5 Ups & 4 Downs From AEW Dark (Jan 19)

Sammy Guevara, Luchasaurus, Top Flight, and Santana and Ortiz shine in Tuesday showcases.

Luchasaurus Brandon Cutler
AEW

What should we expect from All Elite Wrestling this week? Middling ratings, that's for certain. Joe Biden's inauguration as President of the United States will lead to another night of television dominated by news coverage, and it's already established that these things have a bigger impact than Dynamite than NXT. The numbers will almost certainly underwhelm at first glance.

The Dynamite card looks solid without anything that immediately grabs the attention. Cody Rhodes is in action against a guy whose last singles bout on TNT was in November 2019. Jon Moxley will squash a jobber. Brodie Lee Jr.'s birthday celebration will be lovely, endearing, and essential, while the Inner Circle's three-way tag should push them closer to all-out civil war, particularly if Chris Jericho and MJF win.

Dark, meanwhile, came loaded with some of the biggest names you can reasonably expect to see on the YouTube series. The Lucha Brothers, Santana and Ortiz, Sammy Guevara, and Scorpio Sky were all present and correct. There was also a strong focus on mid-level tag teams, with Chaos Project, The Acclaimed, and Top Flight all given showcase spots.

Bumped back up to two hours this week, much of Dark was typical - though the show definitely peaked higher than usual.

Let's light the fuse...


Downs...

4. The Skippables

Nick Comoroto Scorpio Sky
AEW

This week's list of skippable Dark pseudo squashes:-

Gunn Club vs. RYZIN, Adam Priest, and Vary Morales

Ivelisse and Diamante vs. Tesha Price and Katalina Perez

Big Swole vs. Alex Gracia

Scorpio Sky vs. Nick Comoroto

Private Party vs. Aaron Solow and Lee Johnson

Zack Clayton vs. Sonny Kiss

The usual disclaimer applies here. While these bouts weren't necessarily bad, their formulaic, repetitive layouts make them tough to recommend to all but die-hard fans of the performers. Skip 'em if you aren't particularly invested.


3. Blunt Meat Cleavers

The Butcher and The Blade
AEW

A rare miss for The Butcher and The Blade here, as they were made to work their way past Mike Verna and Baron Black, only overcoming the enhancement talents when The Bunny hopped onto the apron for a referee distraction.

Finishes like this rarely resonate well, particularly in the clean finish haven that is AEW. This one contrasts with FTR vs. Jurassic Express, which felt more like a couple of *ssholes cheating not because they had to, but because they felt like it. Here, Butcher and Blade looked like they needed the interference to win.

Couple this with an overly competitive match layout that did little to elevate the bruisers, and you're left with one of the tandem's less effective squashes. They should have carved right through these guys in this scenario.


2. Shanna vs. Marti Daniels Falls Apart

Shanna AEW
AEW

She's a very solid pro wrestler, Shanna, but her match with Marti Daniels was blighted by a bad finish that saw the veteran nail a Tiger Suplex on Daniels for what looked like the match-ending pinfall. Daniels' shoulders weren't properly down, though, meaning they had to break up, stand up, and repeat the exact same spot awkwardly for the win, undermining any rub gained from the victory.

This pseudo squash wasn't great heading towards the cumbersome finish either, with Daniels' mid-match trash talk cumbersome and distracting, making for a stodgy layout.


1. PPA, No Way

Peter Avalon
AEW

Pretty Peter's Pageant Provocation is going to the next level. The Walk Off will see "three pretty judges" run their eyes over a competitive catwalk strut, with Avalon calling Lee Johnson out as his first opponent after handing the Nightmare Family affiliate an 8x10 last week.

Johnson and Avalon will determine who is the better man via fashion show. Here's a radical idea: how about a wrestling match instead?

Avalon is charismatic and pulls this goofy character off better than most would, but this gimmicky non-comedy is the exact kind of content AEW should be veering away from in the quest to find a more cohesive tone in 2021. At least it's going down on Dark, not Dynamite.


Ups...

5. Squishy Squashy

Santana AEW
AEW

Santana and Ortiz squashed Jon Cruz and Danny Limelight with next to no fuss and it was perfect. Bullying and controlling throughout, they brushed off token offense from Limelight, smacked Cruz out of the skies (he never tagged in, only intervened) and put Danny out of his misery in little over a minute, which is as long as this bout needed to be.

