5 Ups & 4 Downs From AEW Dynamite: Blood & Guts 2023 (Review)
Adam Cole is back, and the Elite's brilliance will never go away.
Blood & Guts is an inherently flawed match type.
AEW fans had stratospheric expectations ahead of the first one, which ultimately didn't go ahead - and because it didn't, the match developed a mythology before the cage door was first locked. It didn't just promise an update on one of the all-time great stips; Blood & Guts promised to lead AEW out of the pandemic era. Its very existence was a promise.
The Inner Circle Vs. the Pinnacle was great for 25 minutes, before Chris Jericho took as long to scale the cage as the Iron Sheikh did getting to the ring at WrestleMania X-Seven. Jericho's bump off the top was incredible, well-timed and committed, but the filming was unforgivably atrocious. Nobody expected him not to land on a crash pad, but the production staff printed bits of metal effect on paper and glued them to some cardboard. Garbage.
Utter garbage.
The Jericho Appreciation Society Vs. Blackpool Combat Club was much better, but it was still a bit...underwhelming. Flabby. It didn't reach its ceiling. The problem or part of it is that the enclosed roof indicated a more disciplined approach to the attraction, but it's an excessive plunder brawl at the same time. The genre is confused. What does it want to be? A throwback to a more violent, grudge tone or an exhibition of modern excess in which the contrived leap off the cage spot renders suspension of disbelief all but impossible?
If AEW wants to opt for the spectacle, this year's match promised that to a staggering extent. The Elite Vs. Blackpool Combat Club feud hasn't explored its potential. The premise is thin and has been muddied with too many subplots - but as an exhibition of pure insanity, Blood & Guts III seemed destined for greatness.
Was it a case of third time's a charm...?
Downs...
4. Better In The Ring, Bay-Bay
The Better Than You Bay-Bay material worked exponentially more in the ring last night, and even then, their antics were...subjectively received online.
In this week's pre-taped skit, the team bonded at a Chinese restaurant, in which Adam Cole encouraged MJF to overcome his fear of spicy food. This was thin pretext to do some gags, which weren't as funny as in previous weeks as a result. They got drunk, mistook the waiter for Sammy Guevara and Daniel Garcia, and hit him with the double clothesline, which was cut right before the actual move, obviously. The skit, again, was jarring in the context of AEW. The camera was acknowledged, thank the lord, but visible or no, it had no reason to be there. This is have cake, eat it stuff, and the various post-production effects - the slo-mo, the music cues, the laugh track that might as well be on there - render it all the more weird. Ultimately, if a bit bends the rules of the fictional world, it had better be really good. This skit simply wasn't very funny.
Later on, however...
3. Frankly Unacceptable Women's Division Segment
Dr. Britt Baker beat Kayla Sparks in what was an almost impressively bad match, since it went just 25 seconds.
Enhancement talent Sparks, who isn't meant to be ready in her defence, either fed too obviously and readily or took too long to bump. And that was your lot. What a complete and utter waste of bastard time. This was bleak in a way so transparent that you could almost literally peer through the window into the creative meeting and actually hear the words "Best get the birds on for a few seconds at least, you know what the bloody world's like these days".
Where is Kris Statlander? Why not interview Willow Nightingale to find out what she next has planned after winning the Owen? Has Shida stopped giving a damn about the Outcasts? Does she travel to and from Dynamite by hot air balloon?
When AEW can't be arsed to book an angle to barely advance the one solitary storyline in the women's division, you know it's on its arse. Terrible. It was also insulting. Dr. Britt Baker, to her credit, has done countless jobs over the last year. Far too many, in fact.
This squash win doesn't reverse any of that, and it's bullsh*t that this existed to fool fans into thinking otherwise.
2. The Sad Of Blood & Guts
This gives your writer no pleasure whatsoever, but Kota Ibushi looked rough in Blood & Guts to a shocking extent. Not rusty; rough.
Now, if his condition was known ahead of time, it might have been easier to take. A certain latitude would have been extended towards him, in much the same way fans still hold a clearly broken Hiroshi Tanahashi in the highest regard. Ibushi is beloved and deservedly so.
The thing is, it was as if Ibushi had metamorphosed from sculpted best in class wrestler into a fading veteran five years into his decline overnight. It was inexplicable, sad, and ultimately, in the context of the match, distracting. It was worrying.
He put nothing behind his kicks at first. He was on a different wavelength to his partners on more than double team spot. He blew a convoluted sequence with Konosuke Takeshita and while he did improve somewhat as the match progressed, and added to the highlight reel with an awesome moonsault on the bed of nails, he wrestled as if exhausted or dehydrated. Something was definitely off.
