5 Ups & 4 Downs From WWE SmackDown (Nov 20)
Someone should've told New Day to go home on WWE's final stop before Survivor Series...

WWE had one more chance to shoot their shot and make Survivor Series look must-see on this week's SmackDown.
Did they achieve that goal? The jury's out, but maybe that has more to do with this time of year generally than anything else. It's been said before (and it'll be said again, probably in 2021), but Survivors is a lame-duck pay-per-view these days. Not only that - the show also needlessly spits on recent roster changes.
SmackDown's writers did the best they could with dodgy formatting then. They deserve credit for that, and both Roman Reigns and Drew McIntyre need a pat on the back for injecting some much-needed life into their 'Champion vs. Champion' bout too. Actually, throw Paul Heyman into that as well. His facial expressions are world class.
Whilst there's a definite sense that WWE creative can't wait to motor past Sunday, they did pen some good stuff on SmackDown. Of course, they also suffered because of the boring Raw vs. SmackDown tropes that have strangled November for too long.
Here are all the 'Ups' and 'Downs' from WWE's go home episode...
Downs...
4. Friendly Rivalry

Meh.
That's the prevailing feeling on this New Day vs. Street Profits match at Survivor Series. It all started so promisingly when Dawkins and Ford looked like they might be the villains of the piece, but WWE swiftly moved away from that in favour of painting both as valiant babyface champs.
It's dull as all hell, and isn't doing either team justice. Seeing both duos team up days before they're supposed to beat the crap out of another was a hollow experience, one made worse by ye olde belt-raising antics post-eight man tag on SmackDown. Again, this is seriously lifeless and dull.
These teams shouldn't be having some bullsh*t friendly rivalry. They should be desperate to prove that they're the superior champions; then again, these are the lads who gleefully swapped belts during the Draft, so maybe that's expecting too much.
3. “Brand Solidarity”

What do you see when you look at SmackDown's female Survivor Series team above? Does that look like the kind of combination that'd see eye-to-eye when they've only just aligned? Or, does it look like a random assortment of workers struggling to outshine their last-minute captain?
The latter fits best, sadly.
Team SmackDown's celebration after Natalya beat Tamina was so false, and it weirdly felt like a drop down the ladder for Bayley. If WWE were hoping that her star power would drag everyone else up by the boot straps, they were mistaken - this "brand solidarity" stuff is as generic as they come.
The Riott Squad aren't over, Natalya has been a bit-part for too long now and Bianca Belair is only just getting started. That leaves Bayley to carry the can, and this writer isn't sure that's a fair shift for someone who shouldn't stray too far from Sasha Banks.
2. Fool Me Once…

Speaking of Sasha.
How many times in a row is Banks going to fall for Carmella's ambush tactics? This is becoming a running joke now, and it's making the babyface (tweener?) SmackDown Women's Champion look foolish. Surely, at some point, Sasha has to know that 'Mella will run in from behind and attack her "when she least expects it".
WWE are gonna' have to come up with build better than this is they want fans to take the match seriously come TLC next month. Banks has to cut her new rival off sometime, and show that she's not a standard, dumb pro wrasslin' baby who never learns her lesson.
Christ, Banks is coming off a feud with Bayley during which her old pal constantly attacked her from behind. You'd think she'd know the script by now, eh? Still, at least WWE did use Sasha's upcoming rematch with Asuka to build something else.
1. Draft? What Draft?

As predicted, WWE don't give a rat's ass about the Draft they spent weeks hyping up in October.
New Day, Drew McIntyre and Asuka all gate-crashed Friday night's offering to hype their Survivor Series matches. That's...fine, because WWE have a pay-per-view to promote, but why the heck did they schedule things this way? Why not run the Draft earlier in the year so it doesn't clash with a show relying on Raw vs. SmackDown?
It's infuriating to see this happen every single year without change. Fans find it difficult to get excited for the Draft when they know picks won't actually matter - wrestlers will show up on rival brands to promote Survivor Series anyway. The whole thing is flawed from the start.
Hearing Xavier Woods claim that he and Kofi Kingston don't "check into the SmackDown hotel" these days was cute, but inaccurate. They were literally doing just that, and it hasn't been too long since they were full-timers on the show.
Ups...
5. Murphy’s Win

