5 Ups & 4 Downs From WWE SmackDown (July 24)
Trying to raise the bar by lowering the tone.
If you've ever wanted to see Jeff Hardy pelt a cowering Sheamus with basketballs, then SmackDown was the show for you.
One must measure expectations when it comes to watching WWE's product. Going in thinking logic will be watertight and every decision will have meaning only results in disappointment. That's especially true when it comes to pre-taped brawls like Friday's 'Bar Fight' sketch.
At the same time, some booking is absolutely infuriating and totally undermines all the good. Sometimes, that even happens in the same segment, which barely makes any sense; why would the folks writing these angles do something well and then immediately scupper their own hard work by contradicting the purpose a few minutes later?
There's a reason why the 'Ups' and 'Downs' are so close this week. For every positive SmackDown threw up, there was a negative lurking around the next corner to make viewers feel like a fool if they did emotionally invest in what was going on.
Through all that, it wasn't a bad show. In fact, this week's episode had some smart stuff that made the two hours whizz by...
Downs...
4. Miz TV
As always, let's get the crap out of the way first.
Someone in WWE needs to speak up and suggest that interview segments like 'A Moment Of Bliss' and 'Miz TV' get the old heave-ho, at least for a while. Friday's latest example, which had Naomi attempting to justify online support from fans whilst Miz and John Morrison ripped the p*ss out of Seth Rollins for puking, was hard to watch.
These talk show-style skits have become so stale it's unbelievable. They rarely serve much purpose (when was the last time Miz or Bliss had someone on their show that they were actually feuding with?) or entertain for their 10-15 minute durations. In short, they're a complete waste of everybody's time.
Miz and JoMo work their juvenile humour well, but they absolutely did not need to be involved in things between Naomi and Lacey Evans. They were shoehorned in for the sake of it, and that's just lazy, uninspired booking.
3. Undeserving Contenders
This could be construed as too negative, because it's hardly a bad thing when wrestling companies give fresh talent opportunities, but it'd be nice to see some context behind that opportunity. SmackDown's four-way between Gran Metalik, Lince Dorado, Shorty G and Drew Gulak didn't have that.
What did these guys do to deserve warring for a crack at the IC Title?
The field for this match only served to show how thin on the ground the babyface side is on the SmackDown undercard right now. Nobody is buying Metalik as a credible threat to AJ Styles. Nobody. That'd be the case had Dorado or Shorty won - only Gulak has some recent history with the champ, which WWE could've played with.
Instead, they've got a cold championship clash next week. Styles will bring the best out in Metalik, no doubt, but this is hardly gonna' be a ratings grab for WWE. If they're going to build new stars, then they need to do so properly.
2. Sheamus & Jeff Sitting Down Together
It's easy to see what WWE were going for here.
They wanted to present Sheamus and Jeff Hardy as two battle-weary gunslingers sitting down to talk before fighting. It's the old cinematic 'calm before the storm' trick, and it might've worked well had the feud been presented with some begrudging respect issue. It hasn't though, and therein lies the problem.
Sheamus has been appearing via video link in his "home bar", or sneaking up to attack Jeff from behind. He's also been poking fun at some super-serious substance abuse issues, but Hardy was happy to sit there and chew the fat with him before their 'Bar Fight'. Why?!
It didn't make a lick of sense that Jeff would be so calm and measured. The same goes for Sheamus; he should still be seething that Hardy hurled urine into his face on live television and embarrassed him in front of the watching world. This was a poor presentation choice.
Imagine 'Taker and AJ Styles sitting down to share a pint before 'Boneyard'? It wouldn't happen.
1. Jeff Hardy's Oddly Chirpy Post-Show Promo
Some will claim that it's cheating to criticise something that happened after SmackDown went off the air, but WWE's YouTube channel is still a place to push storylines, characters and the product generally. It's therefore maddening that Jeff Hardy appeared to brush off his 'Bar Fight' issues with Sheamus.
Honestly, watch the short promo linked above. Go on.
Now, think about how intense parts of Jeff's feud with Sheamus have been and how real his drug and alcohol woes are. Wouldn't it make more sense if he was knackered and reflective rather than chirpily delivering his post-match promo like he'd barely broken sweat? This was another poor decision.
It was a conflicting choice to have the face-painted Hardy grin and giggle like he was recording something for WWE 24 so soon after a major storyline moment. Things like this make it so incredibly hard for fans to care about feuds.
Ups...
