5 Ups & 4 Downs From AEW Dynamite (April 17 - Results & Review)

Why was it difficult to FEEL something about a very good Dynamite?

Jon Moxley IWGP
AEW

It's time for AEW to make like Jade Cargill, and cut the s***. What the hell has happened to the promotion over the last few weeks?!

CM Punk happened.

He spoke candidly about his time in the promotion in an interview with Ariel Helwani, and in response, to the detriment of the Dynasty build, Tony Khan suffered catastrophic head loss. He dispatched Adam Copeland to cut a babyface rah-rah speech on Dynamite a few weeks ago, and it was awful: almost word-for-word a pathetic "Just enjoy wrestling guys!" engagement bait post on X.

Then, as announced after night one of WrestleMania 40 in a bid to steal focus from it, Khan vowed to show the footage of CM Punk losing it at Wembley stadium in his infamous altercation with Jack Perry. And he did. And it led to - Jesus Christ - a babyface rah-rah speech, cut by Dax Harwood, talking about how "great" AEW is. Punk, now a top star in WWE again, looked like an unhinged madman - but also, at the same time, the most compelling and must-see man in a company with which he's no longer employed.

In and of itself, Will Ospreay's response to Paul Levesque was justified - Ospreay has worked as hard as anyone and was incredibly diplomatic about his talks with WWE - but on the same show, it reeked of AEW being gotten-to.

AEW cannot sanction that WWE is white-hot and generating critical acclaim. What was once a fun exercise in poking the bear and smirking at WWE's general awfulness is now becoming a sad and defensive display. AEW badly needs to learn how to exist without WWE. The paradigm has shifted.

Did AEW concentrate on selling its own, supposedly important pay-per-view last night...?


Downs...

4. Women's Match Was Just There

Deonna Purrazzo Mariah May
AEW

Mariah May Vs. Deonna Purrazzo was mostly solid and uninspiring, a backdrop for a heavily signposted storyline development.

Deonna is ether costing Rosa the match against Toni Storm at Dynasty or completing the full turn very shortly afterwards - and, given Deonna's unimpressive showing at Revolution, that programme isn't going to be the centrepiece of the division. This was at least tighter and more snug than some of Deonna's TV matches, since May is well-versed in laying it in and doesn't shy away when it's her turn to take it, and only threatened to fall apart once: when May tried to float over a powerbomb attempt and send Deonna into the corner before falling awkwardly halfway through the attempt. She still got a pop with the resulting Hip Attack before Deonna won suddenly with a flash pin.

She'd only just taken May's closing play, which informed the shock but did little else. There's plenty of time to build Mariah as a featured act in the division. Conversely, is time running out for Purrazzo already?

In her defence, it doesn't seem as though she's being encouraged to work her preferred style. Precious little of her marches are wrestled on the mat. Still, she seems to be following the path of Saraya and Tyra Valkyrie: a name star brought in to much fanfare who hasn't met the in-ring standard.

In the post-match, Thunder Rosa daubed lipstick all over Toni Storm. It was a bad revenge angle. Just beat her up.


3. Be Bold

Orange Cassidy Shayne Taylor
AEW

"Shane Taylor Promotions have become a force in AEW, no doubt" said Excalibur after Orange Cassidy defeated Shayne Taylor. Why bother adding to the stable if they're just going to continue to lose? What does that accomplish?

Cassidy Vs. Taylor was well done in and of itself. Orange twisting out of a suplex attempt to hit the Stundog Millionaire was a superb counter that put over his babyface fire and intelligence, but Cassidy endured Taylor and the interference of Lee Moriarty and Anthony Ogogo on the outside, which was booking cowardice. It had been established that Cassidy was without friends on the night (to have made this clearer, AEW perhaps shouldn't have made him tag with 80% off the roster last year).

At a minimum, Trent should have cost him the win; that way, the Best Friends split would have been advanced, and Shayne Taylor Promotions might have at least masqueraded as a threat. It's not as if the stable is a main event concern, but they have to win at times so that beating them means something. As it happens, they exist to facilitate other developments as a pure contrivance. It's a shame.