Seth Rollins is ready to take off for a while and be with Becky Lynch as the couple prepare to welcome their first child. That pushed WWE into shortening (ha) Seth's issues with Rey Mysterio last week, and it's why Rollins worked old 'Disciple' Murphy on this past Friday's show too.
The good news is that it resulted in a memorable win for Murph.
Who knows where the company plan to take his angle with Rey, Dominik and Aalyah next, but it was nice to see him score a huge victory over one of WWE's top stars. This, hopefully, will be a launching pad for the former 205 Live man - he's talented enough to make a splash if creative don't get cold feet.
The logical play is a tag-team with Dom, or maybe even a short-term union before Murphy convinces Aalyah to turn on her family. Whatever the case, it's giving talented workers something else to do other than make up numbers on Team SmackDown. That cannot be considered a bad thing right now.
4. Head Of The Table

Few get their characters like Roman Reigns does.
The 'Tribal Chief' is arguably the best in pro wrestling right now at staying true to his gimmick, and he showed why on SmackDown. Roman walked to the ring for a contract signing segment with Drew McIntyre, then demanded that Adam Pearce vacate his seat so he could sit at the head of the table.
That, dear friends, was absolutely fantastic stuff. It p*ssed off McIntyre (as it should), put a smarmy smirk on Paul Heyman's face and sold that Reigns truly believes he's some father figure for WWE as a whole. Pearce did a solid job of looking confused without wanting to irk the 'Big Dog' further as well.
This part of the show should've been skippable. It should've been standard stuff, and it shouldn't have been as good as it was. The truth is though that Roman and Drew are somehow pulling magic out of their arses and making this potentially special...
3. World Championship Chemistry

Their chemistry on the mic is fierce.
Both men did a remarkable job with very little material on Friday. They let natural competition take centre stage, and managed to weave some realism in there that rewarded those who've been paying attention all year long. For example, Roman believes that Drew was just 'keeping things warm' in his absence.
McIntyre didn't take kindly to the suggestion that he was a placeholder for someone else. This is the dude who tore the house down at Royal Rumble, then connected with fans like never before after beating Brock Lesnar for the WWE Title at WrestleMania. To Drew, 2020 has been his year, not Roman's.
Just look at the eye contact in the pic above - it's mean, it's raw and it's the kind of thing WWE don't do enough. These guys don't like one another, but share a healthy professional respect neither wants to admit. They're turning a passive situation into a thrilling one.
2. Short But Sweet Promos

Some would say that the art of the wrestling promo has been lost. Those critics dislike the formulaic backstage speeches that offer little, and they think WWE must come up with new ways to tell their stories. Their arguments are valid, but not on this week's SmackDown.
Some of the mic work was beautiful.
Firstly, Daniel Bryan and Jey Uso traded backstage promos that did a stellar job of building towards their main event match. Both were short enough that they didn't drag, but explosive enough to sell the thought that the match would be worth seeing. That should be the basic purpose of any wrestling interview.
Then, Seth Rollins took the floor and cut a goodie himself. He's really taken to his 'Messiah' character, and it has led to some of the best promos of his WWE career. See? "Formulaic" needn't be useless if workers put some oomph into things.
1. The Right Call

This writer was wrong.
It's important to put one's hands up when that happens, and he was. Previously, yours truly had said that Jey Uso shouldn't lose for a good while yet. Really, that point should've come with more context. Jey shouldn't lose constantly, but it's perfectly alright for him to come up short against top class workers like Daniel Bryan.
That's what happened on SmackDown, and it rocked. This was a sweet way to prep Daniel for Roman Reigns, which should be awesome. It was also some logical babyface revenge after Uso had attacked Bryan several weeks ago. WWE did a neat job of linking everything together here.
Jey didn't look like some useless jobber either. He got his licks in, and Daniel is a clever-enough performer to realise how vital that could be to the story later on; what's to stop Reigns from sneering and reminding Bry that he struggled to get past Jey?
Rock solid booking all round.
What did you think of this week's WWE SmackDown? For more like this, check out WWE Survivor Series 2020: 10 Things That Must Happen and WWE Survivor Series 2020: 10 Nightmares That Could Come True!