5 Ups & 5 Downs From AEW Double Or Nothing 2023

All Elite Wrestling offers all-timer action hand-in-hand with all the same recent creative concerns.

Matt Jackson Exploding Superkick
AEW

Is it possible for there to be an outright bad AEW pay-per-view in 2023, or for that matter at all?

That was the (admittedly generous) question being asked ahead of the fourth edition of AEW's tentpole Las Vegas supercard, thanks to yet another wildly uneven build and yet another card that promised - literally in the case of Anarchy In The Arena after Jon Moxley's go-home Dynamite promo - at least one match to be in conversation for the best of the year.

Double Or Nothing 2023's card was stipulation-heavy but otherwise disciplined on paper, but could The Blackpool Combat Club, The Elite, and especially The Four Pillars use their collected years of main event poise and experience to ensure the show's biggest offerings were etched into memory as fans left the T-Mobile Arena?

And to at very least cast an eye at the elephant in the room if not quite acknowledge it, could those 12 men in particular - those with the biggest spots, facing the biggest acclaim for things going well and loudest complaints for if and when they haven't - silence the constant whispers about a 13th that stands to walk back in and be the subject of every single conversation for the next few weeks?


Downs…

5. Chris Jericho Vs Adam Cole

Adam Cole

What looked like a blood feud might have been a good feud, and perhaps that was one of the problems with the layout of this disappointing and overlong affair.

Sabu was a late inclusion in proceedings as a device for dealing with the obvious numbers disadvantage between respective associates The JAS and Roderick Strong, but after the 'Suicidal, Homicidal, Genocidal' maniac used a chair and a table (!) to unleash his brand of destruction, the contest felt stilted and disjointed.

At 17 minutes, it was far from the longest match on the card, but you'd be forgiven for thinking otherwise. A handcuff chain was a nice callback to the flashpoint moment of their programme, but the makeshift dog collar portion dragged like just about everything else and assisted spots with it failed to connect live.

This was laid bare at the finish. After everything peaked with Britt Baker and Saraya's kendo stick war, Cole blackened Jericho's eye and won via stoppage. Las Vegas - already miffed with an under-delivery of a show - hated it, and the series might have felt doomed had it not been for an upcoming mixed tag booking and Jericho fireballing a poor backstage staffer.


4. Wardlow (c) vs. Christian Cage

Wardlow Swanton Bomb

Wardlow being the one to request a ladder match against one of the modern architects of the stipulation felt like a knowingly big flex from the TNT Champion, but his own experience with the dangerous implement of destruction was called upon in the build too.

If one draws a line from that to the Swanton Bomb 'The Wardog' hit on Luchasaurus at the end of this odd outing, the whole thing's made sense and the restored titleholder has taken yet another impressive and stature-enhancing scalp. But it wasn't quite that simple. Christian started off dodging big moves, but that thread was dropped. Arn Anderson arrived to try and send the dinosaur packing, but suddenly he was biting his thumbs and nobody could quite work that out. Wardow's sheer mass warped a ladder, then he tried to climb it anyway.

It was impossible to shake the feeling, though Wardlow retaining in such spectacular fashion shows major company commitment to the project if nothing else. That might seem patronising to one of the best big men in the game an industry icon, but a straight singles match might have scaled a little higher than this.


3. Jamie Hayter vs. Toni Storm

Toni Storm
AEW

...didn't happen in the way it was promoted, as AEW tried a little bit to have its cake and eat it too in a way that made the experience of fan favourite Hayter losing her title feel more like a cheat code than a transgression.

It was after Wednesday's Dynamite/Rampage tapings that there were reports discussing the Champion's possible injuries, and though the angle here - The Outcasts cheat and cheat and cheat again - attempted to frame it as a work, it was the sort of thing the company wouldn't have done with the men's Championship and flew too close to deception rather than creative guile.

More's the pity - what little we got of the physicality was predictably great, but then that felt just as difficult to parse. Hayter did quite a bit for somebody that couldn't do anything, and deserves isolating for praise in that respect. Storm will make a great champion once again, but once again her reign has started under something of a cloud.


2. House Of Black (c) vs. The Acclaimed

House Of Black
AEW

It had seemed possible that House Of Black's new formula was just to kick ass first and worry later when it came to angles, storylines and plot twists. The obvious in-built support base, the immense satisfaction of getting to watch them work live and the fact that they'd beaten The Elite with almost no story back at Revolution validated the theory to an extent...

...until they had a match that bordered on boring with the red hot Acclaimed.

