5 Ups & 3 Downs From WWE SmackDown (May 5)
Bad Bunny = WWE main eventer; Bianca Belair needs help; Puerto Rico is hot.
This week's SmackDown was a 'get in and get the f*ck out' kind of broadcast.
WWE were tactical with the show though. It beamed live from the same José Miguel Agrelot Coliseum that'll host Saturday's Backlash pay-per-view, and it told those in charge one thing: Puerto Rico is hot for company action. Those people were loud all night, and they'll be on fire come the PLE 24 hours after this functional episode.
"Functional" suggests it was bland, but that's not true. Triple H's creative team worked hard to make SmackDown look good post-Draft (with one baffling exception), and the LWO seems to have a real chance of becoming something more than just a vehicle for Rey Mysterio's WCW nostalgia coming out of this.
Cody Rhodes was here, fan service was a general rule of thumb, and Bad Bunny even teased what's to come at Backlash. It wasn't all good stuff though. Bianca Belair still feels like she's killing time despite moving brands, and that aforementioned baffling decision neutered someone Hunter reportedly plans on pushing.
Here's all the good and bad from WWE's final pit stop before Backlash.
Downs...
3. 4 From Raw And 4 From…SmackDown?!
Michael Cole made a huge deal out of the World Heavyweight Title tournament including an equal share of wrestlers from both top brands. Erm...doesn't that crap on the whole point of this being Raw's very own World Title?! WWE are making a lot of noise about Roman Reigns and his belts being SmackDown-exclusive, so this is coming across rather odd.
Fans already know a SmackDown guy isn't winning this thing, so why the bluff?
Of course, there could be more post-Draft moving and shaking to come, but that'll aim another bullet at the concept's credibility. If someone on SmackDown wins then moves to Raw by default, the company will make their own Draft look useless. Some consistency isn't much to ask.
Straight up: Raw should dominate this tourney. In fact, there shouldn't be anyone from the blue side involved. They already have two World Titles to fight for as it is, and definitely don't need to be bleeding over onto the red side.
2. An Unconvincing Last-Minute Sell
It still doesn't sit right that Bianca Belair is holding the Raw Women's Title on SmackDown. The whole thing is messy and was avoidable, much like Rhea Ripley winning the SmackDown gold at WrestleMania then ending up on Mondays. WWE literally created this scenario.
Belair's segment with Damage CTRL, Liv Morgan and Raquel Rodriguez was a bit weak, and it didn't do anything to convince fans that IYO SKY has a hope in hell vs. Bianca at Backlash. Some of WWE's female feuds are super-lukewarm. Worse, they're typically over by the time they'd start heating up.
This feels so stock and like a total afterthought.
IYO got a few licks in when Belair was distracted, but was akin to the fly that somehow got in your bedroom window and can't find a way back out again. That's not good, people. Most of Bianca's rivalries have been a tough sell, and this is the classic example of that.
1. Karrion Kross Needed That More
Sorry, but it's stupid to put Shinsuke Nakamura over Karrion Kross right now.
These guys had a decent match, but the result left a bad taste in this fan's mouth. Every other SmackDown draftee won out over soon-to-be-Raw stars. Y'know, everyone except Karrion. He came up just short again, and Scarlett looked like a doofus for refusing to get involved when it mattered most.
Shinsuke could've been easily reheated over on Raw post-defeat, but where the flying f*ck does Karrion go from here? He's looking every bit the midcard jobber to the stars. Remember this if Triple H wants to hype him up with a few squash wins soon - it's coming close to 'too little, too late' for him.
Kross has turned into heel Bray Wyatt 2K23. He makes grandiose promises in unnerving pre-match promises, then rarely comes through come match time. Yours truly understands that Nakamura will probs go far in the World Title tournament, but yeah. Karrion deserves better.
Ups...
5. Smash Mouth Tag Fun
Onto the positives.
The OC vs. Viking Raiders started fairly slow, but it had the physicality you'd want from a bout between both teams and the live crowd definitely elevated it (more on them later). Here's hoping both squads can actually thrive on their respective brands post-Draft, although you've got to be worried for Erik and Ivar.
