5 Ups & 3 Downs From WWE SmackDown (May 21)

Aleister Black starts his first SmackDown feud; Seth Rollins "blacks out"; WWE refuse to move on.

Aleister Black
WWE.com

'Back in Black'.

Aleister Black made his first in-person appearance in WWE since moving to SmackDown in last October's Draft. Was it worth the wait? Well, yes, but only if creative follow-up on this first strike by booking Black in memorable matches and feuds from here on out. This was a really good opening salvo though.

Elsewhere on the latest Smackers, Roman Reigns continued his quite stunning character work and Seth Rollins vs. Cesaro looks set to peak at Hell In A Cell. Nothing has been announced for that yet, but it doesn't take a genius to figure out where WWE are going with things; it's either that or an unexpected rematch between Cesaro and Reigns.

Take your pick.

This week's show also had a thumping main event to cap it, but there was some dirt to scrape off the undercard too. Friday night's writers refuse to move on from a feud that outlived its purpose back at WrestleMania, and it seems like a heel tag-team might be set to split too.

Here are all the 'Ups' and the 'Downs' from the latest effort...


Downs...

3. Move On!

Bayley Shayna Baszler Nia Jax
WWE.com

That opening six-woman tag match was as solid as they come, but Shayna Baszler tapping out Natalya only means one thing: WWE aren't quite ready to move on from Nattie and Tamina vs. Shayna and Nia Jax. Oh goody! Seriously though, this is dragging on now.

The company went from that to announcing a Women's Tag Title rematch for Raw. Why? Is there really any demand for yet another match between these two teams? They've only been feuding for a few months, but it feels like this has been going on forever.

WWE need to move on.

There's a real worry that they'll shoehorn Bayley vs. Bianca Belair into the cage for Hell In A Cell too. That rivalry hasn't been heated enough to warrant that (it's had some comedic moments). The female side of SmackDown doesn't look promising.


2. Heading For Splitsville?

Dolph Ziggler Robert Roode Dirty Dawgs Rey Dominik Mysterio
WWE.com

Neither does this though.

'Dem Dirty Dawgs dropped the SmackDown Tag-Team Titles at WrestleMania Backlash last week, then Robert Roode jobbed to Dominik Mysterio in a short match here. Things do not look good for Roode and Dolph Ziggler - it wouldn't be a shocker if they start arguing soon.

That's WWE's go to booking for tags once they lose the straps. The company seem incapable of penning two tag feuds at once too, meaning the Dawgs could be headed for splitsville. That's be a damn shame, because they've been a consistent highlight on TV this year. They must stick together.

The Mysterio clan can feud with Alpha Academy (or The Usos longer term) without having to split the Dirty Dawgs. If anything, Dolph and Bobby should find themselves some other babyfaces to clash with in the interim. That's what a division is.


1. Where Do We Go From Here?

Rick Boogz Shinsuke Nakamura
WWE.com

Shinsuke Nakamura has been getting one over on 'King' Corbin for a few weeks now. He stole his crown, beat him and is now playing the numbers game against the heel by introducing a new ally. In short, there isn't much scope for this story to really go anywhere other than down.

Heel revenge from Corbin would be an unsatisfying end.

Rick Boogz/Boogs (some sites are spelling it differently, presumably due to Rick's old kayfabe surname "Bugez") vs. Corbin could be a neat way to introduce the electric guitar-playing newbie as an in-ring act, but how far would that stretch things? The answer is...not very far.

Sadly, this could end up being one of those dreaded 'On A Pole' situations at HIAC or something. WWE might hang the crown high above the ring and get two 'Kings' to joust over it. That'd keep the string of weird gimmick matches going ("Nigerian Drum Fight" and zombie lumberjacks).


Ups...

5. The Elitist Champion

Paul Heyman Tamina Natalya
WWE.com

This was the right call.

Realistically, an arrogant mega-heel like Roman Reigns wouldn't be seen hanging around with all the other champions on SmackDown. He'd consider himself above that, and would logically send Paul Heyman out to explain why he wasn't there. So, it's a good thing that WWE went that route.

Some may argue that this sh*ts from an almighty height onto all the other champs, but they're background noise to the Universal Title scene anyway. It's not like anybody considers Dominik Mysterio or Tamina to be competition for Roman - that's not a knock, it's just the truth.