There is a great deal of talent across the dynamic of the group. Khan is too afraid to beat certain wrestlers even when it makes zero sense - on two levels - for them to win.


2. Where's The Emotion?

Samoa Joe Swerve Strickland
AEW

It's difficult to watch Cody Rhodes Vs. Roman Reigns and sense that something is amiss in AEW.

AEW has attempted, over its short history, a more layered and sophisticated way of telling stories. The promotion has excelled at old-fashioned good versus evil - Cody Vs. Chris Jericho, Cody Vs. MJF - but reached unreal artistic peaks with Kenny Omega Vs. Hangman Page and MJF Vs. CM Punk. At times, Page wasn't a true babyface, nor was MJF entirely irredeemable, but by the time of the final show-down, you knew who you wanted to root for, who deserved to be avenged. That emotional thrust is badly missing from AEW in 2024. Where the layers once built fan investment, now they're just making a mess.

Swerve Strickland Vs. Samoa Joe is basically a feud between two not very upstanding dudes whom the crowd deem cool regardless. There's no engaging contrast there. It's not a great story. Meanwhile, the Blackpool Combat Club continues to be baffling and off-putting.

Jon Moxley mentioned that he hates Don Callis. They were aligned last year!

Jon Moxley cut a pure babyface promo at the start of the show. Like a good guy, he stuck up for his mate Bryan Danielson and vowed revenge on Powerhouse Hobbs for the Don Callis Family's post-match attack on the BCC last Saturday. Then, in the main event, babyface Family member Will Ospreay, managed by heel Don Callis, defeated Claudio Castagnoli, who is in the BCC, a group that is feuding with the heel Callis Family. Claudio wasn't a full-blown heel, exactly, but was at a minimum unsportsmanlike at various points. He jumped Will at the start of the match and later targeted his eyes. You could argue that he identifies Ospreay as a Don Callis guy, even though Ospreay is destined to split from him, but it's just messy. It could be so much cleaner and more effective. There's nothing close to a Dusty/Flair dynamic in AEW right now.

This isn't "people are complicated" storytelling, the likes of which worked to wonderful effect when AEW explored Hangman Page's defensiveness, or MJF's ability to be redeemed. It's just a convoluted mess. It's been a mess for a while. Consider the main event of Collision. Don Callis wanted Kyle Fletcher and Powerhouse Hobbs to fight Claudio and Danielson in order to soften Bryan up ahead of Dynasty. He also had each member of the Family wrestle Ospreay so that Will could be as sharp as possible. What?

What's the difference?

It's not as if those Callis Family derbies weren't violent. Hobbs smashed Ospreay on the steel steps. What was that, if not an attempt to maim someone beyond the code of an exhibition?

The contradictions are stupid, the storytelling in the upper midcard is detached from real emotion, and the most basic foundations of pro wrestling are missing.

It's impossible to truly care no matter how great the action is.


1. Chris Jericho Gets His PPV Match

HOOK Chris Jericho
AEW

In a match nobody wants to see, Chris Jericho set up his mandatory pay-per-view arrangement with HOOK in a face-to-face segment moderated by Taz.

Jericho "coined" the "Jericho Vortex" and claimed that, if only HOOK would listen, he could follow the career paths of MJF, Orange Cassidy, and Daniel Garcia - lol - by sitting under his learning tree. Hilariously, Jericho didn't mention Sammy Guevara. Jericho has mentored him for almost as long as WCW Nitro existed and Guevara is a panda bear head away from being in the exact same position. He's actually worse off, if anything. There's a stigma where there was once potential. The idea to implement Taz here was clever, mind.

Jericho dressed him down, saying that if he'd done a half-decent job bringing up his son, HOOK might not be so insolent. HOOK - with a really well-timed deadpan - at last refused Jericho's help. He doesn't need it. This sparked further tension between Taz and Jericho. Taz got shoved into the ropes. This sparked an elusive emotional response from HOOK, who told Jericho to get out of his ring. It was announced later in the broadcast that they'll meet at Dynasty. Of course they will. Jericho needs the spotlight even if, audibly, nobody in the arena cares week to week.