The Inner Circle duo fought with big chips on their shoulders ahead of tonight's tag team three-way. In-character, they have major points to prove right now, so expect this mood to carry over into Dynamite.


4. SNAKEMAN's Had Enough

Serpentico Rey Fenix
AEW

Chaos Project's offensive style is starting to grate on Serpentico, with SNAKEMAN starting to get annoyed with Luther for throwing him around the ring like an infantryman would launch a grenade. This played into last night's main event with Lucha Brothers. Serp kept protesting Luther's sluggishness, as each hurts him almost as much as it hurts the opponent, giving the bout a neat story point to build around.

Beyond this, the bout was roughly what you'd expect. Fast-flowing, fun, and fluid, particularly when Serpentico was in with Fenix and/or Penta, it was one of the most enjoyable things on this two-hour card. SNAKEMAN ate the pin following the double stomp/package piledriver combo.


3. Midcard Tag Teams Show Off

The Acclaimed
AEW

Two of AEW's lower-level tag teams took their opportunities to shine last night. It started with Top Flight, who faced the debuting AJ Kirsch and KC Navarro, who looks like an effective heel. Though the enhancement wrestlers were given a couple of windows to show what they can do, the bout was mostly a canvas for the Martin brothers to once again showcase their in-ring creativity. They did that, taking the W via High Stack roll-up.

Later, we got The Acclaimed's most impressive Dark showing to date. Max Caster's bars were even on point, as he rapped on pouring water on Fuego Del Sol, before they got to working their opponents over in a straightforward but effective bout that finished when Anthony Bowens tagged in for the Critically Acclaimed and the 1-2-3.

A division as stacked as this can make it hard for lower-ranked teams to rack wins up outwith the immediate title picture. It's good to see Dark fulfilling this role.


2. Dragon vs. Dinosaur

Luchasaurus Brandon Cutler
AEW

Dragon vs. Dinosaur is a ridiculous concept, even in professional wrestling, but these are mere aesthetic concepts for two relatively traditional performers. Brandon Cutler is a high-flyer, Luchasaurus is an agile big man with immense power. It's a simple stylistic clash and these two worked it well.

This was a cracking Dark opener. Cutler started hot, going for an immediate pin. He paid for this. Luchasaurus bashed Brandon around ringside and kicked him over the barricade, working like he was punishing Cutler for his earlier insolence. Cutler's slipperiness and superior speed carved him several openings, as they should have, and he bumped like a trooper to make Luchasaurus' work look extra starchy.

His eight-match winning streak came to an end here, but this was one of Cutler's more impressive AEW performances. Strong stuff from both men.


1. Guevara's Trip Down Under Almost Goes Wrong

Sammy Guevara
AEW

El Australiano was once a rising prospect in AAA as Australian Suicide, so last night's match with Sammy Guevara was a good opportunity to see what he's capable of, particularly as there wasn't too much to last week's tag.

It turned out to be the best thing on the show. Though it began with trash talk and taunts, Australiano soon took control with his flashy lucha libre style. 'The Spanish God' is highly adept in this realm. Though Australiano worked him over for much for the first half, he looked right at home when tasked with matching his opponent's dives and flippydoos, turning the tide by countering one on the outside.

One rough landing for Australiano off his sideways Moonsault, this was as big a triumph as you could expect from two fun wrestlers in a six-minute bout on AEW's B-show. A solid promo in which Guevara claimed he was carrying Dark and Dynamite with a growing chip on his shoulder rounded it off.


Channel Manager
Channel Manager

Andy has been with WhatCulture for 10 years and is currently WhatCulture's Wrestling Channel Manager. A writer, presenter, and editor with 10+ years of experience in online media, he has been a sponge for all wrestling knowledge since playing an old Royal Rumble 1992 VHS to ruin in his childhood. Having previously worked for Bleacher Report, Andy specialises in short and long-form writing, video presenting, voiceover acting, and editing, all characterised by expert wrestling knowledge and commentary. Andy is as much a fan of 1985 Jim Crockett Promotions as he is present-day AEW and WWE - just don't make him choose between the two.