8 Biggest Tweeners In WWE History

Too good to be bad...

Raw Samoa Joe Brock Lesnar
WWE.com

The term 'tweener' means different things to different people. On one hand, it can mean that a babyface/heel was bad at their job and couldn't provoke the correct or desired response from WWE's audience. On the other, these performers were so special that they were able to transcend the divide 'good' and 'bad'.

Take the upcoming match between Brock Lesnar and Samoa Joe as an example of the latter. Both are very much over with fans, and whilst Brock is clearly being positioned as the 'good guy' (he's not the one sneak-attacking Joe from behind, after all), Paul Heyman's 'Beast Incarnate' isn't exactly a classic babyface either. Both guys exist on that rare level above being pigeon-holed as babyface or heel.

Neither Lesnar or Joe pander to fans in an attempt to curry favour. Instead, audiences react to them organically, believing both to be elite performers that are worthy of attention regardless of character alignment.

They're not alone...


8. Eddie Guerrero

WWE.com

He lies, he cheats, he steals, and he's also one of the greatest performers to ever grace a WWE ring. Eddie Guerrero was so good in fact that he was regularly cheered even when playing heel. Fans were intoxicated by Eddie's entertainment value and how passionate he was about having the best match on the card.

Guerrero played both heel and babyface during his WWE runs, and although most will likely remember him finally winning the WWE Title at No Way Out 2004 (and all the emotion that came with it), he also excelled as a bitter bad guy. Should anyone need an education on Eddie's heel work, just seek out his vindictive brilliance opposite Rey Mysterio from 2005.

Dodgy angles like Guerrero seeking custody of Rey's son aside, the matches both men had were enhanced because Eddie was just flawless as a character. His promos were good, his in-ring performances better, and fans adored him for it.


7. CM Punk

WWE.com

CM Punk always fostered a great relationship with WWE's audience, because it was believable that he was never supposed to be a top star in the company. Amidst stories of backstage politics, he was world class whenever he appeared in front of fans, and that went a long way to establishing a bond.

Eventually, nothing could break that, not even Punk attacking The Rock in 2012 and turning heel. After coming into his own as a smart-assed babyface antihero (following a successful spell as the Jesus-like 'Straight Edge Saviour'), Punk joined up with Paul Heyman to form quite the partnership. Meanwhile, fans lapped it up.

Think about Punk in 2013: an arrogant sort who claimed to speak on behalf of those watching, he was hardly supposed to be immediately likeable. That didn't stop people from cheering for him even when he was committing dastardly acts or going up against babyfaces.

Punk was over, and didn't need to be bound by conventional heel or babyface tactics.


6. The NWO

Hulk Hogan nwo
WWE.com

Then-WWF fans were delighted to see Hulk Hogan, Kevin Nash and Scott Hall back in the promotion in early-2002. It had been close to six years since they'd watched Nash and Hall as Diesel and Razor Ramon respectively, and close to a decade since the WWF had been exposed to Hulkamania. Besides, that nWo gimmick? Over as hell.

Despite being cited as part of the reason why WCW ultimately failed, the New World Order were treated like returning heroes when they re-appeared on WWF television. Even though Nash, Hall and Hogan were cast as invaders looking to fulfil Vince McMahon's wish to destroy his own creation, people just didn't want to boo the trio.

That cool factor had followed the nWo in WCW too, but it was most glaring in the WWF. The Order were supposed to be destructive heels, but they couldn't get real heat if they tried. Not even beating up established favourites like Steve Austin or The Rock could convince fans to boo the nWo.


5. Roman Reigns

WWE Raw Roman Reigns Fans
WWE.com

You might not like the fact he's here, and some will decry Roman Reigns as more of a heel these days than anything else, but listening closely to crowd reactions reveals both cheering and booing. Perhaps this has more to do with WWE's failure to get Roman over as a definitive face, but he is still a tweener.

Remember the 'other' meaning of the term, the one that turns characters tweener by default because they fail to provoke the desired response from fans? Reigns fits into that bracket, but he's one of the finest examples of someone skirting a fine line between heel and baby in modern wrestling. Just look at the way the guy conducts himself.

Occasionally, Roman will act like a braggart in promos and respond to audience negativity. Then, sometimes he won't and will stand up against the bad guys like a stereotypical wrestling hero would. There's no black and white when it comes to Reigns; he's meant to be a face and yet fans treat him like a heel, and that makes him a tweener.


