5 Ups & 4 Downs From WWE SmackDown (Aug 12)
Hit Row returns; WWE makes the Intercontinental Title look awesome; Ronda Rousey = money.
Wrestling fans have always stuck by the cherished Intercontinental Title even when WWE really hasn't. Vince McMahon's love/hate relationship with the thing is well-known; one minute, the old boss wanted to push the secondary prize as important. The next? It was just a prop that meant bugger all.
Hopefully, that infuriating up and down booking stops now.
This week's episode of SmackDown certainly went a long way towards restoring pride for the put-upon strap. Gunther has been a fine champion to date, but a champ is only as good as the challengers WWE lines up for him. Credit must go to everyone backstage for handpicking Shinsuke Nakamura then, because he was the ideal man to go up against the 'Ring General'.
There was defo more good than bad on Friday, but the bad was...irritating. WWE needs to figure out this women's tag-team title scene fast, and they could also do with moving away from heel vs. heel feuds that won't really go anywhere anyway.
Here are all the 'Ups' and the 'Downs' from WWE's latest (Roman Reigns-less) effort on FOX.
Downs...
4. It’s Still Hard To Get Excited
This fan looked on in awe as several others got frothy at the thought of WWE's Women's Tag-Team Title tournament online. It was like most just expected magic because Vince McMahon is no longer involved and Triple H is calling the shots. There's still one huge problem with the division.
It's full of thrown-together teams.
Neither Raquel Gonzalez and Aliyah nor Shotzi and Xia Li could be considered proper full-time duos. WWE is still lumping loads of singles stars who have nothing to do together and expected people to care when they barely give a sh*t themselves.
Sure, the match was decent, but everything feels so underwhelming that it's difficult to get onboard or view these tourney bouts as truly meaningful. Some sloppy moments also halted any momentum these women were trying to build up.
The division needs more. It deserves more.
3. Where Can They Go With This?
Los Lotharios are heels, and so are Maximum Male Models.
Spotted the problem? There isn't a lot of juice in booking Angel and Humberto vs. Mace and Mansoor on cards going forwards for multiple reasons; one, nobody really cares if they join the faction. Two, those bouts could play before brutal fan silence as everyone sits on their hands wondering who to root for.
OK, perhaps it's too early to pass proper judgement on this story, but the early signs aren't too great. WWE tends to go down the comedy route with these things for the sake of it, and that means peeps could be "treated" to endless backstage promos that really go nowhere.
Again, Lotharios vs. MMM isn't the kind of feud this tag division wants right now. Why not program one of them opposite Hit Row, or something like that? Surely babyface vs. heel is better than heel vs. heel, especially when neither side is particularly over/established.
2. Nobody Thought This Through
Karrion Kross and Scarlett burst back onto the scene last week by laying out Drew McIntyre and telling Roman Reigns that his time is running out as Undisputed Champion. Then, here, The Usos used Scarlett's distraction to ambush McIntyre from behind again.
Hmm.
That...sort of made it seem like Jimmy, Jey and Scarlett got together in the back and put together a plan. This obviously wouldn't make sense, because Kross is gunning for Roman, but WWE should've gone out of their way to make it crystal clear that the heels aren't aligned in any way whatsoever.
Little logic loopholes like this are annoying, to be honest. Michael Cole or Pat McAfee only needed to point out that The Usos were probably planning on blindsiding Drew anyway - instead, they kept quiet, and that made it look like Jimmy and Jey colluded with Scarlett.
1. Bootleg Baszler
Final gripe of the week.
Sure, Liv Morgan has to say something about Shayna Baszler, but calling her a "bootleg Ronda Rousey" is probably not the way to go. Being fair, maybe that would've been a lesser evil had WWE not tag-teamed it with Ronda herself criticising Baszler despite Shayna being number one contender.
To top it all off, Liv got the last laugh by planting Baszler through a table during their contract signing. Meanwhile, fans in the stands chanted "YOU TAPPED OUT" relentlessly at Morgan. To quote well-known philosopher Scooby Doo - "R'uh r'oh".
