5 Ups & 5 Downs From AEW Dynamite (18 May)

Two Jokers debut, Page battles Takeshita, tag teams ride the promo train, and more.

Johnny Elite
AEW

One of the most hurried episodes of AEW Dynamite in the show's history played out in Houston, Texas last night, as another stuffed-to-the-gills lineup struggled to breathe during the penultimate pre-Double or Nothing warm-up.

That AEW often fails to give big moments enough time to settle is an enduring complaint. Last night, it was at the forefront. Dynamite moved at 100mph in good and bad ways, with exciting, fast-flowing action moving swiftly into segments and angles that felt disposable and expendable because of their brevity. It's a consequence of having too many wrestlers, too many mouths to feed, and not enough screentime, and one the company would do well to resolve.

At least one of Dynamite's biggest matches suffered as a direct consequence of this. Multiple storylines feel undercooked heading into Double or Nothing, too, which is far from ideal with only a week-and-a-half to go.

Match-wise, the Owen Hart Foundation Cup tournaments were furthered through bouts featuring Jeff Hardy, Adam Cole, Britt Baker, and two Jokers. 'Hangman' Adam Page faced DDT star Konosuke Takeshita with CM Punk watching on, while Wardlow suffered through 10 lashes as his march towards MJF continues.

Let's light the fuse...


Downs...

5. Going Off The Rails On A Promo Train

Keith Lee
AEW

A case of interesting people doing uninteresting things enveloped the tag division last night, as Double or Nothing's Tag Team Title match was booked using one of modern wrestling's most tired formats: the promo train.

Keith Lee and Swerve Strickland scored a quick victory over the undervalued WorkHorsemen, who are more than capable of playing a bigger role here. Nonetheless, it was tight and well-executed, with the combination powerbomb/stomp finisher looking particularly great.

The train soon rolled into town. Lee grabbed a microphone, signalling his Tag Title intentions before he was interrupted by Ricky Starks and Powerhouse Hobbs. Jurassic Express and Christian Cage then came out, booking the three-way for the pay-per-view and a singles match between Jungle Boy, Starks, and Strickland for next week. Christian, apparently, is the booker now.

A couple of funny trash talk lines couldn't save this lazily laid-out bit of business. Promo train + wrestlers making matches = must try harder.


4. Blood & Guts?

Jericho Appreciation Society
AEW

Again, interesting people doing uninteresting things here.

The Jericho Appreciation Society shutting down their own singalong and William Regal claiming he'd shoved Chris Jericho's toothbrush up his arse was mildly amusing. Jon Moxley's "I ain't doing that sh*t!" at the suggestion of a Stadium Stampede was very amusing. Beyond that, there was little to sink the teeth into with this latest JAS vs. Blackpool Combat Club, Eddie Kingston, Santana and Ortiz segment, which flirted with the idea of Blood and Guts without really delivering it.

None of the promos were strong enough to carry this relatively uneventful segment. This is a shame, given the sheer volume of skilled talkers involved. At least the tension between former rivals Eddie Kingston and Bryan Danielson (who had to be pulled apart towards the end) gave the feud an extra hook, though the rivalry feels underdeveloped beyond the basic wrestlers vs. sports entertainment premise.


3. A Hurried, Unsatisfying Main Event

Adam Cole Jeff Hardy
AEW

Adam Cole and Jeff Hardy may have been shorted for time last night. Their main event ran only seven minutes and gave the impression of a shortcutted, rushed plan, as they struggled to tell the story of Jeff labouring through injuries incurred in last week's destructive Darby Allin match adequately. The wrestlers are therefore entitled to a pass. If they were forced to condense, that's a difficult situation - and one that should be acknowledged.

But the viewing experience was still subpar. Marred, in particular, by a plodding heat segment following the opening flurry (Cole attacked Hardy on the ramp), as well as some sluggish selling from Jeff, the bout struggled to click into gear despite the performers' best efforts.

Lowering the Boom after rolling away from a Swanton Bomb gave Cole the victory. Afterwards, a post-match beatdown featuring both Hardys, reDRagon, and The Young Bucks set the path for Matt and Jeff vs. Nick and Matt at the pay-per-view. Earlier, the two teams further their rivalry through the Bucks' concern-trolling over Jeff's seemingly injured state.