This angle did get more over than his matches of late, to be very fair - but the handling of Jericho continues to be obligatory and spineless. This was a half-OK angle with no merit nor heat.

You have to wonder how Khan feels about this deep down.


Ups...

5. Weirdly Effective Opening Match

Julia Hart Willow Nightingale
AEW

The AEW base appears to have very much taken to Adam Copeland. The rah-rah speeches might have worked, but you'd hope his lovingly crafted series with Christian Cage informed the reaction he received last night.

He was meant to face Brody King alongside Willow Nightingale, but his tag partner was laid out before the bell rang in a continuation of a new mystery storyline in AEW's women's division. Copeland himself was blindsided by Brody King, whose heat sequence was as meaty and as fun as ever. Copeland's comeback generated a volume so loud that even Tony Schiavone was taken aback - and nearly five years in, incidentally, his genuine sense of wonder is the lifeblood of the promotion.

Copeland measured it well and played it to the back row. He attempted several times to remove King from his feet. His facial expressions elevated an incredibly simple match structure: Copeland looked as though he couldn't believe that he eventually did it. Copeland did a lot using his broad but evidently effective body language to portray King as a tough match.

Willow eventually entered the ring, and in an awesome sequence flew into Brody with a splash and then a cannonball. AEW isn't the most disciplined of promotions generally, but Tony Khan has largely preserved the inter-gender match and the pop of a thoroughly unexpected ass-kicking. With great dramatic timing, Hart struck Willow with the chain before applying Hartless, at which point the ref called it. Khan usually blends two programmes into one tag on a go-home show.

This was a neat and very fun tweak on the method: King and Nightingale had displayed chemistry with their interactions on Collision previously, and this was the first time that the TNT and TBS champions had each participated in the same match.


4. World Title Scene Is Good, Not Great (Again)

Swerve Strickland Samoa Joe
AEW

The World title scene continued its flat trajectory: it was good, not great, and unless an in-ring masterpiece is imminent, Swerve Strickland Vs. Samoa Joe will not be remembered as a classic programme. They are two cool wrestlers, working what ultimately is a basic plot, saying the same things to one another over and over and over again. Joe doesn't think Swerve is capable of winning the World title. Swerve on the contrary believes it to be his destiny. This thing is on a loop, and they're both tweeners, more or less. There is little in the way of emotional thrust, and it's dragging.

As unengaging as the content is at this point, Swerve and Joe are still cool, which is an all too rare quality in wrestling. They are carrying this C+/B- tier stuff through their snarls, threats and demeanour. After a pair of familiar-sounding sit-down interviews, Swerve offered to meet Joe in the middle of the ring.

Joe accepted the request in the main event overrun segment, but a fleet of security guards held him back. In a moment that was brilliant and silly at the same time - or brilliant because it was silly - Swerve hit two of them with an avalanche stomp and all of them went flying. Despite the presence of Prince Nana as a distraction - Swerve is the babyface here in yet another messy and flawed character alignment - Joe got the better of him and held the World title aloft to close the show.

That title needs to change hands on Sunday - but, with Will Ospreay waiting, is Khan about to strap up his second consecutive transitional champion?


3. Jon Moxley Reminds Everybody Who He Is

Jon Moxley IWGP
AEW

Jon Moxley cut a rousing babyface promo to begin Dynamite, in which be ultimately challenged Powerhouse Hobbs to a match on Dynamite next week.

This felt restorative.

Mox has spent much too long barrelling between midcard programmes and character alignments as an almost drab tweener. Here, he tapped into his best role. Mox is the babyface on which you can rely, the lead with an awesome grasp of the badass one-liner, the guy who actually endorses AEW when he puts it over. It was another smallish crowd lurking quietly behind that eyesore of an LED barricade. The aesthetic and the atmosphere really isn't what it once was, but when the new IWGP World champion raised the temperature in the building and put over his graft and determination and the scope of his accomplishment, the fans chanted AE-dub so loudly that it almost felt like 2021 again.