On those terms, this proof of concept match was a dismal failure, even if it had its occasional in-ring highs. But those same highs are there all the time in AEW because the company has worked extremely hard to raise the bar beyond any expectations that might once have been held. There'll always be great wrestling matches, but the crowd reactions at Double Or Nothing were a stark reminder that they simply aren't enough.

The match lacked flow, proper out-and-out heel/babyface drama, and both teams and the belts felt too trivial as a result. The House Rules gimmick still has legs, but otherwise it's less "back to the drawing board" and more "actually use it for the first time".


1. "AEW Is Changing"

Kris Statlander Jade Cargill
AEW

Tony Khan used this line to describe the June the company is set to have with the arrival of Collision, the release of Fight Forever, and the Forbidden Door pay-per-view alongside all other events taking place in Canada and beyond.

Was he trying to highlight a quiet philosophical overhaul too?

Not for the first time in 2023, one of AEW core tenets fell at Double Or Nothing 2023. The company had never outright said there'd not be impromptu matches and the like, but they didn't need to and they never booked them. That was how faith in processes was restored, that was how talent got over in more meaningful ways, and that was one of the many ways the group distinguished itself from WWE.

When Kris Statlander unseated Jade Cargill to a monster, monster pop in one of the feel good moments of the year - and more on that later - that's what happened. It can be both happy and sad faces in the theatrical iconography, and that's exactly what it was here.

AEW is changing, but it when it does stuff the same as it always did...


Ups…

5. Blackjack Battle Royal

Orange Cassidy
AEW

The idea of slacker Orange Cassidy assembling one of the best title runs in All Elite Wrestling history was already amazing before his biggest test to date arrived in the form of this charmingly contrived Battle Royal.

The premise - Cassidy is so sick of all these challengers being so awesome that he wants to knock them all out in one go - was so inspired, but the battle royal itself paid it off by making them all so appealing or devastating as potential champions.

Keith Lee and Swerve Strickland's face off drew a reaction that suggested a Dynamite payoff was forthcoming, Juice Robinson and Jay White were devilish in their efforts to eliminate Ricky Starks, and both of Best Friends being dumped to keep Cassidy in left a story beat behind should that be an avenue worth exploring.

'Freshly Squeezed' getting the win after a gripping and captivating last battle with Swerve was one of the more cathartic reactions of the night, but this euphoric "Up" wouldn't be complete without mention of the the glorious Big Bill and everything he did. Playing killer of the faves, he did the damage then laughed in the faces of fans that hated it. It was perfect battle royal booking, and here's to more of Bill after maximising the living sh*t out of these minutes.


4. FTR (c) vs. Jeff Jarrett & Jay Lethal

Jeff Jarrett
AEW

Dax Harwood was far stupider than Mark Briscoe when he dared to patronise the Ring Of Honor icon ahead of FTR's title defence against Jeff Jarrett and Jay Lethal. 'The King Of The Mountain' was just dumb in thinking he could manipulate him too, but the heels' devious plan had worked well enough that Briscoe's impartiality wasn't going to be called into question unless it absolutely had to be.

And it did, as Jarrett's plot spectacularly unravelled in a match that proved that 'Double J' has gone from being nightmare AEW hire to fan service aficionado.

A greatest hits of everything he's in this run done so far, this had the Memphis babyface shine early doors, preposterous cheating from the heels to flip the script and an all-time bells-and-whistles bonanza to see the whole thing over the line. Highlights were Karen Jarrett blasting Aubrey Edwards over the head with a guitar so she yet again couldn't count her husband's shoulders to the match, Jarrett doing his longest ever doomed pre-pinfall celebration, and Mark Briscoe giving it great guns ejecting Sonjay Dutt as the inciting incident. Oh, and all the other highlights, of course. This was utter, utter perfection.


3. Jade Cargill (c) vs. Taya Valkyrie

Kris Statlander
AEW

"Finisher stuff" wasn't exactly the deepest or most meaningful motivation for these two women to twice wage war for the TBS Championship, but Jade Cargill's 59-0 record going into the pay-per-view yet again didn't feel particularly under threat even if they assembled a great match on the night.

And then it did!

Valkyrie and Cargill's occasional miscommunications aside, this was a stirring rematch that featured more than enough physicality from the Challenger that a now-legal Road To Valhalla attempt drew one of the loudest nearfalls all evening. A split crowd thought they were seeing history, dove into the moment, and gave the wrestlers their emotions. Job done, and Jade retained, but then it was time for Jade to finally do a job.

As noted above, the implications of Kris Statlander's impromptu TBS Championship victory could be dire, but it was impossible not to smile as she ended the streak at 60-0, announced her comeback in the most satisfying way imaginable, and gave punters in the building the live experience they'd been craving mere minutes earlier. WWE does this with Money In The Bank for a reason - it's harder to back babyfaces longterm, but the in-arena vibe is undeniable.


