5 Ups & 4 Downs from WWE Raw (12 May - Results & Review)

The women crush the main event while babyface trio unify to tangle with Rollins' clan.

Jey Uso CM Punk Sami Zayn
WWE

At what point does WWE finish setting the table and start serving the banquet?

Four episodes of Raw post-WrestleMania and the company continued Monday night to serve up some appetizers and samplers, but it did not provide any main courses.

(Enough with the analogy, it’s making people hungry!)

It’s completely understandable that WWE needs to reset after Mania and establish new storylines, but they are going to need to offer something more in the coming weeks beyond competent wrestling and slow-but-steady narrative-building.

Seth Rollins’ stable is still getting off the ground. Iyo Sky has had to contend with NXT invaders and formed an uneasy alliance with her potential top challenger. The Judgment Day continues to face internal strife. Becky Lynch is establishing her new heel character. The Raw tag team division apparently only consists of three teams, and they are slowly converging on a triple threat, because that’s all we’ve got.

Most of these developments are actually positive ones, and some are fairly promising. But everything seems to be in the same phase, with little boiling over, and that’s how it has been the past few weeks. The women’s tag main event shined, but the NXT contingent aren’t even officially part of the main roster yet.

This isn’t a serious criticism (yet), but more of an observation. Raw was above decent, featuring one good main event, a solid promo (Lynch) and a laudable angle (CM Punk, Sami Zayn and Jey Uso solidifying their babyface trio). But WWE is pretty far removed from the electricity that pulsed from the Raw after WrestleMania at this point, and they really should be striving to recapture that energy.

Let’s get to it…


DOWNS…

4. Special Treatment

Pat McAfee
WWE

Pat McAfee’s escapade during the past few weeks proved to be a decent diversion for Gunther, mostly inoffensive, though falling far short of what could have been.

Monday night, Raw opened without McAfee at the desk, leading to a thought that maybe he was taking the show off to sell the impact of the match.

Nope. In fact, McAfee was bestowed his own entrance before the opening match, drawing chants from the fans. Later on, they aired highlights from his match against Gunther, eliciting more chants and leading him to standing on the desk to acknowledge the cheers before sitting down and putting other Gunther.

If they wanted McAfee to put Gunther over as a world beater, then he should have been battered in the match and then taken a week off (which he should have done after the initial attack a few weeks ago).

The frustrating part here – and why it gets a “down” – is that there are plenty of wrestlers on Raw who would love to get that spotlight, or at least the time dedicated to McAfee. Ludwig Kaiser was “interviewed” backstage and didn’t even get a word out before Jackie Redmond rushed off to cover Jey Uso being attacked. What has Karrion Kross done since his acclaimed post-WrestleMania promo? (However, he was seen in the background talking to New Day.)

A lot of this would get more leeway if McAfee was a beloved announcer who added value to the product for the viewing audience. But that’s not the case. He adds mainstream value to WWE due to his ESPN show.


3. What Was The Point?

New Day
WWE

During WWE’s nadir before Triple H took over, the company used stupid, noncommittal jargon to describe matches that ostensibly were number one contender’s matches, saying that the winner could possibly envision themselves maybe being positioned for a potential title opportunity at an unspecified time down the line.

That sloppy language was heard less and less these past couple of years, but it has found its way back into WWE’s regular lexicon, and it was not only used, it was upended by more stupidity.

The Creed Brothers battled the War Raiders in a match to potentially earn a future World Tag Team Championship match. The New Day was at ringside repeatedly declaring that they didn’t think either team deserved a title match until they had won a bunch of matches. Fair, they’re heel champs and should say outlandish stuff. Then they interfered to help the Creeds pick up the win.

But backstage, the War Raiders complained to Raw GM Adam Pearce about New Day cheating. When the tag champs entered the room, Pearce announced that the Creeds had earned a tag title match because “the referee’s decision is final.” And then in the next breath, he said that he was inserting the Raiders into the tag title match because of New Day’s interference.

Which is it? Is the ref’s decision final, or does it just not matter? Also, why fall back into the “possible future title opportunity” crap if you’re going to treat it as a contender’s match two segments later?


2. Wrestling Happening

AJ Styles Finn Bálor
WWE

Here’s the difficult part with assigning “ups” and “downs” to a wrestling program: not all matches that are technically “good” deserve positive marks. But in 2025, the standard for what merits an “up” should be higher than it was several years ago.

