5 Ups & 5 Downs From AEW Dynamite 200 (August 2 - Review)
AEW Dynamite celebrates 200 episodes with a mixed bag of action but an ending for the ages.
All Elite Wrestling as an organisation was right to celebrate Dynamite turning 200.
One only need to look upon some of the other Episode 200s over the last few decades to find companies in substantially worse shape than Tony Khan's outfit at the time of the double century.
The 200th Nitro presented a WCW in complete disarray, barely disguising the fact that it was pinished and on the slow-but-quick road to ruin. July 1999 was a terrible month for the company, but in a wholly unremarkable way - every month between January '99 and March 2001 was in some fashion, with the odd shining light obscured by some of the most counterproductive booking in the industry's history.
TNA's 200th edition of Impact found the organisation toasting their highest ever buyrate and rematching the key players, but Samoa Joe and Kurt Angle's televised title clash wasn't a patch on their seminal Lockdown 2008 effort. The commercial peak had literally been passed, and it was hard to spot a creative one in that company without a trough lurking around the corner.
WWE's 200th Raw was a major milestone, but also a panicked necessity. Raw Is War was born on March 10th 1997, but only because the flagship had been roundly humbled by Eric Bischoff's live Nitro for so long that something had to change.
AEW is none of these things. Everybody's mileage may vary on recent creative directions, but the company looks set to secure itself financially forever should rumoured rights fee deals go through, The Elite are staying on board after mild suggestions that they could follow fellow founder Cody Rhodes out the door, and there was the not-insignificant matter of potentially the biggest (voluntarily) attended show in industry history to consider too. That - beyond a specific trios encounter befitting of Dynamite's early legacy - was a major selling point going into this celebratory night. On those terms and others, was this a party show that paid fitting tribute to itself?
For the 200th time, let’s light the fuse…
Downs…
5. Chris Jericho & Konosuke Takeshita Vs Sammy Guevara & Daniel Garcia
AEW
There’s nothing fundamentally wrong with Chris Jericho becoming a card-carrying member of Don Callis’ new Family, but the cloying and unconvincing acting makes it feel that way, and framed against rumours of the All In match likely to spin out from it, the upcoming swerve scans as all the more stupid.
A throwback of a fashion, the hot opening tag team match was all three of those things, with urgency constantly shown from Konosuke Takeshita alongside some violent and witty exchanges between Jericho and his stablemates. But the more Daniel Garcia danced to the tune of a receptive crowd and Sammy Guevara basked in some earned glory, the more ‘The Ocho’ felt redundant in their lives.
They are - or in Garcia’s case will be - absolutely fine without him, and Jericho’s not a good enough actor to pull off conflict or turmoil or whatever he was going for claiming the ill-gotten win. A Wembley showdown with Will Ospreay surely has to position the Canadian as a heel, but why does all of this feel like booking towards the opposite? A trademark carny/corny Jericho Appreciation Segment segment next week promises answers, but the questions just aren’t that captivating.
4. Jon Moxley Vs Trent Beretta Vs Penta El Zero M
The TV show Scrubs once introduced a love interest for Zach Braff’s character’s whose primary flaw was that she said “that’s funny” rather than actually laughing at what he said. It was identified as a significant personality flaw of the female rather than entirely about his relentless and exhausting vanity (such was the gender dynamic on every show for about seventy years - Seinfeld, Friends, The Office and others had variations of the bit, How I Met Your Mother is an entire show premised on it) but it cut to the core of the experience many of us having watching comedy in wrestling.
Occasionally - super super occasionally, and in short bursts from very specific characters - wrestling is laugh-out-loud funny, but more often than not, the writing or creative or both has done well to achieve something resembling humour and the brain will instruct you to think “that’s funny” rather than actually bark out a laugh.
This match-to-build-a-match was that, for violence. Jon Moxley rolling around in tacks isn’t yet as formulaic as when Abyss would grab the bag in TNA, but him doing B.S blood-and-plunder certainly is. Penta’s flipping piledriver through the table rightfully popped the building but didn’t remotely leap through the screen. “That’s violent”, went the brain. Trent and Moxley superplexed through a table from ring to floor; “that’s so violent” went the brain, beaten down by so many cut-and-paste efforts like this that it’s impossible to care about one’s where the characters are so played-out and stale.Orange Cassidy is still maybe the best Champion in wrestling but is colder for hanging around with all these middling characters, and the same can be said for Jon Moxley and the washed Blackpool Combat Club. The Parking Lot Brawl is a nice way to toast a return to Daily’s Place for Rampage, but one great moment in 200 episodes is a pretty shocking return rate for a Best Friends act that persists with its low stakes angles and Lucha Brothers on their never ending violence-for-hire treadmill.