2. MJF (c) vs. Sammy Guevara vs. Darby Allin vs. "Jungle Boy" Jack Perry

Four Pillars
AEW

The prospective quality of this match existed four years ago. That's the point, really; upon formation, All Elite Wrestling as a company carefully assessed what young talents might be fit to go in headline spots within a few years of launch. This was the manifestation of it, the big idea made real, and it's perhaps why a muddled built felt at times like it was doing individual disservices just about everybody other than a Champion too sensational to be denied.

The intricacies and sequencing were a sight to behold as the quartet attempted to tell the story of their first four years in the form of rapid-fire physical abuse. Less about what had been on television in the last few weeks, this was all Four Pillars first using everything they had to kick ass before borrowing from their mentors to do it all again.

This wasn't one story - not Jungle Boy failing once again to fully embrace the dark side, not MJF and Darby Allin's magnificently petty headlock takeover war, not Sammy Guevara's repackaging as a babyface that might just work this time, not countless others woven into the bout - but all of them illustrated through a breathless offering that thankfully did more for the three Challengers than anything we'd seen on screen in the build.

It was far far more than "alright on the night".


1. Blackpool Combat Club vs. The Elite

Konosuke Takeshita Kenny Omega Don Callis
AEW

2022's Anarchy In The Arena set the bar so high for hardcore wrestling and arena brawling that Jon Moxley's promise of quality in the closing moments of Wednesday's Dynamite felt like it was setting up the multi-man blood feud up for failure.

Felt like, because would any wrestling fan doubt Jon Moxley about anything?

Yet again, the staging, arrangement and remarkable gifts of the core players involved cemented Double Or Nothing as the destination for multi-man brawls and Anarchy In The Arena as AEW's best signature gimmick. It's so hard to manufacture this type of carnage, but committing so hard to every spot that bumps into barbed wire and glass may be missed was part of the toll - Kenny Omega and Jon Moxley did just this, but Claudio Castagnoli was swinging Matt Jackson into a bin while Hangman Page and Bryan Danielson fought like lifetime enemies in the ring, so you'd be forgiven for missing it.

On and on this went until a) the live band blasting out Wild Thing were hilariously silenced at three plays via Young Bucks superkick and b) the bigger set-pieces needed the biggest spotlight on them. Matt Jackson hit an exploding superkick, was punished by having his shoe removed and bare foot dropped onto tacks, Omega and Page proved themselves the best double act in AEW history by overcoming 2-on-4 odds, and Don Callis' obsession with ending 'The Best Bout Machine' for good was manifested in the form of Konosuke Takeshita's heel turn.

That last act could have gone a little smoother, but it's an especially petty point to make in light of everything that had come before it. Smooth makes for WWE television magic, not the only North Amrican brand that could produce Anarchy In The Arena. At a time when the organisation needed it most, this main event was another celebration of what AEW was and is, rather than what content overload might one day make it become.


Contributor
Contributor

Michael is a writer, editor, podcaster and presenter for WhatCulture Wrestling, and has been with the organisation for 10 years. Alongside the production of daily written, audio and video content covering WWE and AEW, he also provides knowledge and insights on all aspects of the wrestling industry thanks to a passion for it dating back over 35 years. As one third of "The Dadley Boyz" Michael has contributed to the huge rise in popularity of the WhatCulture Wrestling Podcast and its accompanying YouTube channel, earning it top spot on the UK's wrestling podcast charts with over 10,000 episodes and 70,000,000 total downloads. He also co-hosts Benno & Hamflett, In Your House!, Podcast Horseman: The BoJack Horseman Podcast, and has guested on long-running Sunderland AFC podcast Wise Men Say. With WhatCulture, he has provided in-person coverage of some of the biggest pay-per-views and Premium Live Events in wrestling history, including WrestleMania, Survivor Series, All In & Double Or Nothing in destinations such as New York, New Jersey, Chicago, Dallas, Las Vegas, Philadelphia, London and Cardiff. He has also been featured as a wrestling analyst for the Tampa Bay Times, Fightful, POST Wrestling, GRAPPL, GCP, Poisonrana, 411Mania and Sports Guys Talking Wrestling. Michael's background in media stretches beyond wrestling coverage, with a degree in Journalism from the University Of Sunderland (2:1) and a series of published articles in music and culture magazines The Crack, Pilot as well as Sunderland AFC's premiere fanzine A Love Supreme. When not offering his voice up for daily wrestling podcasts, he can be found losing it every other Saturday at the Stadium Of Light, and at Cribs gigs nationwide.