The content wasn't outstanding - if anything, his talk of dragging Hobbs into "deep waters" was an echo of every other wrestling promo cut over the last however many years - but the belief and star aura that powered it was strong.

Mox should be doing something like this every week.


2. The Elite Continue To Elevate The Show

The Elite Continental
AEW

The Elite Vs. PAC, Penta El Zero Miedo and Daniel Garcia was a very fun match.

The Young Bucks have experimented with a more methodical in-ring style since taking on the EVP gimmick, but this was a more lively and immediate affair than their recent televised output. Instead of stalling, Matthew Jackson sought to generate heat by grabbing a microphone and performing live commentary. This was a good, in-character bit. The higher-up arrogant to think he can do it all was ultimately made a fool of when Garcia, around whom much of this match was plotted, spiked him on his head. Matthew's last-ditch apology was really well-timed.

PAC stormed the ring to blast the Bucks with a pair of Germans. The Bucks bumped themselves daft for this salvo, grasping that PAC needed to look like a killer to appear a threat to Okada's Continental title. The interaction between PAC and Okada was kept brief, as it should have been.

Each man despite being world class has a tendency to stay in a low gear for too long. This tiny glimpse however promised an explosive in-ring dynamic. As lively as the match was, it didn't descend into a party. In fact, the Bucks were exceptional at removing their opponents from the fray just as the action escalated into a state of heart-pounding exhilaration.

This was a formality of a maintenance win, well-measured and exciting but not too exciting, but an effort was made to protect Garcia in defeat. He was laid out by a Superkick party and Rainmaker combination.

In the post-match, Okada and the Bucks continued to beat up Garcia before PAC ran them off with the hammer.


1. Main Event RULES

Will Ospreay Claudio Castagnoli
AEW

Will Ospreay Vs. Claudio Castagnoli was - by the finish - a fantastic "banger".

They probably have an even better match in them, and another barely passable gate didn't help the lack of big fight feel, but this was awesome when it peaked. It took the form of a shoot-out, as expected. Claudio did attempt to focus his attack on Ospreay's ribs, but this beat mostly dissolved under the wave of back-and-forth action packed in the second half of the match. It was almost as good as you'd have expected, had you set your expectations sky-high.

In one of several incredible feats of power and agility, Ospreay used his core strength to sit up when trapped in Claudio's swing and rock him with a spinning DDT. Ospreay's hurricanrana reversal from the Ricola bomb was astonishing as well. Ospreay has worked better white-knuckle, how-is-this-even-physically-possible matches - but this was still a cracking time. It's easy to lose perspective. There were at least three moments in this match in which it was impossible to comprehend the supernatural execution.

In the post-match, the Family and the BCC brawled as Ospreay expressed rage and disbelief at the conduct of his stable. How does he not know what they're about at this point?

AEW has done a pretty wonky job of booking Will as a babyface and adhering to storyline continuity at the same time. A big tidy-up operation must be performed after Dynasty. The character dynamics are shot. Contrast is pivotal in money-drawing personal issues.

AEW lost sight of that ages ago.


Contributor
Contributor

Michael Sidgwick (Creative Writing BA Hons) is an editor, writer and podcaster for WhatCulture Wrestling. With over a decade of experience in wrestling analysis, Michael was published in the influential UK institution that was Power Slam magazine, and specialises in providing insights into All Elite Wrestling - so much so that he wrote a book about the subject. You can order Becoming All Elite: The Rise Of AEW on Amazon. Possessing a deep knowledge also of WWE, WCW, ECW and New Japan Pro Wrestling, Michael’s work has been publicly praised by AEW World Champions Kenny Omega and MJF, and Undisputed WWE Champion Cody Rhodes. When he isn’t putting your finger on why things are the way they are in the endlessly fascinating world of professional wrestling, Michael wraps his own around a hand grinder to explore the world of specialty coffee. Follow Michael on X (formerly known as Twitter) @MSidgwick for more!