5. Alexa Bliss Going Old-School
Right, good vibes only for this point on.
Ignore the fact that Bayley played GM by setting up Alexa Bliss vs. Nikki Cross early in the show. WWE has moved on (although probably not permanently) from endless authority figure matchmaking, and that gives programming a bit more zip. It doesn't make much sense, but it's also harmless.
The match was solid too. Nikki has developed into a likeable spitfire babyface, and seeing her wrestle her on screen pal felt unique. Also, whichever agent made the call for Bliss to go back in time, turn back into her vindictive little witch self and attack Cross' injured ribs deserves a pat on the back.
Alexa did so reluctantly, and that gave some emotional weight to her own dreams of becoming SmackDown Women's Champion. WWE booked the match, gave both enough time, had Bliss tease a heel turn and then re-established her relationship with Nikki backstage.
4. 'King' Corbin's Ransom
There are some on Twitter jumping down WWE's throat for failing to mention exactly how much the bounty 'King' Corbin placed on Matt Riddle's head is. This writer doesn't think a named figure is all that necessary; those same folks would likely bitch if he said something like $10,000 ('that's too little') or a bloated $100,000 ('that's too much').
Guys like Corbin can't win with a certain portion of the audience.
The shame there is that he's the perfect opponent for Riddle's first feature-length feud since moving on from NXT. Corbin is also cast as a minted royal who believes his own sh*t, so why would he need to name a price? SmackDown's proletariat should be happy to get their hands on anything he throws at them.
WWE should, however, use this revolving door of opponents to present Riddle as a dangerous ass-kicker rather than focus on some ill-wanted backstory about why he doesn't wear shoes or boots in-ring. Pretty much nobody gives a toss about that.
3. "It's His Turn Now"
WWE have dropped the ball with Bray Wyatt through so much over the years that a lesser man would've crumbled by now. Thankfully, Bray is one of the most skilled talkers in pro wrestling today, and he's able to make the best of even the worst situations. Case in point: SmackDown's confirmation that the 'Fiend' vs. Braun Strowman is next.
There's almost nothing Wyatt can't rescue.
This week, he appeared via 'Firefly Fun House' to report that the 'Eater Of Worlds' had been eaten and his future was fiendish. He did suggest that Strowman is still mired beneath the swamp they battled in at Extreme Rules, which is bizarre, but this guy can make anything work no matter how daft.
It's a massive compliment to the strength of the character's look and aura that the 'Fiend' didn't melt away as a relevant entity post-Goldberg squash earlier this year. This will either be the death of that gimmick too, or another chance for Bray to prove he's worthy of leading SmackDown as Universal Champ.
2. Bar Brawlers
Once they'd dispensed with their little Clint Eastwood-style sit down, Sheamus and Jeff Hardy made the most of their 'Bar Fight' setting. They were always going to - WWE know how to shoot and format these brawls better than most, and both guys are playing their roles well in spite of the wonky storytelling.
If you rarely watch SmackDown and only use recaps like this to stay abreast, then do yourself a favour and check this week's main event out. It's worth seeing, if only for the typical set destruction, some great use of implied comedy and that barman taking quite the bump for his troubles.
The fact he was called "Vinny Mac" is also tremendous.
Anyone who has wanted to see Jeff put Sheamus in his place would've been delighted by the finish as well. Some of the beats to this tale have definitely been dodgy, but the blow off was everything it needed to be and ended the show on a high.
1. A Big (E) Singles Push?
There are question marks hanging over this one.
Is Kofi Kingston legitimately injured, or are WWE simply experimenting with Big E as a singles act to see if he can catch fire and become that next breakout star? Whatever the truth is, E deserves the chance. The hip-gyrating, big-bump-taking entertainment machine has been one of WWE's most consistent performers for years now.
Anyone worried that this is the end of New Day shouldn't be. The group don't need to split up for Big E to have some solo success. In fact, it'd be better if they didn't and any major wins he did grab were backed by support from Kingston and a still-injured Xavier Woods.
E must now be in contention (along with Jeff Hardy) to face AJ Styles for the Intercontinental Title at SummerSlam in August. That's a fresh match that screams pay-per-view quality, and this could be a great story about diversity and seizing opportunity if WWE handle it sensitively.
What did you think of this week's WWE SmackDown? For more content, check out 22 Craziest Moments From WWE Extreme Rules 2020 and 10 WWE Wrestlers Who Are Missing Right Now!