10 Biggest Promises WWE Broke In 2021

WWE smashed a ton of promises throughout 2021 - these are the biggest ones!

WWE WrestleMania Crown Jewel Vince McMahon
WWE

WWE's word should be taken with ye olde pinch of salt.

The company produces a lot of content every single week, and there's no real off-season - the WWE machine is non-stop, so it makes sense that they'd fail to deliver on promises occasionally. Yeah, maybe toss "occasionally" on the scrap heap, because Vince McMahon's crew shattered on-screen vows loads throughout 2021.

They did so with typical McMahon gusto, to be fair. Backstage reports from all and sundry, including the likes of Dave Meltzer and Wade Keller, seemed to suggest that promotional plans changed daily. Sometimes, WWE's arrangements changed by the hour. That's maybe fine when it comes to incidental booking, match finishes or title wins, but perhaps not when things have already been explicitly explained on television to fans watching at home.

Then, such broken promises also threaten to break trust in the brand and the people penning content for it.

Sadly, this is something Vince's league does with a quite reckless abandon. Whims are one thing (this is McMahon's business, after all), but the constant goalpost-shifting does nothing for those who, y'know, are actually paying attention.

10. The Old "30 Days" Rule

Shinsuke Nakamura Intercontinental Title
WWE.com

Late-2020 was a hot period for the often-ignored Intercontinental Title.

AJ Styles, Sami Zayn and Jeff Hardy all had great matches. Then, Big E won the strap, and it seemed like WWE would strap a rocket to the New Day man's shoulders and make him a credible champ. Then, Apollo Crews bagged it and things fell of a cliff. That has continued since Shinsuke Nakamura took it from Crews.

Throughout this game of title belt pass the parcel, one thing remained consistent: WWE booked regular IC Title matches. That was partly to fill TV time and partly because the company has always told fans that champs must defend at least once per 30-day period of face being stripped of their prize.

So much for that, eh?

Naka has defended the IC Title exactly once since winning it on 13 August - he beat ex-champion Crews on the 24 September SmackDown. The bloody thing is barely even mentioned at all when Shinsuke is on tellyboxes now. He could've been stripped almost three times over.


9. The Hurt Business Are Done (Or Not)

The Hurt Business
WWE.com

WWE received a ton of flak for kicking Shelton Benjamin and Cedric Alexander out of The Hurt Business on the 29 March Raw, and rightly so. Creative decided to trim Bobby Lashley's stable mere weeks before his titanic WrestleMania 37 clash with Drew McIntyre, and it made no sense.

Shelty B and Cedric went on to have a brief feud (one that revolved around Alexander telling ex-partner Benjamin that he was old, useless and washed up - remember that?) before WWE forgot all about it and decided to put some heaters back beside Lashley.

Magically, come the 27 September Raw, Cedric and Shelton were the best of friends again. They helped Bobby fend off New Day, and THB was...well, back in business. This reunion hasn't really recaptured the group's original fire though. In fact, if anything, it's been a half-arsed attempt.

Why even bother breaking them up and making a big song and dance about it in the first place?


8. MITB = Guaranteed New Star Maker

Nikki A.S.H.
WWE.com

There was a time when winning Money In The Bank signified elite status, or at least an attempt to make the chosen wrestler(s) a permanent part of the top line crew. That's not the case in 2021; MITB is a tired trope that could really do with being shelved, and the winners of this year's versions prove it.

Well, one of them does.

Thus far, it's hard to argue with Big E's push towards the top. He traded MITB for the WWE Title, and has become a long-term focal point on Raw. WWE seem genuinely interested in pushing him for good, which is great, but the same cannot be said for the women's side.

Nikki A.S.H won the briefcase, cashed it in and then held the Raw Women's Title for a measly 33 days. Since then, she's been move out of the title conversation, got plopped in a random tag-team with Rhea Ripley and has been doing lowly jobs aplenty.

That MITB sheen has faded.


7. The ‘Demon’ Is Unbeatable

Finn Balor Demon Roman Reigns
WWE.com

Roman Reigns has burned through everyone this year.

WWE's head boy has beaten Kevin Owens, Daniel Bryan, Edge, Cesaro, Rey Mysterio, John Cena, Brock Lesnar and Big E. He's even toppled the previously-"unbeatable" 'Demon' guise Finn Bálor whisks out for major matches. That win, at Extreme Rules, has wrecked the gimmick's value.

Fans were not chuffed with the supernatural bullsh*t WWE put on during the September headliner. Finn's alter ego survived a pasting from Reigns, seemed to summon demonic forces to overwhelm him and then...fell off the top rope when the turnbuckle collapsed. Seconds later, he'd been beaten.

Wow.

Fans were left scratching their heads at this. The 'Demon' had once been considered a surefire win for Bálor - it was his last resort for big time feuds, and it was supposed to be unstoppable. WWE broke prior promises about that by having Finn effectively job to the actual ring itself at Extreme Rules.


6. Randy Orton's "Permanent Burns"

Randy Orton Mask
WWE

No, that's not Dick 'The Destroyer' Beyer up there. It's one Randy Orton. The current RK-Bro man temporarily sported a mask/some bandages that looked like an old wrestling mask after Alexa Bliss tossed a fireball in his face at Fastlane. Afterwards, WWE's announcers claimed that Randall had suffered "permanent facial scarring and burns".

Or not.

Orton literally wore the mask for a few appearances post-fireball chaos. By the time WrestleMania's blowoff match against Bray Wyatt's 'Fiend' rolled around though? Yeah, he was perfectly fine and showed no signs whatsoever of any "permanent scarring".