WWE has to be very careful with all of this. Morgan is already on the proverbial shoogly nail as a champion babyface, and they surely don't want to make Shayna look like some cheap knock-off of the woman she beat. That's not how to sell a big pay-per-view bout, basically.
Ups...
5. Looking On The Bright Side
Onto the good.
Whilst it defo isn't awesome to see The Usos lose a non-title match to guys who aren't even a proper tag-team (rumours that Drew McIntyre and Madcap Moss will be in the Women's Tag title tourney are unsubstantiated), the brothers were still in there with the number one contender to cuz Roman Reigns.
That made this one more palatable, and it's also true that Drew and Moss clicked as a one-off duo. This was a great spot for Madcap to be in, and it's really hard to argue with work as solid as what was presented throughout this tag-meets-post-match-story.
Sami Zayn taking a bullet for his Bloodline brethren is cool too, because that's something WWE can come back to next week when Sam is begging for acceptance. Creative recovered from that wobbly start earlier in the show, put a fun tag out in front of fans then continued the story.
4. Some New (Old) Faces
Hit Row returning can only be a good thing for the tag-team division. They never got a fair shake before leaving last year, and there was enough in SmackDown's comeback squash to suggest that Top Dolla and Ashante Thee Adonis will be a credit to the doubles ranks on Friday nights.
B-FAB is a nice complement to the duo too.
They're missing Swerve Strickland, of course, but that can't exactly be helped given he inked a deal with AEW after leaving WWE. Now, perhaps more than ever, Hit Row has the chance to establish itself as one of SmackDown's top acts, and take a stab at those Undisputed Tag belts.
If nothing else, having Dolla and Adonis around means The Usos don't need to keep fighting The Street Profits or Mysterio clan forevermore. This was a promising restart for a group that really should've worked out first time.
3. All That IC Hype
WWE did a bang-up job of making the Intercontinental Title seem like the most important thing going on this week's show. Match aside (more on that later), the company produced a sterling video package and gave both champion and challenger some to-the-point promo time to help sell their clash.
Simple, but effective.
Michael Cole and Pat McAfee went above and beyond to make sure that fans tuning in knew what SmackDown's focal point was this week. Roman Reigns wasn't there anyway, so Gunther and Shin had a free pass to the top of the mountain, and they grabbed that with both hands.
You've got to appreciate this sort of presentation after years and years of so-so build for countless IC Champs. All those little touches, like showing off the rich history of the belt and capturing wide shots of both men staring a hole through one another, worked well.
2. That Main Event
The match, rather predictably, kicked ass.
Gunther vs. Nakamura was always going to be good. Did it exceed expectations? Nah, not really, because everyone knew these dudes would have in-ring chemistry. Best of all, they're probably even capable of better if WWE books a repeat on pay-per-view sans ad breaks.
Everything, from the spotlight on his championship to the way he defended it, made Gunther look like one of the strongest IC Champs in recent memory. SmackDown was a super-promising sign that Triple H is right behind the secondary belt - he did something similar with the US strap over on Raw.
If you're a fan of hard-hitting wrestling matches with no frills and excellent action, then check this one out ASAP. Kudos must go to the commentary team for getting right into it, and to WWE's creative team for giving Gunther the clean finish.
1. ‘Renegade’ Ronda Rousey
Christ, where has this Ronda Rousey been hiding?!
The ex-MMA star should just stroll around doing whatever the f*ck she likes. All those fake smiles and nervous promos gave way to a bad bitch attitude that really suits her. Everybody knows Rousey is minted too, so it was neat to have her boast about paying WWE's fines with ease.
Why is she content to pay them? Well, Ronda enjoys kicking the crap out of everybody in her path, and she won't stop until she gets revenge on Liv Morgan for taking her title. Yes, the show could've done without Rousey tearing down Shayna Baszler (that was unnecessary), but the good outweighed the bad here.
Ronda looks much more comfortable as a villain who can get away with anything because of her mean streak and bank balance. There was actually a touch of Brock Lesnar about her on Friday's episode, and that's not a negative.
What did you think of this week's WWE SmackDown? For more like this, check out 4 Ups & 3 Downs From AEW Rampage (Aug 5) and 10 Precise Moments When WWE Ruthless Aggression Era Careers Ended!