5 Ups & 3 Downs From AEW Dark (Oct 8)

Darby Allin vs. CIMA highlights AEW's first weekly B-show.

Darby Allin CIMA
AEW

Six days removed from Dynamite's well-received arrival on TNT, AEW debuted their new web series, Dark, last night.

The full show can be found on the promotion's YouTube channel. Comprised entirely of untelevised bouts worked before and after the Dynamite taping broken up by in-studio pieces featuring announcer Tony Schiavone, it looks like Dark is going to be a great vehicle to showcase those wrestlers who didn't make it onto the big show. AEW can't push and promote everyone at once, after all, and if they're going to hold these "dark" matches, they might as well tape and release them.

This episode featured four bouts, Schiavone's hype pieces, and a quick Dynamite recap. It was a light, breezy watch with some solid little 6-10 minute bouts. Should it become appointment viewing? That's hard to say, given how much pro-wrestling content is out there these days, but can fans really afford to skip shows from a promotion in which every single win and loss is supposed to matter?

With CIMA vs. Darby Allin, a Jurassic Express/SCU All Out rematch, and two other tags on display, AEW Dark wasn't without its teething problems, but largely delivered on expectations. Let's break it down...


Downs...

3. A Downgrade Of Jurassic Proportions

SoCal Uncensored vs. Jurassic Express was a fun little six-person tag to close Dark's first episode, but therein lies the problem. Their All Out trios clash was so much more than a "fun little six-person tag." That was an explosive, character-filled, firecracker of a bout, and a perfect pay-per-view opener. Thus, this condensed rematch felt like a letdown.

We've already seen the ****+ version of this match. Given that it only went down a few weeks ago, this makes it difficult to get too excited for the *** version.

The SCU vs. Jurassic Express format probably needed a tad more breathing room. Nine minutes didn't seem enough for the veterans to get going or for Marko Stunt and Jungle Boy to build to a truly spectacular Luchasaurus hot tag and while Dark itself didn't need to be longer (its brevity was one of its greatest strengths), perhaps AEW should've thought twice about putting this match's layout.

Worked at more of a house show clip than the previous scrap, this had some fun moments like the overmatched and undersized Stunt literally bouncing off Scorpio Sky when attempting a crossbody. Again, it was a good, solid match - just a downgrade from All Out.


2. 205 Live Syndrome

AEW Dark
AEW

CIMA vs. Darby Allin was the only Dark bout taped before Dynamite. The other three were held after the show, and the difference in crowd reactions was huge.

The audience were alive, energised, and fully engaged for Allin and CIMA, creating a great atmosphere for a bout that wasn't even advertised prior to the show, but the other matches? Not so much. Those poor fans had been worn out by Dynamite's big moments. They'd expended most of their energy and now, after watching the A-show, they were being asked to receive the B-show with the same level of enthusiasm.

Contrast the difference between the noise SCU and Jurassic Express generated at All Out and their muted responses on Dark. It's night and day.

This is something AEW can learn from. Perhaps it'd be wise to tape all of the bouts before Dynamite to prevent crowd burnout, because everything apart from Allin vs. CIMA was suffering from a bad case of 205 Live Syndrome. Let's fix that.


1. Women's Tag Fails To Impress

Comfortably the worst thing on Dark's first episode was Bea Priestley and Penelope Ford vs Alli and Britt Baker, which did a solid job of highlighting the ongoing Baker vs. Priestley feud, but little else.

This is unfortunate. Women's wrestling is clearly something AEW want (and need) to invest in long-term and Dynamite's Riho vs. Nyla Rose clash stole the show, but bouts like this haven't worked out. This was another slow, clunky offering from a division that has delivered only sporadically, and it felt much, much longer than its ten-minute runtime.

Highlights included Ford occasionally lighting things up with her athleticism, Allie's personality, and a few Priestley/Baker interactions. Regardless, they couldn't hook the crowd. Seconds passed like minutes and Dark delivered a match that should probably have been chopped up and presented as a highlights package with Tony Schiavone's narration, with the extra time alloted elsewhere.

The finish saw Ford verbally submitting to Baker's Crossface after Allie had Speared Priestly. Perhaps this means Britt's getting the advertised shot at Riho on Dynamite's 16 October episode.


Ups...

5. The Format

Tony Schiavone studio
AEW

AEW absolutely nailed Dark's setup and format, delivering a show that still looks and feels like the company's other content, but is different enough to make it stand out from Dynamite and Road To.

Tony Schiavone divided his time between studio work and commentary. He was as great as you'd expect in the studio and it was a revolving team of announcers, with Jim Ross and Excalibur both jumping in at points. This gives the impression that their work was recorded after the show rather than live, and this was reflected on the broadcast, though it didn't make a difference.

The way Schiavone framed and introduced each match was particularly effective, with the ex-WCW man coming through with short blasts of critical information. He put Darby Allin over, highlighted the Priestley/Baker beef, and sold the Tag Team Championship tournament after the eight-man tag, amongst other hype spots. Nothing groundbreaking there, but little touches like this make all the difference.