Mr. RKO out of nowhere was actually back to his typically-handsome best for the biggest pay-per-view of 2021. Meanwhile, hilariously, Wyatt's previously-chargrilled 'Fiend' had also regenerated to look like the classic version. None of this made a lick of sense, and it kinda made the already-OTT story look like another silly tale full of plot points that didn't really matter.


5. “The One Night A Year WWE Goes Extreme”

Vince McMahon WWE Extreme Rules 2021
WWE

OK, so the word "Extreme" could be subjective...maybe. Objectively though, are matches like the dangerous Hell In A Cell, peril-filled Money In The Bank and other bouts involving cages, tables and more not fitting of that descriptor? Why do WWE insist on pretending that Extreme Rules is something it's not then?

It's not "the one night a year when WWE goes extreme". Not at all.

That fancy pants tagline has become the pay-per-view's go-to however, and that continued in 2021. Michael Cole proudly barked out Vinnie Mac's flashy phrase several times during the show's build. Come the big night, WWE's mind-boggling claims only seemed more out of place amidst other gimmicky lures promoted elsewhere.

It's getting harder and harder to stomach the Extreme Rules lie with each passing year. What was more "Extreme" about a weapons-filled brawl on 26 September than one fans could see on countless episodes of Raw, SmackDown or NXT throughout January-December?


4. HIAC Is Strictly A PPV Attraction

bobby Lashley Xavier Woods
WWE.com

Also, this.

Hell In A Cell shifted from its traditional October slot to June this year. Again, come event time, the commentary teams on both major brands walloped fans in the face with lies. "Hell In A Cell only happens once per year", they beamed.

No it f*cking doesn't. Well, technically the pay-per-view does, but WWE promoted a bunch of other Cell bouts on TV and supershows away from the established HIAC brand. Roman Reigns vs. Rey Mysterio was booked for SmackDown's 18 June episode (two days before the pay-per-view!), and Bobby Lashley vs. Xavier Woods happened 24 hours after HIAC on 21 June.

Then, Edge worked Seth Rollins inside the fearsome cage at Crown Jewel in Saudi Arabia. All of these matches were good, but that doesn't alter the fact that WWE claimed Hell In A Cell was a one-night deal for the company.

B*llocks. Absolute b*llocks. It happened when they felt like it or needed to pop a quick rating.


3. Brand Rosters Are Set For 12 Months

WWE Draft 2021 Sonya Deville Adam Pearce
WWE.com

They do this every single year without fail these days - WWE script the October-November period with mind-numbing thickness, then feign ignorance and throw up garbage like the "Brand-To-Brand Invitational" or Vince's infamous 'Wild Card Rule' when they can't be bothered to see their own ideas through.

It's frankly crap that the WWE Draft happens right before a pay-per-view, Survivor Series, that's supposedly all about loyalty to either Raw or SmackDown. How can wrestlers who have only been on a show's books for six weeks max show unflinching loyalty towards it? Why would they even hate the other show anyway?

Jesus, it's painful booking, and it was agony in 2021.

Adam Pearce and Sonya Deville, like Stephanie McMahon before them last year, decreed that Raw and SmackDown's roster would be ironclad for a solid year following the Draft. Predictably, loads of workers have cross-pollinated since, because of course they have.

They'll continue to do so into 2022.


2. WrestleMania Is Unmatched

Roman Reigns Brock Lesnar Paul Heyman WWE Crown Jewel 2021
WWE.com

WrestleMania has been WWE's annual showcase since 1985. It's given the most hype each year, is clearly-presented as being above every other pay-per-view on the calendar and probably splurges more on pyro in one night than 90% of the roster are paid for 12 months. So, what changed in 2021?

Crown Jewel. That's what.

WWE's first jaunt over to Saudi Arabia since February 2020 was given a pre-show hype machine to rival 'Mania 37. Being honest, the 21 October stadium show in Riyadh was promoted as being equal to or almost superior than the "Grandaddy Of Them All", which felt flat out strange to older fans reared on WrestleMania's pageantry.

Admittedly, Crown Jewel did end up being the best Saudi show to date, but that doesn't really excuse WWE acting like it topped their traditional summit. What the hell happened to 'Mania's standalone lustre?

Why did it have to share that with another unwanted international trip?


1. NXT Is “Triple H’s Baby”

Vince McMahon NXT
WWE

...until it's not.

Vince McMahon and Bruce Prichard performed quite the run in on Triple H's brand, and their influence has changed it immeasurably. NXT's popular blend of ROH-style indy wrestling and counterculture edge has been replaced by the polarising product known as NXT 2.0, and some fans are p*ssed about it.

This transformation flies in the face of what people have been told about NXT for years. "It's Triple H's baby" and, "NXT is a small test market for Trips to flex his management muscles before taking over from Vince someday" are both phrases you'll have heard from other fans and industry critics alike.

Apparently, they weren't true.

NXT 2.0 is nothing like the pulsating show Hunter proudly produced, pre-makeover. It's more like the original reality show from 2010-2012 with some wrestling chucked in, to be honest. Triple H's toes have been firmly stepped on, and there's no going back now.

What other big promises did WWE break in 2021? For more wrestling, check out 10 Things WWE Wants You To Forget About Jeff Hardy and 5 Ups & 6 Downs From WWE SmackDown (Dec 10)!


Contributor

Lifelong wrestling, video game, music and sports obsessive who has been writing about his passions since childhood. Jamie started writing for WhatCulture in 2013, and has contributed thousands of articles and YouTube videos since then. He cut his teeth penning published pieces for top UK and European wrestling read Fighting Spirit Magazine (FSM), and also has extensive experience working within the wrestling biz as a manager and commentator for promotions like ICW on WWE Network and WCPW/Defiant since 2010. Further, Jamie also hosted the old Ministry Of Slam podcast, and has interviewed everyone from Steve Austin and Shawn Michaels to Bret Hart and Trish Stratus.