she's champ, to be honest. Sure, the Women's US Title is meant for those outside the top title conversation, but that shouldn't mean WWE's writers had to pick the blandest option imaginable. Again, a higher profile star like Bayley would've made it feel like Green was taking a step up as a member of the division. Another one.
Alternatively, going with someone totally new (B-FAB?) might've been a hoot. There's just nothing new to explore with Michin going after Chelsea. They don't like one another and have totally different personalities. We get it. Sheesh, fingers crossed this isn't something that drags on and on, because Green's title reign needs to start with a bang.
Ups...
5. Way Better Than Expected
Count out losses to Carmelo Hayes? Baaaaaad. Decent bouts vs. Austin Theory? Goooood. Sorry, but something about Braun Strowman just reminds one of those mockups of Metallica frontman James Hetfield during the whole Napster drama. Look it up if you've never had the pleasure. Even the band themselves had a right good giggle at it years later.
WWE didn't reach for the laughs during Braun vs. Theory though. This could easily have been another routine squash that did nothing for either man. In a pleasant surprise, they got a decent chunk of time and used Grayson Waller well as a distraction from ringside. Theory even got some shine throughout the match before Strowman overpowered him, and it's worth saying that the fans were really into Braun.
Personally, this fan's not hot on Strowman tangling with A-Town Down Under on the side when he clearly has unfinished business with Carmelo Hayes and should’ve been solely focused on revenge there, but you’ve got to call this sort of thing on a show by show basis. For what it was, Braun vs. Theory was inoffensive and an easy watch. They meshed well together, which bodes well for Strowman's longer matches going forwards.
This was a fun midcard match. It ticked a lot of boxes.
Side note: Theory deserves way better than he’s been getting in 2024, man. Split the team with Waller and get something going on the babyface side already. They're a busted flush together heading into the new year, and it's time to make some moves.
4. A Decent Tag With Some Sub-Story
It'd be easy to brush this match off as a largely fruitless exercise given that Pretty Deadly proved to be lying through their teeth about Los Garza ambushing The Street Profits a few weeks back. Apollo Crews popped up (a bit too late for Corey Graves!) to reveal that it wasn't Angel and Berto at all. However, you've got to appreciate Triple H at least trying to give otherwise cold bouts like this one some purpose and direction.
The Profits vs. Los Garza had some cool highs, and it’s nice to see Angel and Humberto on TV in a proper match too. They’re criminally underused - the whole Legado del Fantasma reboot faction is. Creative giving the match some context by having PD fib gave Nick Aldis an excuse to book it too. Obviously, this doesn't change the fact that Montez Ford and Angelo Dawkins need freshened up, because they’ve been spinning wheels big time for too long, but they’re a tidy team in matches like this and the added story was appreciated.
Montez and Angelo have some fire to them during comeback spots, and a special mention must go to B-FAB for slotting in neatly alongside the pair. That was never guaranteed once the would-be group with Bobby Lashley went south and he left the promotion, but the trio salvaged things and started to do their own thing.
Now, all because of two rapid fire backstage skits, WWE has follow up matches like Profits vs. Pretty Deadly and Profits vs. DIY on their hands. Profits vs. Motor City Machine Guns is possible too. There are loads of moving parts in the tag division, which is great.
3. Six Woman Was Slick
OK, so it's slightly annoying how buddy-buddy Bianca and Bayley are all of a sudden, but the six woman tag that resulted from them getting along proved to be good stuff. It was so slickly produced. Put a little extra something in the pocket of the agent responsible, please. They formatted the match expertly, and they made sure every little story beat was represented.
Tiffany Stratton had a top dynamic alongside Nia Jax and Candice LeRae. She initially tried to help, but is clearly the outsider nowadays. Realising this, Tiffany then teased cashing in her Money In The Bank briefcase on Nia before Candice put a stop to it. Fans were firmly behind Stratton, so inserting LeRae between she and Jax has been a rip-roaring success.
WWE will probably have to pull the trigger on Tiffany’s cash in soon (maybe on Netflix?), but her character arc is enjoyable.
These six women were given bags of time, and they made it count. Naomi looked strong enough to challenge Nia for the title by winning for her team, Bayley was having more fun out there than she seemingly has for a while, and Belair is just freakishly good no matter what physical task is put in front of her. That woman's a genuine athletic superstar.
It would've been understandable had everyone leaned too hard on the Tiffy cash in stuff and phoned in a six person tag, but they didn't. All six worked their tails off to make this watchable, and the crowd met them halfway by bringing the noise. So many tiny plot pieces in recent months have helped.
2. Bloodline Inspired Chaos
Incoming 'can't believe I'm even typing this' scenario: That was the most bored one can remember being during a Sami Zayn match. It isn't a reflection on the skills of Sami or Carmelo Hayes, but they were killing time before Braun Strowman and The Bloodline arrived. It was painfully obvious just a few short minutes into their bout that we were getting some sort of non-finish that'd lead to an angle.
That's fine, but it means Sami vs. Melo sits awkwardly in the space between 'Ups' and 'Downs'. It wasn't memorable or terrible. Thankfully, the post-DQ stuff more than made up for it. Braun arrived to go after Hayes, who scarpered, then Solo Sikoa, Tama Tonga and Jacob Fatu attacked Zayn to cause the bell. After that, there was a super-fun standoff between Strowman and Fatu before things really broke down.
What a flurry of activity. It was mass hysteria for a minute or two!
Hot segments are nothing new for The Bloodline (even Solo's version). They revel in brawls that see bodies start flying around all over the place, and Sikoa got to send a message to Roman Reigns by taking Sami out before 'Tribal Combat' hits Raw's Netflix debut. There was a lot to take in once Zayn vs. Melo ended, put it that way.
Even Hunter's harshest critics must admit that he's done a bang up job of making Fatu look threatening against everybody, and now Solo has a wee bit of juice before meeting Roman to thrash out this 'Tribal Chief' business too. Job done.
1. Cody Rhodes Pitches A Ladder Match
The minutes were ticking down rapidly on SmackDown's two hour format once Kevin Owens hit the ring for his show-closing segment opposite Nick Aldis and Cody Rhodes, so everybody had to be on their toes to make sure the biggest beats had ample time to sink in. Good news: KO is at his best when he races through some dialogue and makes demands. That led to Cody making a demand of his own.
He pitched a ladder match vs. Owens at Royal Rumble. Add that to the list of epic Rumble moments from the past few decades already - it's sure to be a scorcher. They'll hang both the standard WWE Title Rhodes holds and the 'Winged Eagle' version Kev stole high above the ring and finish their feud once and for all. Hell, we might even get a Randy Orton return. RKO off the ladder for the finish? Don't rule it out.
This was a strong, serious and impactful promo skit that let Owens show himself up as a dirtbag all over again. He shoved Aldis into Cody then stood tall. Meanwhile, Rhodes cut a fiery speech before getting to the payoff. This noble-but-vengeful version of Cody is the best, so it's a good thing KO's brattish behaviour brings that out in him.
It’ll be interesting to see how they string things out for another month, but at least now the writers have an end point to work towards before heading into the next major PLE. You just know wheels will be spinning in the heads of Kevin and Cody already as well. They'll bend over backwards to make sure this ladder match is outstanding.
Let the build begin.
What did you think of WWE's final SmackDown from 2024? For more wrestling, check out 50 Things You Learn Binge-Watching Every WWE Royal Rumble and 50 Things You Learn Binge-Watching Every WWE WrestleMania!