Guys bled for their art, but there’s a wider malaise across much of AEW at present and it felt as though this was the specific place to drop the pin in the sprawling map.
3. The Elite Vs Triple J
There was cause for much celebration amongst much of the AEW audience when - on the day of the 200th episode no less - news broke that The Elite had re-signed with the company.
Unrest stemming from or because of CM Punk’s return and a prevailing feeling that none of them were exactly engaging in their finest runs since the company’s 2019 launch moved many to wonder if a Cody Rhodes-adjacent unlikely WWE move might have been on the cards for some or all of AEW’s “E”. But the majority of villagers rejoiced - the quartet were staying put in the place where they could most likely do things the way they want and without the often-oppressive restrictions of the market leader.
Hopefully this depressingly phoned-in trios match with Triple J wasn’t a sign of things to come now they’ve got their new deals.
A match that had the scope for 40 dumb spots realistically had about four. Kenny playing the guitar was hilarious, the heels doing their opponent’s pose was nice, and Omega and Jarrett facing off in the opening seconds was a celebration of AEW’s impossible and insane range. Elsewhere, some half-baked fun with Satnam Singh’s size fell short of the usual Omega Vs Big Guy charm, and the opportunity to wow alongside the cornball Memphis comedy was squandered in favour of some routine and unremarkable action.
Jarrett took some sideways stick for doing such a good job in an angle with Grado that people were pitching it as a match for All In, but it was hotter and more real-feeling than anything The Elite have done since Hangman Page vanquished Jon Moxley at Revolution. The Blackpool Combat Club flattered to deceive, and short of Kenny Omega name-checking Collision to allow us to imagine wrestling’s biggest dream match, this did too.
If the quartet really are back to business following a challenging year, here’s hoping they get back to best soon too.
2. Aussie Open Vs Vikingo & Komander
Triple H kicked up a bit of fuss this week with a line in the Cody Rhodes documentary far more creative and clever than just about everything he’s fed to his main characters over the last few months.
He classified AEW as “secondary”, which was one of those smart jabs that is both objectively true yet brutally piercing all at once. He annoyed exactly who he wanted to annoy while also solidifying his base of WWE hardcores with a line that - in other terms - Tony Khan has used himself. AEW is the "challenger brand" and thus doesn't get to be Number One, but if all of this is true, Ring Of Honor is tertiary at best and even then it sometimes feels of lesser importance than countless other wrestling products throughout the world. Its USP isn't unique - it promises great wrestling in an era where fans are spoilt for choice on where to find it.
Aussie Open Vs Vikingo & Komander was, at points, great wrestling. At others, it was merely good. It's impossible to not go wild for the latter pair's aerials in person, but the where and why of the spots has been evident with both for several months now, and a wider lack of investment in the stakes hurt this otherwise-decent bout. Time on Dynamite is premium, and the action should be too - by virtue of the titles on the line, this never could be, and there were better ways to make the most of the flagship's 200th edition than this.
1. All In
There are numerous components to enjoying a good wrestling show or good booking in general, and one of those things is getting to live with your own anticipation and excitement. Tony Khan knows this - he was a fan of countless products that traded in longterm storytelling before becoming a great longterm storyteller in his own right, so he understands the alchemy.
Why, then, is he forcing his biggest ever paid crowd to wait and wait and wait for that feeling?
"The Biggest Event In Wrestling History", like Triple H's aforementioned dig, is a fabulous line because it's as true as it is bombastic. It sounds like absurd promoter-speak but is in fact going to out-WrestleMania WrestleMania in terms of attendance and scale. To have one match on the card 24 days away from the first bell ringing is criminal.
Even if one reviews teases on the show, that number only really increases to about four, and some of those are driven by leaked rumours or fan-casting rather than out-and-out clues dropped on television. It's not unreasonable to want to enjoy the build-up as much as they payoff, and the bulk of the 74,888 (so far) in attendance presumably expected more of it by now.
