5 Ups & 4 Downs From WWE SmackDown (April 8)

WWE sets up a huge rematch; Roman Reigns steps down; NXT stars debut on SmackDown.

Ronda Rousey
WWE.com

If you thought WWE would move on from WrestleMania fever, then think again.

The promotion's next pay-per-view is 'Mania Backlash, and that means "WrestleMania season" (at least in the creative team's minds) has been extended beyond the big weekender itself. Anyone expecting a card full of repeats for Backlash should also think twice - a few rematches will happen, but some major stars have already moved on from business in Dallas.

Roman Reigns, for example, has a fresh opponent post-Brock Lesnar. Sadly for everyone, WWE's pick falls short of the star power that 'Cowboy' Brock brought to the SmackDown party over the past few months. It's actually quite a baffling one, and only seems to be happening because Rick Boogs went down with an injury last week.

Questionable reasons for title shots seems to be a rule of thumb around these parts. Someone...random is getting a crack at Ricochet's Intercontinental belt next week too. On the plus side, at least those writers had the sense to tack on a bumper stipulation for Ronda Rousey vs. Charlotte Flair II (III?) come Backlash.

Here are all the 'Ups' and 'Downs'...


Downs...

4. Wasted Opportunity/Flat Finish

Butch Xavier Woods
WWE.com

Small package and roll-up finishes are so overdone in WWE.

Two matches out of four ended via "surprise" pins. The problem? Such moments are hardly surprisingly when they happen every single week. All of that could've been offset had Butch and Xavier Woods been cut loose to have a banger and put on a show, but they were let down by some poor formatting.

The commercial break killed all the momentum they'd been building up before it. Worse, that time could've been saved had Woods and Kofi Kingston not been delivering some uncharacteristically guff material during their pre-match promo. "Records have been reset" and "rabies infested ass" didn't click.

If New Day are free to claim that their loss to Ridge Holland and Sheamus didn't count, then why even bother having the match? Every WrestleMania bout should feel important, if not to fans then at least to the workers involved.


3. Another Miss

Liv Morgan Sasha Banks
WWE.com

Score another one for matches ruined by an ad break - Liv Morgan and Sasha Banks are surely capable of having excellent matches together, but this wasn't one of them. In fairness to both, the set up of Morgan coming to SmackDown and fighting for a tag partner who couldn't be bothered to show up was pretty tepid.

It's getting really hard to stomach seeing would-be champs go on a winning run, take the titles and then start to lose match after match too. That's what'll happen to Sasha and Naomi now they're Women's Tag Champions, and it's painful. WWE needs to start thinking of fresher scenarios than that.

Finally, that finish. Oh...that finish.

Banks visibly raised her legs so Liv could pin her after both landed from Sasha's superplex. The whole thing looked rotten, scripted and didn't make Morgan look particularly strong. It was another "surprise" result, and the kind that leaves nobody satisfied.


2. Random Opponents?

Ricochet Jinder Mahal Shanky WWE SmackDown
WWE.com

First, a minor positive (yes, in a 'Down'!): WWE remember that Ricochet is the reigning Intercontinental Champion, and they've set up a title match for the high-flyer one week ahead of time. The negative bit? It's against Jinder Mahal of all people.

This isn't some anti-Jinder rant, but what the f*ck has he done to deserve a crack at any championship? The guy's last televised win was way back on the 27 September 2021 episode of Raw, for crying out loud - that was also a six man (Mahal, Shanky and Veer vs. Jeff Hardy, Mansoor and Mustafa Ali).

What's the point of "Contender's Matches" if wrestlers can just stroll into Adam Pearce's office, make bold demands their performances don't reflect and then come away with a crack at some gold? That kind of booking is all over the place.

There's a difference between setting up something substantial for Rico and hurling stopgap challengers his way.


1. A Huge Step Down

Roman Reigns Paul Heyman The Usos Shinsuke Nakamura Bloodline
WWE.com

Sorry, but Shinsuke Nakamura also fits that description.

The babyface is a colossal step down from Brock Lesnar for Roman Reigns. Put it this way: Naka was a comedy 'King', then started working tags with Rick Boogs recently. Suddenly, because of Boogs' injury at 'Mania, WWE are happy to pretend that Shinsuke's on Roman's level?

That's not going to cut it. Reigns has been unstoppable as Universal Champion, and now he has the WWE Title in his mitts too. How on earth is someone who hasn't been relevant as a main event act for years going to be a credible threat heading into WrestleMania Backlash?

Again, another side note positive; Reigns demanding that The Usos head to Raw, target RK-Bro, win the Raw Tag-Team Titles and then unify the belts is a cracking idea. Being honest, WWE's tag ranks across both shows have rarely merited two sets of titles anyway.

The Nakamura stuff though? Nah. That'll take some work.


Ups...