AJ Styles versus Finn Balor was a perfectly decent wrestling match, but for about three-quarters of the bout, it felt like an exhibition with the wrestlers running through their spots. Eight years ago, this was viewed as a dream match. Monday night, it was a lengthy affair that needed to get to the obvious Judgment Day interference so things would start to steamroll toward a conclusion.

The final quarter of the match was good, as the action picked up in drama and the outside shenanigans ramped up as well, with Penta making a surprise appearance to help Styles by taking out JD McDonagh and Carlito. But given the length of the match and the wrestlers involved, it feels patronizing to hand out an “up” because these vaunted veterans did C+ work that relied on tropey outside interference to dial up the drama.


1. The More He Talks…

CM Punk Seth Rollins
WWE

Seth Rollins has had his moments on the microphone, but he’s never been regarded as one of the strongest promos in the business. Things get dicey when contrasting him against some of the best on the stick, and it gets worse when that comparison happens in the same segment.

CM Punk opened Raw and gave a strong account of why he’s mad at himself for trusting Paul Heyman before the Wise Man, Rollins and Bron Breakker interrupted him. Seth launched into an over-rehearsed bit about how Punk was selfish and the one to blame in the relationship between the Second City Saint and Heyman.

Rollins delivered a completely hokey “I believe you’re scum; I believe you’re trash; I believe you’re human excrement” line before saying he was mad that Punk was the reason Seth wasn’t World Heavyweight Champion at that moment…

And then Punk cut him off with a sharp “You ain’t ever gonna be world champion as long as I’m on two feet.”

Just like that, with a throwaway line, Punk showcased the gulf between the two of them. Rollins using “human excrement” in a completely unconvincing way in a parade of lines no person would use in real life, followed immediately by Punk sounding defiant and very real.

The Rollins-led heel group still has great potential and is an intriguing act, but the more mic time they give Seth to prattle like this, the more the luster is going to wear off the stable. You have one of the best promos in the business standing right there – hand the microphone to Heyman and let him work his magic.


UPS…

5. Tag Match Has Some Nice Moments

Viking Raiders Creed Brothers
WWE

While the tag match between War Raiders and the Creed Brothers was rendered moot later in the program, the two teams had a pretty decent little match that featured some good arrogant heel work on commentary from the New Day.

The match started slowly but picked up as it wore on, with the Raiders’ tandem offense getting fans up and then turning things over to the Creeds, who threw the bigger Erik and Ivar around a bit to really pop the crowd.

During the entire match, Kofi Kingston and Xavier Woods spent their time on commentary observing that no one deserved a tag title match until they had won a bunch of matches. When it looked like the War Raiders might win, they got involved to prevent their rivals from earning a clear path to a rematch (an effort that was undone a short time later).

The most notable thing about this match was the fans coming to life for the Creeds, who have been in wrestling purgatory for a while now. The truth is that they’re a lot like Lyra Valkyria, in that their connection with fans comes mainly from their work in the ring, not promos or backstage segments. They need matches to showcase their talent and win crowds over, and this match served as a reminder of that.


4. Back In The Saddle

Gunther Jey Uso
WWE

WWE and Gunther himself love to point out that for 80% of the Ring General’s run in WWE, he has held a title.

Since losing his World Heavyweight Championship at WrestleMania 41, Gunther has been preoccupied with Raw’s announce team of Michael Cole and Pat McAfee, feuding with the desk jockeys for the past few weeks.

Monday, the Ring General returned his focus to a title, interrupting Jey Uso to belittle the current World Heavyweight Champion and to remind him that even if Jey survives Logan Paul at Saturday Night’s Main Event, he will have to contend with Gunther next month on the Raw after Money in the Bank.

Even if he loses or is somehow knocked off course in the run-up to 9 June, Gunther should be singularly focused on regaining his title, as holding a championship has become ingrained into his character’s DNA. Had he come out and jawed with Cole and McAfee, it would have been a travesty. Gunther (still regarded as one of the best wrestlers in the world) coming for Jey just feels right.

One could deduct points for this segment blowing right past Logan Paul’s title match next weekend, but honestly, Paul can’t be bothered to show up on television half the time and his matches have become sideshows rather than spectacles, so we’ll allow it.


3. The Man Embraces Her Role

Becky Lynch
WWE

Fresh off losing at Backlash, Becky Lynch wasted little time Monday night in brushing off defeat and pointing out that she was still standing, while her opponent landed in the hospital Saturday night.