Fans are meant to fear for the performers in Blood & Guts, but not like this.
1. The Bad Of Blood & Guts
Blood & Guts III was mostly excellent, but it was by no means perfect.
The constant anxiety over Ibushi's state was a less than ideal plot thread, but that wasn't the only issue with the match. Firstly, the West Side Story stand-off. Even if it wasn't contrived and hokey, it is at this point years and years out of date. It's a grabby attempt to get fans to chant "Fight Forever" and the very fake-feeling of the blocking undermines the idea that these men are going to war. They're not going to war; they are going to the set.
Why is it mandatory?
Because it gets that reaction, sadly.
Also: why couldn't Blood & Guts simply be a match fought between two seats of teams who despise one another? Tony Khan needed a main event for Death Before Dishonor, yes, but setting up PAC and Claudio Castagnoli by having them argue opened up a plot hole. Technically, PAC surrendered. In addition to that, Konosuke Takeshita noped the match by the finish. Why? Why create a scene where the babyfaces win with a two-man advantage?
Also, it took a long time for anybody to bleed, and too few of the wrestlers did - which, following reports of new safety measures, meant that for a few too many minutes, the threat of a Blood & Guts match with no blood lingered.
Beyond that, it was fantastic.
Read on...
Ups...
5. Accomplished Opener
Two things can be true at once:
1) This new heel act does not suit Perry and has a midcard ceiling
2) His match with HOOK was really well-done, unoriginal carny finish aside.
As a referendum on the Jack Perry turn, it was inconclusive, but it worked well as HOOK's first proper "back-and-forth" match. HOOK was asked to sell here for longer than usual, and did a convincing job. The crowd popped for his impeccably timed roll back into the the ring at 9 spot. Perry plays an aloof heel - his taunting of the crowd was low-key - which isn't going to steal many scenes.
He has picked up a useful and intelligent trick from his old mentor, though: the action was backloaded in that slow-burn thriller Christian Cage vintage way. The layout meant that the last few minutes felt more urgent and dramatic, with everybody in the arena intently locked in, when Perry did the smash and grab belt shot. A good TV match with an elegant pacing to it, it wasn't quite a great bit of business.
There must have been a better way to beat HOOK for the first time: instead, the referee was as thick as hell twice, and HOOK went down to a belt shot, which, in AEW canon, isn't a transgression (a lot of heels do it) nor a death blow (a lot of babyfaces kick out of it).
4. Hottest Thing In The Company, Bay-Bay
Better Than You Bay-Bay are the most over act in the company.
If for a moment your resolve hardens and you begin to wonder if this is "worthy" main event material, it gets swept away just as quickly when that crowd stands on their feet and goes ballistic.
Their match against JAS remnants Sammy Guevara and Daniel Garcia was a wonderful exhibition of crowd psychology that was more exciting and dramatic than their previous showings in the Blind Eliminator. By last night, they had teed up the Double Clothesline bit. All that was left to do was to convince the crowd that they couldn't pull it off.
The various teases generated thunderous reactions, but this wasn't just a fun house show match premised on doing one move; it was well-worked and dramatic tag action outside of it. In one awesome spot, Cole ran the ropes only for Guevara to catch him on the back with a kick. It looked like the kick had a delayed effect on Cole, since he initially didn't react to it and stumbled backwards. What he was actually doing was creating sufficient distance with which to counter Guevara's springboard with a superkick. The timing on that out-of-nowhere spot was superb. Cole has rediscovered every drop of confidence.
In a great twist, Bay-Bay didn't just tease the double clothesline: Cole convinced MJF to perform his first ever dive. What a stonking pop that drew, Jesus Christ. A wrestler performing a defined move-set and only deviating from it within the parameters of a wrestling storyline: this was the beautiful opposite of an expositive scripted promo.
Normally, very pedantic wrestling fans would ask why on earth a set of disco lights would be a default preset on a piece of production equipment: when MJF fiddled with a mixing desk that had somehow found itself next to the ring, the TD Garden suddenly morphed into a 1970s nightclub. And then the dance-off happened.
In execution, as a fan of peak PWG, this was great. This was far more incredulous, tangential Reseda riffing than WWE 24/7 "comedy", but suspension of disbelief was elasticised beyond recognition. If AEW was a proper sports-oriented presentation, the incredulity might have worked better, as with Le Dinner Debonair; as it is, AEW is becoming an actual sports entertainment promotion, so the intended jarring effect didn't last as well as it would have in 2020. This was no Stadium Stampede detour; it was a bit hard to determine whether this is just...the direction now.