4. Luchasaurus Rules

While not received with the same rapturous enthusiasm as his Fight for the Fallen and All Out performances, Luchasaurus' run through SoCal Uncensored was the undoubted highlight of their six-man tag.

His hot tag is one of the most exciting things in wrestling right now. It's a simple pleasure, but watching this big, athletic monster of a man run through his opponents with moves he really shouldn't be able to do is a guaranteed crowd-popper. Jurassic Express structure it well, too. Though Jungle Boy gets plenty of offense himself, he'll do the bulk of the selling as the face-in-peril, while Marko Stunt is just a straight-up pest. It's a great dynamic and the way these guys build to Lucahsaurus running wild doesn't get talked about enough.

The big man's moment came soon after absorbing some tandem SCU offence. He was decked, but sat bolt upright like a prehistoric Undertaker, kipped up, then kicked the sh*t out of Frankie Kazarian. Luchasaurs then lifted Scorpio Sky into the ring by his throat, nailed a Flapjack, and Chokeslammed Kaz as his little buddies dived to the outside. Cue: the standing Moonsault and a two-count.

Luchasaurus isn't the best big man in wrestling right now, but he is an absolute hoot.


3. It's An Hour

Orange Cassidy
AEW

Adding any extra content to a busy wrestling fan's schedule is a hard sell at the moment, with AEW and WWE both producing nine hours of A-tier shows between them every single week and things like 205 Live, Beyond Wrestling's Uncharted Territory, Impact, and NWA Powerrr all on the schedule.

Thank the lord, then, that AEW Dark is only an hour long.

It's the perfect length for this kind of show. For the most part, the 60 minutes absolutely fly by (though the women's tag dragged). This is not only thanks to Schiavone's immaculate work between the bouts, but the bouts themselves, with only one stretching beyond 10 minutes and the other three emphasising fun, fast-paced action above all else. It was a breeze of a broadcast.

Let's hope there's never a temptation to expand beyond this hour. It's ideal.


2. Eight-Man Mayhem

The array of talent involved in last night's eight-man tag highlights how awesome AEW's tag division is, with the Lucha Brothers and Hybrid 2 joining forces to face the Best Friends and Private Party.

This was effectively a hype piece for the upcoming tag team tournament. That's how the announcers sold it, that's how Schiavone wrapped it up, and that's how it was performed, with the wrestlers placing greater emphasis on ensuring the crowd had a good time rather than any one team (or performer) getting over.

It was a Movez match. Fast, fluid double-team moves came every other second, making for the bout's basic psychology. If you're into that kind of thing, then great, check this out. If you're not, skip it. It'll do nothing to win you over.

Orange Cassidy drew two of the night's biggest pops, first when he emerged alongside Best Friends, then again when he dived onto a pile of bodies late in the bout. Other highlights included Jack Evans botching a springboard into the ring then selling it like a total goof, Marq Quen getting his sunglasses kicked off his head by Rey Fenix, and Fenix running the roots to boot Chuck Taylor's face. Isiah Kasidy needs to stop f*cking squealing, though. Seriously.

The Lucha Brothers took the victory when Taylor was pinned following their Fear Factor/stomp combo. They, along with the Young Bucks, are established as tournament favourites, though an upset first-round victory for one team might make the most sense.


1. Darby Allin & CIMA Tear It Up

Nobody made greater use of their short Dark time limit than Darby Allin vs. CIMA, who did everything they could within their allotted seven minutes, opening the show with comfortably the best thing on it.

A fast-paced bout began with CIMA blasting Allin with double knees while Darby was sat in the corner, gazing around the arena, but the smaller man soon found a way back in. Allin wrestles at 100mph. He's a propulsive dynamo of a performer who flings his body around as if he's weightless, and he whipped the crowd up with a bunch of consecutive dives to the outside. CIMA largely played the veteran to counter this, looking ground Allin's kamikaze instincts. The Dragon Gate legend countered the Coffin Drop into a Powerbomb at one point, working Darby over with holds thereafter, but Allin did a good job grinding CIMA's knee down himself, showing he's more than just a do-or-die daredevil.

This high energy affair concluded when Darby finally hit the Coffin Drop following a Code Red. If there's one criticism, it's that Allin went for the Coffin Drop thrice in seven minutes and could probably benefit from a more varied approach in that regard, but that's a nitpick. The match was bags of fun.


Channel Manager
Channel Manager

Andy has been with WhatCulture for 10 years and is currently WhatCulture's Wrestling Channel Manager. A writer, presenter, and editor with 10+ years of experience in online media, he has been a sponge for all wrestling knowledge since playing an old Royal Rumble 1992 VHS to ruin in his childhood. Having previously worked for Bleacher Report, Andy specialises in short and long-form writing, video presenting, voiceover acting, and editing, all characterised by expert wrestling knowledge and commentary. Andy is as much a fan of 1985 Jim Crockett Promotions as he is present-day AEW and WWE - just don't make him choose between the two.