5. Better Than Expected

Happy Corbin Madcap Moss Happy Folks
WWE.com

Hands up who else thought an inevitable split angle between Happy Corbin and Madcap Moss would suck balls. If you're anything like this writer, then you haven't really enjoyed their union one bit, but something remarkable happened in Milwaukee on Friday night.

Fans actually responded well to Madcap.

They greeted him warmly as the babyface of the piece, and cheered when he roared back against Corbin's ambush to send Mr. Happy tumbling from the ring. Seeing Moss destroy the 'Happy Lounge' talk show set also gives hope that WWE will move away from that idea.

Honestly, it's been easy to hate everything these 'Happy Folks' have done together, but their work here was solid. It's amazing what a live crowd can do to enhance segments like this too. Those folks in Wisconsin seemed to take a shine to Madcap.


4. Rebuilding Drew McIntyre

Drew McIntyre Sami Zayn
WWE.com

Let the rebuild begin.

A protracted feud with Happy Corbin and Madcap Moss did nothing for one Drew McIntyre. In fact, if anything, it pulled him further away from another go at main events, and that was rubbish to see. Leave it to Sami Zayn, people - he'll get the best out of anybody.

The way Sami got scared sh*tless when he challenged anybody to a fight and Drew marched into view was majestic. Then, to compound a plan to put McIntyre over before the match had even started, Zayn cowered away from the big Scot throughout.

It wasn't much of a proper match, to be fair, but Sami being scared and Drew barely breaking a sweat made all the sense in the world. Now, these dudes can look forward to a rematch. It's one Zayn will have to cheat in, which is fine. That still shouldn't be enough to derail McIntyre.


3. Squash! Squash! Squash!

Gunther Joe Alonzo
WWE.com

Speaking of making workers look physically imposing!

Gunther made his way to this week's SmackDown and blasted the skin off of enhancement worker Joe Alonzo with some super-stiff chops. To finish, the NXT man hit a powerbomb that looked meaty before standing tall with a renamed Marcel Barthel. He's now "Ludvig Kaiser", which is certainly a name.

This revamped Imperium is off to a hot enough start on Friday nights. Kaiser got some mic time, and Gunther got to do what he does best by showing off just how physical he can get between those ropes. Poor Joe Alonzo. Guy earned his money here.

Nobody should have any issues with Gunther squashing jobbers for a few weeks before moving on to bigger challenges. Matches against the likes of Drew McIntyre and Sheamus would be vicious, but the big guy could also work a nice dynamic with someone like Kofi Kingston.


2. Raquel Rodriguez

Raquel Rodriguez Los Lotharios Kayla Braxton
WWE

A lot of folks are going to moan about this particular name change, but it's not as egregious as some over the years. Pearlers like Michael McGillicutty and Shorty G come to mind there. Besides, Raquel Rodriguez isn't too far removed from Raquel Gonzalez.

The NXT star had done everything there was to do on the third brand anyway, so it was time for her to move on to bigger things. She needed this change of scenery, and she'll be a good addition to the women's scene on SmackDown.

It's also promising that Raquel spurned advances from Los Lotharios.

WWE would've come in for some heavy flak had Rodriguez batted her eyelids at Angel and Humberto. She's always been a powerful sort on NXT, and it'd be awful if she suddenly started acting like a shy little flower around the handsome tag-team for no reason.


1. “I Quit” = Right Call

Ronda Rousey Kayla Braxton
WWE.com

OK, so the promo work here was standard shaky Ronda Rousey, and Charlotte Flair didn't say much of note herself. However, booking a rematch between both women under the "I Quit" banner should mean more arm bar teases heading into WrestleMania Backlash. That's a good thing.

So, mind you, is pointing to Charlotte tapping out (which the ref didn't see) at 'Mania. Rousey will surely rectify that come the next pay-per-view, and WWE will furnish the latest chapter in this rivalry with lots of physicality building up to that. That is very much needed.

This could also be the main event come Backlash.

Shinsuke Nakamura challenging Roman Reigns doesn't sound like a big enough match for that slot, and it's hard to imagine WWE coming up with anything else bigger than Rousey vs. Flair with a stip. Maybe this will make up for missing out on the headline slot in Dallas.

What did you think of this week's WWE SmackDown? For more like this, check out 10 Things Post-WrestleMania 38 Raw Told Us About WWE’s Future and WWE 2K22: 15 Best Female CAWs You Must Download!


Contributor

Lifelong wrestling, video game, music and sports obsessive who has been writing about his passions since childhood. Jamie started writing for WhatCulture in 2013, and has contributed thousands of articles and YouTube videos since then. He cut his teeth penning published pieces for top UK and European wrestling read Fighting Spirit Magazine (FSM), and also has extensive experience working within the wrestling biz as a manager and commentator for promotions like ICW on WWE Network and WCPW/Defiant since 2010. Further, Jamie also hosted the old Ministry Of Slam podcast, and has interviewed everyone from Steve Austin and Shawn Michaels to Bret Hart and Trish Stratus.