5 Ups & 4 Downs From AEW Dynamite (January 24 - Results & Review)

Adam Copeland proves his worth on an otherwise incredibly lightweight show.

Toni Storm
AEW

This week's edition of Dynamite had the air of novelty to it going in.

WWE, meanwhile, promoted one of the best big-time promo exchanges in years - the shift in mood in that Cody Rhodes Vs. CM Punk segment was as believable as pro wrestling tension gets - ahead of the the most successful Royal Rumble ever at the box office. This preceded by mere hours the bombshell announcement that WWE is heading to Netflix, for billions and billions of dollars, in a move that could mainstream itself yet further.

And, while it's probably unfair to compare the two promotions at this particular stage, in that AEW is not mere days away from its second-most canonically important show of the year, just how absolutely massive WWE feels right now just threw into sharper relief how lightweight AEW feels. Adam Copeland Vs, Minoru Suzuki was very much a wacky Dynamite special, the sort of match graphic you are supposed to interpret as charmingly whimsical - this guy is wrestling that guy?! - but this sort of novelty does cast AEW as somewhat trivial.

A Jeff Hardy Vs. Swerve Strickland match didn't seem likely to launch the latter into the stratosphere. The best version of Hangman Page Vs. Penta El Zero Miedo promised some awesome, unhinged wrestling violence, but it was a bit of a 2019 match, no?

Was all of this copy too cynical...?


Downs...

4. Well-Intentioned Angle Falls Flat

At the start of the show, Samoa Joe - whose performance was to be brutally honest a little cartoonish by his über-credible standards - gloated about his title victory over HOOK last week, but before he could commentate on Hangman Page Vs. Penta El Zero Miedo, he was confronted by the victim he felled.

This wasn’t a half-bad idea, one designed to reassure anxious viewers that AEW will not forget about HOOK (it’s a bit alarming, incidentally, that Tony Khan felt the need to preempt this frequent complaint). The execution was poor. HOOK still needs some work and experience in live promo exchanges, and when he drew Joe close with the forcible handshake, the crowd didn’t react at all. The intended, sought-after gasp didn’t materialise, which was brutal. Joe then sold fear of HOOK before retreating, and HOOK then threw around some security guards.

A segment designed to get HOOK over as a badass achieved nothing. Is trust in AEW’s ability to follow up so low that fans rolled their eyes?

Or was this one of the worst crowds AEW has ever played to?


3. Another Night In The AEW Women's Division

Thunder Rosa Vs. Red Velvet was developing quite nicely, despite being placed in that dead zone between the top of the hour and the live Sting interview segment. There was a ferocity to the chop exchanges, the body language and intent putting over the most familiar exchange in wrestling. It felt like they were properly scrapping in there. It's a shame that the match threatened to fall apart completely by the finish.

The thread was lost during a series of counters with very awkward, spell-breaking timing, but even before that, the crowd simply didn't react to a thing they were trying to do in there. Bleak, again, was the operative word: this was a match that existed, and this got boring to write roughly four years ago, to put a women's match on the show. AEW - wary of the optics, incredibly - feels like they have to. It's the done thing, isn't it, having women wrestle These Days.

Red Velvet might not receive these shrugging reactions if, for example, AEW actually did something with her that wasn't having her wrestle once every now and then.

AEW should have partnered with a women's promotion years ago, to assist in this sort of talent development exercise, but they somehow managed to work with AAA and CMLL (!) before doing that.


2. Another Wardlow Reboot

Watching Adam Cole grimace as he made his entrance wearing a medical boot, again, was yet another reminder of how much AEW panicked and absolutely sh*t itself after Grand Slam. Everybody knows Cole is a nice fellow.

You aren't meant to feel inordinate sympathy for your resident heel mastermind!

He led the Undisputed Kingdom to ringside ahead of Wardlow's match with Trent Baretta, which was only decent - not ideal, since it was reiterated on commentary that Wardlow intends to challenge for the World title at some point (perhaps even imminently). The long protracted heat spot wasn't compelling, and the creeping sense that the match wasn't a squash was suboptimal, given that Wardlow is expected to work lengthy matches in the main event picture. The action did improve near the finish, but only when the outside activity allowed for smoke and mirrors; Trent scored an improbably dramatic near-fall after lamping Wardlow with a chair. Wardlow did dust off that awesome-looking plunging Go To Sleep, and flexed his unreal core strength by carrying Trent around on his shoulders before landing the powerbomb.