4. John Cena

John Cena entrance
WWE.com

John Cena provided the blueprint that Roman Reigns now uses, and he did it over a decade ago. Initially popular due to his bad-boy rap persona, Cena morphed into the poster child for WWE's PG direction over time, and people hated him for it.

This didn't sit well with WWE at first. Not knowing how to handle someone they so desperately wanted to be a shining example of goodness being booed out of each building, the creative team tried to weather the storm. When that didn't work, they (and Cena himself) were forced to acknowledge the hostility and use it to build John's 'Rise Above Hate' campaign.

Now, Cena remains on the cusp; too popular with younger fans and (predominantly) adult women to be a true heel, he's also despised by a portion of the adult male audience and loathed by those who are sick of his almost superhuman ways.


3. Brock Lesnar

WWE.com

If this were 1987 and Hulk Hogan was still rousing audiences behind his 'Say Your Prayers, Take Your Vitamins' hyperbole, then Brock Lesnar would be the ideal WWF heel. Built from the ground up to physically dismantle guys like Hogan, Lesnar would be finely poised to draw monster business opposing Hulkamania.

Nowadays, people live vicariously through fighting machines like Brock. They admire his killer instinct, find solace in his bad-ass persona and love that he's ultra-violent when the bell rings. Oh, how the industry has changed over time, although it's also true to say that Lesnar isn't a outright babyface.

Brock exhibits many heel characteristics. He acts aloof, almost superior, and he's backed by a loudmouth coward of a manager who does his talking for him. That's hardly the makings of a high-fiving, baby-kissing good guy, but Lesnar doesn't need to pander.

He can go up against both heels and faces equally in today's WWE without sacrificing his integrity or really changing anything about his on screen presence.


2. The Rock

the rock smackdown 1999
WWE.com

He may be the biggest male draw in Hollywood now, but The Rock wasn't very good at getting people to like him back in 1996/97. Ironically, flopping as the happy, smiling Rocky Maivia helped Rock get over as a sneering, suave and cocky character who spoke in third person and later even mocked the fans.

By 1999, The Rock could insult "the people" all he liked, because they were very much on his side. Endlessly entertained by 'The Great One' and his ability to deliver verbal putdowns on the microphone, fans started cheering for Rocky whether he was heel or babyface. This was evident during his 2003 heel run, during which people still found him charming and hard to really hate.

The Rock butted heads with beloved characters like Steve Austin and Mankind without losing any shred of his own appeal. That can't have been easy to do, but it speaks volumes of the persona Rock created and how damn good he was at playing it.

When that 'People's Eyebrow' should have made folks ready to slap Rock silly, it instead became endearing.


1. Steve Austin

steve austin royal rumble 1997
WWE.com

There's no finer example of a WWE tweener than 'Stone Cold' Steve Austin in 1997. Displaying all the traits of a traditional heel, Austin was rough around the edges, prone to colourful language and never played up to fan support. Somehow, that only made him more popular.

Wrestling's greatest renegade, what made Stone Cold exist in the space between heel and babyface was the fact he didn't discriminate; attacking both good and bad alike, Austin was one of the most unique characters on the roster back then. His work would change the way audiences reacted to characters and blur the lines like never before.

Nobody else possessed Austin's degenerate aura in '97, not even D-Generation X. The almighty Bret Hart couldn't keep Austin heel either, because fans had already decided they were firmly in his corner. Just listen to the reception Stone Cold received at both Royal Rumble '97 and WrestleMania 13 for proof of that.

A beer-drinking, foul-mouthed redneck who lived by his own rules was exactly what people wanted in 1997, curiously turning someone who should have been a top heel into the biggest antihero of all time.

-

Which other tweeners do you recall fondly from WWE history? Let us know your thoughts down in the comments section below!


Contributor

Lifelong wrestling, video game, music and sports obsessive who has been writing about his passions since childhood. Jamie started writing for WhatCulture in 2013, and has contributed thousands of articles and YouTube videos since then. He cut his teeth penning published pieces for top UK and European wrestling read Fighting Spirit Magazine (FSM), and also has extensive experience working within the wrestling biz as a manager and commentator for promotions like ICW on WWE Network and WCPW/Defiant since 2010. Further, Jamie also hosted the old Ministry Of Slam podcast, and has interviewed everyone from Steve Austin and Shawn Michaels to Bret Hart and Trish Stratus.