5 Ups & 4 Downs From WWE WrestleMania 41 - Night 2 (Results & Review)

Did the women have the best Mania opener ever? Main event plods along to close an uneven weekend.

Good news, bad news.

Good news: Night two of WrestleMania 41 was a vast improvement over the first night.

Bad news: The main event of Sunday’s show was bad, dragging down an evening that had the potential to salvage the entire PLE.

Mania opened Sunday with what should be in the conversation for the greatest WrestleMania opener of all time, Iyo Sky versus Bianca Belair versus Rhea Ripley. The women’s triple threat had an awful build, but even the harshest critics knew there was a high ceiling and potential for greatness.

The show maintained a fair amount of steam throughout the night – even the negative moments weren’t all that bad – until they got to the main event. Cody Rhodes has carried the company for the past couple years, and John Cena’s abrupt heel turn has produced mixed results, no thanks to The Rock’s disappearing act after Elimination Chamber.

WWE will point to the noise in the stadium for the main event, but this is not a match that will be replayed in the months and years ahead. It potentially damaged Cody’s brand, and unless they’ve got a solid plan for what comes next (and Rock doesn’t blow that up), this could go off the rails. Time will tell.

Overall, WrestleMania 41 was a huge drop-off from the previous two years, both in match quality and fan service. There definitely are cracks forming in WWE’s once-invincible armor, and this weekend’s show put some of that on display. Sunday was a better effort, but it’s hard to call the entire PLE anything more than falling short of its potential.

Let’s get to it…


DOWNS…

4. Bayley Sidelined For The Man

There will be some praise for the return of Becky Lynch in a bit, but for the surprise appearance of The Man to come at the expense of Bayley is ridiculous.

The Role Model has had a difficult few months. Since losing her WWE Women’s Championship, she’s struggled to find her footing, and her match quality had declined to the point where some were wondering whether she’d lost something.

Bayley started stringing together a few good bouts the past couple weeks, culminating in a really good tag team gauntlet match alongside Lyra Valkyria to earn a tag title match at WrestleMania 41… and then WWE pulled the rug out from under her with a storyline injury Saturday, allowing Lynch to be a surprise entrant and win the tag titles with her countrywoman Lyra Sunday night.

Even if Bayley knew weeks in advance of the plan, this still has to be a gutshot for her, to battle on television to get to Mania and then written out for a shock return.


3. Logan, AJ Have A Match

If this were Monday Night Raw, AJ Styles versus Logan Paul would have been a perfectly acceptable TV match.

But as a WrestleMania attraction, their bout Sunday was… eh.

The two had a bathroom break of a match, a series of spots and moves, with the drama coming toward the end when human trope Jeff (Logan’s sidekick) shockingly showed up with brass knuckles… only for Karrion Kross to intervene and stop him. And then AJ inexplicably attacked Kross after refusing to use the knucks. Styles then immediately fell victim to Paul’s loaded punch and a Paulverizer.

While it wasn’t a bad match, this was dull and knocked whatever luster was left off Styles. It also served to normalize Logan. He’s a social media star who’s a spot junkie in the ring, not a wrestler. There’s no real emotion behind his matches, other than “Logan’s a douche.” He needs to start to string together actual matches, because the returns are quickly diminishing.


2. What Was The Point?

When The Rock showed up at Elimination Chamber and facilitated John Cena’s heel turn, the immediate reaction was that WWE could have an absolutely electric pairing with two of the company’s biggest stars ever teaming up to disrupt things.

What ended up happening was Rock disappeared from WWE entirely and Cena cut a series of lifeless promos to build his match against Cody Rhodes. But surely, Rocky would return at WrestleMania to make sense of all of this foolishness and reveal the master plan, right? RIGHT?

Wrong. It was Travis Scott, who looked scrawny by comparison to Cody and Cena, who provided the “big run-in” at the climax of Sunday’s main event, ultimately eating a Cross-Rhodes and providing a distraction allowing Cena to cheat to win his 17th world championship. Anyone looking for answers found none.

Ultimately, it looks more and more like Rock basically showed up like a human tornado, tore up plans, jumbled everything and left WWE to pick up the pieces. You could remove Rock from the entire story and things would have worked the same, just without the questions. Maybe it was a no-win scenario and you can’t fault WWE if Rock insisted on it, but that doesn’t absolve the company from a major plot hole.


1. A Plodding, Badly Booked Main Event

John Cena said he wants to ruin wrestling, and he laid the first bricks Sunday night in a dud of a main event to close WrestleMania 41.

It’s clear Cena and Cody Rhodes were going for the big match feel in a stadium that was hot for everything they did, and they had to navigate a crowd that was going full Rock/Hulk Hogan at WrestleMania X8.

But the match was basic and plodding, with Cody wrestling at half-speed while Cena took about 75 percent of the offense. Rhodes, who ended an epic Roman Reigns title reign last year, lost to the slowest “run-in” in wrestling history from Travis Scott, a low blow and a title shot to the head.

That’s not to say that this should have been a technical display or a fast-paced match with dozens of counters. But the pacing was glacial at several points, with Cody selling for an exorbitant amount of time for a guy that tag team jobber Austin Theory beat two years ago. And then came Travis.

Scott’s saunter-in was the kind of ga-ga that required a suspension of disbelief, with Rhodes and Cena having to basically freeze in the ring while he slowly made his way to ringside to try to punch Cody again. Got that? A rapper, who potatoed a laid-out Rhodes at Elimination Chamber, was the big “interference” to aid Cena, and all he really provided was a distraction – and a huge interruption in the match.

All of this – along with Cody falling for Cena’s Ric Flair beg-off – made him look like the gullible Surfer Sting, which betrayed Rhodes’ character. This was a guy who spent more than a year battling the Bloodline, and he was duped by Cena’s bad acting and Travis Scott? It was an ignominious end to his title reign.