To hear Lynch tell it, Lyra Valkyria had never been more relevant than when she faced Becky, thus proving her point about being the most important figure on Raw.

The Man recounted her journey the past year, how she seemingly walked away from WWE for nearly a year, and she revealed that she heard the rumblings at the time: fans wanted her to leave because she was dominating the scene and beating everyone, winning world titles and holding people down. She’s a Man of the people, so she obliged.

But Monday, Lynch decided that she would be whatever fans said she was: selfish, greedy, cutthroat. Becky warned the women in the back that they were going to “finally find out what it’s like to be held down” by The Man.

This is how to do the “each and every one of you” promo. She turned what a subsection of WWE fans said about her (think the “Becky Hogan” dopes out there) into fuel for her heel turn, justification for her actions. Now Becky is going to relish trying to hold back talent (in storyline) because it turns fans’ worst takes about her into reality. Even if fans legitimately complain, it will automatically become part of the story (though Lynch has showed time and time again that the opposite is true).

A vindictive, megastar Lynch is a nice twist on the Big Time Becks character that descended into cartoonish parody. It’s more grounded in (perceived) reality.


2. Babyfaces Unite!

Jey Uso Seth Rollins CM Punk Bron Breakker
WWE

When you have established a heel stable to run roughshod over a wrestling promotion, the real fun comes from seeing how the babyfaces come together to oppose the group. The best stories often involve reluctant heroes who normally wouldn’t interact joining forces, creating a tenuous alliance to bring down the villains.

Seth Rollins’ unnamed stable is that force on Raw at the moment, and they have targeted Jey Uso and his World Heavyweight Championship. They also have identified Sami Zayn as a threat to their standing on the red brand. And the betrayal by Paul Heyman makes CM Punk a natural enemy.

However, seeing all three faces come together has been a nice, organic experience thus far. They’re clearly brought together by Rollins’ clan, standing unified because it’s the right thing to do, and it’s the only way for any of them to triumph.

Zayn and Uso saved Punk in the opening segment, and that fracas gave way to a tag match for Saturday Night’s Main Event between Rollins and Bron Breakker versus Zayn and Punk.

Backstage, Sami and Punk discussed the situation, with Punk noting that he has “a hard time trusting anyone right now.” The two worked through the conversation to arrive at the conclusion that they needed to cooperate to stop Rollins or neither of them would accomplish any of their individual goals. Later, both men rushed to Jey’s side after Bron had laid him out.

That’s how babyfaces should join forces – not in some instantaneous, smooth, artificial manner, but in a more realistic, uneven way.


1. The All-Aura Tag Team

Roxanne Perez Rhea Ripley
WWE

If there was ever any doubt as to Rhea Ripley’s star power, just watch the Raw main event with the volume turned up.

Fans were clamoring for Mami from the moment her entrance music hit, all the way through the hot tag into the finish. The crowd wasn’t slouching on Iyo Sky either, as the Women’s World Champion had a fair amount of support as well.

The duo battled NXT upstarts Roxanne Perez and Giulia in a match that could have been deflating for the newcomers if not for the fact that they were headhunting for the biggest targets on the women’s roster. Perez and the Beautiful Madness aimed high and kept Sky and Ripley off-balance throughout the match.

A couple of times, Iyo’s efforts backfired on Rhea, giving a hint of a reason for the Eradicator to turn her back on the champ, but that never materialized. Instead, they hung together to thwart Roxanne and Giulia.

While Perez looked completely comfortable in the ring, Giulia seemed almost hesitant a few times in the early going before settling in more. It’s not like the former NXT Women’s Champion has never performed in front of a large audience before, but she certainly looked a step off in the opening moments.

If this is the introduction to the main roster for the NXT team (and given the promo video that aired earlier in the night, it seems that way), then losing to two of the best on the roster in a high-profile match isn’t a terrible start – provided they rebound and pick off some lower-hanging fruit.


Contributor
Contributor

Scott is a former journalist and longtime wrestling fan who was smart enough to abandon WCW during the Monday Night Wars the same time as the Radicalz. He fondly remembers watching WrestleMania III, IV, V and VI and Saturday Night's Main Event, came back to wrestling during the Attitude Era, and has been a consumer of sports entertainment since then. He's written for WhatCulture since 2014, establishing the Ups and Downs articles for WWE Raw and WWE PPVs/PLEs and composing pieces on a variety of topics.