2. Johnny Joker

Samoa Joe Johnny Elite
AEW

John Hennigan (he of interchangeable surnames, competing here as Johnny Elite) would have been a pleasant surprise for WWE viewers let down by the super-athlete's surprising release from the world's biggest promotion last year. His was a name on few peoples' lips while talk of Cesaro and Johnny Gargano swirled - and the mega-pop justified his positioning as the Joker.

It's unfortunate, then, that the Samoa Joe match was so clunky. Suffering from a lack of chemistry and cohesion, it got off on the wrong foot as Johnny clocked Joe with a forearm while the ROH Television Champion was going for a lock-up. Whether worked or not, it gave the impression of communication issues - and the match never truly recovered.

Elite got some of his more spectacular spots off but whiffed a flipping Death Valley Driver and almost missed a 450 splash, necessitating an extra hop after hitting the deck. Minutes later, he was pinned after a successful Muscle Buster, wrapping a match that felt borderline uncooperative at points.

Jay Lethal, Satnam Singh, and Sonjay Dutt destroying Joe's arm with a lead pipe was good stuff post-match. Given the nature of Kyle O'Reilly's win over Rey Fenix later in the show, their second round match now has a clear story.


1. The World Championship Feud

CM Punk
AEW

With one week of programming left before Double or Nothing 2022, AEW has systematically failed what should be one of the biggest matches it has in the chamber feel like an important, blockbuster occasion.

'Hangman' Adam Page vs. CM Punk should be monumental. The sentimental homegrown favourite whose journey has been riddled with insecurities vs. the big-name incomer, who has never been shy of savagely ripping into such things to gain a psychological advantage. Shades of grey aplenty. A real tug of war for the audience's support and affection. Page spending weeks attempting to convince himself that he believes he can fell 'The Best in the World', let alone the viewers. Opposite him, a sharp-tongued fire-spitter taking chunks out of the World Champion with every sentence.

And yet, here we are. The Page vs. Punk match graphic is more exciting than the build. Last night did nothing to change this, as Hangman "sent a message" by beating Konosuke Takeshita with a GTS, then went face-to-face with his challenger, who'd spent the bout sitting in the commentary booth.

This is the only of CM Punk's AEW storylines that hasn't landed so far. That it is happening across from somebody who inspires such devotion as Page is unfathomable, with the blame falling at the booker's feet.


Ups...

5. Serena Shoots

Dustin Rhodes Serena Deeb
AEW

There was some awkwardness to Serena Deeb's in-ring promo. AEW's Women's World Championship contender stumbled over her lines at points and didn't always sound 100% locked in. Nonetheless, these minor flubs are forgivable when the content is so great.

Deeb was affronted on Dynamite. Her 'Professor' character works so well because of the massive chip on her shoulder. Here, she was incredulous at Tony Schiavone's assertion that Thunder Rosa was going to beat her at Double or Nothing. She then called Rosa's mentor, Dustin Rhodes, from the back, ripping into the beloved veteran with similar gusto. She shaved her head, enhanced her chest, and gave it all to make wrestling a better place for women and in here mind, Dustin was overlooking that.

Rosa eventually decided she'd had enough. Storming out from the back, she accidentally clocked Rhodes in the fracas, allowing Deeb to grab the belt and leave.

A good, focused segment that elevated the existing character dynamic.


4. Up Middle finger

Maki Itoh Britt Baker
AEW

AEW played a strong hand with last night's Jokers in that they picked two wrestlers who could get away with losing to established names. Bringing a Cesaro or Athena in to eat an immediate loss would've been suboptimal. Johnny Elite, however, can get mauled by Samoa Joe, while TJPW's Maki Itoh can take pinfalls all day and still be one of the biggest personalities in the building, so strong is her character.

Itoh vs. Baker was barrels of fun. Though Houston didn't sound into Itoh's idol-inspired ring entrance, she was quickly pulling chants from them. The International Princess Champion is extremely useful in shorter television bouts like this one because the gimmick is so connectable. From selling that her skull is made of iron to pulling the middle finger on Baker after swerving out of what looked like a gifted pinfall early on, Maki Itoh did Maki Itoh things here, and the crowd lapped it up.

