5 Ups & 3 Downs From WWE SmackDown (Dec 17)

Roman Reigns fires Paul Heyman; Brock Lesnar wrecks shop; SmackDown's worst segment in years?

Roman Reigns The Usos Paul Heyman Con-Chair-To
WWE

WWE saved one of 2021's biggest storyline moments for the end of the year.

Roman Reigns has officially split from Paul Heyman, and one of the wrestling's best double acts is in the history books. On the plus side, WWE will probably now put Heyman back beside Brock Lesnar (who needs a mouthpiece way more than Roman) and run with that during WrestleMania 38 season.

The angle made this week's SmackDown newsworthy, but it wasn't the only nod towards the future Friday night had to offer. WWE busily prepared a babyface team to challenge for tag-team gold, and there's some moving and shaking going on with the Ridge Holland/Sheamus tandem too.

Glaring negatives came in the form of more Toni Storm mediocrity, the trials and tribulations of one Shayna Baszler, and a segment so bad it caused fans in Chicago to chant for AEW stars. Vince McMahon can't be happy with that, but he only has himself to blame for signing off on something this dreadful.

Here are all the 'Ups' and the 'Downs' from SmackDown, including that mish-mash of storyline genius and chat show hell.


Downs...

3. Shayna Baszler = Collateral Damage

Sonya Deville Naomi
WWE.com

At this point, Shayna Baszler would've been better off staying on Raw.

That's an incredible thing to say considering she was feuding with toy dolls and teaming with Nia Jax on Mondays, but it's true. On SmackDown, Shayna is rapidly becoming a borderline jobber who only exists to play supporting cast for other rivalries. Oh, and she also lost to Naomi in around 30 seconds.

Would someone please explain why Baszler is Sonya Deville's bitch all of a sudden? WWE haven't bothered to flesh that part of the narrative out, and it doesn't look like they're going to. Worse, any hopes of a hot match opposite the recently-debuting Xia Li (who was almost totally ignored here) were dashed by the lame job to Naomi.

It's one step forwards and two steps back for this Deville vs. Naomi feud. WWE want to string things out until Day 1, which is fine - using Shayna as collateral though? Nah, that's not cool. She's ice cold right now, and this role is a complete waste of her talents.


2. Eating Up Airtime

Madcap Moss Happy Corbin
WWE.com

The fact that Drew McIntyre has been reduced to this 'Happy Talk' guff, and has a pay-per-view match vs. Madcap Moss, is pretty depressing. Drew's 'Open Challenges' were a weekly highlight when he first moved over to SmackDown. Since then, the change of scenery has done nothing for him.

'Happy Talk' was so poor that fans started chanting "CM Punk! CM Punk! CM Punk!" to amuse themselves. This writer usually detests that, but he can't blame Chicago for getting restless. WWE may argue that Happy Corbin and Madcap's jokes are deliberately crap, but...do they need to waste so much TV time on them every Friday?

No. The answer is no.

Watching two men struggle to pull a sword from Adam Pearce's desk was "sports entertainment" at its worst. There was just no need for this to run for 10 minutes, and there's next-to-no appetite from fans to see McIntyre collide with Moss at Day 1 either.


1. Still Not Digging It

Toni Storm Sasha Banks
WWE.com

Hmm.

Whilst it was nice to see WWE open SmackDown with a match, that's where the positivity ended. They didn't even bother to give Toni Storm (who, y'know, is the main challenger for Charlotte Flair's SmackDown Women's Title) an entrance, but expected fans to greet her like a big star after a fluke victory.

The Storm/Sasha Banks vs. Charlotte/Shotzi tag went three segments. Long doesn't always equal good though - there were some rough moments in here. Practically everything Shotzi did looked sloppy and uncoordinated, and Toni had some awkward spots herself. Both women badly need some actual character development too.

No, "2 Pies Toni" doesn't count.

Perhaps the most egregious aspect of the whole story is that Storm, despite winning this tag, doesn't come across as a true threat to Flair's belt. Her surprised celebration with Banks even told the tale of someone who couldn't quite believe she'd beaten Charlotte.


Ups...

5. Restoring The Raid

Erik Jinder Mahal Shanky
WWE.com

SmackDown's tag ranks were decimated by the loss of Rey and Dominik Mysterio, Alpha Academy, Apollo Crews and Commander Azeez, The Street Profits and The Dirty Dawgs during the 2021 Draft. In addition, the brand lost newcomers Hit Row rather quickly. That didn't leave a lot for teams like The Viking Raiders to do.

WWE started the healing on Friday.