Yes, the crowd noise was off the charts. But if you weren’t in the stadium, you aren’t going back and rewatching this match over and over.


UPS…

5. Women’s Tag Gets Some Shine

To be honest, this one could have gone either way. Becky Lynch’s return meant Bayley got bumped from WrestleMania, it lead to Women’s Intercontinental Champion Lyra Valkryia playing second fiddle, and it meant that Liv Morgan would lose at Mania after a tremendous year.

However, the match provided some of what you want in a WrestleMania match: a huge moment with Lynch’s shock return, a title change, and some good in-ring action. The match itself was inoffensive fun, with Morgan playing the sh**-talking heel who got her comeuppance after months of claiming that she had driven Becky in retirement.

Lynch had a bit of ring rust, but she came through with the hot tag at the end, delivering a Molly-Go-Round on Raquel Rodriguez, rolling through and hitting Liv with a Bexploder. She and Lyra made a good team, with Valkyria saving Becky after an Oblivion, ultimately allowing Lynch to pick up the win with a Manhandle Slam.

Even though she was overshadowed by Lynch’s big return, Lyra had a nice moment afterward holding two titles aloft at WrestleMania, which is a good endorsement from the company. Hopefully they keep that faith in her going forward.


4. Say His Name And He Appears

The moment Kevin Owens announced he had suffered an injury and was unable to compete at WrestleMania, the speculation began about who Randy Orton would face in his place. Would it be a returning Rusev? Maybe an NXT wrestler?

Instead, TNA Champion Joe Hendry appeared to accept the open challenge. In terms of a WrestleMania surprise and some light fun, Hendry was a perfect choice. He popped the crowd (meeting the definition of a legit good surprise), his viral entrance was over huge in the stadium, and his losing to Orton didn’t hurt anyone of consequence on the roster.

For Hendry, this likely was one of the biggest moments of his career. However, it can’t be understated that TNA’s world champion essentially became a jobber-to-the-stars for Orton. If you’re AAA, which WWE just acquired, you’ve got to wonder if that fate awaits many of your champions going forward.


3. Dirty Dom Gets His Flowers

Has Dominik Mysterio lowkey become a fan favorite? Or are fans just loving him ironically?

Mysterio captured the Intercontinental Championship Sunday night in a fun four-way match that featured some electric moments, most of which were courteous of Bron Breakker. The IC champ coming into the match, Breakker dominated large parts of the match with his combination of speed and power, including a spear from one announce desk to the other, spiking Carlito and ending his night.

But the story of the match belonged to Dirty Dom. Finn Balor crotched Mysterio just as he was going for a frogsplash on Bron, then focused his attack on Breakker. However, Dominik flew in with the frogsplash on both men to pin Finn and win his first main roster title.

Fun match with a memorable finish – though it would have been nice if the agents discussed the fact that the opener used almost exactly the same finish (wrestler jumps off the top rope to break up a pinfall and gets the pin themselves).


2. A Brutal WWE Plunder Brawl

WWE hardcore matches (street fights, no DQ, etc.) have certain limitations and tropes that inhibit their ability to truly cut loose and exude the chaos that they promise.

Sunday, Drew McIntyre and Damian Priest managed to work within those confines to have a really fun plunder brawl that matched the intensity and brutality of the feud in the weeks and months prior. There were the traditional chair and steel steps shots, but Drew and Damian battered each other repeatedly with the weapons before getting to the climax.

After a Razor’s Edge through a table, a FutureShock DDT on the steps and a back-and-forth exchange, Priest went for a ropewalk, only for Drew to shove him off to the floor and through two tables. He dragged Priest onto the turnbuckle and sandwiched Damian’s head against a steel chair with a Claymore to pick up the win.

It wasn’t a classic or even the best street fight of the year, but the second match on the card has a tough task – especially after an all-timer opener. This did an admirable job.


1. Perfect On The Night

No matter how bad the build to the Women’s World Championship triple threat was at times, there was never much of a doubt that Iyo Sky, Bianca Belair and Rhea Ripley would deliver on the night.

And Sunday, they exceeded even the loftiest of expectations with a match that instantly ranks as one of WWE’s best WrestleMania openers ever.

The women kicked off night two with a phenomenal, hyper-action match that started fast and never let up. The thread through the entire battle was Bianca and Rhea repeatedly coming together in the center of the ring to slug it out, with Iyo being sidelined – much like the build to the match. Then Sky would fly in and put both women down and remind everyone why she’s the champion.

There was a fair amount of creativity in spots involving all three wrestlers, such as Rhea hitting Iyo with a Razor’s Edge, but throwing Sky into Belair like a javelin. Bianca grabbed Ripley while she had Iyo in a Prison Lock to attempt a KOD. Sky’s attempted moonsault hit Rhea’s boots, propelling her right into Belair for a KOD.

The finish itself continued that trend with Belair using her braid as a whip on Rhea before delivering the KOD, only for Iyo to moonsault both women to pin Bianca. A silky smooth performance from all three that still somehow felt like an aggressive battle.

It also was the right booking to have Iyo retain after being treated like an afterthought between Rhea and Bianca. Great stuff all around.


 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Scott is a former journalist and longtime wrestling fan who was smart enough to abandon WCW during the Monday Night Wars the same time as the Radicalz. He fondly remembers watching WrestleMania III, IV, V and VI and Saturday Night's Main Event, came back to wrestling during the Attitude Era, and has been a consumer of sports entertainment since then. He's written for WhatCulture since 2014, establishing the Ups and Downs articles for WWE Raw and WWE PPVs/PLEs and composing pieces on a variety of topics.