But there was something about watching the second Wardlow reboot against an LED backdrop inspired by a WWE that is absolutely trouncing them that, again, just felt bleak. AEW can vow to make mistakes no longer, but they cannot hide from those they've already made.


1. Does Everyone Love The Acclaimed?

Because AEW mostly uses a rotating cast, it's all the more pronounced when Tony Khan does use an act either every week or more often than not. It feels like the Gates of Agony and Brain Cage are set to smash the company appearance record at this point. Their fun if one-dimensional act has been overexposed, as has the Acclaimed signature match, which is incredibly basic structurally.

They draw on what is essentially the timeless formula, the heat and the comeback and the rest, but there's never any flair, thought or drama to it. Their matches just exist. This felt nothing like a title fight. They won after Jay White, a wrestler AEW has zero clue what to do with, thwarted interference. All of this is not great, at all, nor is it effective. The Acclaimed sell merch. The Trios titles are now a vehicle with which to help them accomplish that.

People wanted Trios titles in the first place because they fell and fell hard for the dizzying, pulsating action that you couldn't begin to predict where was going next. That's a lot easier and much less exciting now.

Billy Gunn for the hot tag after first being cut off, is it?

Also, on literally the first show after the rankings were announced, a team failed upwards, challenging for a title a week removed from losing a lesser achievement.

Not a great, reassuring look.


Ups...

5. A Decent Promo Duel...BUT...

Does AEW deserve a modicum of credit for booking two feature segments - a match and a live promo duel - that showcased the women’s division?

No.

This was the bare minimum.

Now, the Toni Storm character, when she’s on form, is really funny. She always has a popper of a one-liner in her, and the “nuru massage” line was another out-of-nowhere, “out of pocket” bit of character shading. The problem is that Timeless Toni exists on such a different wavelength that it’s hard to tether whatever she is to another character. Any attempts to add emotional weight to any of it just feel…weird.

Toni and Deonna Purrazzo are shoot great friends in real life, as underscored last night in a weirdly affecting and very real twist: the people behind the personas have matching ankle tattoos. The idea is that Deonna wants to wrestle the real Toni to determine who the better wrestler is, urging her back out of the bizarre psychological state in which she finds herself. Shouldn’t Deonna simply want to win the title? At this point, what fun is it for the audience to want to see Toni abandon the affected persona?

Boil it all down, and the babyface wants to see the back of the fun character that the audience likes. The crowd therefore can’t get behind the babyface.

What, ultimately, does any of this have to do with pro wrestling conflict?

The character does not co-exist with AEW’s storytelling framework, and any attempts to reconcile those two things is doomed, as this segment only highlighted.

Now, on a positive note, as much as the dynamic is flawed, Deonna showed poise on the microphone and Toni was a riot. It worked and it didn’t at the same time.


4. Opener Is Fine, Nothing More

Not quite the vintage opening Dynamite "banger", Hangman Page Vs. Penta El Zero Miedo half-resembled a typical WWE television match in that not a great deal happened, and not a great deal of noise was made, until the finish.

What's worse, Hangman Page drew jeers when he tried to wake up the Savannah crowd in picture and picture. As Tony Schiavone pointed out, Penta has always had his fans, but still: it's potentially another symptom of the five year itch AEW is simply unable to make go away. With so little really happening in a match that, move for move, probably would have sparked wild scenes five years ago, it was hard not to feel a bit glum at the backdrop. The attendance woes and the perception battle are not going away any time soon, no matter how much AEW tells you it is going to restore the feeling. Tepid atmosphere, a visibly bad crowd: the match was very well-wrestled but only developed into something really exciting by the finish, when a fun chess match on the apron followed a great near-fall from a Buckshot lariat into a Made In Japan reversal and led to Page then winning with the Buckshot.

His Orihara moonsault just before the finish looked emphatic even buy his standards, but execution aside, the vibe was just...off in the building, an unshakeable sense that it's all deeply familiar and cannot get hot again for love nor money.

You'd expect better from two noted madmen.


3. A Division Is Forming

The Bucks were shown arriving late, mulling over the format sheet as if it mattered, since the show was already in progress. If you can stomach the leaning in, that was a good punchline.