How much does that matter when it is so unbelievably over and entertaining? How could you not pop for Daniel Garcia making sweet and deep penetrative love to the ring apron? How could you not raise a smile when Adam Cole thrust his hips like a complete goofball, finally getting over as the universally beloved babyface he was fated to be?
He looked at the World title longingly in the post-match, which upset MJF. The feud is happening soon - but it's much too soon for, and this is no exaggeration, everybody in the arena.
3. A Passable Plot Development
The adventures of Chris Jericho worked in hindsight, but at the time, it all felt threatening.
It began with roving reporter Alex Marvez, so woefully unconvincing that he's almost charming, trying to spy on Jericho and Don Callis having a business lunch earlier in the day. He then followed them into the arena for a scoop that wasn't forthcoming.
Jericho commentated on the Blind Eliminator final, after which he was spurned by his JAS underlings. In a neat bit of dovetailing plotting, the Blind Eliminator advanced two stories at once: the MJF/Cole saga and the dissolution of Jericho's stable. Beaten and more crucially embarrassed in their match, evidently tiring of acting like sports entertainer clowns, Garcia and Sammy walked past Jericho's commiserations.
The problem when watching the show as it unfolded was the threat of Callis and Jericho sealing the deal at the close of Blood & Guts and ruining the sense of finality by accelerating a new plot and not allowing the last beat of a major story to breathe.
Mercifully, this didn't happen, but the threat still lingered uneasily.
2. The Good Of Blood & Guts
Various moments within the Blood & Guts main event were so tremendous that it was easy to howl at the ingenuity of it all.
Nick Jackson's introduction was outstanding; the way in which he tweaked and laid out his signature hot tag spot to organically arrive at driving both Claudio and Moxley onto the glass was nothing short of expert plunder assembly. So often, these big set pieces are telegraphed. At no point did anything involving the weaponry feel imminent, obvious or contrived; every last big spot was linked together with the brilliance expected of this world-class fleet of talent.
The level of athleticism was unreal even by their standards; the body control of PAC to land that insane double foot stomp through the table from the cage ceiling was outrageous. While this review is critical of the match in places, it must be stressed that, when it was incredible, it was incredible.
In a very clever spot, after blasting Wheeler YUTA with a terrifying series of northern lights suplexes on the cage roof, Matt Jackson stuck around when YUTA, cowardly heel, ran down the structure. Matt had a bag of tacks with him and rained them down on the canvas. His Elite stablemates countered a dual powerbomb attempt by PAC and Claudio with a pair of back body drops onto the spikes. This tore the roof off the building, and trust the Young Bucks to intelligently craft a roof sequence without relying on the dismal, fake crash pad spot.
How was the match on the whole...?
1. The GREAT Of Blood & Guts
The 50 minute, 49 second long Blood & Guts match was paced incredibly well.
It never once sagged and was escalated to near-perfection. The dream pairing of Kenny Omega and Claudio Castagnoli started the match with a very physical pro wrestling sequence, conscious not to escalate the violence too early. Mox's introduction changed the tenor of the match, which truly fit the billing when he introduced a nail board. The mere sight of that gruesome apparatus, introduced at the perfect time, created an unbearable tension, and Ibushi released it with a fantastic standing moonsault onto it at Mox's expense. Mox, incidentally, wrestled this match like a lunatic. He was unbelievable. He made it feel like a war.
As rough as Ibushi was, save for a few uplifting moments, the crowd went easy on him. The Golden Lovers reunion got over, and followed the continued reconciliation of Page and Omega. The emotional beats intensified as perfectly as the violence.
The nail board lunacy preceded the more demented high spot stunts. Everything was in the right place, and by the finish, both teams expertly arranged two different, suspenseful sequences in which the Elite looked doomed: a wave of superplex spots culminating in the PAC table stomp, and then a sequence in which each member of the BCC had a member of the Elite trapped in a submission before Ibushi, rediscovering a glimmer of his striking power, broke them up one by one.
The previous two Blood & Guts matches collapsed into unfocused dawdling to accommodate the roof jumps. This third match, the best one, was far more focused and dramatic by the finish. Real doubt was cast over the result, investment in which was deafening.
The "we want tables" chant was annoying, but it is to be expected, sadly. The Boston crowd actually saw countless weapons more befitting of a real ultra-violent gimmick match, but the timing was serendipitous, at least: the planned table spot was set up within seconds of the chant.
The "we want fire" chant actually put over the match because, in the throes of bloodlust, the crowd actually deemed these maniacs capable of setting each other alight.
That's how committed and unhinged - and believable - the match was when it peaked.