Ups…
5. 200 Up
All Elite Wrestling celebrated turning four in January, and with Dynamite's 200th episode effectively toasted the same birthday here, and the company and show's lifespan is now long enough to justify taking a rose-coloured look at its impressive legacy.
As is always the case, the best way to honour something like this is to knock the show out of the park, but as far as making use of nostalgia for one of the first times, this was vastly superior to 95% of the Raw tribute shows over the last twenty years. The entrance tunnels and neon explosion graphics were back, Tony Khan teed up a video that served as a reminder of just how impressive a broadcast its been at its peak, and some of the old clips used during wrestler entrances were tremendous at bedding them further into the Dynamite's ever-increasing lore.
Neither overwhelming or underserving, the execution of the reasonable self-aggrandising was measured impeccably. Nobody minds a "This Is Awesome" chant when it's - in Khan's own words - justified.
4. Mr Wednesday Night
The promised face-to-face between Jerry Lynn and Jack Perry was a pointless bait-and-switch all told. The two delivered upon the promotion to the letter, but Lynn had implied violence last week and that never came. Not from him, anyway, and that's when all of this got good.
Rob Van Dam was announced as an ECW legend that can still go, and the jury will be out on that for the next seven days, but him entering to Pantera's "Walk" on a mainstream show in 22 years was an exhilarating experience for fans of a certain vintage - Tony Khan included.
The announcement of an actual FTW Title match between the two next week was the promise of some uppance that won't come for Perry, but will at least invite Van Dam to show exactly what he's got left as part of this oddly compelling ECW revival bit.
3. MJF & Adam Cole Take Their Spot
The hottest angle in the company confirmed its rightful place atop the Wembley Stadium supercard as Adam Cole signed on the dotted line to face MJF for the AEW World Heavyweight Championship at All In London.
But this was more than a contract segment, because of course it was.
Continuing on from his undiluted babyface act on Saturday's Collision, MJF emotionally stumbled through another retelling of his traumatic past to draw out Cole to put over his growth and make the match official. The tension between them remains unbearable - 'The Salt Of The Earth' has realised that he can't work Cole like he did CM Punk (which puts over Cole's intellect tremendously well) so he's working all of us harder than ever before to try and get the advantage he needs. Or is he? Is this a legitimate babyface turn? That these can yet again be questions asked in good faith is another victory for the Champion.
Meanwhile, Cole's smarts not leaving him resulted in a hug including a balled-up fist to MJF's back. Was he literally showing his hand here? A raging Roderick Strong didn't seem to think so, which was both knowingly hilarious and also a detail that remains prevalent in the main story.
Kudos to all three. In a product that's felt too freewheeling for a card that feels undercooked, the top stars fighting for the top prize have got their houses in order.
2. Mogul Embassy Go To War With Nick Wayne
Funny before it became deeply uncomfortable, this disarmingly dangerous heat angle was one of the best AEW outside broadcasts in ages, and captured the cruelty in Swerve Strickland's heart that he's rapidly been able to extract from an enraged AR Fox.
Jumping Nick Wayne and bloodying him up with a framed picture of him and his late father, the two went from menacing to outright evil when they called Darby Allin to make him aware of the damage they'd done. This was sensational heroes-and-villains action, of bad guys picking their moments and good guys unable to do anything until they can.
That destination could and should be Wembley Stadium, and there's no bigger superhero than Sting himself, not least in front of the biggest crowd of his legendary career. This already had the makings of something special, but Wayne's involvement has elevated all of it to an unprecedented height.
1. Toni Storm Vs Hikaru Shida
Excalibur saying this Women's Championship match was a "fitting" ending to the 200th edition of Dynamite was more than a little sly, but the match and result itself paid the line off all the same and disguised a weak build with an incredible bit of business.
The best ever AEW Women's Champion defended against the most under-appreciated one, and in a genuinely wonderful and cathartic twist, the latter is about to get the biggest bouquet of flowers ever. A fabulous brawl in a prestige spot will ensure the match and women involved are remembered for their important contributions too.
Two incredible false finishes appeared to put a Storm retention beyond doubt, but in handling The Outcasts herself and not being dumb enough to fall to their back-up plan, Shida's credibility remained in tact as she returned to the AEW summit. Dynamite 200 was so rarely the best exhibition of what AEW was and can be again, but this was what people talk about when they reference the peak.