AJ Styles should get a nice pat on the back for his performance as a guest commentator too. Most guests at the broadcast table take away from the match you're watching, but not AJ. He added to it with passionate analysis, and even found time to put himself in the hunt for singles gold.
WWE could likely do with splitting the Tag-Team Titles into two distinct sets again so it gives teams like The OC something to fight for. Luke Gallows and Karl Anderson are ultra-reliable in this sort of spot though, and they feel legit fresh on Fridays.
4. Another Good Tag Match
SmackDown was a fine show if you're into doubles action.
The Street Profits vs. Imperium was similarly-well worked. It included a nice jump start moment from Ludwig Kaiser and Giovanni Vinci that gave the bout immediate energy; then, Montez Ford and Angelo Dawkins eased their way back into things before taking the crowd-popping win via Montez' stunning frog splash.
It's hard to argue with this kind of quality. However, and this is the most minor of minor gripes, it'd be nice to see Imperium pick up a few more wins here or there without GUNTHER in the house. Kaiser and Vinci are a damn good duo, and they'd have a scorcher opposite Sami Zayn and Kevin Owens if creative fancied it.
Bonus points go to The Profits for giving Imperium enough that they didn't come across as a 'Z list' tag, and to Vinci for some neat work on the ropes. That was borderline Rey Fenix-esque, which is a big compliment to the guy.
3. Cody Rhodes’ Conviction
Was Cody Rhodes' promo about Brock Lesnar the kind of must-see pay-per-view build the classic PLEs have? No, not really. Did it add a fresh layer on top of what's expected to be a spirited brawl? Again, nah. So, why it is featured in the 'Ups' crowd at all?
You believe in Cody when he's on it like this, that's why.
It appeared his speech might fall a wee bit flat at first, but it turned into a nice piece of build towards his Backlash bout vs. Brock. Best of all, WWE didn't need to waste a Lesnar booking by having him march out to explain why he'd attacked Rhodes in the first place. Cody did the hard yards for him.
Rhodes said he'd "beat it out of" Brock 24 hours after SmackDown. That was the only line anyone needed from this, and it'll be a blessing to the production staff when they're working through the night readying pay-per-view vignettes.
Good work, that Nightmare.
2. The Crowd
Right, time to shower Puerto Rico with praise.
They were red hot for everything on Friday night, and they kept the energy up where other crowds would've sagged. There's an argument to be made for WWE shaking up the product by playing before more markets they don't visit often, especially with TV. Even the reworked SmackDown aisle way added to the presentation.
SmackDown looked vibrant, alive and altogether dazzling compared to the samey big-tron setups you're accustomed to. In the stands, people cheered, booed and made noise for everyone who strolled through the curtain. That makes one heck of a difference when you're watching back home.
An opening segment involving the LWO and Judgment Day was precisely what San Juan needed to get onboard. Plus, Dominik Mysterio hit a cheap shot on Rey right at the end of the skit, and that got some real heat.
Great crowd, and smart formatting.
1. That Show-Ending Angle
Rhea Ripley and Dominik vs. Rey Mysterio and Zelina Vega was a nice blend between one of 'Mania's featured matches and one of Backlash's treats to come. Being totally honest though, it couldn't hold a candle to the show-closing angle that saw Bad Bunny lead the LWO into battle against Judgment Day.
Those stables brawled, and Bunny entered the ring with a kendo stick to confront Damian Priest. Man, the crowd was all over this. Nobody could blame WWE for calling an audible (assuming Cody vs. Brock is the headliner going in) and main-eventing Backlash with the 'San Juan Street Fight' instead.
Puerto Rico badly wants to see Bunny cave Priest's skull in with that weapon, and they'll be amped up for more violence by the time Backlash goes live. Simple angles like this one go a long way when they're played out in front of the right audience.
What did you think of this week's WWE SmackDown? For more wrestling, check out WWE Backlash 2023: 10 Things That Must Happen, WWE Backlash 2023: 10 Nightmares That Could Come True and 10 New Directions For WWE After The 2023 Draft!