Erik and Ivar have been misused since day one on WWE's main roster, but they're still one of the better squads this company has under contract. This week, the pair offed Jinder Mahal and Shanky in a short match that was easy to watch. It didn't overstay it's welcome. It didn't need to.

This was a way better use of The Raiders than having them chat to randoms in the back or suck up to King Woods (who is in a tag-team himself and therefore competition). Plus, Ivar's splash from the top rope onto Shanky for the pin got a nice pop from the live crowd.


4. Keeping It Basic

Ridge Holland Cesaro
WWE.com

WWE also kept things straightforward in other matches too.

Ridge Holland cracked Cesaro in the ribs with his billy club pre-match. That turned their scuffle into more of an extended beatdown angle than a proper match, but it's sweet that they're keeping things so simple with the Holland and Sheamus alliance for now.

Sheamus should be causing distractions and setting traps for Ridge at the moment. They're still in that honeymoon period as a package, and it's not like Cesaro is damaged beyond repair by dropping to defeat following a pre-bell smack to the ribs with a weapon. If anything, that protected him.

It might be wise to stick Holland and Sheamus in the tag-team division for a while. Ridge could use some reps in matches with The Viking Raiders (for example) over the next month or so. He has a genuine chance to make it on the main roster if this booking continues.


3. WWE’s Consistency Quartet

King Woods Jimmy Uso
WWE.com

New Day members Kofi Kingston and King Woods seemed to be holding back a little during their non-title main event vs. The Usos on this week's show. That's smart though, because these teams have another pay-per-view showdown to prepare for come Day 1.

It's impossible for them to have a bad match even when they're sort of phoning it in anyway.

Being brutally honest, this fan didn't really like that New Day and The Usos had been programmed together again after the Draft, but there's a reason why WWE keeps on coming back to this feud. It's high quality all the way, and crowds seem to gobble up Kofi/Woods' hope spots no matter how times they happen.

Kingston hitting his Trouble In Paradise kick on Jimmy also allowed Roman Reigns to kick off his show-closing promo with something neat. It's little nuances like this that help make match results more meaningful in the long run.

Behold...


2. Acknowledging Defeat

Roman Reigns Paul Heyman Jey Uso
WWE.com

...this!

Before laying into Paul Heyman for last week's Brock Lesnar banter, Roman acknowledged that Jimmy and Jey had literally just lost to New Day. This was nifty - Reigns' disappointment when The Usos screw up has been a constant thread running through The Bloodline's business, so it was awesome that he mentioned it here.

Deftly, Roman used that annoyance to point fingers at Heyman too. He said he can forgive his cousins because they're "blood". Cue one of the best facial expressions of the year from Paul, and one hell of a reaction from the audience, when Reigns said Heyman isn't.

Roman managed to recognise that The Usos had lost and put that in its proper place with one short line. That's how good this guy has become on the mic. In storyline, Jimmy and Jey dropping a non-title bout isn't as important as Heyman scurrying around with Brock behind Roman's back.

That came across loud and clear.


1. Brock Lesnar To The Rescue!

Brock Lesnar Roman Reigns
WWE.com

Most WWE TV shows inch stories forward. That's fine - creative has to worry about 52 episodes of each brand per year, after all, and it's unrealistic to expect monumental plot developments every single time. That's why this week's SmackDown was so damn special.

Roman Reigns dumped Paul Heyman as his 'Special Council' and then went to end him for good with some steel chairs. Suddenly, Brock Lesnar marched out to paste The Usos, hit Reigns with some F5s and effectively save Paul E's bacon.

This was a huge, landscape-shifting moment.

It completely alters the dynamic of Reigns vs. Lesnar heading into Day 1 on 1 January; Heyman could be back beside Brock, and Roman won't have a skilled manipulator to fight verbal battles for him with WWE management. What a thumping end to the night this was.

What did you think of this week's WWE SmackDown? For more like this, check out 5 Ups & 6 Downs From WWE SmackDown (Dec 10) and 10 Biggest Promises WWE Broke In 2021!


Contributor

Lifelong wrestling, video game, music and sports obsessive who has been writing about his passions since childhood. Jamie started writing for WhatCulture in 2013, and has contributed thousands of articles and YouTube videos since then. He cut his teeth penning published pieces for top UK and European wrestling read Fighting Spirit Magazine (FSM), and also has extensive experience working within the wrestling biz as a manager and commentator for promotions like ICW on WWE Network and WCPW/Defiant since 2010. Further, Jamie also hosted the old Ministry Of Slam podcast, and has interviewed everyone from Steve Austin and Shawn Michaels to Bret Hart and Trish Stratus.