Everybody worked this segment well. Sonya Deville was inoffensive, Apollo Crews got to cut a nice promo, it led to a fun match (albeit one with an annoying ending) and Heyman was on top form. To be fair, that's a given from Paul E.


4. Roman Guilt-Tripping Jey Uso

Roman Reigns Jey Uso
WWE

The family drama continued between Roman Reigns and Jimmy Uso when Jey informed his 'Tribal Chief' that he'd be wrestling alongside his brother next week. When Jey said 'we", Reigns kinda' lost it. Then, like a magnificent bastard, Roman deployed more mental manipulation on his 'Right Hand Man'.

He said that "we" meant them, not Jimmy. This mental torture is something Reigns does so well in these segments, and the slow-burn feel to an inevitable split from both brothers is welcome. Being honest, it is almost time to cut Jey free and let him waltz off into the tag division with Jimmy.

That's where they'd be most effective.

The Usos can be Roman's reps in the tag leagues if WWE wish, but it might be better if they end Jey's association with Roman full stop. That tale is starting to hang on for dear life a bit now that Jimmy is back on screens weekly.


3. Seth Rollins Is Obsessed

Seth Rollins Cesaro
WWE.com

Things just got weird.

Seth Rollins claimed that he "blacked out" and doesn't remember attacking Cesaro at ringside. Then, contradicting himself, Rollins shouted at a downed Cesaro as the face was wheeled away on a stretcher; he asked why Cesaro is making him act this way.

It's all a little far-fetched, but there's some silver lining: Cesaro vs. Rollins is intense enough as a feud to work inside the cage at Hell In A Cell. They've already excelled at 'Mania, and they'd do so again if they were handed 20-25 minutes in the structure on 20 June and asked to keep making Cesaro look like a viable headline threat.

Seth's obsessive behaviour is workable provided he doesn't delve too deep into that side of things. Nobody needs to see him become borderline Bray Wyatt-like, or go all stalker-ish like it's 2001, he's called DDP and he just jumped over from WCW.


2. That Main Event

Kevin Owens Sami Zayn Apollo Crews Commander Azeez
WWE.com

SmackDown was pretty much a one match show, at least when it comes to what it offered in-ring. The main event Fatal-4-Way for the Intercontinental Title was an all-action cracker that showed what happens when WWE put four guys this talented inside the ring, give them some time and let them structure the match themselves.

This was good. Damn good.

Everyone was fired up, and the finishing stretch (in particular) is the kind that'll play before booming crowd noise when WWE re-introduce fans to TV in mid-July. This is exactly the kind of bout they need to put on that 16 July edition of SmackDown - it'd rock the house.

Apollo Crews filled the cowardly/lucky heel quota, Sami Zayn desperately tried to regain his baby and had some great spots, Kevin Owens looked like a million bucks generally and Big E would've won had it not been for Aleister Black's return. That leads nicely onto...


1. Aleister Black

Aleister Black Big E Apollo Crews
WWE.com

...what could be a nice midcard feud.

Aleister Black's fourth 'Tales Of The Dark Father' vignette was the strongest one yet. He also carries some mystique again after randomly attacking Big E. Now, Black can justify his salty actions and everyone can look forward to some surely-awesome matches between the pair at HIAC and beyond.

This is similar in some respects to Cesaro vs. Seth Rollins, or could be. The roles are reversed between heel and baby, sure, but WWE will want Black to put E over as a major star without sacrificing himself in the process. That's pretty much what's happening elsewhere, and it's a formula WWE should try more of.

Eventual losers don't need to tumble back down the card afterwards - nobody needs to look useless, put it that way. It remains to be seen if Aleister will peter out like he has before, but this was a really strong start to life on SmackDown.

It's about time.

What did you think of this week's WWE SmackDown? For more, check out 10 Wrestlers Who Survived The Impossible and 21 Things You Probably Missed From WWE Raw (May 17)!


Contributor

Lifelong wrestling, video game, music and sports obsessive who has been writing about his passions since childhood. Jamie started writing for WhatCulture in 2013, and has contributed thousands of articles and YouTube videos since then. He cut his teeth penning published pieces for top UK and European wrestling read Fighting Spirit Magazine (FSM), and also has extensive experience working within the wrestling biz as a manager and commentator for promotions like ICW on WWE Network and WCPW/Defiant since 2010. Further, Jamie also hosted the old Ministry Of Slam podcast, and has interviewed everyone from Steve Austin and Shawn Michaels to Bret Hart and Trish Stratus.