In a potentially interesting bit of deft, dovetailing booking - the deep level of thought that once existed during the heyday of the promotion - it can't be a coincidence that the Young Bucks are trying with the notion of abusing their power at the exact same moment AEW itself returns to the meritocracy of the rankings system. Earnest heat could be drawn from this clash of ideas: people really do like the concept of the rankings system. This has potential, as does the Bucks outright pretending to do their jobs. A teased match against Top Flight is always a fun time, too. An actual tag team division is emerging on Dynamite, as opposed to the 25 minutes of acclaim bait FTR get on Collision every other week.

The Bucks watched on as Sting and Darby Allin cut a short, sweet and effective promo outlining their intention to win the World Tag Team titles - and in an argument that was almost three years out of date, correctly identified themselves as #1 contenders. On a night of few actual positives, Darby Allin proved again that he has quietly developed into a strong promo.

When Sting retires, Allin should be elevated all the way into the title picture.


2. Swerve Is The Guy

Without being blow-away great (or truly worth going out of your way to see), Swerve Strickland Vs. Jeff Hardy was both much better than expected and a very robust defence of Swerve's credentials as the man.

He got something hot and dramatic out of a Hardy brother in 2024, and after the initial, towering wave of nostalgia subsided, booming chants of "Swerve's house" rang put across the arena as he prepared to put Jeff away with the House Call. It took a while for a Jeff to warm up - you could see Swerve measuring his steps very carefully to attune to Jeff's slower wavelength - after which the match actively started to rock, since Jeff warms up by taking frightening bumps. Again, not a classic, not even in range of the second-tier of Dynamite matches, but a relatively loud and violently fun time all the more shocking given that Jeff was thought absolutely done, finished, just a few weeks ago.

The storytelling wasn't intricate or sophisticated, but it was believable: you can always buy that Jeff can kick out of anything. He's that sort of wrestler.

Still!


1. Surreal, Good Main Event

Adam Copeland Vs. Minoru Suzuki, a WrestleMania Weekend novelty match, ultimately, was surreal and well-worked - an interesting diversion that AEW can probably justify so many weeks removed from the next major destination event, even if this sort of mad scientist match graphic lost its charms years ago.

His aura is all but dead - he’s done too many jobs, which is fatal for his killer shoot artist character - but Suzuki remains a joy of a live act capable of turning it on. As difficult as it is to get that “You’ve f*cked up” feeling, when Suzuki no-sells a strike and does an unhinged facial - Suzuki doesn’t punish anybody anymore, undermining the whole thing - the main event still worked. Suzuki worked a lot harder than he usually does in his twilight years pantomime match, eating a spear through the railings in a wicked bump he doesn’t have to take at this stage of his career.

Copeland was on excellent individual form. His storytelling was astute, old pro stuff; having worked in the WWE system for 99.9% of his very long career, his character has never reckoned with the strong style approach, much less one of its mos credible practitioners, and without overdoing it - something he is often guilty of - he sold Suzuki’s offence as if actually hadn’t been hit that hard before.

Intelligently arranged to pull a reaction out of a crowd that Austin Gunn put to shame, with some shortcut work on the outside and a very well done count-out tease, Copeland and Suzuki drew on their ridiculously long combined experience in a very good match that told the story of Copeland almost regretting entering deadly and unfamiliar terrain.

This however would have played much better as an undercard bonus on a much better show which, shockingly light on genuinely significant storyline advancement, badly needed a cliffhanger or some sort of hook for the following week, which shouldn’t be dominated by WWE like this one.


 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Michael Sidgwick (Creative Writing BA Hons) is an editor, writer and podcaster for WhatCulture Wrestling. With over a decade of experience in wrestling analysis, Michael was published in the influential UK institution that was Power Slam magazine, and specialises in providing insights into All Elite Wrestling - so much so that he wrote a book about the subject. You can order Becoming All Elite: The Rise Of AEW on Amazon. Possessing a deep knowledge also of WWE, WCW, ECW and New Japan Pro Wrestling, Michael’s work has been publicly praised by AEW World Champions Kenny Omega and MJF, and Undisputed WWE Champion Cody Rhodes. When he isn’t putting your finger on why things are the way they are in the endlessly fascinating world of professional wrestling, Michael wraps his own around a hand grinder to explore the world of specialty coffee. Follow Michael on X (formerly known as Twitter) @MSidgwick for more!