Britt survived the Kokeshi to eventually put Itoh away via Lockjaw. It was the right outcome, though hopefully we'll see more of Maki in the future. Over as hell, even if her gimmick isn't for everyone, she has spent the past 12 months closing the gap between her ring and character work.


3. Rey Fenix Falls Into Kyle O'Reilly's Trap

Kyle O'Reilly Rey Fenix
AEW

Rey Fenix and Kyle O'Reilly told the right story in their Owen Hart Cup bout.

Fenix is faster, more athletic, and capable of dazzling opponents with those advantages. He moves like lightning and takes people out of their game, which is usually how he wins. KOR, meanwhile, is presented as the superior striker and grappler. Their natural story involves using their respective advantages to try and nullify the other person's. Wrestling psychology in a nutshell, really, and they executed it well.

Rey's dynamic, dramatic explosions disrupted Kyle's flow on several occasions, with the Lucha Brother successfully implementing a shock and awe gameplan - but only in bursts. A smart, savvy strategist, Kyle scouted for this, springing multiple traps to catch Fenix, inspiring the flyer to keep pushing the pace.

Arm targeting and selling was paid off in the finish, when KOR finally caught Rey in an armbar. Fenix tapped out as soon as the limb was extended, having struggled desperately to keep his hands together at first, wrapping the story the right way.


2. Lashed Legend

Shawn Spears MJF Wardlow
AEW

A different beast to the classic MJF/Cody Rhodes 10 lashes segment, last night's pre-Double Or Nothing offering was carried by a different kind of selling.

While Rhodes' ordeal was pure agony, Wardlow's was about feeling the impact of the lashes but not wanting to give MJF the satisfaction of showing it. Wardlow stood firm. He smiled and laughed when MJF struck, even as his back reddened up and barbs of pain coursed through his body. This, of course, got inside MJF's head. Whipped into a frenzy by his inability to get his former bodyguard to express pain, the Salt of the Earth helped make the big man look the baddest person alive throughout.

Wardlow winced following the ninth lash. Glibly telling MJF he only had "one more" before the tenth finally sent Max south, with a low blow crashing the giant to his knees, making him powerless to avoid the extra lashes that followed. By the end, Wardlow had been downed by a C4, Dynamite Diamond Ring shot, and mass skullduggery.


1. Konosuke Takeshita & Hangman Page Show Out

Konosuke Takeshita
AEW

A banger of a match between two of the most explosive wrestlers on the AEW roster at the moment, Konosuke Takeshita vs. 'Hangman' Adam Page was comfortably the biggest highlight on this deeply inconsistent episode of Dynamite.

Although he has now gone 0-2 on television, AEW is doing right by DDT's top guy by letting him showcase the breadth of his abilities. Takeshita's work looks great. A snappy, impactful wrestler without a sloppy bone in his body, the former KO-D Openweight Champion looks and sounds like he is decimating his opponents, be he diving over the top to the outside or landing his running knee. That he boasts considerable size gives his moves extra heft, too, and his bursts of action are on par with Page, who has made this a trademark of his style.

Rife with fighting spirit, drama, well-timed moments of delayed onset selling, and neat story details like Takeshita being unable to bridge his German suplex due to neck damage, this fantastic bout concluded with Page nailing the Go To Sleep after his own Buckshot Lariat.

Takeshita continues to come across extremely well in American wrestling. He fills the screen as well as he does in Japan, which bodes well for this year-long excursion.


Channel Manager
Channel Manager

Andy has been with WhatCulture for 10 years and is currently WhatCulture's Wrestling Channel Manager. A writer, presenter, and editor with 10+ years of experience in online media, he has been a sponge for all wrestling knowledge since playing an old Royal Rumble 1992 VHS to ruin in his childhood. Having previously worked for Bleacher Report, Andy specialises in short and long-form writing, video presenting, voiceover acting, and editing, all characterised by expert wrestling knowledge and commentary. Andy is as much a fan of 1985 Jim Crockett Promotions as he is present-day AEW and WWE - just don't make him choose between the two.